Diamond query - Girdle?
Diamond query - Girdle?
Author
Discussion

HughG

Original Poster:

3,753 posts

272 months

Tuesday 4th December 2012
quotequote all
The engagement ring questions has been asked many times here, and I will get in touch with Nightmare in due course, just a quick query though so I know vaguely what I'm talking about before making enquiries.

Looking at BlueNile to get an idea of stones I noticed that there are quite big price differences between stones very similarly graded with the exception of girdle. In this case £1681 for one "medium to slightly thick" vs. £1910 for one "thin to medium".

Could anyone shed some light comment on whether this has a significant effect on the aesthetics?

Dominic H

3,289 posts

263 months

Tuesday 4th December 2012
quotequote all
HughG said:
The engagement ring questions has been asked many times here, and I will get in touch with Nightmare in due course, just a quick query though so I know vaguely what I'm talking about before making enquiries.

Looking at BlueNile to get an idea of stones I noticed that there are quite big price differences between stones very similarly graded with the exception of girdle. In this case £1681 for one "medium to slightly thick" vs. £1910 for one "thin to medium".

Could anyone shed some light comment on whether this has a significant effect on the aesthetics?
Yes, there is a difference. A thicker girdle could suggest that the cutter/polisher has chosen to leave more weight in the stone rather than polish to the correct proportions. For example if a correctly polished stone (Ex proportion/perfect cut) would deliver a 0.98ct stone, by leaving a thicker/heavier girdle the stone becomes a 1.00ct stone which jumps into a much higher pricing index, albeit marked down slightly for a thicker girdle.

Think this helps...

Talk to a diamond dealer...!


HughG

Original Poster:

3,753 posts

272 months

Tuesday 4th December 2012
quotequote all
Thanks Dominic. In this case both are identical apart from the girdle, Round, 0.53ct, E, VVS1, Signature Ideal cut, and everything else detailed by BlueNile list and the GIA & GCAL reports.
Google searches suggest anything thin to thick are optimum but doesn't say what the affect on the stones' appearance is.

ecain63

10,653 posts

206 months

Tuesday 4th December 2012
quotequote all
Be aware also that the addition of certification is a waste of time. Its an added expense that is as useless as tits on a fish when it comes to the stones insurance credentials. Its more cost effective to buy the same stone from a dealer non-certified and have it valued by an independent insurance valuer, which you'll need anyway when putting it on your home insurance. Why pay twice for the same info?

1.52ct i bought for my mum a couple of months back was (trade price) £4000+vat non-cert vs £4500+vat certified. Insurance valuation of the ring once I'd made it up in a platinum mount was £350, which was less than the cost of the certificate by a good yard. To insure it i'd need to have spent the £350 anyway and the info is the same, if not better on the insurance docs. £500 saved!!!

Eddie

ecain63

10,653 posts

206 months

Tuesday 4th December 2012
quotequote all
HughG said:
Thanks Dominic. In this case both are identical apart from the girdle, Round, 0.53ct, E, VVS1, Signature Ideal cut, and everything else detailed by BlueNile list and the GIA & GCAL reports.
Google searches suggest anything thin to thick are optimum but doesn't say what the affect on the stones' appearance is.
No affect on stones appearance when a thicker girdle is used as the facets on the diamond are designed to avoid displaying flaws and cutting. The thicker girdle in my opinion is a better thing to have as the diamond is stronger and is less likely to chip. Also, should you need claw work doing its less likely the jeweller (if he's not that hot on his retipping) will chip it if it has a thicker girdle as the diamond is much stronger around the rim.

Dominic H

3,289 posts

263 months

Tuesday 4th December 2012
quotequote all
ecain63 said:
Be aware also that the addition of certification is a waste of time. Its an added expense that is as useless as tits on a fish when it comes to the stones insurance credentials. Its more cost effective to buy the same stone from a dealer non-certified and have it valued by an independent insurance valuer, which you'll need anyway when putting it on your home insurance. Why pay twice for the same info?

