Heuer Carrera re-edition valuation query
Heuer Carrera re-edition valuation query
Author
Discussion

stemarsden

Original Poster:

31 posts

188 months

Wednesday 20th March 2013
quotequote all
I have a Heuer Carrera re-edition 2 chronograph that I bought in 1999.

After many house insurance renewals and me thinking 'I must get my watch valued'; I bit the bullet and had it valued yesterday.
I have been out of the watch market for ages now and see that 'Grand Carreras' seem to be the flavour of the month.

I bought the watch because I really wanted an original but could not afford it.

Is there a market for these watches now?
Personally, I like fact it's very similar to the original, but it does not seem to desirable compared to the massive Grand Carrera's.

Any thoughts on this?
Or even a stab at a valuation? (mine will take 10 days to receive)

GC8

19,910 posts

221 months

Wednesday 20th March 2013
quotequote all
New for old surely, so current fashion shouldnt affect this?

aeropilot

40,913 posts

258 months

Saturday 23rd March 2013
quotequote all
stemarsden said:
Is there a market for these watches now?
Personally, I like fact it's very similar to the original, but it does not seem to desirable compared to the massive Grand Carrera's.
Manual wind version I pressume?
If so, they don't seem to hang around long when they do come up for sale on the well known used specialists, so I'd say there is definately a market for them.

Price depends on which version it is, as well whether it has original box, papers etc.

s/s black face seem to sell quickest from what I've noticed, silver face and other versions slightly less so.
Price in dealers seem to vary between £1600-1800.

andy tims

5,606 posts

277 months

Saturday 23rd March 2013
quotequote all
Sold my one of these for £1,100 in 2008



It was mint / full set

GC8

19,910 posts

221 months

Saturday 23rd March 2013
quotequote all
Stephen, as an example I have a manual 1965 Omega Seamaster. It is valued against a Speedmaster for the purposes of insurance replacement. Their used values are very different, but a new for old policy provides a new watch where the old one was lost and that is the only manual wind watch that they offer.

I have another Seamaster and a Chronostop which are also pegged to manual Speedmaster prices now since the Railmaster XL was discontinued. Hopefully I wont have to claim for all three because I will end up with at least one more Speedy than a fellow can wear.

So, find a current Carrera which has all of the features, dont undersell your own because a Heuer-marked re-edition cant be replaced new, and send it off to the insurers.

Unless you have an unusual indemnity policy, do not value your Heuer used then propose a new TAG Heuer which retails at that value!

stemarsden

Original Poster:

31 posts

188 months

Wednesday 27th March 2013
quotequote all
aeropilot said:
Manual wind version I pressume?
If so, they don't seem to hang around long when they do come up for sale on the well known used specialists, so I'd say there is definately a market for them.

Price depends on which version it is, as well whether it has original box, papers etc.

s/s black face seem to sell quickest from what I've noticed, silver face and other versions slightly less so.
Price in dealers seem to vary between £1600-1800.
Thanks aero,
Yes it's a manual wind version with original sales invoice, guarantee card, boxes, instructions etc and it IS the black face version too.

The only issues are that it now runs stupidly fast (plus 5 mins per 24 hours), leather straps are becoming worn and the plexi-glass face has some damage in the corner.

I have been quoted circa £420 to replace the plexi-glass only from a well known jewellers in Chester.
Should I get it serviced and the straps replaced at the same time?

stemarsden

Original Poster:

31 posts

188 months

Wednesday 27th March 2013
quotequote all
GC8 said:
Stephen, as an example I have a manual 1965 Omega Seamaster. It is valued against a Speedmaster for the purposes of insurance replacement. Their used values are very different, but a new for old policy provides a new watch where the old one was lost and that is the only manual wind watch that they offer.

I have another Seamaster and a Chronostop which are also pegged to manual Speedmaster prices now since the Railmaster XL was discontinued. Hopefully I wont have to claim for all three because I will end up with at least one more Speedy than a fellow can wear.

So, find a current Carrera which has all of the features, dont undersell your own because a Heuer-marked re-edition cant be replaced new, and send it off to the insurers.

Unless you have an unusual indemnity policy, do not value your Heuer used then propose a new TAG Heuer which retails at that value!
Sound advice, thank you, I had not thought of that.

aeropilot

40,913 posts

258 months

Wednesday 27th March 2013
quotequote all
stemarsden said:
Should I get it serviced and the straps replaced at the same time?
I'd say yes.
(But make sure you keep the original strap as well for if you do sell it. I've seen a couple at dealers advertised with replacement strap fitted, but includes original strap with boxes/paperwork etc)

GCH

4,142 posts

233 months

Wednesday 27th March 2013
quotequote all
stemarsden said:
I have the same watch.
I have been quoted circa £420 to replace the plexi-glass only from a well known jewellers in Chester.
Should I get it serviced and the straps replaced at the same time?
A replacement plexi itself costs about £3. That is an outrageous price just for that, and is more than a service from TAG would cost. Are you sure they havent quoted you for a sapphire by mistake?

Servicing isnt too specialist- IIRC the lemania 1783 you have is the same movement as the 1861 as fitted to the omega speedmaster moonwatch.

Try some polywatch/brasso on the crystal- it should make a huge difference unless it is really deep. I have only ever had to replace plexi crystals when they are actually cracked- scratches have always come out.

I played the replacement 'official' strap game for some time- I found that the heuer ones dont last particularly long and are expensive for what they are, so I use an aftermarket large holed racing strap instead with the original buckle and keep the original one in the box with the paperwork for when I sell it on. Plenty of high quality aftermarket straps available out there.


