MG ZT CDTi or Volvo S60 D5 for £2kish
MG ZT CDTi or Volvo S60 D5 for £2kish
Author
Discussion

Emeye

Original Poster:

9,781 posts

254 months

Tuesday 9th April 2013
quotequote all
I'm looking to get something that will suit me as my daily driver, but also be an economical and comfortable European cruiser for when I take the family on holiday to France.

For around £2k the best choices seem to be a manual MG ZT cdti or a Volvo S60 D5 - the MG ZT is probably more fun, relatively, to punt along, but the Volvo is likely to be more comfortable, and faster as it's more powerful.

I'm guessing the MG may be more economical but not too sure about reliability or running costs compared to the Volvo which doesn't seem too bad. It looks like I can get a lower mileage MG for my cash.

Another option is a Mondeo TDCi, but they just don't appeal to me, unless it was a ST155, but they are outside budget.

I don't really want a car with over 130k miles on the clock.

Anyone with experience of both the MG and Volvo?

cheers.

ModernAndy

2,094 posts

166 months

Tuesday 9th April 2013
quotequote all
A well equipped Volvo will be streets ahead of the Rover. The D5 isn't particularly quick but does have quite a bit of torque and sounds alright for a diesel thanks to 5 cylinders. Not sure about fuel economy, I'd imagine a 4 cylinder diesel in a lighter car would beat it there.

Fire99

9,868 posts

260 months

Tuesday 9th April 2013
quotequote all
I own an MGZT cdti so may be able to help a bit. In standard trim the MG isn't desperately quick (in either 115 or 130 bhp trim) but can be quite easily pepped up a bit.
Engine is very strong, being chain driven and not having swirl flaps or variable vane turbos etc but it can be slow to warm and economy around town isn't amazing. (Improves on a run)

In standard trim a tdci mondeo or D5 volvo will feel stronger.

greggy50

6,281 posts

222 months

Tuesday 9th April 2013
quotequote all
I would personally get the MG ZT and then tweek it to 165bhp with a map myself. They are very good cars my Dad had two and never had an issue with either reliability wise either and these were both company cars so were driven pretty hard as well.

sebbyr

23 posts

190 months

Tuesday 9th April 2013
quotequote all
I drive an S60 D5 through europe twice a year, and I get somewhere around 45-50mpg, so they are not that bad on fuel. Also those seats are incredibly comfortable and great for long journeys. Honestly I think its a brilliant car, but its not very spacious in the back which can be annoying on long journeys. The only think I will say, is when something goes wrong, its not exactly cheap to repair.

Emeye

Original Poster:

9,781 posts

254 months

Tuesday 9th April 2013
quotequote all
Thanks for the replies, so they're both good? biggrin Both appeal to me for different reasons. Think I will have to go and have a look at a couple locally to see what I'm getting for my money.

davepoth

29,395 posts

230 months

Tuesday 9th April 2013
quotequote all
If you like the MG but fancy more comfort, take a look at the 75 version. Still nice for the twisties but much better for long trips.

RenesisEvo

3,828 posts

250 months

Tuesday 9th April 2013
quotequote all
I could be wrong, as I'm no expert on these matters, but IIRC with the S60, you want the early 5-speed Euro 3 engine, not the later Euro 4 with 6 speed, for better reliability and marginally better economy. Hopefully someone more knowledgeable will be along shortly. I would imagine your budget would restrict you to earlier cars anyway. And avoid the autos, they do fail.

Emeye

Original Poster:

9,781 posts

254 months

Tuesday 9th April 2013
quotequote all
davepoth said:
If you like the MG but fancy more comfort, take a look at the 75 version. Still nice for the twisties but much better for long trips.
Not really keen on the 75 tbh, i still feel a bit young to be driving one! Great cars, but just like a Jag, I don't feel ready for one yet. wink

Meths

2,114 posts

167 months

Tuesday 9th April 2013
quotequote all
if you're getting the mg zt diesel, make sure the clutch is good.

it's a £1200 job to replace!

Jakg

4,070 posts

199 months

Tuesday 9th April 2013
quotequote all
sebbyr said:
but its not very spacious in the back which can be annoying on long journeys
While I love my ZT, there is no room in the back whatsoever. An Astra is more comfortable for the rear seat passengers.

Having said that - I never sit in the back, so I really don't care!

Mr Happy

5,910 posts

251 months

Tuesday 9th April 2013
quotequote all
I've heard that the S60 D5s have a bit of a reputation for popping their intercoolers, so be wary at that kind of price point. I was looking not long ago and the only D5s I found were pretty leggy 163hp versions, so it's definitely something to bear in mind.

