Car parks - why are they so narrow!
Car parks - why are they so narrow!
Author
Discussion

272BHP

Original Poster:

6,949 posts

267 months

Monday 8th April 2013
quotequote all
Have noticed in a lot of places these days that car parking is a nightmare because the spaces are not the appropriate width for todays cars.

Went to the NEC yesterday and found it so difficult to park, we have a A3 and I had to get out of the passenger seat before my wife parked as there is no way I was getting out of the car once it was in the space, both cars either side were regular sized cars and parked centrally in their spaces. Walking along the rows of cars we noticed that maybe 1 in 5 spaces were straddling the lines purely because they could not fit.

Why do they do this? when I shop I would actually go out of my way to go to a supermarket that has wider spaces rather than a more conveniently located one purely to avoid the parking hassle.

Perd Hapley

1,750 posts

204 months

Monday 8th April 2013
quotequote all
The spaces didn't get smaller, the cars got fat!

ATTAK Z

19,566 posts

220 months

Monday 8th April 2013
quotequote all
"Standard" dims used to be 2.4 x 4.8 metres ... I now design at 2.5 x 5.0 metres as a matter of course ... cost per space is around £1500

RichB

56,474 posts

315 months

Monday 8th April 2013
quotequote all
Exactly so they need to make the spaces wider to accommodate them.

poing

8,743 posts

231 months

Monday 8th April 2013
quotequote all
Perd Hapley said:
The spaces didn't get smaller, the cars got fat!
Yes but places like Tesco go to great lengths to fit as many spaces as they can in the car park, each one at whatever the minimum they are allowed is. All my other local supermarkets are far better with Sainsbury being the best locally by a good margin and as such I'd much rather shop there.

They need to review the minimum space requirements every 10 years or so and adjust accordingly. Doesn't look like cars are going to get any smaller in the near future.

MarkRSi

5,782 posts

249 months

Monday 8th April 2013
quotequote all
272BHP said:
when I shop I would actually go out of my way to go to a supermarket that has wider spaces rather than a more conveniently located one purely to avoid the parking hassle.
Because people like you are in the overwhelming minority, and most people who treat cars like white goods don't care, and obviously the shop cares even less (if possible) but they do care if they can squeeze a few more cars in since more cars = more customers = more £££


I agree, it's bloody annoying rage

Edited by MarkRSi on Monday 8th April 22:51

RichB

56,474 posts

315 months

Monday 8th April 2013
quotequote all
ATTAK Z said:
.. cost per space is around £1500
Surely that depends on what part of the country the car park is located.

ATTAK Z

19,566 posts

220 months

Monday 8th April 2013
quotequote all
RichB said:
ATTAK Z said:
.. cost per space is around £1500
Surely that depends on what part of the country the car park is located.
that's cost to build not including the cost of the land

SystemParanoia

14,343 posts

229 months

Monday 8th April 2013
quotequote all
it costs £1500 to lay 2.5m x 5m of tarmac.. thats some expensive hot gravel!

Tannedbaldhead

3,214 posts

163 months

Monday 8th April 2013
quotequote all
ATTAK Z said:
RichB said:
ATTAK Z said:
.. cost per space is around £1500
Surely that depends on what part of the country the car park is located.
that's cost to build not including the cost of the land
And if the space is built requires SUDS build technology a damn site more. Land costs are dictated by RSV calcs.
If your car doesn't fit in a space buy a smaller one. Small cars provide much more driving pleasure anyway.

RichB

56,474 posts

315 months

Monday 8th April 2013
quotequote all
Tannedbaldhead said:

If your car doesn't fit in a space buy a smaller one. Small cars provide much more driving pleasure anyway.
You know and I know that wont happen so it's a daft thing to say.

SystemParanoia

14,343 posts

229 months

Monday 8th April 2013
quotequote all
Tannedbaldhead said:
ATTAK Z said:
RichB said:
ATTAK Z said:
.. cost per space is around £1500
Surely that depends on what part of the country the car park is located.
that's cost to build not including the cost of the land
And if the space is built requires SUDS build technology a damn site more. Land costs are dictated by RSV calcs.
If your car doesn't fit in a space buy a smaller one. Small cars provide much more driving pleasure anyway.
he's right



Mr Gear

9,416 posts

221 months

Monday 8th April 2013
quotequote all
RichB said:
Exactly so they need to make the spaces wider to accommodate them.
Why is it the problem of the car park owner? Why is it not the problem of the car owner?

One of the many reasons I like my car is because it is narrow and as such makes my life easier.

ATTAK Z

19,566 posts

220 months

Monday 8th April 2013
quotequote all
SystemParanoia said:
it costs £1500 to lay 2.5m x 5m of tarmac.. thats some expensive hot gravel!
lighting - drainage - sub base - access road - soft landscape - auto barriers - fencing - need I go on ?

Tannedbaldhead

3,214 posts

163 months

Monday 8th April 2013
quotequote all
SystemParanoia said:
it costs £1500 to lay 2.5m x 5m of tarmac.. thats some expensive hot gravel!
How it's costed is the total build cost of the car park: planning, design, site investigation, pre tender costs, founds, frame, superstructure, roof, fitting, services, admin costs, and possibly even running costs divided by the expected lifespan of the property.

It all adds up.

Tannedbaldhead

3,214 posts

163 months

Monday 8th April 2013
quotequote all
ATTAK Z said:
SystemParanoia said:
it costs £1500 to lay 2.5m x 5m of tarmac.. thats some expensive hot gravel!
lighting - drainage - sub base - access road - soft landscape - auto barriers - fencing - need I go on ?
We were singing so much from the same hymn-sheet I had to look at your profile to see if you were a QS.

B'stard Child

31,180 posts

277 months

Monday 8th April 2013
quotequote all
272BHP said:
Why do they do this? when I shop I would actually go out of my way to go to a supermarket that has wider spaces rather than a more conveniently located one purely to avoid the parking hassle.
They already do wider spaces - "Disabled" and "Parent and Child" Spaces

getmecoat

RichB

56,474 posts

315 months

Monday 8th April 2013
quotequote all
Mr Gear said:
RichB said:
Exactly so they need to make the spaces wider to accommodate them.
Why is it the problem of the car park owner? Why is it not the problem of the car owner?

One of the many reasons I like my car is because it is narrow and as such makes my life easier.
I dunno, it's certainly not my problem, I'm not the one who stated the thread but it seems stupid to make spaces too small for one's customers to use. It seems common sense to me and I don't drive a Q8 or X9 or whatever the latest super sized 4x4 is but even in a small car one has to park next to these monsters occasionally so, yes, I do think it's time car park spaces were made to accommodate the cars being sold. All in my opinion of course people can disagree. It's not life and death to me smile

sawman

5,179 posts

261 months

Monday 8th April 2013
quotequote all
I usually have plenty of space in my 1989 mercedes....

marshalla

15,902 posts

232 months

Monday 8th April 2013
quotequote all
B'stard Child said:
They already do wider spaces - "Disabled" and "Parent and Child" Spaces

getmecoat
I know of a Sainsbury's where they have "comfort" spaces - far from the door, marked by signs showing a car with both doors wide open. Why they didn't just mark them "PH" or "goatees only" is beyond me.