How not to repair a pot hole
How not to repair a pot hole
Author
Discussion

zed4

Original Poster:

7,248 posts

253 months

Thursday 11th April 2013
quotequote all
There was a massive pot hole on this road, approximately 20cm deep and was hit by nearly every single car that drove past it due to the strange road layout.

As a traffic calming measure, instead of laying a straight road, they have the road curve round the corner, and the straight ahead direction as a junction, see here: http://goo.gl/maps/41Raq

This is fine as it slows cars down in the residential area, but it does mean everyone drives over the give way markers and across the middle of the road, instead of slowing and turning into the junction properly. This has meant the pot hole in the middle of the road (which has been repaired countless times already) has broken up again.

This time it was repaired and lasted a whole day, before this happened:



One whole day!!

It seems when I took this photo someone had put the huge lump of tarmac back into the hole, as last night there was a good 15cm thick block of tarmac sat next to the hole! :lol:

Why don't they just do the job properly to start with? And why try and fill a pothole by chucking a load of loose tarmac in there right before a big rain storm?! Numpties.

shotgunfacelift

247 posts

166 months

Thursday 11th April 2013
quotequote all
It would be interesting to hear from someone who does this as a living or is in some way connected to road maintenance, that could shed light on why this happens on an almost daily basis all over the country afaik...

It can't solely be attributed to cost can it?

lufbramatt

5,695 posts

165 months

Thursday 11th April 2013
quotequote all
Same thing keeps happening on the A249>M2 coastbound sliproad. In the last month I think they have filled the 2-3 MASSIVE potholes in about 4 times. This morning there were tennis ball sized lumps of tarmac all over the sliproad and lane 1 of the motorway, suprized it didn't cause a bad accident tbh. What's worse is it's on a bridge that they completely dug up and resurfaced last autumn.

It's not like roads are a new thing, you would have thought someone has worked out how to repair them properly by now.

zed4

Original Poster:

7,248 posts

253 months

Thursday 11th April 2013
quotequote all
I've found this website: http://www.fixmystreet.com/report/342584

Which seems to be pretty good at keeping this sort of thing up to date. I see the original pot hole was reported on 1st April, so to be fair, they filled it pretty quickly. It's just a shame they did a rubbish job!!

cptsideways

13,895 posts

283 months

Thursday 11th April 2013
quotequote all
When they say this country is full of workshy dole slackers I can think of one job they could all be employed on. It could be renamed Potholers Allowance hehe


Perhaps one of those petition things to the house of commons with some decent backing would be a good idea along with passing by the Daily Wail.

anonymous-user

85 months

Thursday 11th April 2013
quotequote all
I'm not local to the area, I can only see the Google maps link, so...

Initial musings:

The pothole is (99% likely) repaired by a maintenance gang on a call-out basis, 2 guys in a transit with a tub of Instamac and a whacker plate. A proper repair needs engineering input and planning, and looking at the location, some sort of consultation with locals.

Very residential road. To do a proper job would involve closure of all 3 arms as the defect is in the turning area. At a guess, it's a bus route (and possibly a rat run for heavies) too, so there will be a lot of resistance and objections to closing the road during the daytime to fix it.

Too many houses to close overnight (noise pollution)

Turning movements destroy roads. It's no surprise that a temporary repair will fail if lots of vehicles are stopping on the repair, then accelerating from a standstill over the patch. The whole surface needs to be taken off and relaid. Patching will always, eventually, fail.

As for your comment about filling a hole before it rains, what's the alternative? Leave it open, then it fills with water, people hit it and then scream "COMPO!!!" from the local authority. Damned if you do, damned if you don't. Weather kills roads. Repeated freeze/thaw cycles especially - so any potholes repaired in December will most likely have failed again by Feb. Is the answer not to fill them til March, as they'll inevitably pop out? Of course not, but whatever you do is going to get criticised by someone.

I know it's frustrating, but the highways guys don't deliberately leave holes/defects... If they know about them, they get fixed.

zed4

Original Poster:

7,248 posts

253 months

Thursday 11th April 2013
quotequote all
Fair enough. It's not that much of a busy road actually, and HGV's don't go down there due to the width restrictions and several other traffic calming measures further down the road. There are two other (larger) roads running parallel to this one which they use (Station Road/Fernhill Lane and Vaggs Lane). One of which has been closed for a while as it's been completely resurfaced, which is nice.

So it wouldn't really be an issue to close it, it would just mean locals would need to take a small detour. We've been used to that anyway as one of the local roads flooded due to blocked drains and was like it for about 2 months!


shotgunfacelift

247 posts

166 months

Thursday 11th April 2013
quotequote all
OpulentBob said:
I'm not local to the area, I can only see the Google maps link, so...

