Solar charger - will it work?
Solar charger - will it work?
Author
Discussion

Kentish

Original Poster:

15,169 posts

265 months

Wednesday 3rd April 2013
quotequote all
My BMW battery is getting a little tired and I don't have the time to change it at the moment (buried in the boot and has to be coded by BMW after installation) so have considered plugging in my solar briefcase 2W charger.

However, the cigar lighter is not live with the ignition off, so will it be trickle charging the car or not?

I have an opinion on this but wouldn't mind some others; thanks! smile

renrut

1,478 posts

236 months

Wednesday 3rd April 2013
quotequote all
Can't help much but how on earth is a battery coded to a car?!? Surely its just 12V +ve and -ve?

Kentish

Original Poster:

15,169 posts

265 months

Wednesday 3rd April 2013
quotequote all
renrut said:
Can't help much but how on earth is a battery coded to a car?!? Surely its just 12V +ve and -ve?
They basically set up the charging rate to match the battery; unless it is exactly the same - it could damage the battery or alternator, apparently.

New battery technology and higher output batteries require different charging rates, so I can kind of see why.

renrut

1,478 posts

236 months

Wednesday 3rd April 2013
quotequote all
Really? I'm surprised as I would have thought the charging rate could be very different for the same battery just in different weather (hot vs cold etc) so doesn't seem sensible to me but I don't design these things.

FWIW a 2W charger won't do an awful lot to a typical 72Ah 12V car battery. 2W @ 12V is about 0.2A and would take ~15 days to fully charge at constant maximum sunshine. If its gonna sit idle for a while and you can position it in sunshine then it might be worth hooking it up.

But the cig sockets are switched lives so need the ignition on to allow current to pass either way.

Dr Interceptor

8,183 posts

227 months

Wednesday 3rd April 2013
quotequote all
Is there an accessory socket in the boot? On some cars that remains live while the cigar socket in the cabin switches off....

Kentish

Original Poster:

15,169 posts

265 months

Wednesday 3rd April 2013
quotequote all
Dr Interceptor said:
Is there an accessory socket in the boot? On some cars that remains live while the cigar socket in the cabin switches off....
Not sure the solar panel will work in the boot wink


zcacogp

11,239 posts

275 months

Wednesday 3rd April 2013
quotequote all
No, it won't. The rating of the solar charger will be VERY optimistic, and taken under unrealistically ideal conditions. Given the fall-off of output from cheap solar cells in less than ideal conditions you'll struggle to achieve any type of output at all from them. Put them behind another layer of glass (i.e. inside the car) and they may make a very sensitive ammeter twitch, but won't put anything worth having into your battery.

Don't bother. (And I speak from experience.)


Oli.

PhillipM

6,564 posts

220 months

Wednesday 3rd April 2013
quotequote all
If it was a 30W panel, maybe, but a 2 watt panel will barely do anything when the conditions are taken into account (i.e. realistically it might average half a watt if you're lucky)

SV8Predator

2,102 posts

196 months

Wednesday 3rd April 2013
quotequote all
renrut said:
Can't help much but how on earth is a battery coded to a car?!? Surely its just 12V +ve and -ve?
This is becoming more common now. BMWs have had it for a while though. There are aftermarket electronic tools that will do the 'battery config'. Different requirements for different marques, but if the car has start-stop technology it will certainly need to have a new battery properly set up and configured. Sometimes the battery's serial number has to be entered to ensure that the battery is the correct type, model and capacity.

If the ECU has been carefully managing and charging a battery that is past its best, and then this battery is changed for a brand new one, the charging requirements are completely different. Plus (as I said) the new battery has to be the correct type, it may have to be an AGM for example (and not a standard flooded lead acid type)and the ECU wants confirmation of this.

Edited by SV8Predator on Wednesday 3rd April 20:13

Darkcat

2,354 posts

201 months

Wednesday 3rd April 2013
quotequote all
SV8Predator said:
This is becoming more common now. BMWs have had it for a while though. There are aftermarket electronic tools that will do the 'battery config'. Different requirements for different marques, but if the car has start-stop technology it will certainly need to have a new battery properly set up and configured. Sometimes the battery's serial number has to be entered to ensure that the battery is the correct type, model and capacity.
Jesus, its really starting to get silly isnt it...

