Cartier Santos Tourbillion
Discussion
Haven't posted in here for a while, in fact I hardly seem to wear a watch at the moment for fear of scratching/losing/getting mugged for it!
In any case, last year while on a trip to HK and Macau I saw this watch in Dubai and really liked it. Not sure if its a well-regarded watch or not but I've always loved the Santos design but I understood that it was to be discontinued but this was its final send off. I tried it on, and the sales assistants were being very nice to me and offering champagne etc which I thought unusual, but maybe just how they do things over there. I did a rough currency conversion in my head that put it at £20k(!!) which I thought was expensive, but possibly do-able, in any case I left to mull it over for a week.
The next week I was in Macau and saw it again, decided I really wanted it tried it on etc and then worked out the price again to see whether it was cheaper there or in Dubai and it came out to £75k!! Jesus, no wonder they were offering me champagne before!!
I love the watch, and the tourbillion adds a bit more interest to the (IMO) timeless design but at £75k I would never have one...can Cartier really justify this price??
In any case, last year while on a trip to HK and Macau I saw this watch in Dubai and really liked it. Not sure if its a well-regarded watch or not but I've always loved the Santos design but I understood that it was to be discontinued but this was its final send off. I tried it on, and the sales assistants were being very nice to me and offering champagne etc which I thought unusual, but maybe just how they do things over there. I did a rough currency conversion in my head that put it at £20k(!!) which I thought was expensive, but possibly do-able, in any case I left to mull it over for a week.
The next week I was in Macau and saw it again, decided I really wanted it tried it on etc and then worked out the price again to see whether it was cheaper there or in Dubai and it came out to £75k!! Jesus, no wonder they were offering me champagne before!!
I love the watch, and the tourbillion adds a bit more interest to the (IMO) timeless design but at £75k I would never have one...can Cartier really justify this price??
Its avalable at £59,512.96 http://www.swissluxury.com/cartier-watches-santos-... i prefer the skelinton model underneath however if i was spending that sort of cash it would be a patek for me
michael gould said:
Cartier dont make watches they are a fashion house......complete madness to spend any money on what is probably a swatch movement (ETA).....buy a proper watch like a Patek/JLC/VC at least they make their own movements
Pretty sure that's a watch in the picture and pretty sure its an in house movement. michael gould said:
Cartier dont make watches they are a fashion house......complete madness to spend any money on what is probably a swatch movement (ETA).....buy a proper watch like a Patek/JLC/VC at least they make their own movements
I wouldn't let mere facts get in the way of a great put down."1888 - Creation of the first ladies jewelry bracelet-watch"
"In the early 1920s Cartier formed a joint company with Edward Jaeger (later of Jaeger-LeCoultre) to produce movements solely for Cartier. "
PH Ignorance Matters.
Edited by Tanguero on Thursday 7th March 21:24
michael gould said:
Cartier dont make watches they are a fashion house......complete madness to spend any money on what is probably a swatch movement (ETA).....buy a proper watch like a Patek/JLC/VC at least they make their own movements
A very naive, wannabe elitist viewpoint that Michael. Cartier are doing some ground breaking stuff, you should broaden your horizons...http://www.watchalyzer.com/magazine/news-events/ca...
Tanguero said:
michael gould said:
Cartier dont make watches they are a fashion house......complete madness to spend any money on what is probably a swatch movement (ETA).....buy a proper watch like a Patek/JLC/VC at least they make their own movements
I wouldn't let mere facts get in the way of a great put down."1888 - Creation of the first ladies jewelry bracelet-watch"
"In the early 1920s Cartier formed a joint company with Edward Jaeger (later of Jaeger-LeCoultre) to produce movements solely for Cartier. "
PH Ignorance Matters.
Edited by Tanguero on Thursday 7th March 21:24
That was a long time ago......we talking about modern day watches, JLC made movements for Cartier, they also made movements for Patek and many others..I'm pretty sure all the Skelton movements are made by a French company with a double barrel name which I can't remember .......Cartier I believe still buy in blanks and finish the movements in house...... Most Cartier movements are still purchased from ETA ......they don't make time pieces just the case and strap that goes round them ....... I understand that might not be important to some people but it is to me and it certainly should be to someone who is considering forking out tens of thousands of pounds on a watch
You can now buy fake Cartier watches with the same ETA movements in as the original .
