My Fleet Dilema - S2000\Z4M\M135i
My Fleet Dilema - S2000\Z4M\M135i
Author
Discussion

scz4

Original Poster:

2,851 posts

272 months

Thursday 11th April 2013
quotequote all
Morning all. I would be interested to hear a range of opinions on my ongoing dilemma. Hear me out.

I currently have a '11 BMW 525d M Sport Touring, '05 Honda S2000 and the wife has a 2010 Mazda 3 "Sport".

The 5 series isn't going anywhere, can't think of a better daily for family (2 kids) and biking duties. The choice I have to make is sell the S2000 later this summer and pick up a Z4M over the winter, or keep the S2000, sell the Mazda 3 at the end of the year and replace with a AUC 5 door M135i.

My thoughts:

The S2000 is mildly modified with just a few tweaks here and there which have made a big difference. It is absolutely mint with just 40k miles on it.. Whilst dynamically not the best car in the world it really is a blast with the roof down. Hitting 9000rpm with the induction kit it sounds insane, handles really well, gear change is sublime, I love the snug cabin and running costs and reliability are very good. I also like how old school it feels, no traction control, an actual throttle cable, roadster layout etc. Downsides are steering lacks feel and it's just a 4 cyl when driving normally. Plus my mind wanders when it's off the road over the winter.

Z4M Roadster - I used to have a Z4 3.0 which was supercharged to 370bhp. I've always lusted after a Z4MR, just never made the jump. The S54 engine is of course the main appeal (had a E46 M3 and a S50 in the M3 Evo), it just turns every drive into an event. Downsides are it's fairly heavy, doesn't handle well on bumpy B roads and it fairly expensive to run with servicing and road tax. The wife would then be free to choose a cheaper\more economical car.

M135i, yet to drive one, none at my local dealer. But I hear nothing but good things and love the concept of it. It would give me that fantastic big engine noise and performance I'm missing in life, all in a practical 5 door body the wife would be happy to drive.

I'm edging towards keeping the S2000 as my thrash car, keep modifying and maintaining it as my hobby and getting the M135i which I can enjoy over the winter when the S2000 is locked up. But that Z4M itch will always be there!! Has been for years and prices are very reasonable.

I can't decide if in my head I'm making the S2000 out to be a better package than it is and I'd never look back if I bought a Z4MR, or the Zed could turn out to be a massive disappointment when I point it down my local back road. This factor is more important than the M135i want, that's my backup plan to have a big engine. I've driven loads of Z4M's, but not in full anger on familiar roads.





Edited by scz4 on Thursday 11th April 10:43

AB

20,656 posts

226 months

Thursday 11th April 2013
quotequote all
M135i...

Incredibly better than the Mazda.

Z4M probably not enough of a step up from a mildly modded S2K.

No dilemma in my eyes other than your wife will be in the M135i more than you? That might be annoying.