1.52ct i bought for my mum a couple of months back was (trade price) £4000+vat non-cert vs £4500+vat certified. Insurance valuation of the ring once I'd made it up in a platinum mount was £350, which was less than the cost of the certificate by a good yard. To insure it i'd need to have spent the £350 anyway and the info is the same, if not better on the insurance docs. £500 saved!!!

Eddie
I disagree.

Diamond grading reports give the prospective buyer the knowledge to make like for like comparisons with alternate stones in the market place. How are they able to assess value if the qualities of the item are unknown?


ecain63

10,653 posts

206 months

Wednesday 5th December 2012
quotequote all
Dominic H said:
ecain63 said:
Be aware also that the addition of certification is a waste of time. Its an added expense that is as useless as tits on a fish when it comes to the stones insurance credentials. Its more cost effective to buy the same stone from a dealer non-certified and have it valued by an independent insurance valuer, which you'll need anyway when putting it on your home insurance. Why pay twice for the same info?

1.52ct i bought for my mum a couple of months back was (trade price) £4000+vat non-cert vs £4500+vat certified. Insurance valuation of the ring once I'd made it up in a platinum mount was £350, which was less than the cost of the certificate by a good yard. To insure it i'd need to have spent the £350 anyway and the info is the same, if not better on the insurance docs. £500 saved!!!

Eddie
I disagree.

Diamond grading reports give the prospective buyer the knowledge to make like for like comparisons with alternate stones in the market place. How are they able to assess value if the qualities of the item are unknown?

All the important info is there even without a gia or other cert. No decent stone is advertised without statingthe clarity, colour etc. All the crap about symmetry and girdle thickness is irrelevant in the real world. Buy by looking at the stone in person and comparing that way. All good dealers will allowa stone to be sent to a workshop on appro, all you may have to pay if you don't like it is postage.

Dominic H

3,289 posts

263 months

Wednesday 5th December 2012
quotequote all
ecain63 said:
Dominic H said:
ecain63 said:
Be aware also that the addition of certification is a waste of time. Its an added expense that is as useless as tits on a fish when it comes to the stones insurance credentials. Its more cost effective to buy the same stone from a dealer non-certified and have it valued by an independent insurance valuer, which you'll need anyway when putting it on your home insurance. Why pay twice for the same info?

1.52ct i bought for my mum a couple of months back was (trade price) £4000+vat non-cert vs £4500+vat certified. Insurance valuation of the ring once I'd made it up in a platinum mount was £350, which was less than the cost of the certificate by a good yard. To insure it i'd need to have spent the £350 anyway and the info is the same, if not better on the insurance docs. £500 saved!!!

Eddie
I disagree.

Diamond grading reports give the prospective buyer the knowledge to make like for like comparisons with alternate stones in the market place. How are they able to assess value if the qualities of the item are unknown?

All the important info is there even without a gia or other cert. No decent stone is advertised without stating the clarity, colour etc. All the crap about symmetry and girdle thickness is irrelevant in the real world. Buy by looking at the stone in person and comparing that way. All good dealers will allowa stone to be sent to a workshop on appro, all you may have to pay if you don't like it is postage.
Make your mind up. How can you advertise a decent stone stating colour, clarity etc without it being certified?

Lets hypothesise. The OP is considering a 0.53ct E vvs1, triple ex on a GIA cert at c£1681 plus vat. You have an uncertified diamond, also 0.53ct and also and £1681+. How are you able to demonstrate that your loose 0.53ct at £1681+ is an equal or better proposition without having established the colour,clarity etc?

ecain63

10,653 posts

206 months

Wednesday 5th December 2012
quotequote all
Dominic H said:
ecain63 said:
Dominic H said:
ecain63 said:
Be aware also that the addition of certification is a waste of time. Its an added expense that is as useless as tits on a fish when it comes to the stones insurance credentials. Its more cost effective to buy the same stone from a dealer non-certified and have it valued by an independent insurance valuer, which you'll need anyway when putting it on your home insurance. Why pay twice for the same info?

