100k on a car is nothing these days right?
100k on a car is nothing these days right?
Author
Discussion

TankRS

Original Poster:

2,850 posts

185 months

Thursday 11th April 2013
quotequote all
I’m in the market for a new motor. And have taken a shine to a e46 3series, the facelift version, however, in my pitiful £2-2.5k budget I’m struggling to find decent motors that have under 100k on the clock.

There are a few out there that are around the 80k mark, but are either above the budget, or the buyers I’ve contacted are reluctant to let it go for much less than the asking price. I don’t mean massively less, just some leeway in making a deal, and not being stubborn as in it’s that price, that’s all I’ll take.

The reason I’m looking for cars around the 80k mark is that I’m expecting this to be my daily driver for at least the next 5 years. And after a few unreliable motors recently I want something that should last, so settled on the BMW. Not much took my fancy from the japs, and the VW/Audi’s are all stupidly overpriced!

Of the local cars, within say 60miles of me there are a handful of under 100k cars for sale. But most are from 100k through to 150k cars.

I know a car over 100k with FSH and receipts will likely be just as good as the same car I’m looking at with 80k. But even these are appearing fairly rare, especially low owner cars!

I also know that widening my search around the UK will likely throw up a car to fit both budget and requirements, but I have to bear in mind the cost of going to see what appears to be a great looking car to only end up with a car that hasn’t had this or that mentioned, meaning a 400 mile round trip wasted!
I was all set to go to Carlisle this weekend with the intent of buying what was a mint car from the photos exterior wise. The interior pics were less impressive, with obvious tears in the seats and carpets, random stains on the headlining and a badly fitted dash trim and radio ‘update’.( no wonder it took 2 times of asking to get interior pics sent through.)
Price of a ticket up there for just me would have set me back £160.

Help me convince myself that a car with average mileage for its age is ok to look at/buy and that I’m just being a fool/idiot for thinking I can get what I want in my low budget!!

Let the insults commence
[flame suit at the ready]

excel monkey

4,837 posts

258 months

Thursday 11th April 2013
quotequote all

Paul O

3,189 posts

214 months

Thursday 11th April 2013
quotequote all
I bought an Audi A4 last year for £400 with 155k on the clock. 1 year on, zero spent and 10k further on.

As with any car though, any second hand car is a gamble. Can't really say for certain, but 100k wouldn't both me personally if that is all the budget allows.

smile

sandman77

3,441 posts

169 months

Thursday 11th April 2013
quotequote all
The engine on a high millage car is nothing to worry about so long as it has been serviced regularly. But it is not the engine I worry about on high millage cars; it is the rest of the car. The gear change mechanism, the steering pump, the shocks, the suspension bushes, the exhaust, the wheel bearings etc. These are the parts that generally are forgotten about unless a problem arises with them. They are also the parts that wear out when cars reach the 80,000-100,000 mile mark.

Hudson

1,857 posts

218 months

Thursday 11th April 2013
quotequote all
I had a Mondeo TDCI with 179k on it when i traded it, its close to 190k now and it is starting to show signs of needing a new flywheel. Going by the horror stories online i expected the injectors to explode every time i started the car.

tl;dr treat car good car last long time. biggrin

jones325i

755 posts

184 months

Thursday 11th April 2013
quotequote all
Are you looking at a diesel or petrol?

My old man has had an '02 E46 330d from new and it's been virtually faultless. Now on 90k odd. However, it has recently it has started showing an airbag light and an intermittent ABS light so there could be some bills soon. But other than that it runs like a watch, and has been de-flapped to prevent that particular problem.

I took an E36 325i from 77k to 195k and the engine was still very strong and didn't use oil.

Si_man306

532 posts

216 months

Thursday 11th April 2013
quotequote all
Take it from an ex-E46 3 series owner, many cars will cruise well over 100k (IMHO Jap being the most preferable) but please steer clear of the beemers either diesel or petrol.

My immaculate, one owner, FBMWSH 330ci example all but fell apart from every angle and cost a fortune. I sadly came to the conclusion that BMWs are designed to last for the period of time that the initial owner buys them for (2-5 years) and after this, they make a a good wedge of cash selling you bits to fix it.

Some of course will last longer but sadly, too many buyers (especially of VW/ BMW) buy cars and then just don't give them the care and maintenance which they require- assuming that the money they pay at the garages covers this (when in fact they're essentially just performing oil changes).

Deva Link

26,934 posts

276 months

Thursday 11th April 2013
quotequote all
Mileage seems to be a UK thing - a colleague in Holland got a "new" Volvo S80 recently. Apparently "new" means only 160,000KMs (100K miles, of course) on it. Cost at least double what it would have been in the UK.

He changed cars as his previous one was over 300,000Kms (I think it might have been nearer 400,000).

jones325i

755 posts

184 months

Thursday 11th April 2013
quotequote all
sandman77 said:
The engine on a high millage car is nothing to worry about so long as it has been serviced regularly. But it is not the engine I worry about on high millage cars; it is the rest of the car. The gear change mechanism, the steering pump, the shocks, the suspension bushes, the exhaust, the wheel bearings etc. These are the parts that generally are forgotten about unless a problem arises with them. They are also the parts that wear out when cars reach the 80,000-100,000 mile mark.
That is true. My 325i was well kept so still felt like a very good car, but I'd be cautious buying a high miler as things like just bushes, mounts, shocks, brakes can really add up. And BMs do seem to consume suspension components.

I think the trick is to find a good indy and stick with them. They will spot the jobs that need doing in plenty of time and so things don't all come at once and bite you in the ass.

MysteryLemon

4,968 posts

222 months

Thursday 11th April 2013
quotequote all
100k is nothing for a modern, maintained car.

Sadly, owners these days seem to think a car will do 100k without a single service. It may well and likely will do, but it till be a st heap by the time it gets there. These are the cars flooding the second hand market.

TankRS

Original Poster:

2,850 posts

185 months

Thursday 11th April 2013
quotequote all
excel monkey said:
i'd somehow managed to miss these threads!


Paul O said:
I bought an Audi A4 last year for £400 with 155k on the clock. 1 year on, zero spent and 10k further on.

As with any car though, any second hand car is a gamble. Can't really say for certain, but 100k wouldn't both me personally if that is all the budget allows.

smile
i need to stop being a snob then! smile

and yeah, you just never know with used cars! i could end up with a 60k one thats nothing but trouble!

PaulMoor

3,209 posts

194 months

Thursday 11th April 2013
quotequote all
Depends on the car.

A well looked after rep car that has run up and down the motorway for 100K should be fine for another 100k

A city runaround thats had someone skimp on looking after and been doing stop start, lots of short runs, could be dead.

Deva Link

26,934 posts

276 months

Thursday 11th April 2013
quotequote all
If you buy at around 80K miles then you're probably going to take it over 100K and take the hit in value. So you might as well buy one that's already taken that hit.

wolfy1988

1,426 posts

194 months

Thursday 11th April 2013
quotequote all
Si_man306 said:
Take it from an ex-E46 3 series owner, many cars will cruise well over 100k (IMHO Jap being the most preferable) but please steer clear of the beemers either diesel or petrol.

My immaculate, one owner, FBMWSH 330ci example all but fell apart from every angle and cost a fortune. I sadly came to the conclusion that BMWs are designed to last for the period of time that the initial owner buys them for (2-5 years) and after this, they make a a good wedge of cash selling you bits to fix it.
Horse Manure!

I drive a 1998 523i e39 with a 142k on it and its brilliantly reliable so far, I drive it 90% on fast Irish B-roads and its great and I have bought another 523i except with 179k miles and its just as tight and smooth as my other one.

