Aftermarket Tuner takes Volvo to court...
Discussion
Just thought this might be of interest.
http://en.bsr.se/about/volvo-pin/
I didn't think OEM were allowed to exclude the after market in the way it seems Volvo has tried to do with BSR.
Will we be seeing more of this kind of thing in the future as car manufacturers try and ensure that all future owners for the life of the car will need to take it to a dealer? And will this mean in 10 years time we can't modify our cars?
Mat, what do you think?
http://en.bsr.se/about/volvo-pin/
I didn't think OEM were allowed to exclude the after market in the way it seems Volvo has tried to do with BSR.
Will we be seeing more of this kind of thing in the future as car manufacturers try and ensure that all future owners for the life of the car will need to take it to a dealer? And will this mean in 10 years time we can't modify our cars?
Mat, what do you think?
Quite frankly, an extremely shoddy ploy by Volvo. They have truly left their integrity well behind. When I had my S60, a car I quite liked, the ETM failed and needed replacing. The car was in warranty from a used car dealer who had to pay the cost of the part and the encoding of it to the engine. A process that would have been much, much more expensive had it not been for aftermarket coding services!
I'd expect something like this from Volkswagen/Audi, but not from Volvo, who I always thought of as a 'customer focused' brand.
I'd expect something like this from Volkswagen/Audi, but not from Volvo, who I always thought of as a 'customer focused' brand.
I think there are a few factors involved here.
Firstly, I think it could definitely be a warranty thing.
Also, a lot of manufacturers are cashing in on the aftermarket and customization enthusiasm - cars like the new Adam and 500 are designed to be broadly customized using a huge options list. More OEMs are making properly hot cars (Kia, Hyundai, Skoda, Volvo are definitely making more of an effort, for example) and offer a wide variety of high quality performance and visual upgrades, which puts them in direct competition with the aftermarket. Only makes sense to pull dirty tricks to push the others out of business. That's (unfortunately) how most big companies are successfully run.
Firstly, I think it could definitely be a warranty thing.
Also, a lot of manufacturers are cashing in on the aftermarket and customization enthusiasm - cars like the new Adam and 500 are designed to be broadly customized using a huge options list. More OEMs are making properly hot cars (Kia, Hyundai, Skoda, Volvo are definitely making more of an effort, for example) and offer a wide variety of high quality performance and visual upgrades, which puts them in direct competition with the aftermarket. Only makes sense to pull dirty tricks to push the others out of business. That's (unfortunately) how most big companies are successfully run.
jimbobsimmonds said:
Fittster said:
I wonder if Volvo's logic is to determine if the ECM has been modified before deciding on warranty issues.
My S60 throws a code when read on Volvo dealer software which shows immediately that it has been remapped...Fittster said:
jimbobsimmonds said:
Fittster said:
I wonder if Volvo's logic is to determine if the ECM has been modified before deciding on warranty issues.
My S60 throws a code when read on Volvo dealer software which shows immediately that it has been remapped...And again, depends on the dealer, one particular dealership throws a track day for us every year

I'm not up on ECU/ECM thingys but can this by bypassed? I know that companies use piggy-back ECU boxes for tuning so could something similar be used in this case when fitting something new to the car?
Alternatively, could it just be completely replaced? Little black electronic boxes are not like they used to be in complexity given the information out there. Even if getting a company to make a new replacement is too expensive then could it be swapped for one from another car? For example Volvo and Ford share engines so take one out of a Mondeo instead if that's not locked down.
People will always find a way past these things. I'm sure garages and tuners had a terrible time when the first black boxes were fitted to cars but now it's just a small machine or a laptop plugged in, load the right software and away you go.
Alternatively, could it just be completely replaced? Little black electronic boxes are not like they used to be in complexity given the information out there. Even if getting a company to make a new replacement is too expensive then could it be swapped for one from another car? For example Volvo and Ford share engines so take one out of a Mondeo instead if that's not locked down.