Emeye

Original Poster:

9,781 posts

254 months

Tuesday 9th April 2013
quotequote all
Meths said:
if you're getting the mg zt diesel, make sure the clutch is good.

it's a £1200 job to replace!
I assume that includes replacing the Dual Mass thingy?

mattyprice4004

1,342 posts

205 months

Tuesday 9th April 2013
quotequote all
Meths said:
if you're getting the mg zt diesel, make sure the clutch is good.

it's a £1200 job to replace!
It's only £1200 if you have a very expensive garage and replace everything - if you were just to do the usual suspects (Clutch and Slave) the parts cost £126 for an AP Freelander TD4 Slave and Borg and Beck clutch. It's usual to replace the Slave with the Freelander TD4 version as it's a bit tougher, and should outlive the car. It's a straight fit.

Add £100 for a Master if it needs one, and around £270 for a DMF.

Book time is 5.5 hours, so find a good indy for £40 an hour and you're looking at a much more realistic £400 tops for Clutch and Slave.

If you're a home mechanic it's £126 for the job, with the added bonus of you being able to do other bits and bobs like CV boots while you're in there.

I've had 3x 75s and a ZT, I had the 75 Estate I had remapped and fitted a tuning box for circa 185BHP. Oh what fun that was! biggrin

Worth a drive, drive both and see which you like. I've driven an S60 and S80, and bought the 75 Estate.

I've actually just bought my 3rd 75 Estate specifically as it needed a clutch - with my knowledge it'll work out to be a steal when repaired.

SebastienClement

1,952 posts

171 months

Tuesday 9th April 2013
quotequote all
mattyprice4004 said:
It's only £1200 if you have a very expensive garage and replace everything - if you were just to do the usual suspects (Clutch and Slave) the parts cost £126 for an AP Freelander TD4 Slave and Borg and Beck clutch. It's usual to replace the Slave with the Freelander TD4 version as it's a bit tougher, and should outlive the car. It's a straight fit.

Add £100 for a Master if it needs one, and around £270 for a DMF.

Book time is 5.5 hours, so find a good indy for £40 an hour and you're looking at a much more realistic £400 tops for Clutch and Slave.

If you're a home mechanic it's £126 for the job, with the added bonus of you being able to do other bits and bobs like CV boots while you're in there.

I've had 3x 75s and a ZT, I had the 75 Estate I had remapped and fitted a tuning box for circa 185BHP. Oh what fun that was! biggrin

Worth a drive, drive both and see which you like. I've driven an S60 and S80, and bought the 75 Estate.

I've actually just bought my 3rd 75 Estate specifically as it needed a clutch - with my knowledge it'll work out to be a steal when repaired.
+1 a clutch is absolutely not a £1k+ job - despite the stories.

Emeye

Original Poster:

9,781 posts

254 months

Tuesday 9th April 2013
quotequote all
A lex said:
A clutch and DMF in the Volvo very much is a £1k job im afraid frown

Emeye - get the Volvo! Youve been umming and aaring about getting one for what seems like forever. Its time to bite the bullet hehe
A lex, have you seen my question in the S60 owners thread about the S60 Sport? I can't find much info about the Sport spec. I do fancy the Volvo, but seems I can get a lower mileage MG for less money!

Meths

2,114 posts

167 months

Tuesday 9th April 2013
quotequote all
mattyprice4004 said:
Book time is 5.5 hours, so find a good indy for £40 an hour and you're looking at a much more realistic £400 tops for Clutch and Slave.
I must have been screwed when I got the zt done a couple of years ago.


Bought cheap and sold it on for a good profit though biggrin (£800 boom!)

Edited by Meths on Tuesday 9th April 20:26

VolvoT5

4,155 posts

205 months

Tuesday 9th April 2013
quotequote all
I test drove the MG 135 CDTI not so long ago and it was anything but fun.... needed 20% more power IMO, but of course if you are going to be doing most your miles cruising down the motorway then that probably doesn't matter much.

Never had a s60 or D5 but had plenty of Volvos and they do take big miles well and a very comfortable. Only downside is when they go wrong it seems to be expensively so and I hear they are a PITA to work on.

Fire99

9,868 posts

260 months

Tuesday 9th April 2013
quotequote all
VolvoT5 said:
I test drove the MG 135 CDTI not so long ago and it was anything but fun.... needed 20% more power
I drive one and to be honest.....That's exactly what it needs. smile Remap is said to achieve that but I can't personally vouch for that bit.

George111

6,930 posts

282 months

Wednesday 10th April 2013
quotequote all
Had both and the Volvo is a far superior car - better built, more reliable and much more comfortable. The MG had slightly better handling but less comfortable, noisier and more crude.