what car USA edition: DONE with my STi, what next?
what car USA edition: DONE with my STi, what next?
Author
Discussion

gigjam

Original Poster:

205 posts

181 months

Thursday 27th December 2012
quotequote all
I am at wits end with my 2012 STi Limited, after what seems like the most arduous ordeal and plethora of problems, I think I am finally throwing in the towel.

cliff notes:
motor blew after 2000 miles
all manner of electrical issues
power steering leak
driver window broke
and generally have lost all interest in driving it spiritedly in fear of more issues.

I am considering all sorts but here are the current contenders (has to be new):

BRZ/FR-S/GT-86 (fully optioned)
Focus ST (fully optioned)
Mustang 5.0 (base model)

any ideas?

CraigyMc

18,369 posts

266 months

Thursday 27th December 2012
quotequote all
gigjam said:
I am at wits end with my 2012 STi Limited, after what seems like the most arduous ordeal and plethora of problems, I think I am finally throwing in the towel.

cliff notes:
motor blew after 2000 miles
all manner of electrical issues
power steering leak
driver window broke
and generally have lost all interest in driving it spiritedly in fear of more issues.

I am considering all sorts but here are the current contenders (has to be new):

BRZ/FR-S/GT-86 (fully optioned)
Focus ST (fully optioned)
Mustang 5.0 (base model)

any ideas?
Mustang V6 or Camaro V6.

HTH.

C

mattshiz

461 posts

171 months

Thursday 27th December 2012
quotequote all
mazda miata

FisiP1

1,279 posts

183 months

Thursday 27th December 2012
quotequote all
Depends where you are exactly I'd say.

I love my Mustangs, obviously less polished products than some options but they are just fun whatever you do with them, even if that is tentatively approaching some state park twisties.

The 5.0 is a pretty damn good engine too.

What about a Boss 302 even?

ETA: Scratch that used suggestion.

davepoth

29,395 posts

229 months

Thursday 27th December 2012
quotequote all
Crown Vic.

SystemParanoia

14,343 posts

228 months

Thursday 27th December 2012
quotequote all
GT2 RS

danjama

5,728 posts

172 months

Thursday 27th December 2012
quotequote all
Surely it's got to be a GT86?

Crafty_

14,167 posts

230 months

Thursday 27th December 2012
quotequote all
CraigyMc said:
Mustang V8 or Camaro V8.

HTH.

C
EFA.

Or a challenger R/T smile


gigjam

Original Poster:

205 posts

181 months

Thursday 27th December 2012
quotequote all
FisiP1 said:
Depends where you are exactly I'd say.

I love my Mustangs, obviously less polished products than some options but they are just fun whatever you do with them, even if that is tentatively approaching some state park twisties.

The 5.0 is a pretty damn good engine too.

What about a Boss 302 even?

ETA: Scratch that used suggestion.
Love the Boss 302 but they are a touch out of my price range frown

gigjam

Original Poster:

205 posts

181 months

Thursday 27th December 2012
quotequote all
davepoth said:
Crown Vic.
I hope that's a joke hahaha

Stu R

21,661 posts

245 months

Thursday 27th December 2012
quotequote all
Mustang 5.0 is a great steer - base model or otherwise the DNA is largely the same as the higher-ups. Would certainly be my choice from those listed.

You can pick some pretty good deals up on Challengers and Camaros at the minute too - worth considering depending on what you like in a car.

davepoth

29,395 posts

229 months

Friday 28th December 2012
quotequote all
gigjam said:
davepoth said:
Crown Vic.
I hope that's a joke hahaha
Don't knock it. Get a P71 and watch the freeway lanes clear in front of you Like Moses parting the Red Sea.

Matt Harper

7,045 posts

231 months

Friday 28th December 2012
quotequote all
davepoth said:
Don't knock it. Get a P71 and watch the freeway lanes clear in front of you Like Moses parting the Red Sea.
Maybe once upon a time - but fewer and fewer State Troopers drive white cars anymore - so the cop simulator color is something of a crap-shoot - and more frequently they are going to be in a Charger rather than a Crown Vic today.

Note to OP - get the Mustang. I was a non-believer and tried my best to find fault with mine, but for the money, they are huge value - and for less than $700 you can bring that Coyote to Boss 302 spec. SS Camaro's and R/T Challengers are lard-asses, in comparison.

FisiP1

1,279 posts

183 months

Friday 28th December 2012
quotequote all
Matt Harper said:
Maybe once upon a time - but fewer and fewer State Troopers drive white cars anymore - so the cop simulator color is something of a crap-shoot - and more frequently they are going to be in a Charger rather than a Crown Vic today.

Note to OP - get the Mustang. I was a non-believer and tried my best to find fault with mine, but for the money, they are huge value - and for less than $700 you can bring that Coyote to Boss 302 spec. SS Camaro's and R/T Challengers are lard-asses, in comparison.
+1 on both points.

gt500nick

960 posts

168 months

Friday 28th December 2012
quotequote all
get the mustang you'll not regret it and have a Cheshire Cat grin every time you start it up

gigjam

Original Poster:

205 posts

181 months

Friday 28th December 2012
quotequote all
I used to have a 350Z and have never been a huge fan of the 370Z. but my local dealer has insane deals on them including two NISMO editions (350hp)

thoughts? would the mustang still be better?

CraigyMc

18,369 posts

266 months

Friday 28th December 2012
quotequote all
gigjam said:
I used to have a 350Z and have never been a huge fan of the 370Z. but my local dealer has insane deals on them including two NISMO editions (350hp)

thoughts? would the mustang still be better?
An "Insane deal" to me is where you purchase a car for the list price, and the dealer rubs jelly into a hamster while making notes on the quality of your socks in order to complete the transaction.

C

PS. Why not take the 350z for a drive, and compare it with a test drive in a mustang?


gigjam

Original Poster:

205 posts

181 months

Friday 28th December 2012
quotequote all
CraigyMc said:
PS. Why not take the 350z for a drive, and compare it with a test drive in a mustang?
that's an idea! haha i'm going to drive the 370, 5.0, BRZ, Focus ST this weekend. I will report with impressions biggrin


TheHeretic

73,668 posts

285 months

Friday 28th December 2012
quotequote all
G37, (2+2 version of the 350Z), or how about the Genesis as a left field option?

FisiP1

1,279 posts

183 months

Friday 28th December 2012
quotequote all
gigjam said:
CraigyMc said:
PS. Why not take the 350z for a drive, and compare it with a test drive in a mustang?
that's an idea! haha i'm going to drive the 370, 5.0, BRZ, Focus ST this weekend. I will report with impressions biggrin
I was in a similar situation a few years ago. My first Mustang sold itself the second I started it up, the test drive just confirmed it was the right one for me, looking forward to reading your assessment of each car and hope you find something nice.