Over-moderation...
Over-moderation...
Author
Discussion

Hard-Drive

Original Poster:

4,291 posts

260 months

Monday 21st January 2013
quotequote all
Right, this "you can't discuss homages" policy strikes me as a load of BS. I absolutely don't agree with "fakes", where there is a brand name used where clearly the watch isn't made by that company, although personally I don't see what wrong with discussion, most of which is anti fake anyway. OK, so perhaps a link to where you can buy a fake is a bit much, but banning discussion just comes across as a bit "we don't talk about that nice Mr Savile here at the BBC..."

As for moderating discussions about homages, well that just comes across as complete BS with a hint of elitism. Where do we draw the line? Parnis isn't OK but Steinhart is? That AP thread has been closed where there's nothing wrong with it...it comes across that it's been closed by someone who knows nothing about watches whatsoever.

I do hope that as this is PH most of the kit car section is closed down, especially anything that refers to any car that looks like a Cobra or a Caterham. (Sorry Westfield owners, that's just how we roll on PH). Any BMW drivers who have foolishly stuck M badges on their M sports, as well as being a bit muppetish, you are now committing a PH offence and will no longer be allowed in the BMW forums. And all references to "buy an MX5" are no longer allowed as we all know it's not a real MGB/Lotus Élan and is actually just some dodgy far eastern mass produced copy of the genuine English article.

And please do not even consider mentioning any Aldi pretend toblerone, dishwasher tablets, digestive biscuits or muller corner lookalikes...

Propaganda music will now be streamed instead from the palace of our dear leader if anyone tries to access any homage threads...especially the £50 watch one...what an outrageous thread.

Right, Seamaster for me today then...just in case anyone is watching...can't be too careful...

RudeDog

1,670 posts

205 months

Monday 21st January 2013
quotequote all
I totally agree and I sent Stuart a message expressing my thoughts when I saw that he had closed the thread about the AP ROO homage.

Its not the first time Stuart has over-moderated in my opinion either. Your reference to Cobra "style" kit cars is a very valid point too.

Podie

46,649 posts

306 months

Monday 21st January 2013
quotequote all
I imagine there is a fine line that HM have to tread, in today's overly litigious society...

anonymous-user

85 months

Monday 21st January 2013
quotequote all
This was posted in that thread right before it was locked:

Rushmore said:
I think PH should follow the example of many watch forums and ban/delete/moderate discussions on fakes.

Otherwise we should allow discussions on how to break IP law in the IT section of PH.

And exchange shoplifting tips etc.
I couldn't disagree more with it. Putting aside the dubious analogies for one moment, there is nothing wrong with talking about how to break the law. It's not illegal. It's a hypothetical discussion. It's actually breaking the the law that is illegal. Not considering breaking the law, or talking about it, or whatever.

Everyone knows how to break IP law, it's obvious and self explanatory and no harm whatsoever is caused by me saying, "oh, photocopy that book and then sell the copies, you could earn some cash".

The same principle applies here. It's overly precious. I think we're all grown up enough to decide for ourselves the merits and disadvantages of a given course of action and therefore to prevent a discussion on such a subject is a bit of a joke.

ReaperCushions

7,607 posts

215 months

Monday 21st January 2013
quotequote all
Another vote here for less moderation.

I was annoyed that the AP ROO thread was closed, no-one was discussing or advocating fakes, we were discussing homages.

Also that the thread on fakes / homages as a topic itself, far too heavy handed.

I agree that any links to, or instructions on how to buy a fake should be moderated. But nothing else, we are all grown adults here.

Hard-Drive

Original Poster:

4,291 posts

260 months

Monday 21st January 2013
quotequote all

MG511

1,754 posts

272 months

Monday 21st January 2013
quotequote all
I agree, closing the AP thread and seemingly banning any discussion of 'homage' watches is going way too far. So, no more mention of Steinhart or Christopher Ward watches? Sin bin for mentioning Parnis or Tao? What about 'sportline' Audi's looking like 'S' models? will all adds for BMWs with 'M' badges on, or replica Alpina wheels, be banned? Kit car forums being closed are they? Put your sledgehammer away and use some common sense, and consistency.

Edited by MG511 on Monday 21st January 08:59

Hard-Drive

Original Poster:

4,291 posts

260 months

Monday 21st January 2013
quotequote all
Stuart, just to check, you did agree a royalty with Ferrari before you made your "homage" T shirt and started selling it in the PH shop, didn't you?

http://www.shotdeadinthehead.com/sniff-petrol-fern...


nickcowen

625 posts

194 months

Monday 21st January 2013
quotequote all
Glad you guys said it biggrin

MG511

1,754 posts

272 months

Monday 21st January 2013
quotequote all
These sections of the classifieds need closing asap:
http://classifieds.pistonheads.com/classifieds/use...
http://classifieds.pistonheads.com/classifieds/use...
http://classifieds.pistonheads.com/classifieds/use...
All advertisers will, of course, receive full refunds...

andy tims

5,606 posts

277 months

Monday 21st January 2013
quotequote all
Hard-Drive said:
Right, this "you can't discuss homages" policy strikes me as a load of BS.
The thread was about fakes, which are illegal. Homages came into the discussion & of course are legal.

trickywoo

14,287 posts

261 months

Monday 21st January 2013
quotequote all
andy tims said:
The thread was about fakes, which are illegal. Homages came into the discussion & of course are legal.


Royal Oak thread never mentioned fakes.

