Defence costs since Oct 2012 for existing cases
Defence costs since Oct 2012 for existing cases
Author
Discussion

catfood12

Original Poster:

1,572 posts

173 months

Friday 1st March 2013
quotequote all
If any legal chaps could provide some clarification please, it would be much appreciated.

I'm pleading not guilty to a FPN, I kid you not, for being on a handheld phone in local Tesco's car park. It's getting out of hand and has been dragging on nearly a year. Just had 4th case management hearing, trial date now set. Now awaiting additional prosecution photographs, as they've sent the police helicopter up to get these !

Don't wish to post more details at present, sub judice and all that, but will post all details and copied of relevant statements after the trial for the collective's incredulity and amusement.

I'm into about £4K fees to date, so well committed, solicitor has recommended instructing counsel, at a cost of nearly £1K/day. He says CPS getting out of hand and thinks counsel would suit better. Defence is very simple, I accept being on the phone in the car park, and do not believe an offence was committed. There's no technicalities or anything contrived in the defence.

As case is existing I shouldn't be affected by defence costs changes last year, but does this include new instruction to counsel, and are they likely to tax they bill in a different way if they think appointment of counsel was unjustified ? I am 100% sure of not guilty, and am just posting to get second opinion, reassurance, or the facts otherwise, as I don't want to lose out by not getting all of my costs back. This is before issues of being abroad (previously booked) on the trial date and having to fly back for the trial....


10 Pence Short

32,880 posts

248 months

Friday 1st March 2013
quotequote all
I may be wrong, but from memory, the old system would allow you to get reasonable costs back. Whether a barrister is reasonable will depend on the circumstances and the cost, I would have thought.

Less than 1k for a barrister for the day seems a bit of a bargain, too. smile

agtlaw

7,433 posts

237 months

Friday 1st March 2013
quotequote all
catfood12 said:
I accept being on the phone in the car park, and do not believe an offence was committed.
Because?

To answer your question, the new rules do not apply to an ongoing case [1] If costs were and are reasonably incurred then they are usually allowed on taxation. Of course, you're not guaranteed a costs order.

[1] date proceedings commenced must be pre 1.10.12. The offence date isn't the relevant date.

Edited by agtlaw on Friday 1st March 18:14

pitmansboots

1,372 posts

218 months

Friday 1st March 2013
quotequote all
The police say you were on the phone, you say you were on the phone; if you were driving then an offence has been committed.

I sense you are going to defend it because a) you were in Tesco's car park so contend it is not a public road and/or b) you were stationary with engine running so you say you were not driving. If a) and/or b) is your defence then you may be heading for a disappointment. Good luck. smile

bobthebench

398 posts

294 months

Friday 1st March 2013
quotequote all
Sorry I can't help on the costs thing, wrong side of the border for me. However, I'm always cautious of a lawyer suggesting counsel this far in. Sounds like cold feet. My approach would be if there is nothing to stop me walking or driving in, it's a public place. Case law shows a car sitting stationary at traffic lights is being driven, and using a mobile phone doesn't need to involve talking or text, it is use in it's simplest sense.

Sounds like you are accepting guilt in all but name. Maybe your brief has only just realised this, or hopefully there is a lot more to your case than your post. Might be worth counsel's opinion on it, without fully instructing them to run the trial just yet.

petergukM500

2,622 posts

248 months

Friday 1st March 2013
quotequote all
The law is quite clear , some offences apply to public places, others to roads, mobile phones is road only.

Are the CPS claiming the car park is classed a "road"?

vonhosen

40,597 posts

248 months

Friday 1st March 2013
quotequote all
petergukM500 said:
The law is quite clear , some offences apply to public places, others to roads, mobile phones is road only.

Are the CPS claiming the car park is classed a "road"?
There are stated cases where a car park is classed as a road.

