Recommendations for a second watch? And a third?
Discussion
Hello all,
The bug has bit, I must have another watch! I already have a Heuer Monaco, and until I started following this forum, was pretty sure I wanted an IWC Portuguese . Now however, my brain's capsized! Submariner 5513 was looking good until I saw a Panerai 219 Destro, then there's the JLC Reverso and so on.......
If you were building a collection around a Monaco, what would you look at? I started out thinking I wanted something 'dressier' than the Monaco, hence the IWC but now I just don't know....
Jorrocks.
The bug has bit, I must have another watch! I already have a Heuer Monaco, and until I started following this forum, was pretty sure I wanted an IWC Portuguese . Now however, my brain's capsized! Submariner 5513 was looking good until I saw a Panerai 219 Destro, then there's the JLC Reverso and so on.......
If you were building a collection around a Monaco, what would you look at? I started out thinking I wanted something 'dressier' than the Monaco, hence the IWC but now I just don't know....
Jorrocks.
Take a DEEP breath and step back 
You wanted a Portuguese - My suspicion is that after you've been briefly smitten by lots of other watches, you'll still want one of those (and with good reason), so I'd go for that next.
Once you have, see if maybe something in the 'diver' style still appeals and then look at something like that for your next watch (Rolex Sub is an always popular, but rather obvious, choice - Consider a Longines Legend Diver or a Blancpain Fifty Fathoms if you don't want to follow the herd).
M.

You wanted a Portuguese - My suspicion is that after you've been briefly smitten by lots of other watches, you'll still want one of those (and with good reason), so I'd go for that next.
Once you have, see if maybe something in the 'diver' style still appeals and then look at something like that for your next watch (Rolex Sub is an always popular, but rather obvious, choice - Consider a Longines Legend Diver or a Blancpain Fifty Fathoms if you don't want to follow the herd).
M.
There are countless different ways of collecting watches:
1) Just buy whatever you desire and build the collection that way. That is how quite a few people start, often starting to refine the collections later on.
2) Find a genre/type/theme and collect only those in your selected group, eg diver, pilot, motorsport, chronographs, German-made, G-Shock, vintage etc.
3) Build a collection based on watch types, so you would have one dive watch, one dress watch, a chronograph, a beater, a vintage watch, a birth year watch etc etc
Given what you are starting with (motorsport/chronograph) anything should/could work.
The Sub and the Portuguese are both good choices, BTW.
1) Just buy whatever you desire and build the collection that way. That is how quite a few people start, often starting to refine the collections later on.
2) Find a genre/type/theme and collect only those in your selected group, eg diver, pilot, motorsport, chronographs, German-made, G-Shock, vintage etc.
3) Build a collection based on watch types, so you would have one dive watch, one dress watch, a chronograph, a beater, a vintage watch, a birth year watch etc etc
Given what you are starting with (motorsport/chronograph) anything should/could work.
The Sub and the Portuguese are both good choices, BTW.
Spice_Weasel said:
Just buy whatever you desire and build the collection that way. That is how quite a few people start, often starting to refine the collections later on.
That's what I did. Buy smartly, buy pre-owned and when you come to refine your collection, likely after a good few years, you'll know what to get rid of and should lose no money, or even make a few hundred here and there.I think Monaco works for dressy anyway so I'd go sports next. Do you have budget constraints? 5513 is lovely; classic acrylic crystal looks, JB/military connection, nice weight and a tough watch that will make you money long term. Portuguese... well, it's just a Valjoux 7750, I sold my Rattrapante (7760) as it looked special, but wasn't. Slightly too large to be very dressy either. Reverso... now you're talking, a watchmaking icon and Haute Horologie at an achievable price.
My 'refining' is taking the shape of interesting chronographs and in-house movements where possible for my budget nowadays. Your path may differ