Initial musings:

The pothole is (99% likely) repaired by a maintenance gang on a call-out basis, 2 guys in a transit with a tub of Instamac and a whacker plate. A proper repair needs engineering input and planning, and looking at the location, some sort of consultation with locals.

Very residential road. To do a proper job would involve closure of all 3 arms as the defect is in the turning area. At a guess, it's a bus route (and possibly a rat run for heavies) too, so there will be a lot of resistance and objections to closing the road during the daytime to fix it.

Too many houses to close overnight (noise pollution)

Turning movements destroy roads. It's no surprise that a temporary repair will fail if lots of vehicles are stopping on the repair, then accelerating from a standstill over the patch. The whole surface needs to be taken off and relaid. Patching will always, eventually, fail.

As for your comment about filling a hole before it rains, what's the alternative? Leave it open, then it fills with water, people hit it and then scream "COMPO!!!" from the local authority. Damned if you do, damned if you don't. Weather kills roads. Repeated freeze/thaw cycles especially - so any potholes repaired in December will most likely have failed again by Feb. Is the answer not to fill them til March, as they'll inevitably pop out? Of course not, but whatever you do is going to get criticised by someone.

I know it's frustrating, but the highways guys don't deliberately leave holes/defects... If they know about them, they get fixed.
Pretty spot on it seems, certainly answered my questions anyway. Seems like there is a lot more planning goes into repairing these things than most people appreciate. Just a shame they can't come up with a decent/better material than 'Instamac', which would then make it a one hit emergency repair and gives the planning/engineering teams longer to figure out a way of repairing it properly. Anything down the line you know of?

anonymous-user

85 months

Thursday 11th April 2013
quotequote all
Yeah, they've started using "jetpatching" techniques lately. It's basically a high-pressure air hose to blow out all the debris, then (hot) bitumen and stone is blasted in again at high pressure, which self-compacts. Then a dusting of stone is laid over the top to soak up and residual stickiness (although it looks scruffy as hell). It works quite well if my experience is anything to go by - I spent a couple of £M last year sending JP crews around the County I worked for at the time, and they appear to have survived the winter quite well. Seems like the way forward to me - although it, like other bituminous repair methods, is pretty unsuitable for repairs to concrete roads.

A pothole like in the OP *could* be filled in about 10-15 minutes I would estimate. However, it depends whether the local authority has approved that type of repair, or if they are tied in to a maintenance contract with someone who does it in the more traditional way or won't pay for the JP unit.


lufbramatt

5,695 posts

165 months

Thursday 11th April 2013
quotequote all
lufbramatt said:
Same thing keeps happening on the A249>M2 coastbound sliproad. In the last month I think they have filled the 2-3 MASSIVE potholes in about 4 times. This morning there were tennis ball sized lumps of tarmac all over the sliproad and lane 1 of the motorway, suprized it didn't cause a bad accident tbh. What's worse is it's on a bridge that they completely dug up and resurfaced last autumn.

It's not like roads are a new thing, you would have thought someone has worked out how to repair them properly by now.
Turns out someone else thought the potholes were bad this morning, just seen this eek


zed4

Original Poster:

7,248 posts

253 months

Thursday 11th April 2013
quotequote all
OpulentBob said:
Yeah, they've started using "jetpatching" techniques lately. It's basically a high-pressure air hose to blow out all the debris, then (hot) bitumen and stone is blasted in again at high pressure, which self-compacts. Then a dusting of stone is laid over the top to soak up and residual stickiness (although it looks scruffy as hell). It works quite well if my experience is anything to go by - I spent a couple of £M last year sending JP crews around the County I worked for at the time, and they appear to have survived the winter quite well. Seems like the way forward to me - although it, like other bituminous repair methods, is pretty unsuitable for repairs to concrete roads.

A pothole like in the OP *could* be filled in about 10-15 minutes I would estimate. However, it depends whether the local authority has approved that type of repair, or if they are tied in to a maintenance contract with someone who does it in the more traditional way or won't pay for the JP unit.
That sounds interesting. I know there are potholes everywhere, but the roads are terrible around the New Forest.

cptsideways

13,895 posts

283 months

Thursday 11th April 2013
quotequote all
I remember seeing that technique being demonstrated on tomorrows world in the 80's !!

Its hardly new is it

yellowjack

18,549 posts

197 months

Thursday 11th April 2013
quotequote all
zed4 said:
....the roads are terrible around the New Forest.
Roads? They're calling them roads now? They're only entitled to be described as 'roads' if they are vaguely fit for purpose. Shocking is how I'd describe them.