1.52ct i bought for my mum a couple of months back was (trade price) £4000+vat non-cert vs £4500+vat certified. Insurance valuation of the ring once I'd made it up in a platinum mount was £350, which was less than the cost of the certificate by a good yard. To insure it i'd need to have spent the £350 anyway and the info is the same, if not better on the insurance docs. £500 saved!!!

Eddie
I disagree.

Diamond grading reports give the prospective buyer the knowledge to make like for like comparisons with alternate stones in the market place. How are they able to assess value if the qualities of the item are unknown?

All the important info is there even without a gia or other cert. No decent stone is advertised without stating the clarity, colour etc. All the crap about symmetry and girdle thickness is irrelevant in the real world. Buy by looking at the stone in person and comparing that way. All good dealers will allowa stone to be sent to a workshop on appro, all you may have to pay if you don't like it is postage.
Make your mind up. How can you advertise a decent stone stating colour, clarity etc without it being certified?

Lets hypothesise. The OP is considering a 0.53ct E vvs1, triple ex on a GIA cert at c£1681 plus vat. You have an uncertified diamond, also 0.53ct and also and £1681+. How are you able to demonstrate that your loose 0.53ct at £1681+ is an equal or better proposition without having established the colour,clarity etc?
Simples:

You can buy any stone without the certificate from a dealer and still know what you are buying. All stones from decent dealers come graded, weighed etc regardless of whether or not they come with a shiny certificate or not. The point im making is you can choose to pay for the physical copy of the GIA etc (if it has one) certificate or choose not to. The certificate is only a 'nice to know', not a necessity. Not all stones come with the certification but you can have it certificated at a cost if you feel it lets you sleep better at night. The point im making is you shouldn't feel bullied into buying the certificate when its no use when insuring. A good insurance valuer will give just as much info about your stone as the stone certificate will.

Buy with your eyes!

kazino

1,596 posts

249 months

Wednesday 5th December 2012
quotequote all
Are you aware of the potential variations involved in different certificates on colour and clarity on the same stone, that's before you get to a salesmans opinion of what the colour is if it wasn't certificated.
Do you know how fluorescence can lift the colour of the stone.
Do you know that there are lab grown diamonds,
Are you aware there are treatments for improving the colour of diamonds e.g hpht
Are you aware that there are ways of removing diamond inclusions
Are you aware there are ways of filling diamond inclusions.
If somebody swaps your diamond, and you don't have your certificate number lasered into the girle, how are you going to prove they swapped it.

These are just a few reasons to have a certificated stone.

Simples

ecain63 said:
Simples:

You can buy any stone without the certificate from a dealer and still know what you are buying. All stones from decent dealers come graded, weighed etc regardless of whether or not they come with a shiny certificate or not. The point im making is you can choose to pay for the physical copy of the GIA etc (if it has one) certificate or choose not to. The certificate is only a 'nice to know', not a necessity. Not all stones come with the certification but you can have it certificated at a cost if you feel it lets you sleep better at night. The point im making is you shouldn't feel bullied into buying the certificate when its no use when insuring. A good insurance valuer will give just as much info about your stone as the stone certificate will.

Buy with your eyes!

Dominic H

3,289 posts

263 months

Wednesday 5th December 2012
quotequote all
ecain63 said:
Dominic H said:
ecain63 said:
Dominic H said:
ecain63 said:
Be aware also that the addition of certification is a waste of time. Its an added expense that is as useless as tits on a fish when it comes to the stones insurance credentials. Its more cost effective to buy the same stone from a dealer non-certified and have it valued by an independent insurance valuer, which you'll need anyway when putting it on your home insurance. Why pay twice for the same info?

1.52ct i bought for my mum a couple of months back was (trade price) £4000+vat non-cert vs £4500+vat certified. Insurance valuation of the ring once I'd made it up in a platinum mount was £350, which was less than the cost of the certificate by a good yard. To insure it i'd need to have spent the £350 anyway and the info is the same, if not better on the insurance docs. £500 saved!!!