Stuart

11,639 posts

282 months

Monday 21st January 2013
quotequote all
All,

Fair comment - the homage thread was closed in a hurry, early this morning, and in error. I'll reopen it shortly. Apologies.

Agree or not with discussion of fakes, we don't want those threads here, in much the same way as other watch forums don't allow them.

So how about this as a sensible compromise:

Allowed: discussion and links to watches which ape the style of famous watch designs (ie Steinhart, Precista etc).

Not allowed: discussion and links to watches which are overt fakes - direct copies, including logos, of famous watch brands (i.e a "replica" 2012 Rolex Ceramic Sub).

I think that this covers off the way in which we deal with all the cobra alikes. There's no question that someone is going to buy a Gardner Douglas in the belief that they are buying anything but that, but clearly if we discover someone selling something described as a genuine 427 which turns out to be fake, we'd remove it.

The Ferrari T shirt isn't one of our designs - Sniffpetrol.com also use the same suppliers as us.

Comments?

Stuart


yeti

10,704 posts

306 months

Monday 21st January 2013
quotequote all
Stuart said:
Comments?

Stuart
Eminently sensible yes

Lolz at those with nothing to do but post vitriolic rants full of piss-poor analogies smile

Hard-Drive

Original Poster:

4,291 posts

260 months

Monday 21st January 2013
quotequote all
Stuart said:
All,

Fair comment - the homage thread was closed in a hurry, early this morning, and in error. I'll reopen it shortly. Apologies.

Agree or not with discussion of fakes, we don't want those threads here, in much the same way as other watch forums don't allow them.

So how about this as a sensible compromise:

Allowed: discussion and links to watches which ape the style of famous watch designs (ie Steinhart, Precista etc).

Not allowed: discussion and links to watches which are overt fakes - direct copies, including logos, of famous watch brands (i.e a "replica" 2012 Rolex Ceramic Sub).

I think that this covers off the way in which we deal with all the cobra alikes. There's no question that someone is going to buy a Gardner Douglas in the belief that they are buying anything but that, but clearly if we discover someone selling something described as a genuine 427 which turns out to be fake, we'd remove it.

The Ferrari T shirt isn't one of our designs - Sniffpetrol.com also use the same suppliers as us.

Comments?

Stuart
Nice one. Common sense prevails! thumbup

Zigster

2,005 posts

175 months

Monday 21st January 2013
quotequote all
Stuart said:
All,

Fair comment - the homage thread was closed in a hurry, early this morning, and in error. I'll reopen it shortly. Apologies.

Agree or not with discussion of fakes, we don't want those threads here, in much the same way as other watch forums don't allow them.

So how about this as a sensible compromise:

Allowed: discussion and links to watches which ape the style of famous watch designs (ie Steinhart, Precista etc).

Not allowed: discussion and links to watches which are overt fakes - direct copies, including logos, of famous watch brands (i.e a "replica" 2012 Rolex Ceramic Sub).

I think that this covers off the way in which we deal with all the cobra alikes. There's no question that someone is going to buy a Gardner Douglas in the belief that they are buying anything but that, but clearly if we discover someone selling something described as a genuine 427 which turns out to be fake, we'd remove it.

The Ferrari T shirt isn't one of our designs - Sniffpetrol.com also use the same suppliers as us.

Comments?

Stuart
Feels like a sensible approach. There is a fine line between fakes and homages and I think PH should err on the side of caution with this issue.

Podie

46,649 posts

306 months

Monday 21st January 2013
quotequote all
Stuart said:
Comments?

Stuart
Are you the real Stuart, a fake Stuart, or just a homage? silly

Stuart

11,639 posts

282 months

Monday 21st January 2013
quotequote all
Podie said:
Are you the real Stuart, a fake Stuart, or just a homage? silly
I look exactly like the real Stuart, but I'm only 10% of the cost. Oh, and my name is spelt Starut. Other than that, you really wouldn't know. At least not until I give you a nasty rash and one of my arms falls off.

MG511

1,754 posts

272 months

Monday 21st January 2013
quotequote all
Stuart said:
Podie said:
Are you the real Stuart, a fake Stuart, or just a homage? silly
I look exactly like the real Stuart, but I'm only 10% of the cost. Oh, and my name is spelt Starut. Other than that, you really wouldn't know. At least not until I give you a nasty rash and one of my arms falls off.
You'll be fine (for a few weeks at least) as long as you never take a shower. Very sensible decision on the new 'rules'.

LukeBird

17,170 posts

240 months

Monday 21st January 2013
quotequote all
Stuart said:
Fair comment - the homage thread was closed in a hurry, early this morning, and in error. I'll reopen it shortly. Apologies.

Agree or not with discussion of fakes, we don't want those threads here, in much the same way as other watch forums don't allow them.

So how about this as a sensible compromise:

Allowed: discussion and links to watches which ape the style of famous watch designs (ie Steinhart, Precista etc).

Not allowed: discussion and links to watches which are overt fakes - direct copies, including logos, of famous watch brands (i.e a "replica" 2012 Rolex Ceramic Sub).
Excellent stuff Stuart, I was a little surprised at the heavy-handed moderation that was experienced on here (as often mentioned, one of the more pleasant corners of PH) and was surprised at the suggestion that 'they' mustn't be discussed.

I'm probably a little more liberal with my views on fakes than some on here (not that I'm an owner of any, just interested in certain aspects of them) but I think the changes made over the discussion and linking to watches that are infringing copyright is a good move.
There's a fine line between homage and fake watches, but it's a clear line.