A(nother) what load lugger thread
Discussion
Sorry for another what car thread but I really don't want to buy the wrong car, again.
The wife and I are fortunate enough now to be able to replace the god awful Vauxhall Insignia we have for something 'better'.
We bought the Insignia to replace a Focus ST170 Estate which we bought to aid with transporting the pooch but the Insignia is just not right, neither of us like it so it's got to go.
We need something which has a big enough boot for 2 medium sized dogs. We also need it to be capable of chewing up the motorway miles (so no Ibiza estates...) with 2 bikes on the back (so no centre exit exhausts) and, as she is into watersports (fnar?), able to have a canoe and or 2 kayaks on the roof, so no piddly little 1.6D engines.
Obviously we want something which is a little better than Vauxhall's poor show so the usual suspects have been considered but getting a decent, low mileage German bus is difficult for the money.
We've got a maximum of £13,000 to spend (although less would be better as it eats into MY car budget) and would like something as low mileage as possible as we plan to keep it for a good few years.
We had an E90 320d before and that was fine until it had done about 80k when it started to need loads of bushes etc, that's what I'm trying to avoid here.
Finally, in anti-PH mode, it needs to be a diesel as it's only going to be used for longer trips.
I know there's loads of these threads and I should use the classifieds to narrow it down but I've done all that and it doesn't give the owner reviews which I'm really after.
At the moment, we're hovering around a Volvo V70 D5 R-design but I don't know if I'm not 100% convinced about it.
What would PH do?
The wife and I are fortunate enough now to be able to replace the god awful Vauxhall Insignia we have for something 'better'.
We bought the Insignia to replace a Focus ST170 Estate which we bought to aid with transporting the pooch but the Insignia is just not right, neither of us like it so it's got to go.
We need something which has a big enough boot for 2 medium sized dogs. We also need it to be capable of chewing up the motorway miles (so no Ibiza estates...) with 2 bikes on the back (so no centre exit exhausts) and, as she is into watersports (fnar?), able to have a canoe and or 2 kayaks on the roof, so no piddly little 1.6D engines.
Obviously we want something which is a little better than Vauxhall's poor show so the usual suspects have been considered but getting a decent, low mileage German bus is difficult for the money.
We've got a maximum of £13,000 to spend (although less would be better as it eats into MY car budget) and would like something as low mileage as possible as we plan to keep it for a good few years.
We had an E90 320d before and that was fine until it had done about 80k when it started to need loads of bushes etc, that's what I'm trying to avoid here.
Finally, in anti-PH mode, it needs to be a diesel as it's only going to be used for longer trips.
I know there's loads of these threads and I should use the classifieds to narrow it down but I've done all that and it doesn't give the owner reviews which I'm really after.
At the moment, we're hovering around a Volvo V70 D5 R-design but I don't know if I'm not 100% convinced about it.
What would PH do?
E60 530d Touring 
ETA: this seems a nice example:
http://www.autotrader.co.uk/classified/advert/2013...

ETA: this seems a nice example:
http://www.autotrader.co.uk/classified/advert/2013...
Edited by M159V8 on Wednesday 10th April 09:59
Edited by M159V8 on Wednesday 10th April 10:08
Boring but practical answer is Accord estate - wife has the saloon version and loves it, it's never needed more than tyres and servicing, it's comfortable and the estates are big enough for most people.
Not sure about the Honda diesel, but out petrol Accord is one of those cars you just know you can depend on.
Not sure about the Honda diesel, but out petrol Accord is one of those cars you just know you can depend on.
Robmarriott said:
The 530d link doesn't work, what year was it?
Te thing with the V70 is its MASSIVE, might be too big really
Owning one (albeit a P2, not the similar sized P3), I find they're not as big as you think. A Mondeo estate is physically larger. The V70 compromises on rear seat space.Te thing with the V70 is its MASSIVE, might be too big really
VW Passat Estate, 2.0 TDI. It's not going to set the world on fire, but is comfortable, spacious, and reliable.
If you can stretch your budget a bit:
http://www.pistonheads.com/classifieds/used-cars/s...
If you can stretch your budget a bit:
http://www.pistonheads.com/classifieds/used-cars/s...
Robmarriott said:
Had considered an Accord, quite like how they look but I'm not sure about build quality (or the engine)
I've had a couple of Hondas. Absolutely nothing wrong with build quality or engines IME, it's just that they don't use the same sort of plastics on the inside as the germans do, so they maybe don't look quite as high quality. But they are well built and don't rattle or squeak. IME anyway.You might also think about a Mazda 6 estate. Not very PH, but a good one can be bought cheaply now that the new model is out, and they tend to have more kit as standard than the german alternatives.
Running costs are cheaper too. Certainly cheaper than running a BMW.
Robmarriott said:
Had considered an Accord, quite like how they look but I'm not sure about build quality (or the engine)
Saab is a no, if they'd released the new shape 9-5 as an estate I probably would have bought one.
I like the 159 but she won't risk an Alfa, which I can't argue my way past
As I say, wife very happy with hers, she's had 2 CR-Vs previously too. It's not the last word in style, but it's OK. The spec ('Executive' IIRC) she has comes with an integrated touchscreen satnav, radio and CD system, leather, dual zone climate, heated seats and the like and as I say, we've never had a thing go wrong with any of the Hondas we've had.Saab is a no, if they'd released the new shape 9-5 as an estate I probably would have bought one.
I like the 159 but she won't risk an Alfa, which I can't argue my way past

Uninspiring to drive, handsome enough to look at and as reliable as the reputation suggests I'd say
Gassing Station | General Gassing | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


