What car thread: Clio 172 or Clio 172??
What car thread: Clio 172 or Clio 172??
Author
Discussion

scarble

Original Poster:

5,277 posts

188 months

Thursday 21st February 2013
quotequote all
Yup, it's a what a car thread.
Please take title with a pinch of salt.

Back story:
the other day my snotter broke its clutch adjuster again and I started looking at other cars. It's fixed now but I had a go in a 52 plate Clio 172 non-cup, turns out they go for about £2k scratchchin. I quite liked it but as seems to be endemic with them it had no cambelt history (and was overfilled with very dark oil, one of the rad top rail bolts was sheered, ecu bracket snapped.. clean HPI though eek hazard light button broke too wink)

Important bit:
So anything in the £2kish range that will be quite so much fun?
I'm starting to feel like something rather light is required, even if it is wrong-wheel drive and can't do 0-60 in 12 parsecs.

MX5? Can I get a nice clean 02 or newer one which will do 0-60 in 7.2 or less for under 2k? With a hard top?

So suggest something cheap and fairly "focused" but easy to find in non-ropey form which I think rules out 106 GTi's and Saxo VTS/R's frown


More rambling:
I had a look at a Cup too but it wasn't even worth test driving, airbox replaced by daft open cone filter, two-piece chipboard boot floor rolleyes


roystinho

3,767 posts

206 months

Thursday 21st February 2013
quotequote all
You would get a decent 172 for £2k. Service history and cambelt are the things to look out for, but if all is fine they'll go on for a good while. There's a 172 cup doing the rounds on 230k last I heard (and that was a while back)

_Neal_

2,965 posts

250 months

Thursday 21st February 2013
quotequote all
You can definitely get a very decent 172 for less than £2k, but as you've found you need to shop around to find one that hasn't been abused/neglected/both. For example, I just sold my 172, full history, recent belts, mechanically spot-on, 96k on the clock, refurbed Cup Turini alloys, for £1600. It had even had a new hazard light switch (very common fault) biggrin


Baked_bean

1,948 posts

223 months

Thursday 21st February 2013
quotequote all
I used to have a 182 clio (full fat) and it was great fun and i still regret selling it now at times. Plenty fast enough and could be hustled down a backroad at silly speeds.

Funnily enough i found it easy to find good examples as a fair few seem enthusiast owned.

Bear Phils

891 posts

167 months

Thursday 21st February 2013
quotequote all
Even my crappy 1.2 8v was fun. Would love a 172/182 but funds don't quite allow it.

You can get a hazard switch on ebay.

300bhp/ton

41,030 posts

221 months

Thursday 21st February 2013
quotequote all
scarble said:
So anything in the £2kish range that will be quite so much fun?
Loads. But depends what you want and why.

Don't get me wrong I don't hate Clio's or fwd in general. But for me I'm not sure I'd find it that much fun longer term. Fine for a one of blast now and again, but fwd is inherently annoying at times.

I guess if it's fwd then for me one of the best hatches is still the Rover 200 BRM. Close ratio gearbox and a front LSD make a huge difference and it's still the closest thing to a DC2 that I've driven. And a DC2 being easily the best fwd car I've ever experienced.

5678

6,146 posts

258 months

Thursday 21st February 2013
quotequote all
Problems areas on the 1*2s...

Cambelt
Gearbox
Water pump
Cambelt
Cambelt
Cambelt!

scarble

Original Poster:

5,277 posts

188 months

Thursday 21st February 2013
quotequote all
doogz said:
Mk3 MR2.
Much more fun than a Clio.
Yes but the bit that goes at the top of the windscreen seems to be missing, they've tried to cover it up with a bit of cloth but I'm not falling for that.
It's also slower and the cheapest I can see is 2.5k

Can anyone comment on how significant the cup/non-cup difference is (cups seem to be considerably rarer) and what the main differences are and.. er.. what about the 182 vs the 172? There's one for sale at the mo for around 2k but it's private, I don't want to buy a car without driving it myself first and don't want to fuss about with/pay for temp insurance.

Have seen a few fuzzily written ads, most dealers don't even know what a 172 is when you ask about the Clio 172, despite having listed it as that laugh

Prof Prolapse

16,163 posts

221 months

Thursday 21st February 2013
quotequote all
I'm not sure any Mx5 that can do 7.2 to 60?

The Mr2 mk3 is a really good shout. Assuming you're alright with the fuel and insurance RX8s can be had for obscenely low prices now as well.

You can get Clio Cups for under £2000 that are alright you just need to be patient.


Prof Prolapse

16,163 posts

221 months

Thursday 21st February 2013
quotequote all
In a nutshell I believe 172 Cups are lighter and don't have ABS.

They also share brake calipers with Peugeot 106s and VTSs which is somewhat of a curiosity...

J4CKO

47,105 posts

231 months

Thursday 21st February 2013
quotequote all
I had a BRM and you are right 300, the gearbox and diff made a huge difference, not quite as quick as a 172 but not night and day slower, the problem was that the leather seatswere a bit flat and slidy for enthusiastic cornering, think the VI was better for that or the later ZR 160 but I dotn think that had the same gearbox and LSD, BRM's are very cheap nowadays.