People will always find a way past these things. I'm sure garages and tuners had a terrible time when the first black boxes were fitted to cars but now it's just a small machine or a laptop plugged in, load the right software and away you go.
Baryonyx said:
Quite frankly, an extremely shoddy ploy by Volvo. They have truly left their integrity well behind. When I had my S60, a car I quite liked, the ETM failed and needed replacing. The car was in warranty from a used car dealer who had to pay the cost of the part and the encoding of it to the engine. A process that would have been much, much more expensive had it not been for aftermarket coding services!
I'd expect something like this from Volkswagen/Audi, but not from Volvo, who I always thought of as a 'customer focused' brand.
This isn't anything out of the ordinary, most manufacturers do something similar, new ECUs/control modules are supplied blank and require programming. The only difference being that (usually) the PIN code is supplied to the customer.I'd expect something like this from Volkswagen/Audi, but not from Volvo, who I always thought of as a 'customer focused' brand.
poing said:
I'm not up on ECU/ECM thingys but can this by bypassed? I know that companies use piggy-back ECU boxes for tuning so could something similar be used in this case when fitting something new to the car?
Alternatively, could it just be completely replaced? Little black electronic boxes are not like they used to be in complexity given the information out there. Even if getting a company to make a new replacement is too expensive then could it be swapped for one from another car? For example Volvo and Ford share engines so take one out of a Mondeo instead if that's not locked down.
The problem is that all the control modules talk to each other, the systems are integrated. So, for example:Alternatively, could it just be completely replaced? Little black electronic boxes are not like they used to be in complexity given the information out there. Even if getting a company to make a new replacement is too expensive then could it be swapped for one from another car? For example Volvo and Ford share engines so take one out of a Mondeo instead if that's not locked down.
Driver presses the aircon switch to turn it on.
Aircon ECU sends a message to the engine ECU that says "hey, I need to turn aircon on, is that ok?"
Engine ECU says "No can do, we're at full throttle / load, I can't afford to run the compressor, tell you what I'll let you know.."
So the driver comes off throttle, engine ECU notices and sends a message to the aircon ECU "Hey, you can turn on now".
This is theoretical, but illustrates the communication.
So, even if we could replace the engine ECU and the replacement could service the requests when the ECUs communicate they do a check to make sure they are compatible. This will be encrpyted/secure, so the replacement won't be able to do this.
This goes a bit further. I know one manufacturer knows the firmware loaded in to each ECU in every single car. Whenever an update is done in the dealer network the information is updated. If an ECU needs to be replaced the correct firmware is available at the click of a few buttons.
Even if an ECU doesn't go faulty when the car next goes for service the diagnostic equipment gets attached. The system already knows what updates to download to the car, because it already knew the firmwares onboard.
Where this goes wrong is third party access. Lets say that a third party gains access to the ECU and enables a feature that wasn't enabled - lets say cruise control, or the stereo unit in the car is changed for one equipped with satnav etc. The database of firmwares the manufacturer holds is now out of date. So, the car goes for service, incorrect downloads are applied and all of a sudden the stereo doesn't work, because the updates are incorrect.
Note sometimes it'll be a dealer doing this to upspec a car that they sell, they buy a base spec model and then add some bling/factory options for little outlay.
This sort of thing might be the reason that Volvo are trying to keep the PIN codes to themselves.
Edit: As others have alluded to, its not just ECUs that get encoded, pretty much anything can be nowadays - injectors, fuel pumps, aircon compressors, even a window motor could be.
Crafty_ said:
Lots of interesting and educational stuff
Cheers for that and I guess thinking about it logically it makes sense, bit like printer companies chipping the ink cartridges so they know when you've used a cheap alternative.It'll be interesting to see how this goes in the future when a car is 15+ years old needs work and the dealer shrugs and says that they no longer have the code.
poing said:
Cheers for that and I guess thinking about it logically it makes sense, bit like printer companies chipping the ink cartridges so they know when you've used a cheap alternative.