Zeeky

2,954 posts

243 months

Saturday 2nd March 2013
quotequote all
bobthebench said:
...using a mobile phone doesn't need to involve talking or text, it is use in it's simplest sense.
There isn't any case law for that assertion (although Magistrates often apply the law in that way). If "use" was interpreted in its simplest sense for traffic offences generally it would lead to some daft results.

More generally, a car park is not a road because you drive on it any more than a road is a car park because you park on it. It may be possible for a car park to contain a road.



agtlaw

7,433 posts

237 months

Saturday 2nd March 2013
quotequote all
vonhosen said:
There are stated cases ...
I only ever see this expression on this forum.

davepoth

29,395 posts

230 months

Saturday 2nd March 2013
quotequote all
agtlaw said:
vonhosen said:
There are stated cases ...
I only ever see this expression on this forum.
Everyone else is wrong then. biggrin

anonymous-user

85 months

Saturday 2nd March 2013
quotequote all
pitmansboots said:
The police say you were on the phone, you say you were on the phone; if you were driving then an offence has been committed.

I sense you are going to defend it because a) you were in Tesco's car park so contend it is not a public road and/or b) you were stationary with engine running so you say you were not driving. If a) and/or b) is your defence then you may be heading for a disappointment. Good luck. smile
http://www.publications.parliament.uk/pa/ld199798/ldjudgmt/jd981022/clarke02.htm

IANAL but I would imagine he's relying on the above, summary as I understand it is that the house of lords found that in normal circumstances a car park is not a road. The mobile phone legislation states road only, not road or other public place.

anonymous-user

85 months

Saturday 2nd March 2013
quotequote all
Wow, spending 4K to resist a 60 quid fine!

It's not uncommon to instruct counsel well into a case. Some solicitors do lots of advocacy, some little or none, and bringing in someone who is a specialist advocate may make sense. The idea of obtaining an opinion is a good one, as a good barrister can bring a detached judgment to a case that can persuade the client to think again about his or her staunch position.

People blame lawyers for encouraging clients to press on with daft projects, but sometimes clients just rock on regardless of their lawyers. Last year I had a guy who had spent £300,000 suing on a business debt of 15K. He had sacked two previous barristers who had told him that his case was a dog. He wanted to pay me a huge chunk of cash to take the case to trial. He would have lost, and would have ended owing the other side a massive amount in costs. I told him so, and he finally agreed and settled the case on a reasonable basis. Giving that advice cost me a five figure brief fee, but it was the right advice, and now the bloke declines to pay the modest sum that I charged him for the advice, but, hey ho.

agtlaw, I suppose that people here used the made up term 'stated cases' because they may have heard of the process of 'appeal by way of case stated' and mistakenly supposed that any decided case is to be referred to as a stated case.

agtlaw

7,433 posts

237 months

Saturday 2nd March 2013
quotequote all
Breadvan72 said:
agtlaw, I suppose that people here used the made up term 'stated cases' because they may have heard of the process of 'appeal by way of case stated' and mistakenly supposed that any decided case is to be referred to as a stated case.
Sounds good though. It's almost like the poster knows what he's talking about.

anonymous-user

85 months

Saturday 2nd March 2013
quotequote all
People often seem to suppose that, if discussing a legal subject, they have to dress up what they say in quaint and curious language, although most half decent lawyers these days use plain English. Still, cuiusvis hominis est errare; nullius nisi insipientis in errore perseverare, eh?


catfood12

Original Poster:

1,572 posts

173 months

Saturday 2nd March 2013
quotequote all
petergukM500 said:
The law is quite clear , some offences apply to public places, others to roads, mobile phones is road only.

Are the CPS claiming the car park is classed a "road"?
Got it in one.

catfood12

Original Poster:

1,572 posts

173 months

Saturday 2nd March 2013
quotequote all
Bluequay said:
http://www.publications.parliament.uk/pa/ld199798/...