Mine died of HGF, like they all tend to eventually.

scarble

Original Poster:

5,277 posts

188 months

Thursday 21st February 2013
quotequote all
I'm wary of RX8s on account of the catastrophic failure stories wink
Some for sales circa 1500 with "needs new engine" in description rofl
The fact you can get a 2006 for under 2k speaks volumes.

Here's a good one:
"WELL LOOKED AFTER! RUNS WITHOUT FAULT, REST ASSURED ANYTHING THAT COULD GO WRONG PROBABLY HAS AND BEEN FIXED AT 110000 MILES"
yea, keep telling yourself that mate.

ajb85

1,124 posts

173 months

Thursday 21st February 2013
quotequote all
Early Audi S3? These are getting cheaper now. A bit like the Clio Sports, they're either fastidiously maintained by enthusiasts or neglected pieces of...

Other cheaper alternative, albeit a bit of a rough diamond - how about an MG ZR 1.8 160ps?

scarble

Original Poster:

5,277 posts

188 months

Thursday 21st February 2013
quotequote all
J4CKO said:
the problem was that the leather seatswere a bit flat and slidy for enthusiastic cornering
Mine died of HGF, like they all tend to eventually.
Yea supportive seats are a must, only time I've ever got out of shape I fell out my seat and accidentally grabbed the handbrake trying to hold myself up. Got out of it ok but it was a bit scary. Not my fault, handbrake is in the wrong place.
Weary of Rover build quality. Not sure they're fast enough etc.

ajb85 said:
Early Audi S3? These are getting cheaper now. A bit like the Clio Sports, they're either fastidiously maintained by enthusiasts or neglected pieces of...
er.. you can.. get them that.. oh. 6.8 seconds?
damn.. I.. hmm.. scratchchin

Only trouble is it's an Audi laugh

Anyone know what they weigh? Lightness is important here. Although 6.8 seconds from 210hp means they can't be that heavy, right?

Prof Prolapse

16,163 posts

221 months

Thursday 21st February 2013
quotequote all
scarble said:
I'm wary of RX8s on account of the catastrophic failure stories wink
Some for sales circa 1500 with "needs new engine" in description rofl
The fact you can get a 2006 for under 2k speaks volumes.

Here's a good one:
"WELL LOOKED AFTER! RUNS WITHOUT FAULT, REST ASSURED ANYTHING THAT COULD GO WRONG PROBABLY HAS AND BEEN FIXED AT 110000 MILES"
yea, keep telling yourself that mate.
For your budget mate its a lot of car and no matter what you buy, you're always going to be rolling the dice.

You're right though, the engines can go. But I've always been a gambler.

roystinho

3,767 posts

206 months

Thursday 21st February 2013
quotequote all
scarble said:
Can anyone comment on how significant the cup/non-cup difference is (cups seem to be considerably rarer) and what the main differences are and.. er.. what about the 182 vs the 172? There's one for sale at the mo for around 2k but it's private, I don't want to buy a car without driving it myself first and don't want to fuss about with/pay for temp insurance.
There's a fantastic guide on Cliosport.net, well worth looking on there. Also vast amount of knowledge and you can view cars for sale on there (probably more likely to be owned by the caring enthusiast)

J4CKO

47,105 posts

231 months

Thursday 21st February 2013
quotequote all
I had a BRM and you are right 300, the gearbox and diff made a huge difference, not quite as quick as a 172 but not night and day slower, the problem was that the leather seatswere a bit flat and slidy for enthusiastic cornering, think the VI was better for that or the later ZR 160 but I dotn think that had the same gearbox and LSD, BRM's are very cheap nowadays.

Mine died of HGF, like they all tend to eventually.

ajb85

1,124 posts

173 months

Thursday 21st February 2013
quotequote all
BMW 325ti Compact would also just about be in budget.
For the money I don't think there'll be another suggestion with a nicer engine. They will all be better looking though redface

Mastodon2

14,346 posts

196 months

Thursday 21st February 2013
quotequote all
scarble said:
Anyone know what they weigh? Lightness is important here. Although 6.8 seconds from 210hp means they can't be that heavy, right?
4WD helps there. They are nippy, but not what you'd call exciting.

scarble

Original Poster:

5,277 posts

188 months

Thursday 21st February 2013
quotequote all
ajb85 said:
BMW 325ti Compact would also just about be in budget.
For the money I don't think there'll be another suggestion with a nicer engine. They will all be better looking though redface
I give precisely 0 f**ks about looking nice, fashionabalism or manlyness. Besides I actually quite like the "ugly" looks (and the fact it probably makes them less desirable and therefore cheap)
Sadly there is far too much Bavarian loving in the office, in fact.. I think someone has one of these already, unless he got rid.. he's gone home so I'll have to look tomorrow laugh
so in some respects it'd be nice to have something a bit different but I won't rule anything out for such a trivial reason.
The 0-60 seems sufficient (7.1 for spanish box, 8.2 for lazy mode?? eek) but kerb weight is ~1400 compared to the Clio's SFA.