Help a former muscle car owning yank find a daily driver :)
Help a former muscle car owning yank find a daily driver :)
Author
Discussion

LostInScotland

Original Poster:

16 posts

163 months

Wednesday 10th April 2013
quotequote all
Hello all, I just joined the forum after months of lurking and reading and would like to ask for a bit of advice...

But 1st some background: I'm a 36 year old man who's recently returned to the UK after 22 years in the USA where I owned almost exclusively Mustangs (for fun) and Hondas (for winter, and running around town). My last car was a 425RWHP fox bodied mustang GT with 6.7 Litre (stroked 351 - 408ci) engine that ran low 11s in the quarter mile. My runabout/daily driver was a EG Honda civic with a 2.2 Prelude H22 engine (200bhp). So its fair to say I like my speed... Since moving back to the UK where I've never driven anything but fiesta rental cars when I've been over on holiday, I find myself a bit depressed at the serious lack of affordable powerful cars - I suppose understandable given the ridiculous costs of ownership over here and the price of Petrol. I'm just about to get my full UK licence and it's time to buy a car.

My budget: £3000-£4000 (mostly due to high insurance being technically a new driver). I would stretch to £5k if it were seriously worthwhile to do so.

My requirements: Reliability foremost, and enough power (~200+) that I don't get too homesick for cheap American V8s. I'm more than capable of working on my own cars, but I'm renting a city centre flat at the moment with street parking, and have no tools, so something that I don't have to spend weekends wrenching on would be nice! I also need enough boot space to be able to move myself and my 2 big suitcases, as I've not quite settled on where I want to live. A bit of comfort would be nice. Lastly, I don't do 4-5door cars, it has to be a 2-3 door, and i'm favoring a hatchback for cargo room.

So far my list after a fair bit of research looks like this:

EP3 Honda Civic Type R: Pros: Performance and Cargo area, Honda Reliability. Cons: A bit too boy racer looking at my age, and sincerely hate the interior styling.

DC2 Honda Integra: Pros: I've had an Integra before (US GSXR 1.8 (B18C)) and it was a fantastic reliable car and the type R is even better (not available in the US). Cons: High miles on most in my price range, and slightly overpriced for the age of the car.

S3 Audi: Pros: Luxurious interior, decent performance, feels more grown up than the honda's. Cons: Not sure about reliability or cost of parts? It seems quite a complex car, with a lot of electronics and the AWD system.

ST170 Ford Focus: Pros: Nice interior, great cargo, like the styling, and I'm forever a Ford Fanboy. Cons: Again, no sure about reliability, and seems underpowered and poor fuel economy for what it is.

VVTL-I Toyota Corolla: Pros: Toyota reliability, Cargo room Cons: Slow feeling for 185ish HP and squishy suspension as I understand it

330 BMW: Pros: Power and looks. Cons: Never had a German car, no clue about reliability issues - they are very expensive to fix in the US, not sure if that is the case here.

C230k Merc: Pros: quite pretty. Cons: everything else


I'm sure I've missed loads of cars being unfamiliar with the UK/EU market - I will say French cars seem really cr@p in the reliability department(?), so I've not considered them, but I'm open to anything at this point.

I would love some input on my selections, and any other suggestions that might fit my requirements, and also feedback from anyone that owns any of the cars I've mentioned.

Sorry this post has turned into a novel.... but it's my very 1st UK car after all wink

Thanks!









BorkFactor

7,278 posts

189 months

Wednesday 10th April 2013
quotequote all
BMW E46 330i is a good bet, you will get a lovely one for that money. Watch for cooling systems and rust on the front wings, besides that they are pretty much bullet proof! Independent specialists are very reasonably priced if you find a good one, no more expensive to service than any other car.

Or if you really want a V8, BMW E39 540i?

mat777

10,714 posts

191 months

Wednesday 10th April 2013
quotequote all
That budget would get you a nice E39 BMW 540 saloon or wagon. They are pretty indestructible asking as you avoid the ones with nikasil engine liners.
Similarly, check out fast Volvos. An 850 T5R or the later V70 T5 are very very rapid, very safe, reliable, and don't cost a fortune to run

calibrax

4,788 posts

242 months

Wednesday 10th April 2013
quotequote all
Something with similar handling to an American muscle car perhaps? winkbiggrin


clarkey540i

2,220 posts

205 months

Wednesday 10th April 2013
quotequote all
BorkFactor said:
BMW E46 330i is a good bet, you will get a lovely one for that money. Watch for cooling systems and rust on the front wings, besides that they are pretty much bullet proof! Independent specialists are very reasonably priced if you find a good one, no more expensive to service than any other car.