Eddie
I disagree.

Diamond grading reports give the prospective buyer the knowledge to make like for like comparisons with alternate stones in the market place. How are they able to assess value if the qualities of the item are unknown?

All the important info is there even without a gia or other cert. No decent stone is advertised without stating the clarity, colour etc. All the crap about symmetry and girdle thickness is irrelevant in the real world. Buy by looking at the stone in person and comparing that way. All good dealers will allowa stone to be sent to a workshop on appro, all you may have to pay if you don't like it is postage.
Make your mind up. How can you advertise a decent stone stating colour, clarity etc without it being certified?

Lets hypothesise. The OP is considering a 0.53ct E vvs1, triple ex on a GIA cert at c£1681 plus vat. You have an uncertified diamond, also 0.53ct and also and £1681+. How are you able to demonstrate that your loose 0.53ct at £1681+ is an equal or better proposition without having established the colour,clarity etc?
Simples:

You can buy any stone without the certificate from a dealer and still know what you are buying. All stones from decent dealers come graded, weighed etc regardless of whether or not they come with a shiny certificate or not. The point im making is you can choose to pay for the physical copy of the GIA etc (if it has one) certificate or choose not to. The certificate is only a 'nice to know', not a necessity. Not all stones come with the certification but you can have it certificated at a cost if you feel it lets you sleep better at night. The point im making is you shouldn't feel bullied into buying the certificate when its no use when insuring. A good insurance valuer will give just as much info about your stone as the stone certificate will.

Buy with your eyes!
ecain63 said:
You can buy any stone without the certificate from a dealer and still know what you are buying.
You can if you're a gemologist, or an experienced diamond dealer. If you're Joe Public, you won't .

ecain63 said:
All stones from decent dealers come graded, weighed etc regardless of whether or not they come with a shiny certificate or not.
Graded by whom? An opinion of colour and clarity may be expressed. The quality of the opinion will vary hugely. You'll have dealers who are suggesting that the colour/clarity is better than it is, and you'll have dealers who simply aren't as experienced as others. A certified diamond gives the buyer and exact report on what they are being offered, and avoids them being sold something that is probably falsely/mis-described....

ecain63 said:
Buy with your eyes!
Great, if you know what you're looking at. Most won't....

RudeDog

1,670 posts

205 months

Wednesday 5th December 2012
quotequote all
HughG said:
Looking at BlueNile to get an idea of stones I noticed that there are quite big price differences between stones very similarly graded with the exception of girdle. In this case £1681 for one "medium to slightly thick" vs. £1910 for one "thin to medium".
I'm not sure how much the girdle thickness affects the price however there are many other factors that affect a stone's value.

In particular, you should pay attention to the sizes in mm of the width of the stone. Similarly sized stones can vary by several tenths of a mm across the diameter of the stone and this can be noticeable when viewed with the naked eye.

You also have the effect of Fluorescence (which makes a stone cheaper), Symmetry and Polish. Are all of these things the same too?


With regards to a certificate, I think that unless you are capable of accurately classifying a diamond then a certified stone is the only way to know what you are buying. Most GIA stones will be laser etched on the girdle too and any good diamond dealer will be able to show you the serial number under a microscope before you exchange your hard earned for the rock.

RudeDog

1,670 posts

205 months

Wednesday 5th December 2012
quotequote all
ecain63 said:
Simples:

You can buy any stone without the certificate from a dealer and still know what you are buying. All stones from decent dealers come graded, weighed etc regardless of whether or not they come with a shiny certificate or not. The point im making is you can choose to pay for the physical copy of the GIA etc (if it has one) certificate or choose not to. The certificate is only a 'nice to know', not a necessity. Not all stones come with the certification but you can have it certificated at a cost if you feel it lets you sleep better at night. The point im making is you shouldn't feel bullied into buying the certificate when its no use when insuring. A good insurance valuer will give just as much info about your stone as the stone certificate will.

