E53 X5 4.8 or 4.6IS
E53 X5 4.8 or 4.6IS
Author
Discussion

smokey145

Original Poster:

616 posts

181 months

Saturday 24th November 2012
quotequote all
Currently looking at these as a replacement/downsize for my current BMW. Blown away by the value for money, don't know anyone that has owned one before though, any former owners out there? Your experiences please?

Max M4X WW

5,031 posts

213 months

Saturday 24th November 2012
quotequote all
What are you coming from?

I love the look of an Estoril 4.6iS but would never change my 540i for one as the 540i produces big enough bills!

I presume you know the 4.6 is the early front end and 4.8 late style front end.

HoHoHo

15,407 posts

281 months

Saturday 24th November 2012
quotequote all
I bought a 6 month old Ex-BMW management 4.8iS some years ago and ran it for a year (I assume you're talking about the E53 rather than E70?)

I put over 30,000 miles on it and spent a small fortune in fuel. No major problems at all aside from the gearbox which is ste at best. I had previously had a 3.0D M sport from new and after a year with the 4.8iS I wondered why I'd bought it. I was able due to the car climate at the time sell it for £9k less than I paid so it wasn't massively expensive from that angle.

Lots of great V8 noise, sure but IMO they are overrated and there's better ways of spending your money. As I mentioned the gearbox is ste, 3rd to 4th was always awful and BMW couldn't find out what the fault was and the interior is no better than the then 'Le Mans' special edition which was nearly as quick (certainly is given a re-map) and costs significantly less to run.

That said, a wonderful looking car yes


BMW X5 4.8iS by Martin_Bennett, on Flickr


BMW X5 4.8iS by Martin_Bennett, on Flickr


BMW X5 4.8iS by Martin_Bennett, on Flickr

Max M4X WW

5,031 posts

213 months

Saturday 24th November 2012
quotequote all
Its just the exhausts and wheels (4.6iS) for me. I don't know why but I love them! Oh and the wheel arch extensions.


fen7on

97 posts

248 months

Saturday 24th November 2012
quotequote all
Quote from my neighbour when I came home in the M6: 'the x5 sounded better'.

I had one for three years from new, fuel economy is excellent in comparison to M6! Build quality was very good, had an M3 before, which was forever going back with issues; the 4.8 never went in for any warranty work. I would buy one tomorrow as a winter car, but having already had one for three years, I would get bored. I'll just add, I only did around 27k miles over 3 years, would recommend one.

Max M4X WW

5,031 posts

213 months

Sunday 25th November 2012
quotequote all
Looks like you took quite a depreciation hit!

fen7on

97 posts

248 months

Sunday 25th November 2012
quotequote all
Max M4X WW said:
Looks like you took quite a depreciation hit!
Yes, whoops! Managed to sell at lowest point of 4x4 market.

graemel

7,230 posts

248 months

Sunday 25th November 2012
quotequote all
I bought the missus a 4.6iS a few years ago. Great car but the ride quality is pretty poor. Anyone sitting in the back whilst driving over potholes or speed bumps will need an osteopath afterwards.

8Tech

2,221 posts

229 months

Monday 26th November 2012
quotequote all
I have had a 4.4i Sport and am currently running a 4.8iS.

Fuel economy is about the same on both. Gearbox in the 4.4 was sooo much better than the 4.8 which has an awful change and is up and down gears like a fiddlers elbow.

Not much to tell in the performance difference although the 4.8 is a fair bit more powerful. You cannot feel it.

Both had continuous niggly issues and the full airbag suspension on the 4.8 is giving trouble now for the 3rd time in a year, all different faults.

I also have an E39 540i Sport which overall is a much better drive, although of course, less roomy.

Despite the running costs though, I really like the car and it is only marginally worse on fuel than my best friends 3.0d (35d twin turbo X-Drive).

If you can justify the need for the bigger car then go for it.

Max M4X WW

5,031 posts

213 months

Monday 26th November 2012
quotequote all
Based on that, Get a 7 Series smile

honest_delboy

1,775 posts

231 months

Tuesday 27th November 2012
quotequote all
How good/bad is the MPG? I guess there isn't a huge amount in it between the 4.4/4.6/4.8 ?

cerb4.5lee

45,352 posts

211 months

Tuesday 27th November 2012
quotequote all
honest_delboy said:
How good/bad is the MPG? I guess there isn't a huge amount in it between the 4.4/4.6/4.8 ?
My 4.8 did 12 mpg on my 44 mile round trip commute if I drove it with any vigour, if you drive like miss daisy it will return 19/20 mpg, they are thirsty little swines...mine nearly ruined me & I made a knee jerk reaction & bought a E61 520d banghead