Or if you really want a V8, BMW E39 540i?
I just bought a 540i for 2k. It's a great car and isn't really more expensive to fix than any other I have had. Insurance won't be cheap, but in your case it may be worth ringing insurance companies and seeing if they will accept your American driving experience. My girlfriend is Spanish and they were happy to accept that, but it's in the EU so may be different.

Disco You

3,749 posts

211 months

Wednesday 10th April 2013
quotequote all
Even though you are right to say that French cars are crap, it's worth considering a hot Clio.

RB Will

10,909 posts

271 months

Wednesday 10th April 2013
quotequote all

Hoddy910

92 posts

178 months

Wednesday 10th April 2013
quotequote all
As the previous poster said, don't ignore them french hot hatches! A 172cup you could get for between 2-3k (170bhp, 1012kg!) or considered the best, a decent clio 182 trophy. I think only 300 were made (or came to the uk?) there rare and quick with very expensive sache(sp?)dampers. My only worry for you would be insurance :|

btw my brother owns a 172 cup and its been very reliable for him, think hes had it over 4 years now with a few tasty mods and its a great laugh biggrin

Shame you can't stretch to a focus rs mk1 biggrin I may be a bit biased cos I own one but like the clios it handles really well, is more practical than them and infact has a lower insurance rating (and is turbocharged)
You can get plenty of subaru imprezas for little money but they would rape you for insurance...but obv are fast.

Get a hot hatch you yanks dont know what your missing!

LuS1fer

43,566 posts

276 months

Wednesday 10th April 2013
quotequote all
calibrax said:
Something with similar handling to an American muscle car perhaps? winkbiggrin

Why would he want an MG?

Highway Star

3,616 posts

262 months

Wednesday 10th April 2013
quotequote all
Fiat Coupe Turbo or Alfa GTV V6 and yes, I did read the bit in the spec that said 'reliable'.

BorkFactor

7,278 posts

189 months

Wednesday 10th April 2013
quotequote all
LuS1fer said:
Why would he want an MG?
rofl

Could you get a good E36 M3 for that money?

LostInScotland

Original Poster:

16 posts

163 months

Wednesday 10th April 2013
quotequote all
Borkfactor, Mat777: Thanks for the input - so is it safe to say an E46 is a good reliable ride? I'd not considered volvos - i'll certainly have a look, they are nicely equipped. the E36 540 is out of the question - too old, and I really have a hate for saloons and estates. Probably desperately trying to cling to my youth here wink

Calibrax: LOL, thanks for the laugh mate - you aren't far off! Having owned 6 mustangs, none of which could go around corners, and one that almost killed me when I tried I am a bit scared of turns in the road! haha

RB Will: Aye, that's my kinda car - there is also a nice one in the classified for around £4k - VERY tempting, but insurance, tax and petrol would be a nightmare... but so very tempting!

Disco, Hoddy: Everything i've read about clios is they are unreliable - and to be honest I just don;t like the look of them. I do really appreciate the input though! The Focus RS would be great - but well over my budget at the moment.

How reliable are imprezas? I do like the look of the early 2 door ones.

Highway Star: Looked at both the alfa (love the looks and interior) and the fiat coupe (ugly, but good specs) and decided to pass on them both after some owner reviews smile

Edited by LostInScotland on Wednesday 10th April 18:56

talksthetalk

10,821 posts

166 months

Wednesday 10th April 2013
quotequote all
Don't believe about the Corolla's legendary reliability.
It has a Yamaha race head on it and mine dropped a valve at 60k, and then chewed itself to death after 82k miles, probably due to oil starvation as the toyota Engineers "never found" the bit of valve that snapped off.

LostInScotland

Original Poster:

16 posts

163 months

Wednesday 10th April 2013
quotequote all
talksthetalk said:
Don't believe about the Corolla's legendary reliability.
It has a Yamaha race head on it and mine dropped a valve at 60k, and then chewed itself to death after 82k miles, probably due to oil starvation as the toyota Engineers "never found" the bit of valve that snapped off.
Really? I had it in my head toyotas were all bombproof smile Good to know on the Yamaha head (I had a yamaha powered ford briefly called a Taurus SHO 3.0V6 and while revvy and fun it exploded after a few months of abuse... lol).

Dominicc01

530 posts

198 months

Wednesday 10th April 2013
quotequote all
Hang on! Maybe I'm getting the wrong idea here, but I think there's plenty of excellent 2 door coupes you haven't looked at. Unless you're doing serious mileage, there's no reason why you shouldn't consider a V8 coupe here too! It does depend on insurance as well, but if you shop around it shouldn't be too bad.

