The Dark Charisma of Adolf Hitler
The Dark Charisma of Adolf Hitler
Author
Discussion

TwigtheWonderkid

Original Poster:

49,310 posts

181 months

Tuesday 20th November 2012
quotequote all
Anybody witness this utter dumbed down tripe dished up on BBC2 last night. Shockingly bad.

First half hour was about German amalgamation of Austria in 1938, and they managed to not mention the word Anschluss at all. That's a real achievement!!!

Watched it with my 14 y/o son who is doing history GCSE, but he thought it was total tripe so went to bed in disgust.

I've emailed Points of View in fury. Suggested the follow this series up with "Stalin's Death Camps"....with Keith Chegwin.


anonymous-user

85 months

Tuesday 20th November 2012
quotequote all
I watched the last 20 minutes of it (forgot it was on) was the narrator on piece work? he got 'dark charisma' into every other sentence.

RegMolehusband

4,117 posts

288 months

Tuesday 20th November 2012
quotequote all
Well I've watched 1 and 2 and enjoyed it even though there's nothing new in it. I love watching the old film reels of Hitler and his cohorts enjoying the adulation. However I guess my enjoying it makes me considerably thicker than yow.

I assume you won't be bothering with episode 3.

Halb

53,012 posts

214 months

Tuesday 20th November 2012
quotequote all
I have it on in the background.
I am enjoying it also. The narrator has the right sort of voice for this. Reminds me a bit of Ian Curtis.

N Dentressangle

3,453 posts

253 months

Tuesday 20th November 2012
quotequote all
It is poor, isn't it?

A historian and occasional TV presenter friend of mine tells me it's because it's been filmed to appeal to American audiences when it gets sold to the likes of the History Channel.

Zuckerman

39 posts

170 months

Tuesday 20th November 2012
quotequote all
I was shocked by how bad and simplistic it was. Particularly after watching 'Nazis - a warning from history' the other day. I think at the start the narrator said 'but Hitler didn't hypnotise the German people into voting for him' - And I'd always thought that was how he got into power, Derren Brown.

DJRC

23,563 posts

267 months

Halb

53,012 posts

214 months

Tuesday 20th November 2012
quotequote all
Any excuse!


"This is the H-Man here, is Admiral Adama there?"
laugh

N Dentressangle

3,453 posts

253 months

Wednesday 21st November 2012
quotequote all
Zuckerman said:
I was shocked by how bad and simplistic it was. Particularly after watching 'Nazis - a warning from history' the other day.
That's precisely what my mate said - he'd dug up 'Warning from History' on iplayer too.

PaulG40

2,381 posts

256 months

Wednesday 21st November 2012
quotequote all
Hitler is a great example of transformational leadership style. Inspiring people to follow you through belief in your vision.

I thought it was a good programme. Kept me suitably entertained. Haven't seen that Nazi: A warning from history programme though yet. Will try and dig it out, looks good. I love history programmes about WW2.

Eric Mc

125,980 posts

296 months

Wednesday 21st November 2012
quotequote all
I actually think it is a good programme - but it is not a patch on "The Nazis - A Warning From History" - which was written by the same historian, Laurence Rees.

The huge advantage of "A Warning from History" is that it has interviews with important people from the era who could give first hand accounts of the time and events.

In the intereving period (15 years) almost all these people have died.

DJRC

23,563 posts

267 months

Wednesday 21st November 2012
quotequote all
A lot about Hitler could be said about Churchill. In many ways they were 2 sides of a similar personality coin.

It is often the way with the cult of driven, obsessive and Depressive personalities.

Eric Mc

125,980 posts

296 months

Wednesday 21st November 2012
quotequote all
I think that too - although I wouldn't take the analogy too far.

TEKNOPUG

20,509 posts

236 months

Wednesday 21st November 2012
quotequote all
They couldn't, really, at all. Not even close. You need some obsessive drive to succeed at anything. But that isn't the defining element of your personality.

Hitler and Stalin are a better comparison. Although one was driven by hate and the other by power, they shared many of the same personality traits.

Eric Mc

125,980 posts

296 months

Wednesday 21st November 2012
quotequote all
But differed massively too. Stalin was consumed by paranoia and the urge to control everything.

Hitler wasn't like that. Indeed, he delegated to a massive extent - more than a normal democratic government would. As a "Great Dictator", he did very little actual dictating.

DJRC

23,563 posts

267 months

Wednesday 21st November 2012
quotequote all
TEKNOPUG said:
They couldn't, really, at all. Not even close. You need some obsessive drive to succeed at anything. But that isn't the defining element of your personality.

Hitler and Stalin are a better comparison. Although one was driven by hate and the other by power, they shared many of the same personality traits.
Yes you could quite easily. It is in fact darkly amusing that Uncle Jo, the H-man (see previous link gag), Winnie and FDR could all be said to share some very similar personality traits, esp on their darker sides. What alleviates Winnie and FDR was that the darker sides of them were not the dominant sides, but even their lighter sides encompassed absolute arrogance, ignorance, stubborness, pig headedness and outright unpleasantness. To not get this is to misunderstand their personalities in a very significant way.

To combat Hitler, you needed Churchill. Absolute complete and commanding utter faith in your personality as a force of nature than cannot be denied and cannot be moved. At other times, such a thing is something that cannot and will not be tolerated as they are a threat to all stability around them. Such people are humanity magnified in one person.

TwigtheWonderkid

Original Poster:

49,310 posts

181 months

Thursday 22nd November 2012
quotequote all
Zuckerman said:
I was shocked by how bad and simplistic it was.
^^^THIS.

I've got the whole series of The World At War on dvd. Made in 1973, it's brilliant. And with Laurance Olivier narrating.

After that, this was shockingly poor.

Eric Mc

125,980 posts

296 months

Thursday 22nd November 2012
quotequote all
TwigtheWonderkid said:
^^^THIS.

I've got the whole series of The World At War on dvd. Made in 1973, it's brilliant. And with Laurance Olivier narrating.

After that, this was shockingly poor.
Have you seen "The Nazis - A Warning From History"?

In my opinion, it's even better than the World At War - although it doesn't quite cover the same topic.

McClure

2,173 posts

177 months

Thursday 22nd November 2012
quotequote all
Eric Mc said:
Have you seen "The Nazis - A Warning From History"?

In my opinion, it's even better than the World At War - although it doesn't quite cover the same topic.
I've got this and "dark charisma" saved, looks like I'll be deleting the latter and just watching the former. Thanks.

Wuzzle

9,658 posts

168 months

Thursday 22nd November 2012
quotequote all
You can say what you like abut Hitler, but I wouldn't mind his money.