Buy with your eyes!
When you are talking about a ~£1,500 diamond, the certificate is a sizable portion of the cost but if you are buying a £10,000+ Diamond (which these days only gets you a decent 1.3ct) then the cost of the GIA cert is much less significant and for me the peace of mind it brings is well worth it

HughG

Original Poster:

3,753 posts

272 months

Wednesday 5th December 2012
quotequote all
RudeDog said:
I'm not sure how much the girdle thickness affects the price however there are many other factors that affect a stone's value.

In particular, you should pay attention to the sizes in mm of the width of the stone. Similarly sized stones can vary by several tenths of a mm across the diameter of the stone and this can be noticeable when viewed with the naked eye.

You also have the effect of Fluorescence (which makes a stone cheaper), Symmetry and Polish. Are all of these things the same too?


With regards to a certificate, I think that unless you are capable of accurately classifying a diamond then a certified stone is the only way to know what you are buying. Most GIA stones will be laser etched on the girdle too and any good diamond dealer will be able to show you the serial number under a microscope before you exchange your hard earned for the rock.
I didn't note the dimensions of the two, but all the other properties you mention we're the same. For the same shape and size(carat) stone do the dimensions vary much? I'll go and investigate further.
Thanks for all the replies
Hugh

ecain63

10,653 posts

206 months

Wednesday 5th December 2012
quotequote all
kazino said:
Are you aware of the potential variations involved in different certificates on colour and clarity on the same stone, that's before you get to a salesmans opinion of what the colour is if it wasn't certificated.
Yes! In which case you are admitting the certificates are subjective. As a GIA qualified Coloured Stone and Diamond Grader myself i agree that the certificates are written up differently depending on who sat down to do the job. When i was on my courses in 2008 there was decent variation between the grades people had written down, most of which were classed as correct. So long as the grade given by the student was close enough the certificate was accepted. FYI i came top of both courses despite having had no experience at the time and was on the courses with Sotherby's and other auction house staff.

kazino said:
Do you know how fluorescence can lift the colour of the stone.
Yes! Acually i do!

kazino said:
Do you know that there are lab grown diamonds,
Yes! But these are easy to spot if you know the signs.


kazino said:
Are you aware there are treatments for improving the colour of diamonds e.g hpht
Yes! Not so easy to spot these but generally if they look too good to be true they probably are. eg. If the stone is a large, D-Flawless stone, yet has wonky facets or girdle you can put your money on it having been tampered with by somebody in the lab.

kazino said:
Are you aware that there are ways of removing diamond inclusions
Yes! As above!


kazino said:
Are you aware there are ways of filling diamond inclusions.
Yes! As above!


kazino said:
If somebody swaps your diamond, and you don't have your certificate number lasered into the girdle, how are you going to prove they swapped it.
Dont take it to a jeweller you dont trust and you wont have an issue. No decent jeweller or setter will swap a large diamond (small ones are not worth worrying about) for his own gain as its just plain wrong. Ive had plenty of rings in with shoulder stones (mainly bagettes as they are more brittle) swapped for poor quality replacements and smaller brilliant cuts swapped for CZ's but never had a ring in with a larger centre or main stone thats been swapped for a duffer. The customer would have spotted it straight away. Its only the little ones the customer doesnt notice so easily.


kazino said:
These are just a few reasons to have a certificated stone.

Simples
OK! Its your choice, i only voiced my opinion.

ecain63

10,653 posts

206 months

Wednesday 5th December 2012
quotequote all
RudeDog said:
ecain63 said:
Simples:

You can buy any stone without the certificate from a dealer and still know what you are buying. All stones from decent dealers come graded, weighed etc regardless of whether or not they come with a shiny certificate or not. The point im making is you can choose to pay for the physical copy of the GIA etc (if it has one) certificate or choose not to. The certificate is only a 'nice to know', not a necessity. Not all stones come with the certification but you can have it certificated at a cost if you feel it lets you sleep better at night. The point im making is you shouldn't feel bullied into buying the certificate when its no use when insuring. A good insurance valuer will give just as much info about your stone as the stone certificate will.