IANAL but I would imagine he's relying on the above, summary as I understand it is that the house of lords found that in normal circumstances a car park is not a road. The mobile phone legislation states road only, not road or other public place.
Indeed. It would appear there is case law where in very certain conditions drink drive convictions have stood whilst on private ground but public place, but everything else, construction & use violations, speeding etc is not an offence.

catfood12

Original Poster:

1,572 posts

173 months

Saturday 2nd March 2013
quotequote all
Breadvan72 said:
Wow, spending 4K to resist a 60 quid fine!

It's not uncommon to instruct counsel well into a case. Some solicitors do lots of advocacy, some little or none, and bringing in someone who is a specialist advocate may make sense. The idea of obtaining an opinion is a good one, as a good barrister can bring a detached judgment to a case that can persuade the client to think again about his or her staunch position.

People blame lawyers for encouraging clients to press on with daft projects, but sometimes clients just rock on regardless of their lawyers. Last year I had a guy who had spent £300,000 suing on a business debt of 15K. He had sacked two previous barristers who had told him that his case was a dog. He wanted to pay me a huge chunk of cash to take the case to trial. He would have lost, and would have ended owing the other side a massive amount in costs. I told him so, and he finally agreed and settled the case on a reasonable basis. Giving that advice cost me a five figure brief fee, but it was the right advice, and now the bloke declines to pay the modest sum that I charged him for the advice, but, hey ho.

agtlaw, I suppose that people here used the made up term 'stated cases' because they may have heard of the process of 'appeal by way of case stated' and mistakenly supposed that any decided case is to be referred to as a stated case.
£60 and 3 points. It's the latter that I'm wishing to avoid. Many thanks for you advice and clarification above, and the other lawyers who've added their comments about costs being reasonable, but also how costs orders relate to preexisting cases.

My position isn't staunch or on principle alone. The prosection keep chainging their view of the definition of the location and what it's used for, either with or without the owners consent, Tesco's Manager has given us a statement, they've since handily put up signs in the car park too. I don't wish to discuss further details until after the trial. We're at £4K due to initial hearing where I pled not guilty with no lawyer, about six adjournments, a two inch deep file and now four case management hearings. CPS is making a proper meal of this.

anonymous-user

85 months

Saturday 2nd March 2013
quotequote all
Popular misunderstandings of the law, Volume 97: There is pretty much no such thing as the so called sub judice rule. You can say whatever you like here, and be as detailed as you like, subject only to the faint risk that the CPS dude who has your file reads this thread and gets some advance notice of your tactical planning.

Discussion of a case that crates a substantial risk of serious prejudice is not allowed, but this case will not go before a jury, and it is unlikely that anything said here could prejudice the views of any magistrate who will hear the case.

Good luck, OP, and if you want any tips on good junior crimmo barristers to instruct, ask agtlaw or me (but agtlaw knows much more about the subject than I do, so listen to him first and me second). Also, if your sol is not impressing you, why not switch to agtlaw?

XCP

17,760 posts

259 months

Saturday 2nd March 2013
quotequote all
There is quite a lot of case law concerning whether a car park can be a road. IIRC correctly there was a long and involved case in relation to insurance where various factors were taken into account. Still I am sure the OP has read this in great detail already!

catfood12

Original Poster:

1,572 posts

173 months

Thursday 30th May 2013
quotequote all
In the unlikely event that anyone was awaiting with baited breath the outcome of this.... Trial date was in April, was adjourned again two days before, literally as I was getting on a plane to come back to the UK for the trial, as the BiB was off sick and wouldn't be available. It continues to drag on, as it seems does the BiBs malady. Just my luck it seems to be some non-specific non-physical illness without a predicatable recovery time (no disrespect whatsoever meant to anyone suffering from any such real illness or similar here). Currently awaiting new trial date, I think. Regardless of the continuing escalation of costs, we've done a forest of trees, contributed significantly to keeping to Post Office in marginal profit, and I'm now on first name terms with the counsel. We have case law, definitions etc, that the charge of using a mobile phone whilst driving on the road, cannot in any way apply to such a private car park, even it being a public place. Here's to the defence costs order !