I bought one of these a year ago, at the age of 27. Admittedly with 7 years' NCB, my insurance is £320p.a. Massive amount of boot space, and ultra-reliable:
£4,000 280bhp


You can get a 5.0 within budget too, but the insurance would have been £750 for me, for a 40bhp increase:
£4,000 320bhp


You can even get a newer model within budget, although these do need checking carefully:
£3,800 306bhp


The wonderful BMW 840Ci is also in budget, although boot space won't be as capacious:
£4,000 286bhp


Not a V8, but an S2 944 can't be sniffed at - even has a rear hatch! angel
£3,300 211bhp


Or how about a 5.0 V8 928 S4:
£3,600 320bhp


Finally, my favourite is the ever-youthful looking XK8:
£3,500 294bhp




Jayfish

6,795 posts

234 months

Wednesday 10th April 2013
quotequote all
Oh that 840 is lovely always wanted one of those.

Hoddy910

92 posts

178 months

Wednesday 10th April 2013
quotequote all
LostInScotland said:
Disco, Hoddy: Everything i've read about clios is they are unreliable - and to be honest I just don;t like the look of them. I do really appreciate the input though! The Focus RS would be great - but well over my budget at the moment.

How reliable are imprezas? I do like the look of the early 2 door ones.
Edited by LostInScotland on Wednesday 10th April 18:56
Hello again mate. Imprezas I'm led to believe are very reliable, a good mate of mine has one and says aslong as they have been looked after there bulletproof. Unfortunatly a lot of people who can't give a fk about cars and just wanted the noise/presense of the scoobs run them (cos alot of the older ones are cheap) so if you hear any horror stories bear that in mind. Have a look on the "P1" thread, think its under general gassing or readers cars. The p1 is the dogs bks biggrinbiggrin

LostInScotland

Original Poster:

16 posts

163 months

Wednesday 10th April 2013
quotequote all
Thanks very much for your post!

I have drooled over the newer style CL500 for a long time - am I to understand by your post that the older ones are more reliable than the newer? I suppose the only think that has put me off is the historical expense of parts of german cars while I was living in the US - would you categorize as reliable and cheap to upkeep?

The 8 series Bimer is a gorgeous car too - I'll take another look at insurace and reviews.

Porche hold no interest with me - never have.

The Jag on the other hand.... nice smile I saw one in Edinburgh a few weeks ago and it turned my head - I didn't realize they were so cheap.

Some great food for though there, thanks!

Dominicc01 said:
Hang on! Maybe I'm getting the wrong idea here, but I think there's plenty of excellent 2 door coupes you haven't looked at. Unless you're doing serious mileage, there's no reason why you shouldn't consider a V8 coupe here too! It does depend on insurance as well, but if you shop around it shouldn't be too bad.

I bought one of these a year ago, at the age of 27. Admittedly with 7 years' NCB, my insurance is £320p.a. Massive amount of boot space, and ultra-reliable:
£4,000 280bhp


You can get a 5.0 within budget too, but the insurance would have been £750 for me, for a 40bhp increase:
£4,000 320bhp


You can even get a newer model within budget, although these do need checking carefully:
£3,800 306bhp


The wonderful BMW 840Ci is also in budget, although boot space won't be as capacious:
£4,000 286bhp


Not a V8, but an S2 944 can't be sniffed at - even has a rear hatch! angel
£3,300 211bhp


Or how about a 5.0 V8 928 S4:
£3,600 320bhp


Finally, my favourite is the ever-youthful looking XK8:
£3,500 294bhp

LostInScotland

Original Poster:

16 posts

163 months

Wednesday 10th April 2013
quotequote all
I may have to revisit the impreza as well! I can see it being a money pit for modifications though - I can never leave a car alone - there's actually something to be said for me buying a car that has no aftermarket parts available smile haha



Hoddy910 said:
Hello again mate. Imprezas I'm led to believe are very reliable, a good mate of mine has one and says aslong as they have been looked after there bulletproof. Unfortunatly a lot of people who can't give a fk about cars and just wanted the noise/presense of the scoobs run them (cos alot of the older ones are cheap) so if you hear any horror stories bear that in mind. Have a look on the "P1" thread, think its under general gassing or readers cars. The p1 is the dogs bks biggrinbiggrin

Hoddy910

92 posts

178 months

Wednesday 10th April 2013
quotequote all
haha yeah mate the modifications game is a slippery slope, I've fell into that trap myself but its bloody good fun biggrin Old Lancer Evos may be in with a shout aswell if you fancy a scoob, there quicker but there lacking the character of the old imprezas.