Battery -> fat wire -> Alternator : has worked for nearly 100 years.

And OP, no, the clock & alarm will probably drain more than 2W anyway, so would have nearly no effect.

Edited by Darkcat on Wednesday 3rd April 20:11

SV8Predator

2,102 posts

196 months

Wednesday 3rd April 2013
quotequote all
Darkcat said:
Jesus, its really starting to get silly isnt it...
Battery -> fat wire -> Alternator : has worked for nearly 100 years.
I don't think there were many alternators about 100 years ago, but I take your point.

Darkcat said:
And OP, no, the clock & alarm will probably drain more than 2W anyway, so would have nearly no effect.
This is certainly correct and a very good response to the original question.

Turkey

382 posts

215 months

Wednesday 3rd April 2013
quotequote all
The average drain on most moderns cars is around 0.5W i have found. From experience with a 1.8W solar charger, it will not maintain the battery on mine (75Ah non AGM).

I would be looking at a 10-20W charger to be confident of the battery not discharging over time when the car is left idle, you could check on Ebay for one if you want to.

As said before, if your lighter socket is not live with the ignition on, then you can't charge the battery through it with a solar charger, but an auxiliary power socket could work, you could always run the cable from the boot to the cabin.

On mine, I ran some cables to the battery, and fed them through a rubber grommet between the bulkhead and the cabin, and through to the rear parcel shelf - I used velcro to fix the panel to the parcel shelf.

Kentish

Original Poster:

15,169 posts

265 months

Wednesday 3rd April 2013
quotequote all
I have it connected direct to the jump starting connections & it seems to help, probably only in that its partially topping up what is being drained by all the electronics.

I think the car had what BMW call IBS.

For the intelligent battery system you've also got to tell it that a new battery has been fitted - it alters how it charges as the battery ages. So one way or another it's got to be connected to a computer.


SV8Predator

2,102 posts

196 months

Wednesday 3rd April 2013
quotequote all
Kentish said:
For the intelligent battery system you've also got to tell it that a new battery has been fitted - it alters how it charges as the battery ages. So one way or another it's got to be connected to a computer.
Yes that is correct, as I explained a few posts previously.

hman

7,497 posts

225 months

Wednesday 3rd April 2013
quotequote all
Buy a new identical battery, fit it, don't bother coding it.

Worked for me in my e60, you can try unplugging the IBS if you are getting battery drain problems as these ironically drain the battery when they malfunction instead of saving you from a flat battery as they are designed to do.

Dr Interceptor

8,183 posts

227 months

Thursday 4th April 2013
quotequote all
Kentish said:
Not sure the solar panel will work in the boot wink
I could sit in the rear screen, put the cord through the seats, and plug into the boot.

hman

7,497 posts

225 months

Thursday 4th April 2013
quotequote all
Seriously if your battery is weak then you need a new battery.


Any other "fix" is bullst.

Kentish

Original Poster:

15,169 posts

265 months

Thursday 4th April 2013
quotequote all
Dr Interceptor said:
I could sit in the rear screen, put the cord through the seats, and plug into the boot.
That's very kind of you but are you sure you'd be comfortable enough wedged in behind the rear headrests? wink

Dr Interceptor

8,183 posts

227 months

Thursday 4th April 2013
quotequote all
Kentish said:
That's very kind of you but are you sure you'd be comfortable enough wedged in behind the rear headrests? wink
laugh

  • it*

Kentish

Original Poster:

15,169 posts

265 months

Thursday 4th April 2013
quotequote all
hman said:
Seriously if your battery is weak then you need a new battery.


Any other "fix" is bullst.
Yes I know, it ultimately needs replacing but I've not had the time to book it in at my local BMW dealers yet, it's not a 5 minute job on my car. They'll have it in for the day. It's also in the region of £300 to have a replacement fitted & coded.

The solar panel is doing its job at the moment.

It's not that bad yet, I expect it wouldn't have even been a problem had the weather been warmer.

Anyway, I'll get it booked in for next week.