It'll be interesting to see how this goes in the future when a car is 15+ years old needs work and the dealer shrugs and says that they no longer have the code.
They'll have the codes. I got the radio code for my 16 y/o 850 from a Volvo dealers in 30 seconds over the phone just by giving the reg. plate. For something as important as any ECU code, they'll be able to supply it. FWIW Volvo spares/support is rather good!It'll be interesting to see how this goes in the future when a car is 15+ years old needs work and the dealer shrugs and says that they no longer have the code.
If this becomes a trend it may put an end to people modding their cars on the quiet with the intention of not declaring it to their insurers. So from that perspective it could be a good thing. However being tied to a main dealer could obviously be rather expensive and annoying for many.
k-ink said:
If this becomes a trend it may put an end to people modding their cars on the quiet with the intention of not declaring it to their insurers. So from that perspective it could be a good thing. However being tied to a main dealer could obviously be rather expensive and annoying for many.
It does make me giggle when you see people on about remaps "its invisible, not even the dealer knows"bulls
t.Besides, if a technician who is in and out of the cars all day drives it up the road he'll flipping well know.. if he can't tell the remap can't really be worth having ?
There will be any number of 'tells' that an ecu has been remapped or otherwise fiddled with.
Quite right too, imagine you go out and buy a 997 with your hard earned, only to find that its previously been remapped and is carrying a number of over rev warnings, which invalidate the Porsche warranty. You wouldn't be very impressed.
We are way beyond "black boxes" already, you've got a network inside the car with an entire software system running on it that is sharing data in some of the most bizarre ways imaginable. Within the software world there is a buzzword from the last few years that is "big data". Basically its the acknowledgement that we can have a metric bottomload of data - we need to understand that data to extract the important pieces of information and present them to the user.
Cars are reaching that point, the damm thing pretty much knows everything thats going on.
For example the ABS ECU probably knows if the windscreen wipers are on or not. Why ? if the wipers are on, its probably raining, rain means diminished braking due to corrosion on the discs. So, if the ABS ecu knows it can use the pump to gently modulate brake fluid pressure, which very gently applies the brakes for a second or two, just enough to clear any fresh corrosion from the discs. Note that in this case we need to know the difference between the wipers being on and the driver operating the wash/wipe function!
Pretty much anything you turn on in the car will route a request to the power management ECU, which is monitoring battery level and managing the charging of the battery, if it decides that the battery is failing and/or not being charged it may deny the request - so the window won't go down or the radio wont come on etc.
Have you noticed cars with DRLs dim the DRL light when the indicator is on ? So thats the ECU that the stalks are wired to talking to the lighting ECUs to turn the indicator on and cut the voltage to the DRL to make it dim.
Another one is you might find the Aircon ECU picks the engine temperature data from the engine ECU. This is so the aircon ECU can properly do climate control. Tomorrow morning I'll jump in the car to go to work, climate control is set to 20 degrees, ambient will probably be 8 or 9, so the aircon ECU wants to blow warm air to heat the cabin. Problem is there is no warm air available, the engine is stone cold. If the aircon ECU knows this it can decide not to run the blower motor, because all that will happen is it'll blow cold air in the car, which isn't really helping us get to the 20 degrees target temperature. So, the aircon ECU will wait until it sees the engine at (say) 40 degrees, it'll probably put the blower on say speed 2 (of 6). As the engine warms up it can run the blower motor a bit harder to push the increasingly warm air through the cabin.
ECUs for the seats know road speed and consume data from lateral g sensors, so that if you corner quickly the seat ECU can deploy the get side bolsters to keep you in the seat.
There are all sorts of whacky things going on when you drive up the road. Some cars use fibre optic cable between ECUs to keep bandwidth up because there is so much data flying around. There is pretty much no limit to whats possible once you start sharing data.
