RE: Speed aware - one man's story
RE: Speed aware - one man's story
Friday 12th April 2013

Speed aware - one man's story

Speed doesn't kill; coming to an abrupt halt does



The one thing which unites all motorists, irrespective of social standing, political or religious views, colour or creed - even opinions on DSG gearboxes - is that we all believe we are better drivers than we actually are. I know I do. That's why, on a quiet stretch of the A23, late at night, I got caught driving 7mph over the speed limit. I knew I was good for the extra speed, even if Sussex police thought otherwise. It's not exactly the crime of the century, is it? I was more annoyed I got nicked rather than shouldering any guilt for breaking the law - and I guess that's how many of us feel when the Notice of Intended Prosecution lands on our doormat. We're not interested in the Road Traffic Act we've contravened, all we want to know is how fast, how many points and what's the fine. A momentary lack of concentration from our finely honed sixth sense to spot a speed camera from half-a-mile away had failed us and now we are left to pay the price for our minor misdemeanour.

I was given the choice; three points and a £60 fixed-penalty fine or, and wait for it, pay 85 quid and attend a speed awareness course, with no endorsements. It was a no-brainer. Just like the other 53 per cent of speeding motorists who opt for the speed awareness course, so did I.

And then on to the day in question. None of us wanted to be there. We didn't need to give the reason why we had all been gathered together in a makeshift classroom, like a group of naughty children kept behind for after-school detention, we all knew. We got caught speeding.

We hear it enough but do we listen?
We hear it enough but do we listen?
Gruesome twosome
Our lecturers were a male/female duo tag-team, taking it in turn to front the Powerpoint presentation. Julie, who reminded me of the Matt Lucas character, Marjorie Dawes, the patronising leader of the Fatfighters slimming club, kicked the proceedings off. With a sunny smile and no sincerity she gleefully informed us we'd be there for 'approximately' four hours. That's four hours and 85 bloody quid I'd never see again, and in the company of a woman who mimed inverted commas with her fingers. Anyway. I was there, and before Marjorie started her evangelical sermon about the evils of speed she did mention that unless we stayed to the bitter end we'd fail the course, our details passed to the police, we'd receive a £60 fine, and the three points. Whether I liked it or not, she had me by the short and curlies.

But that was it, no written exam, no driving test, just a lost Saturday afternoon spent listening to something I knew already. I once interviewed Andy Green, the holder of the World Land Speed record, and he was very much alive. So speed obviously doesn't kill. Admittedly, coming to an abrupt halt won't do your internal organs much good, but that's just common sense. Hey-ho, the coffee was free and I didn't need permission to go to the loo. "These sessions are run by the National Speed Awareness Course," Marj told us, "a non-profit making organisation which has a £20million turnover, all from receivable fines, and run in conjunction with local authority road safety departments and overseen by their respective police authorities." My eyelids were getting heavy, her well-rehearsed script draining.

Just a few extra mph and back to school
Just a few extra mph and back to school
Copping it
Andrew, the other half of the double-act, took over. He didn't need to tell us he was a retired traffic cop, you just knew it by looking at his military stance and highly polished shoes. When not eulogising over the benefits of curbing an enthusiastic right foot, he's also an advanced driving instructor, like Marjorie. However, he was a lot more engaging than the leader of the Fatfighers club. Maybe Marjorie was his warm-up act? Either way, he presented the facts to us in a manner that didn't patronise. With over 6,000 speed cameras dotted across the country the odds are one-in-five drivers will get caught for speeding, and we were that one, while the other four got away with it, and he sort of sympathised with us.

"What happens if you get caught speeding in the next three years?" He asked the apathetic group in front of him. But before any of us could muster the energy to speak he answered his own question. "I'll tell you", he said, while finding a clean piece of paper on the flip-chart. With black marker pen to hand, he readied himself. "You'll get a fixed penalty and three points". He then wrote the very same at the bottom of the blank sheet of paper. "And then if you get caught again?" He surveyed the room, pointed to the heavily pregnant woman who had earlier confessed to being 2mph over the speed limit. "You get more points and another fine", he again answered his own question and wrote it just above his last jottings. This went on, exploring at length the consequences speeding can bring, the highlights then written above the last. Before long, and in six easy stages, the list is neared the top of the paper. We'd gone from a laughable three points and fine to disqualification, and that was "if we're lucky". Points seven to 10 covered injury, death and jail. And if it was injury or death, how would our family feel if it was us, but worst still, how would we feel if we did it to someone else.

Could education be the more subtle answer?
Could education be the more subtle answer?
Change of heart
Cynicism to one side, and as much as it pains me to write this, the NSAC ideology is quite sound; it wants to solve the speeding problem rather than just manage it by dishing out points and fines. Not everyone is eligible to attend and even though it's meant to be a national scheme not every county has adopted it yet. Scotland doesn't run it all. Even those counties which have signed-up still have the flexibility to adapt it as they see fit, as long as it conforms to NSAC guidelines - so not every course is the same, either. Offenders are only offered places if their speed falls within 10 per cent + 2mph to 10 per cent + 9mph of the limit. For example; the tolerance level of a 30mph zone is actually 35mph before prosecution, but using the NSAC formula, anything over that but less than 40.5mph could qualify for the course, just as I did.

Did they succeed in converting me? Well, the flip-chart exercise about maiming or killing somebody else really struck home and I do now find myself checking my speed more regularly than before, so I guess they did. Then again, when I gave up smoking I was this resolute to begin with, and then failed miserably. The only difference this time is that I now realise if I fail I could die, or worse still spend another four hours with the Gruesome Twosome. Either way that's a good enough reason for me to slow it down a bit.

Author
Discussion

aww999

Original Poster:

2,078 posts

292 months

Friday 12th April 2013
quotequote all
The only "speeding problem" is that limits which are set for (and probably by!) Mrs Miggins in a 14-year old Korean hatchback appear entirely ridiculous to an alert driver in a modern performance car. What a load of crap.

steveb8189

516 posts

222 months

Friday 12th April 2013
quotequote all
Artice said:
and I do now find myself checking my speed more regularly than before
The cynic in me would say you should be keeping your eyes on the road...

MrTrilby

1,170 posts

313 months

Friday 12th April 2013
quotequote all
steveb8189 said:
The cynic in me would say you should be keeping your eyes on the road...
The cynic in me would say that if you find it tricky keeping half an eye on your speed whilst watching the road, perhaps you're not the skilled driver you thought you are, and maybe a motoring enthusiast website is the wrong place for you.

Edited by MrTrilby on Friday 12th April 12:01

Deva Link

26,934 posts

276 months

Friday 12th April 2013
quotequote all
Article said:
Just like the other 53 per cent of convicted speeding motorists who opt for the speed awareness course, so did I.
They're not convicted. They're not even convicted if they accept a fixed penalty.

And a fixed penalty is not a fine.

Only a court can convict you. Only a court can fine you.

Funk

27,807 posts

240 months

Friday 12th April 2013
quotequote all
I would respect speed limits more if they stopped pointlessly reducing them on roads which have had higher limits for years.

I drove up to Teddington today and noted that stretches of road which were once 70 have been reduced to 50 (just north of Dorking) and a road which was previously NSL has been reduced to 50 too.

If more people are breaking the speed limits it's not because we're driving faster than we used to (I genuinely think we're not), it's because the goalposts have been moved resulting in unrealistic speeds which people are inclined to disregard. As more roads have their limits reduced, more people are likely to a) break the new limit and b) be caught as they're now breaking the law which they weren't before.

Conversely I've seen fewer TrafPol around and the number of new fixed cameras seems to have declined now that revenues go to government coffers.

Guybrush

4,364 posts

237 months

Friday 12th April 2013
quotequote all
steveb8189 said:
Artice said:
and I do now find myself checking my speed more regularly than before
The cynic in me would say you should be keeping your eyes on the road...
Quite. By speed watching via the instrument, you may not get caught exceeding the stupidly low limits, but you may become a less safe driver.

Devil2575

13,400 posts

219 months

Friday 12th April 2013
quotequote all
Artice said:
He surveyed the room, pointed to the heavily pregnant woman who had earlier confessed to being 2mph over the speed limit.
Artice said:
Offenders are only offered places if their speed falls within 10 per cent + 2mph to 10 per cent + 9mph of the limit. For example; the tolerance level of a 30mph zone is actually 35mph before prosecution
Am I the only onw who thinks this doesn't make sense?

2 mph over the limit, yet the tollerance level is actually 10% + 2mph.



Edited by Devil2575 on Friday 12th April 12:17

eldar

25,351 posts

227 months

Friday 12th April 2013
quotequote all
Set your cruise control to 2mph below the limit and doze. Obviously emergency brake stabbing every time you spot a camera. Must be safe, it is becoming more common, it appears.

Dan Trent

1,866 posts

199 months

Friday 12th April 2013
quotequote all
Deva Link said:
Only a court can convict you. Only a court can fine you.
Correct, and corrected. And I'll see if Danny can clarify the circumstances of the pregnant lady's attendance.

Cheers,

Dan

exceed

455 posts

207 months

Friday 12th April 2013
quotequote all
I think any NSL should be unlimited, and towns, villages, cities and the like kept to 30-40mph.

Cars are soo much more capable these days that speed limits are obsolete...

Although I'm a strong contender of increasing the driving license difficulty and involving something along the lines of advanced driving days whereby you have to drive a car with 2 wheels and no brakes or experiencing a loss of control.

In a situation where speed is unlimited everyone will be doing whatever speed they feel safe at; For example I'm not going to feel very safe doing more than 80-85mph in my Peugeot 106 but would happily cruise at North of 120mph in my DC5/370Z.

Dual carriages around cities could remain at 70mph only to keep the green party happy.

Anubis

1,029 posts

210 months

Friday 12th April 2013
quotequote all
It's not about speeding - it's about being honest and fair by both driver and authorities.

Humans by nature make mistakes and by making someone continuously paranoid about their speed will make them a less safe driver - as my driving instructor many moons ago said "stop looking at the gauges so much; the danger is out there beyond the window". And that's just it - we've gone down a path of having to constantly look at instruments to tell us if we are being 'safe'.

More and more cameras appear, often already in perfectly safe areas. They are hidden behind signs, around corners and sneaky cops using mobile radars away from view (until it's too late). Rarely have I seen a genuine need for the things other than by a school or hospital for example. If speeding was really an issue in the area then stick some speed bumps along the road - they work.

Those that are obviously taking the censored and driving like a prat are by default bundled in with those that have made a small human mistake by driving 5mph above the limit. It's done by numbers and not by common sense, which only a human can determine such as a Police officer on patrol.

Cameras were intended to be used to stop death by dangerous driving - now they are there purely to generate cash for local authorities and in doing so means taking away driving licenses and increasing insurance premiums. All for the sake of an extra 2mph across 10ft of road. rolleyes - is that fair?

Edited by Anubis on Friday 12th April 12:24

MC Bodge

30,206 posts

206 months

Friday 12th April 2013
quotequote all
Funk said:
I would respect speed limits more if they stopped pointlessly reducing them on roads which have had higher limits for years.
Almost everywhere I drive I see examples of this, and there are often multiple changes of limit on previous NSL roads. The result of this being that it is often now the case that many side roads have higher speed limits than the more major ones.

By all means make people aware of the risks of sudden stops from speed or collisions with other road users, but exceeding the posted speed limit is not reckless or dangerous per se.

1mph under the limit isn't "safe" and 1mph over the lmit isn't "unsafe".

youngsyr

14,742 posts

223 months

Friday 12th April 2013
quotequote all
Article said:
Did they succeed in converting me?
Clearly they did:


Article said:
...
the NSAC ideology is quite sound; it wants to solve the speeding problem rather than just manage it by dishing out points and fines.
We have the safest roads in the world and fatalaties have fallen for nearly two decades, yet by your own admission "one-in-five drivers will get caught for speeding".