Edited by michael gould on Thursday 7th March 23:57
michael gould said:
That was a long time ago......we talking about modern day watches, JLC made movements for Cartier, they also made movements for Patek and many others..I'm pretty sure all the Skelton movements are made by a French company with a double barrel name which I can't remember .......Cartier I believe still buy in blanks and finish the movements in house...... Most Cartier movements are still purchased from ETA ......they don't make time pieces just the case and strap that goes round them ....... I understand that might not be important to some people but it is to me and it certainly should be to someone who is considering forking out tens of thousands of pounds on a watch
You can now buy fake Cartier watches with the same ETA movements in as the original .
Edited by michael gould on Thursday 7th March 23:57
Although I do appreciate your feelings on the matter. However they are slightly more subjective. Is that a relatively fair analysis?
michael gould said:
Tanguero said:
michael gould said:
Cartier dont make watches they are a fashion house......complete madness to spend any money on what is probably a swatch movement (ETA).....buy a proper watch like a Patek/JLC/VC at least they make their own movements
I wouldn't let mere facts get in the way of a great put down."1888 - Creation of the first ladies jewelry bracelet-watch"
"In the early 1920s Cartier formed a joint company with Edward Jaeger (later of Jaeger-LeCoultre) to produce movements solely for Cartier. "
PH Ignorance Matters.
Edited by Tanguero on Thursday 7th March 21:24
That was a long time ago......we talking about modern day watches, JLC made movements for Cartier, they also made movements for Patek and many others..I'm pretty sure all the Skelton movements are made by a French company with a double barrel name which I can't remember .......Cartier I believe still buy in blanks and finish the movements in house...... Most Cartier movements are still purchased from ETA ......they don't make time pieces just the case and strap that goes round them ....... I understand that might not be important to some people but it is to me and it certainly should be to someone who is considering forking out tens of thousands of pounds on a watch
You can now buy fake Cartier watches with the same ETA movements in as the original .
michael gould said:
Tanguero said:
michael gould said:
Cartier dont make watches they are a fashion house......complete madness to spend any money on what is probably a swatch movement (ETA).....buy a proper watch like a Patek/JLC/VC at least they make their own movements
I wouldn't let mere facts get in the way of a great put down."1888 - Creation of the first ladies jewelry bracelet-watch"
"In the early 1920s Cartier formed a joint company with Edward Jaeger (later of Jaeger-LeCoultre) to produce movements solely for Cartier. "
PH Ignorance Matters.
Edited by Tanguero on Thursday 7th March 21:24
That was a long time ago......we talking about modern day watches, JLC made movements for Cartier, they also made movements for Patek and many others..I'm pretty sure all the Skelton movements are made by a French company with a double barrel name which I can't remember .......Cartier I believe still buy in blanks and finish the movements in house...... Most Cartier movements are still purchased from ETA ......they don't make time pieces just the case and strap that goes round them ....... I understand that might not be important to some people but it is to me and it certainly should be to someone who is considering forking out tens of thousands of pounds on a watch
You can now buy fake Cartier watches with the same ETA movements in as the original .
Edited by michael gould on Thursday 7th March 23:57
Edited by Tanguero on Friday 8th March 08:39
I’m a bit anal when it comes to watches.....I think the majority of people who pay 4 or 5k for a watch with a recognised brand or a fashion house such as Cartier don't realise that it has the same movement in as a £500 Tissot .......it's a racket that fashion houses have got away with for years. I am a victim to this con as I own a Chanel J12 which has an ETA movement in and it’s a good watch, but, at £4500 you’re paying £750 to the tax man.....£2000 to the retailer, The watch probably cost £300 to produce...... Chanel have nothing to do with watches....they are maximising the value of their iconic brand.
