Tough call - have to decide between 2 cars I own. Help!
Tough call - have to decide between 2 cars I own. Help!
Author
Discussion

mattyprice4004

Original Poster:

1,342 posts

205 months

Sunday 7th April 2013
quotequote all
Well guys, as a lot of you will see a fair bit I tend to buy cheap British cars to either repair, run for 6 months and sell, or break for parts.

I appear to have acquired a rather nice 75 Tourer CDTi for a rock-bottom price, I only really realised what I'd done when it was on the drive as I was heavily hungover. smile

It's a 51 plate Connoisseur model, so has the usual dual climate and HiLine IPK plus parking sensors, auto wipers and auto dim-dip mirror. No Xenons though.

The reason it was cheap was due to a knackered clutch system (owner had fitted a new master cylinder, however the slave was the actual cause. £500+ job so he flogged it) and the ABS light was on.
The speedo also didn't work, and after lots of end-to-end wiring checks and head-scratching I paid a fiver for a new ABS modulator and voila, everything works.

New clutch system to be fitted - fitting the tougher Freelander Slave cylinder and a Freelander TD4 clutch assembly. This will cost about £150 inc fluids and tools.

The issue I have is I currently own a rather nice Rover 600 diesel. I'm not a massive 600 fan, however it does the job and has the half-leather Recaro interior from the 620ti.

My issue is - what would you choose to keep?

In the 600s favour:
- Rock solid clutch and transmission (rarely gives issue) rather than the cheese-based system on the 75
- Most parts are quite cheap, lots of Land Rover parts fit the L series diesel engine. Parts for the 75 seem more expensive
- Maintenance work seems much easier (when bolts aren't rusted!), some simple jobs on the 75 are just ridiculous to do.

In the 75s favour:
- Massively, massively comfy
- It has a sunroof!
- Lots of toys
- Does the same MPG as the 600
- It's an estate, again really handy

Some stats (we all love them!)
MPG: 600 - 49MPG, 75 - 47MPG
0-60: Pretty much the same, about 10 minutes
Insurance: Pretty much the same
VED: 600 - £230, 75 - £170
Tyres: 600 - £52/corner, 75 - £44/corner (Nankang NS2, I quite like them)
Miles on the clock: 600 - 102k, 75 - 160k

Finally, some pictures:





Cheers smile

fjord

2,143 posts

168 months

Sunday 7th April 2013
quotequote all
You really do have stylish taste in cars... rolleyes

Jimbo.

4,238 posts

220 months

Sunday 7th April 2013
quotequote all
fjord said:
You really do have stylish taste in cars... rolleyes
PH: The home of friendly motoring advice.

OP: Keep the 600. Less trouble (cost!) in the long run smile

Matt UK

18,084 posts

231 months

Sunday 7th April 2013
quotequote all
Keep the 600 and sell the 75 for a profit now you have sorted the issues.

Biker's Nemesis

41,487 posts

239 months

Sunday 7th April 2013
quotequote all
Yep, sell the 75.

mattyprice4004

Original Poster:

1,342 posts

205 months

Sunday 7th April 2013
quotequote all
fjord said:
You really do have stylish taste in cars... rolleyes
Well, aren't you a charming individual. I choose cars based on my knowledge of what's under the bonnet, not how many women I pick up.

Have a universally accepted salt-shaker symbol... smile

To everyone else, thank you for your input. I was debating selling the 75, purely as it's worth a grand or slightly more (depending how 'perfect' I can get it..!)

vrooom

3,763 posts

298 months

Sunday 7th April 2013
quotequote all
I would run 75. but then 600 is good.

mattyprice4004

Original Poster:

1,342 posts

205 months

Sunday 7th April 2013
quotequote all
vrooom said:
I would run 75. but then 600 is good.
Forgot to mention this, but I'm going to run the 75 for a few months over summer and then sell in Autumn - the air con in the 600 is totally dead.

fjord

2,143 posts

168 months

Sunday 7th April 2013
quotequote all
mattyprice4004 said:
Well, aren't you a charming individual. I choose cars based on my knowledge of what's under the bonnet, not how many women I pick up.

Have a universally accepted salt-shaker symbol... smile

To everyone else, thank you for your input. I was debating selling the 75, purely as it's worth a grand or slightly more (depending how 'perfect' I can get it..!)
I've got a spare copy of readers digest if you want it?

I might even have an old packet of Werther's knocking about too.

mattyprice4004

Original Poster:

1,342 posts

205 months

Sunday 7th April 2013
quotequote all
fjord said:
I've got a spare copy of readers digest if you want it?

I might even have an old packet of Werther's knocking about too.
Will go perfectly with my box of tissues, my trilby and my pipe, cheers.

Interested in the Digest too - more books, more sl*ts? Works for doors and wes! wink

Zerotonine

1,171 posts

205 months

Sunday 7th April 2013
quotequote all
Personally I would keep the 600.

soprano

1,613 posts

231 months

Sunday 7th April 2013
quotequote all
fjord said:
You really do have stylish taste in cars... rolleyes
Do you still have a 320d?

fatboy69

9,424 posts

218 months

Sunday 7th April 2013
quotequote all
Give me the 75 to look after for a while!!

Quite like that car tbh.


Figgle

86 posts

166 months

Sunday 7th April 2013
quotequote all
I personally would keep the 75 but purely because its an estate and waaaay more practical than the saloon. But if you're not too fussed about that the general consensus seems to be flog the 75 for profit and keep the 600.

Good luck

AmitG

3,572 posts

191 months

Sunday 7th April 2013
quotequote all
It's a tough one but personally I would keep the 75. It seems to come down to "easier maintenance" versus "better car". Maintenance is an occasional pain whereas driving the car is something you do every day. The jobs on the 75 are harder but are presumably not impossible given your skills. Plus the estate shape is more versatile. So, 75 for me.

I do have a real soft spot for old Rovers paperbag

pad58

12,549 posts

212 months

Sunday 7th April 2013
quotequote all
I'd keep the estate,practical and estates are so now.

fjord

2,143 posts

168 months

Sunday 7th April 2013
quotequote all
soprano said:
Do you still have a 320d?
Got an mx5 with winter tyres (top of the range of course, £200 a corner). I popped a remapped 335d engine in for good measure.

ging84

9,548 posts

177 months

Sunday 7th April 2013
quotequote all
no where in that story does it tell you the rover 75 is gold
if you had put the photos at the top you could have saved me a lot of reading

poo at Paul's

14,621 posts

206 months

Sunday 7th April 2013
quotequote all
fjord said:
You really do have stylish taste in cars... rolleyes
What a fking nobcheese!

DubZeus

1,401 posts

249 months

Sunday 7th April 2013
quotequote all
Sell the 75, its worth more