Edited by GCH on Wednesday 27th March 12:17

GC8

19,910 posts

221 months

Wednesday 27th March 2013
quotequote all
stemarsden said:
GC8 said:
Stephen, as an example I have a manual 1965 Omega Seamaster. It is valued against a Speedmaster for the purposes of insurance replacement. Their used values are very different, but a new for old policy provides a new watch where the old one was lost and that is the only manual wind watch that they offer.

I have another Seamaster and a Chronostop which are also pegged to manual Speedmaster prices now since the Railmaster XL was discontinued. Hopefully I wont have to claim for all three because I will end up with at least one more Speedy than a fellow can wear.

So, find a current Carrera which has all of the features, dont undersell your own because a Heuer-marked re-edition cant be replaced new, and send it off to the insurers.

Unless you have an unusual indemnity policy, do not value your Heuer used then propose a new TAG Heuer which retails at that value!
Sound advice, thank you, I had not thought of that.
I will add, for clarity which is missing in my original post, that Im encouraging you to find a new TAG Heuer with the same features and to submit the price of this new watch to your insurance company. This may be £3,000 and your Heuer marked re-edition may be worth £1,000 now, but this is how it goes. Do not look for a new TAG Heuer model chrono which sells for £1,200 new and propose this, solely because its the same price as your used watch is worth in the example that I have used.

New for old is always about features, and damn the cost.

stemarsden

Original Poster:

31 posts

188 months

Wednesday 27th March 2013
quotequote all
GCH said:
A replacement plexi itself costs about £3. That is an outrageous price just for that, and is more than a service from TAG would cost. Are you sure they havent quoted you for a sapphire by mistake?

Servicing isnt too specialist- IIRC the lemania 1783 you have is the same movement as the 1861 as fitted to the omega speedmaster moonwatch.

Try some polywatch/brasso on the crystal- it should make a huge difference unless it is really deep. I have only ever had to replace plexi crystals when they are actually cracked- scratches have always come out.

I played the replacement 'official' strap game for some time- I found that the heuer ones dont last particularly long and are expensive for what they are, so I use an aftermarket large holed racing strap instead with the original buckle and keep the original one in the box with the paperwork for when I sell it on. Plenty of high quality aftermarket straps available out there.


Edited by GCH on Wednesday 27th March 12:17
The plexi glass IS actually cracked and would need to be replaced rather than polished. Where would you buy a replacement from? And where would you recommend for the watch to be serviced?
I'm guessing there will be someone out there that can quote me for both.

I have also been searching for replacement straps too, anyone you have used before that you would recommend too?

stemarsden

Original Poster:

31 posts

188 months

Wednesday 27th March 2013
quotequote all
GC8 said:
I will add, for clarity which is missing in my original post, that Im encouraging you to find a new TAG Heuer with the same features and to submit the price of this new watch to your insurance company. This may be £3,000 and your Heuer marked re-edition may be worth £1,000 now, but this is how it goes. Do not look for a new TAG Heuer model chrono which sells for £1,200 new and propose this, solely because its the same price as your used watch is worth in the example that I have used.

New for old is always about features, and damn the cost.
Thanks again GC8.
I have been looking at this:
http://www.thewatchhut.co.uk/TAG-Heuer-Gents-Carre...
which has nearly all of the same features BUT is automatic.

Should this be what I would be looking at to replace my current watch with new? (in the event of a loss)

Soir

2,277 posts

270 months

Thursday 28th March 2013
quotequote all
andy tims said:
Sold my one of these for £1,100 in 2008



It was mint / full set
I have the same one as this but with white/silver face. £1100 - oh bugger!

edit to add : I actually prefer the black one!

Whitean3

2,197 posts

229 months

Thursday 28th March 2013
quotequote all
Soir said:
andy tims said:
Sold my one of these for £1,100 in 2008



It was mint / full set
I have the same one as this but with white/silver face. £1100 - oh bugger!

edit to add : I actually prefer the black one!
I was after a white/silver re edition for a while but there didn't seem to be any on the market! Anyway, from my searches, I would think that 1200-1800 gbp would be the going rate, depending very much on condition and full box, papers etc in top condition. I ouldthink that if yours isingood nick with box and papers, you'd be looking at 1400-1500

Soir

2,277 posts

270 months

Saturday 6th April 2013
quotequote all
Whitean3 said:
Soir said:
andy tims said:
Sold my one of these for £1,100 in 2008



It was mint / full set
I have the same one as this but with white/silver face. £1100 - oh bugger!

edit to add : I actually prefer the black one!
I was after a white/silver re edition for a while but there didn't seem to be any on the market! Anyway, from my searches, I would think that 1200-1800 gbp would be the going rate, depending very much on condition and full box, papers etc in top condition. I ouldthink that if yours isingood nick with box and papers, you'd be looking at 1400-1500
Many thanks, that does make me feel a bit better!


GC8

19,910 posts

221 months

Saturday 6th April 2013
quotequote all
stemarsden said:
GC8 said:
I will add, for clarity which is missing in my original post, that Im encouraging you to find a new TAG Heuer with the same features and to submit the price of this new watch to your insurance company. This may be £3,000 and your Heuer marked re-edition may be worth £1,000 now, but this is how it goes. Do not look for a new TAG Heuer model chrono which sells for £1,200 new and propose this, solely because its the same price as your used watch is worth in the example that I have used.

New for old is always about features, and damn the cost.
Thanks again GC8.
I have been looking at this:
http://www.thewatchhut.co.uk/TAG-Heuer-Gents-Carre...
which has nearly all of the same features BUT is automatic.

Should this be what I would be looking at to replace my current watch with new? (in the event of a loss)
Something like that - youve got the right idea, but Im not sure whether that is the most suitable replacement. Id be looking for the dearest watch that I was able to justify thropugh features or range position (even though this means higher premiums), because its always better to have a little to give up should it come to a fight.