Apologies to the op Cartier are indeed making their own movements in house for their exotics, not sure if the watch you’re interested in has an in house movement…..good article for you to read
http://www.google.co.uk/url?sa=t&rct=j&q=&...
Apologies to the op Cartier are indeed making their own movements in house for their exotics, not sure if the watch you’re interested in has an in house movement…..good article for you to read
http://www.google.co.uk/url?sa=t&rct=j&q=&...
michael gould said:
I’m a bit anal when it comes to watches.....I think the majority of people who pay 4 or 5k for a watch with a recognised brand or a fashion house such as Cartier don't realise that it has the same movement in as a £500 Tissot .......it's a racket that fashion houses have got away with for years. I am a victim to this con as I own a Chanel J12 which has an ETA movement in and it’s a good watch, but, at £4500 you’re paying £750 to the tax man.....£2000 to the retailer, The watch probably cost £300 to produce...... Chanel have nothing to do with watches....they are maximising the value of their iconic brand.
Apologies to the op Cartier are indeed making their own movements in house for their exotics, not sure if the watch you’re interested in has an in house movement…..good article for you to read
http://www.google.co.uk/url?sa=t&rct=j&q=&...
A watch is a watch, so what if the manufacturer makes things other than watches? If people like it, good luck to them. Oh no Zonda buy a bought in engine, don't buy one they are sApologies to the op Cartier are indeed making their own movements in house for their exotics, not sure if the watch you’re interested in has an in house movement…..good article for you to read
http://www.google.co.uk/url?sa=t&rct=j&q=&...
t, buy a Toyota, they make their own.Back to the topic at hand (!)
The watch itself is an iconic design, so having a flagship when it bows out is obviously good PR for them (when was the last Cartier thread on PH?) and will be made in such small numbers, I am sure there are a sufficient number of afficianados who will buy.
I imagine the sort who will already own a flying panda will do so, even if us mere mortals can only look on with envy.
The watch itself is an iconic design, so having a flagship when it bows out is obviously good PR for them (when was the last Cartier thread on PH?) and will be made in such small numbers, I am sure there are a sufficient number of afficianados who will buy.
I imagine the sort who will already own a flying panda will do so, even if us mere mortals can only look on with envy.
obob said:
michael gould said:
I’m a bit anal when it comes to watches.....I think the majority of people who pay 4 or 5k for a watch with a recognised brand or a fashion house such as Cartier don't realise that it has the same movement in as a £500 Tissot .......it's a racket that fashion houses have got away with for years. I am a victim to this con as I own a Chanel J12 which has an ETA movement in and it’s a good watch, but, at £4500 you’re paying £750 to the tax man.....£2000 to the retailer, The watch probably cost £300 to produce...... Chanel have nothing to do with watches....they are maximising the value of their iconic brand.
Apologies to the op Cartier are indeed making their own movements in house for their exotics, not sure if the watch you’re interested in has an in house movement…..good article for you to read
http://www.google.co.uk/url?sa=t&rct=j&q=&...
A watch is a watch, so what if the manufacturer makes things other than watches? If people like it, good luck to them. Oh no Zonda buy a bought in engine, don't buy one they are sApologies to the op Cartier are indeed making their own movements in house for their exotics, not sure if the watch you’re interested in has an in house movement…..good article for you to read
http://www.google.co.uk/url?sa=t&rct=j&q=&...
t, buy a Toyota, they make their own.
RudeDog said:
A very naive, wannabe elitist viewpoint that Michael. Cartier are doing some ground breaking stuff, you should broaden your horizons...
http://www.watchalyzer.com/magazine/news-events/ca...
That is beautiful...I hope it turns out like the Tag Monaco V4 concept and makes it into production! Anyone care to guess a price for that?http://www.watchalyzer.com/magazine/news-events/ca...
michael gould said:
for me part of the ownership is about a brands history and the craftsmanship that went into making the watch or car. But according to my wife I’m nearly always wrong, so probably am with my opinions on watches and cars 
Well as you showed your ignorance for the history of the brand and workmanship that goes into the inhouse tourbillon movement, your wife is right 

Gassing Station | Watches | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff



