2.7 Boxster or S2000 - What to buy
2.7 Boxster or S2000 - What to buy
Author
Discussion

carpetmanuk

Original Poster:

10 posts

163 months

Thursday 11th April 2013
quotequote all
I am looking for a new car and was curious about peoples views on either of these cars.
I have driven both and am torn between the two. The fact that I am a 29 year old man kind of makes me think I can't have a boxster but I don't drive aggressively enough to make maximum use of the vtec engine in an S2000. I could use advice on living with the cars but to be honest if the general consensus is I will get laughed at in a boxster then I will just go for the S2000.

billzeebub

3,913 posts

230 months

Thursday 11th April 2013
quotequote all
Out of those two the 2.7 Boxster is the best all round proposition for me. People who laugh at Boxsters have rarely driven one. However, I would probably want to go for a TVR Chimaera

Codswallop

5,260 posts

225 months

Thursday 11th April 2013
quotequote all
Why would you get laughed at in a Boxster? confused Why do you even care?

If you like the way both drive, then think about what you want from a car. If you use motorways more/ plan long touring holidays, a Boxster might be more suited to that than the S2000, for example.

The Porsche is likely to be more expensive to run, if that's a factor.

delmatt

506 posts

222 months

Thursday 11th April 2013
quotequote all
Ok so I will be the first to comment. Lived with an S2000 for 8 years or so and thought it was great. I had always convinced myself it was as good as the Boxster. Finally got bored with it and got myself a 3.2s Boxster and realised how much better the Porsche is as a car.

The S2000 is cheaper and easier to run and look after and possibly more fun in some respects but the Porsche does feel the nicer to drive.I know you said 2.7 Boxster but would look into 3.2 as well.


There have been several previous posts for the same question and no real conclusion has ever been made. As for hairdresser image they both have it so man up and get one and not worry what other people say or even think!

carpetmanuk

Original Poster:

10 posts

163 months

Thursday 11th April 2013
quotequote all
Should probably say drove a Z4 and didn't like it before anyone suggests it, ride was too hard.Not a fan of TVRs, no particular reason just not my style.

cherad

37 posts

229 months

Thursday 11th April 2013
quotequote all
I've heard that S2000s are becoming quite hard to insure nowadays. May or may not be true, an online quote or two would confirm and might help your decision.

Riknos

4,701 posts

235 months

Thursday 11th April 2013
quotequote all
delmatt said:
Ok so I will be the first to comment. Lived with an S2000 for 8 years or so and thought it was great. I had always convinced myself it was as good as the Boxster. Finally got bored with it and got myself a 3.2s Boxster and realised how much better the Porsche is as a car.

The S2000 is cheaper and easier to run and look after and possibly more fun in some respects but the Porsche does feel the nicer to drive.I know you said 2.7 Boxster but would look into 3.2 as well.
Sound advice here. Despite being in the same kind of 'market' there is quite a big difference in the running costs of the two. I looked at both, but went for the S2000 in the end - I like the Jeyll and Hyde nature of the car, whereas if you're never going to get into VTEC then there's not much point in you buying one!

carpetmanuk

Original Poster:

10 posts

163 months

Thursday 11th April 2013
quotequote all
3.2 boxsters also too pricey since I want relatively low mileage and no more than 10 years old

Lee540

1,586 posts

175 months

Thursday 11th April 2013
quotequote all
cherad said:
I've heard that S2000s are becoming quite hard to insure nowadays. May or may not be true, an online quote or two would confirm and might help your decision.
S2000's have always had high insurance premiums

Codswallop

5,260 posts

225 months

Thursday 11th April 2013
quotequote all
cherad said:
I've heard that S2000s are becoming quite hard to insure nowadays. May or may not be true, an online quote or two would confirm and might help your decision.
I was checking insurance prices 2/3 weeks ago on things like Z4s, 350z, Boxsters and S2000s (before becoming somewhat side-tracked and buying something entirely different...), and they were all within a few pounds of each other to insure in my case.

MC Bodge

30,206 posts

206 months

Thursday 11th April 2013
quotequote all
carpetmanuk said:
The fact that I am a 29 year old man kind of makes me think I can't have a boxster....if the general consensus is I will get laughed at in a boxster
?

carpetmanuk said:
I don't drive aggressively enough to make maximum use of the vtec engine in an S2000.
Suggestion:

wink

karl_h

223 posts

211 months

Thursday 11th April 2013
quotequote all
What sort of driving are you going to do. I had an S2000 and commuting soon became tiresome so it had to go. Having said that I thought it was utterly brilliant. I also test drove a Z4 and the Honda blew it in to the weeds, that VTEC hit and the sense of occasion that they summoned from what is little more than a selection of standard Honda parts was wonderful and if I'm ever in a position to have a Sunday sports car that doesn't cost the earth it would be top of my list.
However if you need to live with it daily over any serious distance then I'd be leaning towards the Porsche or more likely something with a solid roof!

karl_h

223 posts

211 months

Thursday 11th April 2013
quotequote all
Double post.

carpetmanuk

Original Poster:

10 posts

163 months

Thursday 11th April 2013
quotequote all
Re. Pug. Wow thanks that was so helpful :-) I know the 'will I look stupid?' comment about the boxster is childish so just ignore that from now on thanks.

carpetmanuk

Original Poster:

10 posts

163 months

Thursday 11th April 2013
quotequote all
It will be a second car as I have a van for work so it is literally for evenings and weekends for fun.

delmatt

506 posts

222 months

Thursday 11th April 2013
quotequote all
Ok so I will be the first to comment. Lived with an S2000 for 8 years or so and thought it was great. I had always convinced myself it was as good as the Boxster. Finally got bored with it and got myself a 3.2s Boxster and realised how much better the Porsche is as a car.

The S2000 is cheaper and easier to run and look after and possibly more fun in some respects but the Porsche does feel the nicer to drive.I know you said 2.7 Boxster but would look into 3.2 as well.


There have been several previous posts for the same question and no real conclusion has ever been made. As for hairdresser image they both have it so man up and get one and not worry what other people say or even think!

karl_h

223 posts

211 months

Thursday 11th April 2013
quotequote all
Ok but Sunday blasts or are you hoping to use it as a car for best, weekends away, trips to a nice restaurant etc. if its the latter even though I loved my Honda I couldn't recommend one over a Boxster in those circumstances.

carpetmanuk

Original Poster:

10 posts

163 months

Thursday 11th April 2013
quotequote all
Would be be for Sunday blasts.

karl_h

223 posts

211 months

Thursday 11th April 2013
quotequote all
S2000 then despite the reputation for them being tricky they have more character and being inept at driving I found it provided me with more accessible smiles without having to drive all that quickly. As I said the sense of occasion was fantastic.

carpetmanuk

Original Poster:

10 posts

163 months

Thursday 11th April 2013
quotequote all
Also should say I don't have a garage so would be out on the drive. I will get a cover for it but would either of these be a problem in those cicumstances.