morrisons diesel
Author
Discussion

BFG TERRANO

Original Poster:

2,172 posts

179 months

Thursday 29th November 2012
quotequote all
Filled up at last night at our local morrisons. I've heard all the stories about super market diesel and quality issues but its a company car under warranty, were encouraged to use the cheapest with our fuel cards and we regularly get the fiver off shopping vouchers.

Noticed on the pump last night a sign- Up to 7% Bio Diesel. Why is this there? I've not noticed it on other outlets? Is all diesel the same amount of bio? And lastly my 11 plate Seat has a sticker saying No Bio. Do I avoid this fuel, I've had no problems so far?

Howitzer

2,865 posts

247 months

Thursday 29th November 2012
quotequote all
Despite it being a donkey diesel 218,000 mile 200tdi Defender that I've run on all manner of fuels and rapeseed oil etc the only fuel it smokes on under load is Morrisons, I get worse mileage too so after a few experiments over the years I no longer use it.

All engines are different and most are fine with it.

Dave!

CraigyMc

18,374 posts

267 months

Thursday 29th November 2012
quotequote all
BFG TERRANO said:
Filled up at last night at our local morrisons. I've heard all the stories about super market diesel and quality issues but its a company car under warranty, were encouraged to use the cheapest with our fuel cards and we regularly get the fiver off shopping vouchers.

Noticed on the pump last night a sign- Up to 7% Bio Diesel. Why is this there? I've not noticed it on other outlets? Is all diesel the same amount of bio? And lastly my 11 plate Seat has a sticker saying No Bio. Do I avoid this fuel, I've had no problems so far?
The relevant standard is BS EN 590, which permits up to 7% bio content in petrodiesel.

Have a read of this if you're still worried:
https://www.smmt.co.uk/2009/12/smmt-statement-on-t...

C


CraigyMc

18,374 posts

267 months

Thursday 29th November 2012
quotequote all
Incidentally: Morrisons don't make or refine diesel - petrol companies do that.

Where do you suppose Morrisons and the other supermarkets get their fuels from?
The exact same refineries the petrol companies own and use for their own petrol stations.

C

lbc

3,340 posts

248 months

Thursday 29th November 2012
quotequote all
I had 2 EGR valves replaced while using Morrisons diesel at £400 a time.

Now I only use Morrisons for petrol, and avoid supermarket diesel where possible.

RicksAlfas

14,607 posts

275 months

Thursday 29th November 2012
quotequote all
A few years back a memo went out via a leasing company warning drivers of certain cars not to use Morrisons BIOdiesel because they wouldn't honour their warranties. It was quite a comprehensive list as I remember but it related to a specific Biodiesel and not the run of the mill stuff I think.

CraigyMc

18,374 posts

267 months

Thursday 29th November 2012
quotequote all
RicksAlfas said:
A few years back a memo went out via a leasing company warning drivers of certain cars not to use Morrisons BIOdiesel because they wouldn't honour their warranties. It was quite a comprehensive list as I remember but it related to a specific Biodiesel and not the run of the mill stuff I think.
B30, which comes out of an orange pump, as opposed to B5 or B7 which come out of a black one?

C

Defcon5

6,479 posts

222 months

Thursday 29th November 2012
quotequote all
CraigyMc said:
Incidentally: Morrisons don't make or refine diesel - petrol companies do that.

Where do you suppose Morrisons and the other supermarkets get their fuels from?
The exact same refineries the petrol companies own and use for their own petrol stations.

C
And are the additive packs that go into the fuels the same? And the amount of bio-fuel included the same?

JM

3,170 posts

237 months

Thursday 29th November 2012
quotequote all
Howitzer said:
D I get worse mileage too so after a few experiments over the years I no longer use it.
I used to run a diesel Cherokee and nearly always used either Morrisons or Shell for deisel, both were near me and both were the same price.

I then started noticing that I would get more miles between fills using Shell rather than Morrisons.
Probably about 50 miles more on average.

I often brimmed from near empty then ran till near empty again, lots of mixed use. Without fail Shell gave more miles. Also noticed I went even further with Shell if the tyres were getting worn, but that's a different matter!


mattnunn

14,041 posts

192 months

Thursday 29th November 2012
quotequote all
I've done about 24,000miles this year on morrisons diesel this year, mainly because it's convenient and you get 1% back as a £5 store voucher once a month or so.

But I do notice slightly better mpg when I use other brands on occasion.

The Wookie

14,209 posts

259 months

Thursday 29th November 2012
quotequote all
If it's a relatively modern car just take a look at the fuel cap. If it's not on there check the manual. Chances are somewhere it will say something like 'No biodiesel, B5/B10 maximum'.