There are some good suggestions here already.
OP, you call the Sub an 'unimaginative' choice. I know what you mean. It's unimaginative because lots of us have them (I have a 16610 and love it), but that's the point isn't it? It's a stone cold classic and suits every occasion. If you are tossing up Sub -v- JLC diver, for example, and prefer the JLC; that's great but don't get a JLC/Blancpain etc just to be different. If you want a Sub: get one and don't be concerned that others have them too.
IWC Portugese- a lot of money for a 7750 that you will find in various forms in other, less expensive watches. As ever though, if the aesthetics are the deciding factor, you can do a lot worse.
Good luck to you and post pics when you take the plunge
OP, you call the Sub an 'unimaginative' choice. I know what you mean. It's unimaginative because lots of us have them (I have a 16610 and love it), but that's the point isn't it? It's a stone cold classic and suits every occasion. If you are tossing up Sub -v- JLC diver, for example, and prefer the JLC; that's great but don't get a JLC/Blancpain etc just to be different. If you want a Sub: get one and don't be concerned that others have them too.
IWC Portugese- a lot of money for a 7750 that you will find in various forms in other, less expensive watches. As ever though, if the aesthetics are the deciding factor, you can do a lot worse.
Good luck to you and post pics when you take the plunge
Vvroom said:
There are some good suggestions here already.
OP, you call the Sub an 'unimaginative' choice. I know what you mean. It's unimaginative because lots of us have them (I have a 16610 and love it), but that's the point isn't it? It's a stone cold classic and suits every occasion. If you are tossing up Sub -v- JLC diver, for example, and prefer the JLC; that's great but don't get a JLC/Blancpain etc just to be different. If you want a Sub: get one and don't be concerned that others have them too.
IWC Portugese- a lot of money for a 7750 that you will find in various forms in other, less expensive watches. As ever though, if the aesthetics are the deciding factor, you can do a lot worse.
Good luck to you and post pics when you take the plunge
Totally agree on watches in general. OP, you call the Sub an 'unimaginative' choice. I know what you mean. It's unimaginative because lots of us have them (I have a 16610 and love it), but that's the point isn't it? It's a stone cold classic and suits every occasion. If you are tossing up Sub -v- JLC diver, for example, and prefer the JLC; that's great but don't get a JLC/Blancpain etc just to be different. If you want a Sub: get one and don't be concerned that others have them too.
IWC Portugese- a lot of money for a 7750 that you will find in various forms in other, less expensive watches. As ever though, if the aesthetics are the deciding factor, you can do a lot worse.
Good luck to you and post pics when you take the plunge
Buy what YOU like, not what you think will appeal to others.
No point having a collection of watches with no appeal to you.

M
Sorry, unimaginative was a poor choice of word. I just liked the idea of a somewhat 'left field' alternative to the Rolex, although on initial investigation there's a hefty price difference between it and the Blancpain!
I take it the 7750 you're referring to is a 'bought in' movement that IWC use in the Portuguese? Anything else I should look at in a similar style / price range to the IWC but with an 'In house' movement?
J.
I take it the 7750 you're referring to is a 'bought in' movement that IWC use in the Portuguese? Anything else I should look at in a similar style / price range to the IWC but with an 'In house' movement?
J.
Jorrocks said:
I take it the 7750 you're referring to is a 'bought in' movement that IWC use in the Portuguese?
It's one of the industry standard workhorse movements along with the ETA 2892. They can be found in various guises and are produced in various grades (of which IWC use the top grade) but the same movement can be found in watches that cost a few hundred pounds. If this doesn't bother you, and there is no reason it should, then don't worry about it. It's well made and relaible. But it bothered me.A bit like buying something special like a Lotus and finding out it had the engine from a Mini-Metro... Oh

Jorrocks said:
Yeti,
Sonds to me like a Stowa Marine Chronograph or the Stowa Chronograph 1938 might be worth a look over the Portuguese then, both use the 7753 (Does the higher number equal better finish?) movement and look rather lovely, and both cost a fraction of the IWC to boot.
Jorrocks.
Just to clarify, I wasn't knocking the 7750- it's a hearty movement and IWC tweak it to their specification. It's just that others use very similar configurations in cheaper clothes. The Junghans Max Bill Chronoscope has always struck me as a good looking and affordable chronograph: I think I'm right that this is an ETA 7750 (someone will promptly correct me...) Sonds to me like a Stowa Marine Chronograph or the Stowa Chronograph 1938 might be worth a look over the Portuguese then, both use the 7753 (Does the higher number equal better finish?) movement and look rather lovely, and both cost a fraction of the IWC to boot.
Jorrocks.
If you're interested in an in-house chrono- what about a Zenith El Primero? I'm about to pull the trigger on either a Chronomaster 1969, or the black dialled 'open' variant.
Exciting hobby.
Gassing Station | Watches | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff



