370Z vs. E46 M3
Author
Discussion

S3000

Original Poster:

513 posts

190 months

Friday 15th March 2013
quotequote all
They have almost identical weight and power.. however Nissan is the newer car, can it be comparable with a older M3 ?

Kong

1,503 posts

202 months

Friday 15th March 2013
quotequote all
They will probably cost about the same to run with heavier maintenance on the M3 but worse depreciation on the Nissan. The M3 is more practical but the Nissan will have more modern features. Guess it depends on your needs and which you prefer.

fastka

156 posts

219 months

Friday 15th March 2013
quotequote all
e46 M3 every day of the week.

other than the subframe fault (which can be remedied for not a great deal of money and time) they are superb in every respect.

the 370Z is essentially, just a nice two seater.

kambites

71,726 posts

252 months

Friday 15th March 2013
quotequote all
Never driven a 370Z, but I understand it to be pretty good. I'd suggest that you need to drive both and see which you prefer.

Fastdruid

9,417 posts

183 months

Friday 15th March 2013
quotequote all
M3 is a tarted up and tuned reps car and compromised and expensive because of it.
370Z is purpose designed to be what it is and so cheaper.

The M3 will cost more to run, insurance will be higher. Servicing costs will be higher and as a ' halo' model all the parts will be much more expensive than the std 3 series. Depreciation likely to be lower however and despite imo being overrated they are fantastic cars.

rb5er

11,657 posts

203 months

Friday 15th March 2013
quotequote all
kambites said:
Never driven a 370Z, but I understand it to be pretty good. I'd suggest that you need to drive both and see which you prefer.
+1

blade7

11,311 posts

247 months

Friday 15th March 2013
quotequote all
An old Jap car v an old German car, which one was built to last past the first MOT whistle

rb5er

11,657 posts

203 months

Friday 15th March 2013
quotequote all
blade7 said:
An old Jap car v an old German car, which one was built to last past the first MOT whistle
Since when was the 370z an old Jap car?

billzeebub

3,913 posts

230 months

Friday 15th March 2013
quotequote all
E46 M3

EddieFelson

1,168 posts

245 months

Friday 15th March 2013
quotequote all
E46 M3

mackie1

8,169 posts

264 months

Friday 15th March 2013
quotequote all
Surely the Z4 M Coupe has to be in the running too?

jontysafe

2,370 posts

209 months

Friday 15th March 2013
quotequote all
One has one of the best, if not THE best naturally aspirated six cylinder engines ever put in a standard road car. The other, erm doesn`t. Rev them both through to the red line and your ears will choose for you.

JonathanLegard

5,196 posts

268 months

Friday 15th March 2013
quotequote all
The E46 M3 is better in virtually every dynamic regard here.

gaz1234

5,233 posts

250 months

Friday 15th March 2013
quotequote all
no comparision

vz-r_dave

3,469 posts

249 months

Friday 15th March 2013
quotequote all
Top gear track

370 = 1:27.50
E46 M3 = 1:31.80

Better in every way? Really?

fastka

156 posts

219 months

Friday 15th March 2013
quotequote all
oh dear, slightly slower around a track... so what?

in the M, you've taken your family and luggage to the track.
in the Z, you've taken the girlfriend.

M3 all the way.

poing

8,743 posts

231 months

Friday 15th March 2013
quotequote all
fastka said:
oh dear, slightly slower around a track... so what?

in the M, you've taken your family and luggage to the track.
in the Z, you've taken the girlfriend.

M3 all the way.
For that exact reason, Z all the way! The wife and kids stay at home while you and the girlfriend go have some fun.

Edit to add: Heart would say Z, head would say M3. Not sure which I'd pick but it's a nice choice to make.

JonathanLegard

5,196 posts

268 months

Friday 15th March 2013
quotequote all
vz-r_dave said:
Top gear track

370 = 1:27.50
E46 M3 = 1:31.80

Better in every way? Really?
Yep. Drive the two cars and then if you really can claim the 370Z to be the better handling car I will graciously accept that you have no clue how to assess a chassis. wink

Only kidding. The 370Z might be a little quicker but in all the areas that matter, it comes up short compared to the M3. If you'd tried the two cars, you probably wouldn't have to ask this question.

FWIW, I think the 370Z is a step backwards from the 350Z.

CampDavid

9,145 posts

229 months

Friday 15th March 2013
quotequote all
anonymous said:
[redacted]
Are they not definitive?

Anyhoo, driven neither but the 370 is a good car, the BMW though has the reputation of being a great car.

The run out CS models are really difficult to look passed IMO

Mastodon2

14,346 posts

196 months

Friday 15th March 2013
quotequote all
From what I gather, the engine in the E46 M3 is an absolute gem. No review I've read has lavished the same praise on the 370Z. Tbh, of the two I'd go for the M3 every time. I don't see it as being any more "compromised" than a 370Z. The BMW might have back seats and a large boot which I know to some people is a big no no, but the 370Z is a two seater that weighs as much as the M3 saloon, so despite the compromises of less practicality, it's not going to be a weapon in comparison to the M3.

I know some people will always say "Car X is compromised, it has a boot, seats, air con etc", but if you really cared about not having any "compromises" you'd be in a Caterham Superlight.