B5 is 5%, B10 is predictably 10% biodiesel, and if your car demands B5 then you need to be a little careful where you fill up.

If you can't find it anywhere then chances are it's quite a tolerant setup and you probably don't have to worry.

big_boz

1,685 posts

238 months

Thursday 29th November 2012
quotequote all
I am an ex user of B100 both refined myself and also bought from a local trusted supplier, and have been very active in the VegoilBiodiesel forum.

I have run numerous VAG TDI's on B100 and also one on pure Veg oil, racking up something like 70k miles on Veg based fuels.

Most Pump Diesel will contain some Biodiesel be it from a supermarket or not, and until recently the European allowed maximum was 5%. If you check your handbook if you drive a diesel, chances are it will say that the maximum recommended by the manufacturer is 5% Bio, however if you have a pre-2004 Vag TDI 1.9/2.0 it may very well state that B100 is acceptable. That is because VAG warranted many of these engines in Germany to run B100. Also some French cars will have an acceptable level listed as B30.

In the last few years the allowed maximum in forecourt pump was increased to 7% and Morrow's were the first to move to the higher content, they have had the 7% message displayed for sometime, i would imagine as a liability get of jail card if anyone running a car with a maximum warranted 5% decides to take any action due to a blown fuel system if the manufacturer warranty is voided by the use of B7 fuel.

It is widely accepted by most Bio/Veg users that most diesel engines will run on B100 so long as it is of good enough quality, the problem being that the majority of B100 available in the UK is not of high enough quality to fuel a modern common rail diesel engine with out issues, which in the main is built and designed to run on pump diesel, and has not been tested to run on Bio, probably, but not definativley, due to development costs. This would make sense as why would a manufacturer spend lots of money testing engines to run on what is currently a minority fuel.

There are a few exceptions, those that spring to mind are some BMW and Vauxhall Diesels that have plastic swirl flaps in the inlet manifold. Bio is more corrosive to plastic and so running High levels of Bio through a car with plastic swirl flaps can have an obvious effect. Many Bio users that post into the forum mentioned at the top of this post have confirmed that swapping or removing the flaps cures the issue.

It is possible that your engines ECU may take a while to adjust to using B7 if its never been used before, I know from personal experience that when I have first started running a VAG TDI on B100 it will often drop into Safe mode a few times in the first few runs as it adjust to the different combustion properties, after that never have any issues.

Prof Prolapse

16,163 posts

221 months

Thursday 29th November 2012
quotequote all
Defcon5 said:
CraigyMc said:
Incidentally: Morrisons don't make or refine diesel - petrol companies do that.

Where do you suppose Morrisons and the other supermarkets get their fuels from?
The exact same refineries the petrol companies own and use for their own petrol stations.

C
And are the additive packs that go into the fuels the same? And the amount of bio-fuel included the same?
+1

bks I'm afraid. They really do vary. A fair amount of research goes into this.

Don't know what the extent of the effects, if any, would be on an engine though.


big_boz

1,685 posts

238 months

Thursday 29th November 2012
quotequote all
Prof Prolapse said:
Defcon5 said:
CraigyMc said:
Incidentally: Morrisons don't make or refine diesel - petrol companies do that.

Where do you suppose Morrisons and the other supermarkets get their fuels from?
The exact same refineries the petrol companies own and use for their own petrol stations.

C
And are the additive packs that go into the fuels the same? And the amount of bio-fuel included the same?
+1

bks I'm afraid. They really do vary. A fair amount of research goes into this.
+2

if you want to know about Bio fuel get on here:-

http://vegetableoildiesel.co.uk/forum/

This is the best source of Bio fuel knowledge (possibly) in the world

All that jazz

7,632 posts

177 months

Thursday 29th November 2012
quotequote all
It's not just Morrisons running 7% bio, it's also Esso if you look at the label on the pump. I made a bit of a FUBAR when I was up in Edinburgh a few days ago and urgently needed to fill up with V-Power to get home but the Shell garage was closed so ended up at the Esso garage off the bypass at the top of the A702(?). It was there I noticed the 7% bio label on the pump. Put me in half a tank to get home and reset my computer - 215 miles of god-awful throttle response later my computer reads 45.5mpg, yet the journey up on the exact same route with half a tank of V-Power was 53.3mpg. So even though Esso was 8ppl cheaper it's actually cost me £3 more in fuel than it would've done using V-Power plus suffered stty throttle response that feels like you're driving through treacle.

kpb

305 posts

206 months

Thursday 29th November 2012
quotequote all
big_boz said:
I am an ex user of B100 both refined myself and also bought from a local trusted supplier, and have been very active in the VegoilBiodiesel forum.

I have run numerous VAG TDI's on B100 and also one on pure Veg oil, racking up something like 70k miles on Veg based fuels.

Most Pump Diesel will contain some Biodiesel be it from a supermarket or not, and until recently the European allowed maximum was 5%. If you check your handbook if you drive a diesel, chances are it will say that the maximum recommended by the manufacturer is 5% Bio, however if you have a pre-2004 Vag TDI 1.9/2.0 it may very well state that B100 is acceptable. That is because VAG warranted many of these engines in Germany to run B100. Also some French cars will have an acceptable level listed as B30.

In the last few years the allowed maximum in forecourt pump was increased to 7% and Morrow's were the first to move to the higher content, they have had the 7% message displayed for sometime, i would imagine as a liability get of jail card if anyone running a car with a maximum warranted 5% decides to take any action due to a blown fuel system if the manufacturer warranty is voided by the use of B7 fuel.

It is widely accepted by most Bio/Veg users that most diesel engines will run on B100 so long as it is of good enough quality, the problem being that the majority of B100 available in the UK is not of high enough quality to fuel a modern common rail diesel engine with out issues, which in the main is built and designed to run on pump diesel, and has not been tested to run on Bio, probably, but not definativley, due to development costs. This would make sense as why would a manufacturer spend lots of money testing engines to run on what is currently a minority fuel.

There are a few exceptions, those that spring to mind are some BMW and Vauxhall Diesels that have plastic swirl flaps in the inlet manifold. Bio is more corrosive to plastic and so running High levels of Bio through a car with plastic swirl flaps can have an obvious effect. Many Bio users that post into the forum mentioned at the top of this post have confirmed that swapping or removing the flaps cures the issue.

It is possible that your engines ECU may take a while to adjust to using B7 if its never been used before, I know from personal experience that when I have first started running a VAG TDI on B100 it will often drop into Safe mode a few times in the first few runs as it adjust to the different combustion properties, after that never have any issues.
Learnt a lot there. Thank you.

big_boz

1,685 posts

238 months

Thursday 29th November 2012
quotequote all
All that jazz said:
It's not just Morrisons running 7% bio, it's also Esso if you look at the label on the pump. I made a bit of a FUBAR when I was up in Edinburgh a few days ago and urgently needed to fill up with V-Power to get home but the Shell garage was closed so ended up at the Esso garage off the bypass at the top of the A702(?). It was there I noticed the 7% bio label on the pump. Put me in half a tank to get home and reset my computer - 215 miles of god-awful throttle response later my computer reads 45.5mpg, yet the journey up on the exact same route with half a tank of V-Power was 53.3mpg. So even though Esso was 8ppl cheaper it's actually cost me £3 more in fuel than it would've done using V-Power plus suffered stty throttle response that feels like you're driving through treacle.
Did you do an off/on IT reset? Obviously i cant say this would have made a difference for sure but in my experience that might have cured it for you if the ECU was just having a hiccup adjusting.

As it goes i hardly ever use Morrows diesel for purely geographical reasons (the total garage 1/4 mile from my house is usually cheapest in the area according to petrolprices.com) I did fill up recently at M's as they were having a 15p off per/l promo and the car drove poorly and the fuel economy went to pot.

When its been run on Tesco fuel and continental diesel its never caused a problem so may well be down to the additives rather than Bio content.

All that jazz

7,632 posts

177 months

Thursday 29th November 2012
quotequote all
big_boz said:
Did you do an off/on IT reset? Obviously i cant say this would have made a difference for sure but in my experience that might have cured it for you if the ECU was just having a hiccup adjusting.

As it goes i hardly ever use Morrows diesel for purely geographical reasons (the total garage 1/4 mile from my house is usually cheapest in the area according to petrolprices.com) I did fill up recently at M's as they were having a 15p off per/l promo and the car drove poorly and the fuel economy went to pot.

When its been run on Tesco fuel and continental diesel its never caused a problem so may well be down to the additives rather than Bio content.
I've had Morrisons and Esso diesel in my cars before and they've all acted the same with the same significant reduction in mpg and sluggish drive. It's the bio in it that clogs up your EGR and engine internals too as it doesn't "burn" fully, hence all the crap that spews out the back when you boot it.

mattnunn

14,041 posts

192 months

Thursday 29th November 2012
quotequote all
All that jazz said:
I've had Morrisons and Esso diesel in my cars before and they've all acted the same with the same significant reduction in mpg and sluggish drive. It's the bio in it that clogs up your EGR and engine internals too as it doesn't "burn" fully, hence all the crap that spews out the back when you boot it.
Nah, don't think so.

BFG TERRANO

Original Poster:

2,172 posts

179 months

Thursday 29th November 2012
quotequote all
kpb said:
Learnt a lot there. Thank you.
Second that. Good reading.