I work for a large conglomerate, traditionally they have made machines - turbines, locomotives, nuclear reactors, aircraft engines, MRI scanners etc. Not too long ago a guy in senior management said that software wasn't a core activity for our arm of the business - we make machines he said.
He was wrong. "Software is eating the world" (Marc Andreessen - http://online.wsj.com/article/SB100014240531119034... ).
Our entire business is now switching to software being at the heart of everything we do. We are banding about phrases like "intelligent machines". The reason is that if we can use data to understand our machines better we can make them more reliable and efficient. That saves our customers money, which means they buy our machines instead of rival products. We want to use software (and data) to make better machines. Imagine our aircraft engine can send maintenance crews a report that says:
"In 50 flight hours I need a new bleed air valve, I've found a valve that reacts slowly, its causing excess fuel to be burnt. In 88% of cases the valve is found defective, the serial number of the item to replace is #12345, it is part number #456332".
If we didn't find that problem:
The airline spends extra money on fuel
You get delayed going on holiday because the aircraft went technical and couldn't fly until the issue (which is now critical) is fixed.
The airline need to find another aircraft to complete your flight, which causes all sorts of havoc to their scheduling.
They also need to get a relief crew in to fly the replacement aircraft, because the original crew are up on their hours.
I forget the exact number, but we did a field study and found we could be saving airlines millions of dollars, per aircraft per year by prognosis of faults and efficiency monitoring.
We can already do some of this stuff. A colleague deals with data from wind turbines. An issue was found in the data for a turbine (not one of ours btw!). It was duly reported and the maintenance teams were alerted, they sent a chap out who scaled the 80 meter tower and confirmed the diagnosis. Parts were ordered and a repair carried out. The faulty part was destruction tested in a lab and it was found it would of lasted 5 weeks from the original alert.
Had the fault not been found the turbine would of been damaged and taken out of service, and they'd of needed a crane to dismantle the turbine and take it to a repair workshop to fix and then another crane to put it back again, all at an immense cost. The system is currently looking after 17,000 turbines, if we didn't have that system we'd need to manually inspect the turbines, lets say each one needs to be checked once a year and it takes a day to check a turbine, we'd need 93 engineers to do that (assuming no holidays etc). Even then the manual inspections wouldn't find everything, lots can happen inside of 6 months!
Cars will go the same way, probably to a lesser scale, but think about how useful it'd be if the car could report that the battery has 2 weeks until it dies, rather than you go out on a cold January morning to find the blasted thing will not start ?
Or that the aircon needs a recharge, until we get our one day of summer and you're stuck in a hot car in traffic.
Or that the MAF sensor, whilst not faulty is becoming inaccurate and is causing excess fuel to be burnt, thats costing you money?
Apologies for the rambling, just thought it may be of interest to see what cars are on the fringe of

MarJay said:
It's actually against European Law.
I wonder if it is, or whether it will need testing in court.Volvo can't stop their customers taking their cars to unofficial garages as per Block Exemption Regulations, but if those garages are incapable of doing certain jobs because they do not possess or cannot acquire access to the ECU, is that still a breach? Volvo isn't saying those dealers can't work on customer cars, but they won't be able to provide the full service so it's just strongly disincentivising the customer...
Saab are even worse. Same system but they don't use a pin.. You must connect your programming computer (tec2) to another computer with a special dongle or since 2007 the Internet, to get a security key. Only then can you add or remove modules or change settings. You have to get a new code for every session..
Want to add oem heated seats? You need to get a tech2 plugged in, and connect to saab for a new session security key, to enable the unit.
Vauxhall use the same tech2 hardware, however they use a 4 digit pin that is supplied with car and never changes.
It's all very annoying.
Want to add oem heated seats? You need to get a tech2 plugged in, and connect to saab for a new session security key, to enable the unit.
Vauxhall use the same tech2 hardware, however they use a 4 digit pin that is supplied with car and never changes.
It's all very annoying.
Gassing Station | General Gassing | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