As a second car with limited mileage they would make some sense as the V8 roar is intoxicating & a lot more enjoyable than the diesel clatter I now put up with! As a daily I just think the weight of them & the 4x4 drag & big V8 just doesn't add up, I think the 3.0d x5 is a better bet.

dave_s13

14,032 posts

300 months

Tuesday 27th November 2012
quotequote all
cerb4.5lee said:
My 4.8 did 12 mpg on my 44 mile round trip commute if I drove it with any vigour, if you drive like miss daisy it will return 19/20 mpg, they are thirsty little swines...mine nearly ruined me & I made a knee jerk reaction & bought a E61 520d banghead

As a second car with limited mileage they would make some sense as the V8 roar is intoxicating & a lot more enjoyable than the diesel clatter I now put up with! As a daily I just think the weight of them & the 4x4 drag & big V8 just doesn't add up, I think the 3.0d x5 is a better bet.
Mate, you need to get rid of this 520d. I get the impression it's making you a bit sad smile

cerb4.5lee

45,352 posts

211 months

Tuesday 27th November 2012
quotequote all
dave_s13 said:
cerb4.5lee said:
My 4.8 did 12 mpg on my 44 mile round trip commute if I drove it with any vigour, if you drive like miss daisy it will return 19/20 mpg, they are thirsty little swines...mine nearly ruined me & I made a knee jerk reaction & bought a E61 520d banghead

As a second car with limited mileage they would make some sense as the V8 roar is intoxicating & a lot more enjoyable than the diesel clatter I now put up with! As a daily I just think the weight of them & the 4x4 drag & big V8 just doesn't add up, I think the 3.0d x5 is a better bet.
Mate, you need to get rid of this 520d. I get the impression it's making you a bit sad smile
Your right Dave it does make me sad, but I am very grateful that I have my z4m as a toy & use of the mrs's TT-S to get my thrills, I just miss having some power in the 520d as I use it everyday & if money grew on trees I would have kept the X5 we both miss it in many ways.

sumo69

2,164 posts

251 months

Tuesday 27th November 2012
quotequote all
My 4.4 is showing around 18mpg and is uised around town fror taking the kids to nursery, shopping and commuting to the Mrs's part-time job.

Sounds awaful but it was around £3k cheaper than a like for like 3.0D version and those struggle to get to high 20's apparently, so not much in it in reality.

David

smokey145

Original Poster:

616 posts

181 months

Tuesday 27th November 2012
quotequote all
HoHoHo said:
I bought a 6 month old Ex-BMW management 4.8iS some years ago and ran it for a year (I assume you're talking about the E53 rather than E70?)

I put over 30,000 miles on it and spent a small fortune in fuel. No major problems at all aside from the gearbox which is ste at best. I had previously had a 3.0D M sport from new and after a year with the 4.8iS I wondered why I'd bought it. I was able due to the car climate at the time sell it for £9k less than I paid so it wasn't massively expensive from that angle.

Lots of great V8 noise, sure but IMO they are overrated and there's better ways of spending your money. As I mentioned the gearbox is ste, 3rd to 4th was always awful and BMW couldn't find out what the fault was and the interior is no better than the then 'Le Mans' special edition which was nearly as quick (certainly is given a re-map) and costs significantly less to run.

That said, a wonderful looking car yes


BMW X5 4.8iS by Martin_Bennett, on Flickr


BMW X5 4.8iS by Martin_Bennett, on Flickr


BMW X5 4.8iS by Martin_Bennett, on Flickr
formally an M6 and now a 335i E92 coupe. looking to buy the 4.8IS for cash and just bring down my monthly outgoings generally. wont have to worry about fuel as i have a fully expensed fuel card.

cerb4.5lee

45,352 posts

211 months

Tuesday 27th November 2012
quotequote all
smokey145 said:
formally an M6 and now a 335i E92 coupe. looking to buy the 4.8IS for cash and just bring down my monthly outgoings generally. wont have to worry about fuel as i have a fully expensed fuel card.
If you have a fuel card then defo go for it...I think if I had a fuel card I would invest in a nice E61 M5,happy days!

What a great position your in, my garage would be full of V8/V10/V12s! Sounds like heaven to me smile

tigerkoi

2,927 posts

229 months

Tuesday 4th December 2012
quotequote all
HoHoHo said:
....Lots of great V8 noise...

That said, a wonderful looking car yes


BMW X5 4.8iS by Martin_Bennett, on Flickr
Such a bully car! I do love the look of the 4.6/4.8.

karimagha

1 posts

148 months

Monday 14th July 2014
quotequote all
Can anyone help me find 4.8is E53 Wheel arches?

You know the plastic stuff that goes above the wheel...

I need preferably originals.

hass1804

3 posts

127 months

Wednesday 20th April 2016
quotequote all
Im looking at buying a 2005 X5 4.8si exclusive with LPG conversion, any thoughts/experiences on running costs here? thanks