Willy Nilly

12,511 posts

198 months

Thursday 11th April 2013
quotequote all
My manager had one of the early E46's new as a company car. It spent most of its time at the dealer having various cooling and electrical problems (unsuccessfully) sorted. It got to the stage where he would only use it for local trips because he couldn't be sure if it would get him where he was going. I doubt that they got better with age.

5 years trouble free motoring is a lot of ask for £2.5 grand. With the best will and luck in the world you are going to be driving a 10 year old car. My money would be on something Japanese. The BMW probably be a better steer, but do you want to get to work or do track days?

TankRS

Original Poster:

2,850 posts

185 months

Thursday 11th April 2013
quotequote all
PaulMoor said:
Depends on the car.

A well looked after rep car that has run up and down the motorway for 100K should be fine for another 100k

A city runaround thats had someone skimp on looking after and been doing stop start, lots of short runs, could be dead.
part of the problem beign that unless i'm contacting private sellers, the mileage history is unknown, or made up by dealers!

Deva Link said:
If you buy at around 80K miles then you're probably going to take it over 100K and take the hit in value. So you might as well buy one that's already taken that hit.
didnt think of it that way!


Meant to ad, it’s going to be a petrol motor. Had a Focus tdci with turbo problems, and really wasn’t much a fan of the derv anyway. And wasn’t doing the mileage to make the derv really that much economical.

I understand that a 10 year old car isn’t going to be flawless mechanically wise. I expect to have to change certain things on it like brakes, bearings, roll bar links etc. Being fairly handy with a mechanic in the family will keep some costs too.
I do believe I have found a reliable indy garage now also.

I think I need to get my head out of the lower mileage cloud and get a good look at the history on some of the over 100k cars.
I may get lucky and find one that’s had the majority of the bigger costing parts replaced some miles ago, and now they’re just moving the car on as it’s had its time with them.
I need to try and avoid the sellers I guess that are aware of the imminent big changes, suspension/water pump/clutch changes, who are trying to offload the car before having to fork out for it!

I may even give one of those rac/aa used car checks a go to see if they can identify any potential issues.

Krikkit

27,943 posts

212 months

Thursday 11th April 2013
quotequote all
Forget the mileage and go on condition and recent work. If you want something with a bit of anti-b0rk insurance then something NA without a DMF or auto box is a good start.

Adam_W

1,098 posts

231 months

Thursday 11th April 2013
quotequote all
Iv had a number of cars over 100k miles, most I buy are like that, used to change quite frequently so was rare for me to have them for a year or more.

e46 M3 over 100k miles, engine was excellent, steering pipework failed leaking all the fluid, rear floorpan cracking.
e61 530d over 100k miles, engine brilliant, rear suspension control arm failed causing damage to other components and leaving me stranded at the roadside.
Audi a6 over 100k miles, power steering rack seal failed, loss of steering fluid, new rack had to be installed and another trip on a recovery truck.
vw Passat over 100k miles, diesel injection pump failed, again recovery truck and over £1000 to fix

Personally if I were you and were serious about a daily car for 5 years id consider a lesser brand that's both newer and less miles.

TankRS

Original Poster:

2,850 posts

185 months

Thursday 11th April 2013
quotequote all
Krikkit said:
Forget the mileage and go on condition and recent work. If you want something with a bit of anti-b0rk insurance then something NA without a DMF or auto box is a good start.
cheers.

a NA manual petrol motor is the route im heading in!

and insurance wise, theres very little difference in insurance prices between a a basic 316 and the 3ltr 330! must be about £20 in it!!!

gary3170

250 posts

186 months

Thursday 11th April 2013
quotequote all
i,ve just bought a pre facelift 323ci cab 2001 80k miles fbmwsh a few niggles but great summer fun for £2250
leather,auto,100% condition rag top works 100% electric wise
before that we used a e46 318 touring that had 150k miles total problem free (got stolen!)