Alfa Romeo GTV - how can these be so expensive to run
Alfa Romeo GTV - how can these be so expensive to run
Author
Discussion

Baryonyx

Original Poster:

18,295 posts

190 months

Sunday 7th April 2013
quotequote all
Afternoon all,

As I have recently mentioned, Mrs Baryonyx has been looking for a new car. She has always wanted a coupe of some sort, having driven hatchbacks for the past 8 years. Now, she has set her sights on an Audi TT. Me, I'd rather have an Alfa Romeo GTV on my drive.

I was out for a stroll yesterday when I spotted a bloke working on an 2.0TS GTV on his drives. He was working on the rear suspension, and I commented that it was a nice car (I've seen it locally, always polished clean and with a cherished plate despite probably only being worth £1500, at the most). He said he liked the car, but that it was a nightmare to keep on the road, and hoovered up way more cash than you'd expect, though he was persevering despite having his wallet battered regularly by the Italian coupe.


It seems this is a common perception about these cars (or in this bloke's case, a common experience). I've read plenty of opinions saying they are just as reliable as any other car, if you look after them. I've read others saying they are frail things, and problems both big and small will arise regularly. Tellingly, I read something along the lines of "every GTV is a £4000 GTV. If you pay £1000 for a GTV, you'll spend the other £3000 putting it right". Hardly confidence inspiring. I just don't see how it can be such an unreliable car. It contains nothing of any real complexity, as far as I can see. A N/A engine, no fanciful electrics, no air suspension, no active dampers. It's as complex as a Ford Sierra, despite being much older. So why do they go wrong so much?


I'd love to get one. It would make a nice alternative to my Rallye. Something comfortable and sleek for the rare occasion when I don't want to drive the Peugeot. I wouldn't be after a 3.0 V6, this would be the wife's car, and she wouldn't appreciate picking up that fuel bill. Her eyes popped out of her head when she looked back on my A8's fuel receipts!

excel monkey

4,825 posts

258 months

Tuesday 23rd April 2013
quotequote all
Baryonyx said:
As I have recently mentioned, Mrs Baryonyx has been looking for a new car. She has always wanted a coupe of some sort, having driven hatchbacks for the past 8 years. Now, she has set her sights on an Audi TT. Me, I'd rather have an Alfa Romeo GTV on my drive.
Call me a spineless wuss, but I reckon your life would be a lot easier if you just bought what she wanted, rather than what you think she ought to have. If/when the GTV breaks, you'll never hear the last of it.

The TT is a nice car, and clean Mk1s are emerging modern classics.

ImpossiblyDaft

399 posts

212 months

Tuesday 23rd April 2013
quotequote all
Assuming you're talking about the '90s model rather than the classic ones, wear and tear items need doing more frequently than on other brands rather than anything else - cambelts twice as often, the suspension bushes rarely last, etc. and at main dealer prices that obviously builds up fast.

trashbat

6,318 posts

184 months

Tuesday 23rd April 2013
quotequote all
The cars weren't cheap when new, and now they are in comparison to their peers, but the servicing is still proportional to the original price. The suspension is more complex and certainly more fragile than many of those cars too.

Apart from that, my view on this is that Alfas, and certainly the ones you notice, are typically owned by people who have an above average interest in their car - usually keeping it healthy for the long term. This isn't necessarily sound economics. It also means they spend more than they absolutely need to in any case; e.g. I do oil changes twice as often as I probably must. It hasn't gone wrong either, but keeping it far from wrongness has certainly cost me.

As another example, I've recently spent £800 on suspension work for a car that's notionally worth £2000. I say notionally because I couldn't buy another one in the same sorted condition for that, so what's it really worth? Still £2000.

If it's a GTV with a TS engine, it must be at least ten years old? That's probably beyond the average lifespan of the UK car, so in a way, what do you expect?

I've got a blow-by-blow account of my Alfa 156 here that isn't the worst by any means, but will still make you squirm: http://www.pistonheads.com/members/showServiceHist...

SturdyHSV

10,443 posts

198 months

Tuesday 23rd April 2013
quotequote all
I've had the V6 for just under 2 years, and have spent about £800 on unexpected repairs in that time.

This doesn't include the actual servicing cost, which isn't that much really, and a cambelt change.

It's done about 5,000 miles in that time, so probably a bit under used to be honest.

In fact, over the winter it developed a flickering dash light due to I think a dodgy connection to an ABS sensor, which now that I've driven it more, has completely resolved itself.

Naturally it's also reasonably expensive to insure (although not bad at all on a multi car policy thankfully), fairly thirsty (mercifully there's no mpg gauge, so it doesn't matter) and VED is ~£250 (to some people, this is really important for some odd reason...)

There is absolutely no good reason for me to have the car, I walk to work, and have a bigger toy, but it's just gorgeous, I love it, and it sounds laugh out loud brilliant. As in, I genuinely exclaim and pull faces on almost every drive biggrin

underphil

1,362 posts

241 months

Tuesday 23rd April 2013
quotequote all
I had one (V6) for five years, spent loads on it!! - no regrets though

Baryonyx

Original Poster:

18,295 posts

190 months

Tuesday 23rd April 2013
quotequote all
excel monkey said:
Call me a spineless wuss, but I reckon your life would be a lot easier if you just bought what she wanted, rather than what you think she ought to have. If/when the GTV breaks, you'll never hear the last of it.
I suspect this is the answer. I've looked at the mk2 GTV's myself in the past, but always found something I wanted more at the time. I reckon life would be easier just getting her what she wants rather than forcing my choice on her. She'd only moan when something went wrong, and I'd moan about having to shell out to fix her car when she should be driving something functional and reliable!

CaptainSlow

13,179 posts

243 months

Tuesday 23rd April 2013
quotequote all
This. When the slightest thing goes wrong it'll be your fault.

Get her the TT and have a peaceful life.

re the GTV..I want one! I think the TS models are best avoided, too much pain for little joy. I think the v6 should be viewed as a cheap Ferrari in regards to cost expectations, running one as a daily driver wouldn't be my idea of fun but I'd rather have one than a cheap Boxster.

98elise

32,891 posts

192 months

Tuesday 23rd April 2013
quotequote all
A bloke at work bought one for 7k, and spent nearly that again repairing it in the 18 months he owned it. He sold it to another bloke at work for about 3k. That bloke spent about 3k during the couple of years he had it.

Bloke no1 worked out that as he mainly used it for visiting he parents every month or soi it would have been cheaper to hire a TVR for every journey.

98elise

32,891 posts

192 months

Tuesday 23rd April 2013
quotequote all
A bloke at work bought one for 7k, and spent nearly that again repairing it in the 18 months he owned it. He sold it to another bloke at work for about 3k. That bloke spent about 3k during the couple of years he had it.

Bloke no1 worked out that as he mainly used it for visiting he parents every month or soi it would have been cheaper to hire a TVR for every journey.