Buy with your eyes!
When you are talking about a ~£1,500 diamond, the certificate is a sizable portion of the cost but if you are buying a £10,000+ Diamond (which these days only gets you a decent 1.3ct) then the cost of the GIA cert is much less significant and for me the peace of mind it brings is well worth it
Thats a fair point. If it were a £10k+ stone then i can see the purpose of the paperwork but as far as im concerned, in my experience as a jeweller the certification thing is a fashion and 'knowledge is power' fad. I get lots of people coming into the shop spouting off about how they can get a stone with grade X, Y and Z for £X'XXX off the internet and that they want the same grade off me for the same price or less. Or some wag says they want to know what grade the 0.05ct stones are in the shoulders of her engagement ring. Some knowledge is a good thing so you know what youre doing, but all this emphasis on certification is just giving the public more to cluck about in my opinion and its embarrassing when you have to tell the customer that its made the diamond no more valuable by having that little laminated docket. Its a sales gimic unless you know what you are looking for. As ive said before, its always best to buy with your eyes from a reputable dealer or workshop.

Are you talking £10k trade or £10k high street? £10k trade will get you more than 1.3ct of good quality.

ecain63

10,653 posts

206 months

Wednesday 5th December 2012
quotequote all
Dominic H said:
ecain63 said:
You can buy any stone without the certificate from a dealer and still know what you are buying.
You can if you're a gemologist, or an experienced diamond dealer. If you're Joe Public, you won't .
This is true, it can be difficult. But id always say, dont buy from anywhere you dont trust. That way you'll always get what you see. Eye Clear (ie what the naked eye can see) with hidden inclusions (by way of cut) is often as good or better than a certificated higher graded stone with a poor cut that shows the one single lump of coal within.

Dominic H said:
ecain63 said:
All stones from decent dealers come graded, weighed etc regardless of whether or not they come with a shiny certificate or not.


Graded by whom? An opinion of colour and clarity may be expressed. The quality of the opinion will vary hugely. You'll have dealers who are suggesting that the colour/clarity is better than it is, and you'll have dealers who simply aren't as experienced as others. A certified diamond gives the buyer and exact report on what they are being offered, and avoids them being sold something that is probably falsely/mis-described....
But even graded, certificated stones are variable in thier actual grading. You have to remember that people grade these stones most of the time, not robots with constants and perfect sight. I qualified as a Diamond and Coloured stone grader in 2008 and nobody on the course wrote exactly the same grades for thier assessments, yet we all passed. There are always tolerances to the left and right of the true grade.

Dominic H said:
ecain63 said:
Buy with your eyes!
Great, if you know what you're looking at. Most won't....
Indeed. Again, buy from a reputable dealer!

RudeDog

1,670 posts

205 months

Wednesday 5th December 2012
quotequote all
ecain63 said:
Are you talking £10k trade or £10k high street? £10k trade will get you more than 1.3ct of good quality.
I am not in the trade so I am talking retail, be it Internet or High Street.

ecain63

10,653 posts

206 months

Wednesday 5th December 2012
quotequote all
RudeDog said:
ecain63 said:
Are you talking £10k trade or £10k high street? £10k trade will get you more than 1.3ct of good quality.
I am not in the trade so I am talking retail, be it Internet or High Street.
In that case youre on the money.

RudeDog

1,670 posts

205 months

Wednesday 5th December 2012
quotequote all
ecain63 said:
RudeDog said:
ecain63 said:
Are you talking £10k trade or £10k high street? £10k trade will get you more than 1.3ct of good quality.
I am not in the trade so I am talking retail, be it Internet or High Street.
In that case youre on the money.
I know... I got engaged on the 1st November. Spent all summer researching diamonds!!! laugh