Head on or hit a tree?
Author
Discussion

HertsBiker

Original Poster:

6,443 posts

302 months

Thursday 11th April 2013
quotequote all
Your choice. The other driver is way out of control. On your side of the road. Do you go rad to rad, or head off road and almost certainly hit a tree? I'd choose to hit, because cars are softer than trees, and atleast you stop them doing a runner. What would you do? I may change my mind if you can argue a good point. Be careful out there everyone.

TheHeretic

73,668 posts

286 months

Thursday 11th April 2013
quotequote all
The tree. It seems daft both of you having a life threatening collision, when you could avoid it.

Baryonyx

18,295 posts

190 months

Thursday 11th April 2013
quotequote all
Depends on the tree, but in general, it'd be far easier to dissipate the energy of a crash against a soft, moving car than a deeply rooted tree!

See...

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xJA7V4YyQCI

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nlA3khy90Vs

The second one is particularly sad.

HertsBiker

Original Poster:

6,443 posts

302 months

Thursday 11th April 2013
quotequote all
TheHeretic said:
The tree. It seems daft both of you having a life threatening collision, when you could avoid it.
And if they do a runner? It becomes your fault!

HertsBiker

Original Poster:

6,443 posts

302 months

Thursday 11th April 2013
quotequote all
TheHeretic said:
The tree. It seems daft both of you having a life threatening collision, when you could avoid it.
And if they do a runner? It becomes your fault!

TheHeretic

73,668 posts

286 months

Thursday 11th April 2013
quotequote all
HertsBiker said:
And if they do a runner? It becomes your fault!
You are right. You should hit them for insurance purposes.

SV8Predator

2,102 posts

196 months

Thursday 11th April 2013
quotequote all
HertsBiker said:
And if they do a runner? It becomes your fault!
How can the tree do a runner?

Conian

8,030 posts

232 months

Thursday 11th April 2013
quotequote all
There is/was a thought that a collision at 60 into a tree (closing speed = 60), is half as bad as a collision at 60 into a car coming the other way at 60 (closing speed = 120)

This has been proven that while closing speed is double the mass cancels each other out and the closing speed is 60 each resulting in the same damage as hitting a stationary object.

So... question is... if you hit the tree and the other fella straightens his car up and drives off, you slapped a tree for nothing, so may as well tt his car and claim off him.

the_lone_wolf

2,622 posts

217 months

Thursday 11th April 2013
quotequote all
Depends of the vehicle...

Oncoming truck doing 70mph? Hello Mr. Tree, G-Whiz? Might not even brake...

If it's another normal sized car I'd like to think if I had the presence of mind to think it through I'd try and swerve so that the oncoming car glanced off the side of my own...

In reality I expect I'd brake hard, scrub off as much speed as I could and let Volvo's safety cell engineers take care of the rest...

Fire99

9,868 posts

260 months

Thursday 11th April 2013
quotequote all
I would assume natural reflexes would intervene. It would take a great deal of self control to deliberately 'choose' to crash head-on into another car.

57Ford

6,220 posts

165 months

Thursday 11th April 2013
quotequote all
Possible tree at closing speed of 30/50 rather than a definite car at closing speed of 60/100.
This is even taking into account the possible solid construction of the possible tree - seems like better odds to me.

Fire99

9,868 posts

260 months

Thursday 11th April 2013
quotequote all
57Ford said:
Possible tree at closing speed of 30/50 rather than a definite car at closing speed of 60/100.
This is even taking into account the possible solid construction of the possible tree - seems like better odds to me.
That said, the closing speed of the other vehicle doesn't matter (except to them of course) There is no greater force possible than hitting a stationary object. (if that makes sense)

Blackpuddin

19,584 posts

236 months

Thursday 11th April 2013
quotequote all
Fire99 said:
I would assume natural reflexes would intervene. It would take a great deal of self control to deliberately 'choose' to crash head-on into another car.
This. If you are in a position to be able to choose your target, you should also able to choose the third option of not hitting anything. Bit of a daft hypothesis really.

RobM77

35,349 posts

265 months

Thursday 11th April 2013
quotequote all
HertsBiker said:
And if they do a runner? It becomes your fault!
It's always your fault if you're in a pistonhead type car anyway to be honest. I had this exact situation a number of years ago, and instinctively I chose the tree rather than an 80mph head on with a Passat - it was pure instinct and I didn't really think about it; the Passat swerved to my side of the road and I ducked out of the way. The lady who was on the wrong side of the road (trying to read a map in her husband's car whilst she was driving she said immediately after the accident), once home and calmed down to make her statement, claimed that I'd lost control of my MR2 on a corner and slid into her as she was tootling along the road. The fact that the collision happened on an arrow straight Roman road and I was in a steady 40mph queue of cars didn't wash with the insurance company, because I was 25 years old and in a sports car. Thankfully I was being followed by a solicitor, but initially the insurance company didn't bother talking to him, until I told them to, then the truth came out and I got a profuse apology and all expenses paid. And the tree? Thankfully I slid to a halt in a deep ditch about a foot from it - the only damage to my car was the door and wing where she'd struck my car.

blugnu

1,523 posts

272 months

Thursday 11th April 2013
quotequote all
I'd hit the other car. Trees don't move. Here is an A6 cut in half by a tree (driver survived) - and it's not even a big tree.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uFzClbqILrA

maxdb

1,547 posts

188 months

Thursday 11th April 2013
quotequote all
I would rather hit a tree then risk other peoples lives.

In reality it would depend on the road and situation. If the other vehicle was larger then mine or a motorbike then I would go for a tree.

If there was a deep drop either side of the road then head on..

amstrange1

617 posts

207 months

Thursday 11th April 2013
quotequote all
Trees don't have crumple zones, so unless it's something significantly larger than what I'm driving; I'd go for the head-on - assuming that otherwise a tree-impact at the same speed was inevitable.

Baryonyx

18,295 posts

190 months

Thursday 11th April 2013
quotequote all
Fire99 said:
I would assume natural reflexes would intervene. It would take a great deal of self control to deliberately 'choose' to crash head-on into another car.
Funny, I could recount a tale told to me by a friend, and one I have heard many times now, where he was driving a performance saloon at high speed down a dual carriageway. As he exited onto an offslip, he found his brakes had faded to nothing. Seeing two stationary cars at the top, an Astra and a Jaguar XJR or something (not a cheap one!), he positioned himself to hit the Astra, knowing it's value would be less. His brakes just managed to stop him in time, inches from the back of the Astra. But he made that concious decision to hit the Astra, if he was hitting anything!

Edited by Baryonyx on Thursday 11th April 22:55

RobM77

35,349 posts

265 months

Thursday 11th April 2013
quotequote all
Baryonyx said:
Funny, I could recount a tale told to me by a friend, and one I have heard many times now, where I was driving a performance saloon at high speed down a dual carriageway. As he exited onto an offslip, he found his brakes had faded to nothing. Seeing two stationary cars at the top, an Astra and a Jaguar XJR or something (not a cheap one!), he positioned himself to hit the Astra, knowing it's value would be less. His brakes just managed to stop him in time, inches from the back of the Astra. But he made that concious decision to hit the Astra, if he was hitting anything!
Nice story! I guess it depends how long you have. In my story above I had a second or less to make the decision - it was an instant reaction almost like ducking. In your friend's position I'd definitely choose to hit a Vauxhall over a Jag though wink

HertsBiker

Original Poster:

6,443 posts

302 months

Thursday 11th April 2013
quotequote all
I'm liking the discussion so far. Cheers lads. It would be a monumental decision to make. I think a big tree would give less than a car though. I just hate the idea of trashing a car and the perpetrator sods off leaving you to foot the bill - assuming you live to tell. Atleast with the car you would have two crumple zones to absorb the impact? Instinct to swerve may be more dangerous. You tell me, please.