A cynical person would say that the only problem is that the limits are too low.

Varn

205 posts

232 months

Friday 12th April 2013
quotequote all
MrTrilby said:
steveb8189 said:
The cynic in me would say you should be keeping your eyes on the road...
The cynic in me would say that if you find it tricky keeping half an eye on your speed whilst watching the road, perhaps you're not the skilled driver you thought you are, and maybe a motoring enthusiast website is the wrong place for you.

Edited by MrTrilby on Friday 12th April 12:01
He didn't say that he finds it tricky. I believe he's referring to the % of your driving time looking out of the cockpit, not in. It's about maximum utilisation of your skill, no matter how much you have.

Funk

27,807 posts

240 months

Friday 12th April 2013
quotequote all
youngsyr said:
We have the safest roads in the world and fatalaties have fallen for nearly two decades, yet by your own admission "one-in-five drivers will get caught for speeding".

A cynical person would say that the only problem is that the limits are too low.
Actually a cynical person would say that the limits are set artificially low in order to generate revenue by turning drivers into cash machines.

How low do the limits go before someone eventually stands up and calls "bullst"? At this rate, all roads everywhere will be 20mph. In fact, how about a man with a flag walking in front of each car to make sure people know it's coming?

And apparently this is progress...

Devil2575

13,400 posts

219 months

Friday 12th April 2013
quotequote all
youngsyr said:
We have the safest roads in the world and fatalaties have fallen for nearly two decades, yet by your own admission "one-in-five drivers will get caught for speeding".

A cynical person would say that the only problem is that the limits are too low.
How do you know that part of the reason our roads are as safe as they are is not down to the limits?

I'm not saying it is, just challenging your assertion that limits are too low.

Roono

70 posts

190 months

Friday 12th April 2013
quotequote all
Join the hordes and just drive everywhere at 40mph. Doh, does not work in 30 limits.

After the BBC plastered the news about proposals for the National Speed Limit to be 50 mph on A-roads, the amount of numpties that just do 40 everywhere has increased (and the whole saving fuel thing). Most people I talk to at work seem to think the limit is now 50!

Ultimately on my journey to work, Mr/Miss/Mrs/Ms doing 40mph everywhere does catch me up compared to me sticking to the 30-60-40-30mph limit.

I do wonder what they think when I overtake them in a 60 and then they catch me up in a 30 because I am sticking to the speed limit. "look see Derrick, that idiot overtook you, but has not got anywhere" - 'hello' your speeding in a 30.

Rant sort of over. Thanks I feel better :-)

youngsyr

14,742 posts

223 months

Friday 12th April 2013
quotequote all
Funk said:
Actually a cynical person would say that the limits are set artificially low in order to generate revenue by turning drivers into cash machines.

How low do the limits go before someone eventually stands up and calls "bullst"? At this rate, all roads everywhere will be 20mph. In fact, how about a man with a flag walking in front of each car to make sure people know it's coming?

And apparently this is progress...
700 miles of Greater London roads were lowered to 20mph between 2008 and 2010 (https://www.whatdotheyknow.com/request/20mph_zones_in_london), to add to the 2,000 miles of them that already existed.

If you tried to run down Usain Bolt at that speed, you wouldn't catch him.

youngsyr

14,742 posts

223 months

Friday 12th April 2013
quotequote all
Devil2575 said:
youngsyr said:
We have the safest roads in the world and fatalaties have fallen for nearly two decades, yet by your own admission "one-in-five drivers will get caught for speeding".

A cynical person would say that the only problem is that the limits are too low.
How do you know that part of the reason our roads are as safe as they are is not down to the limits?

I'm not saying it is, just challenging your assertion that limits are too low.
Because at least 1 in 5 drivers ignore them. wink

Deva Link

26,934 posts

276 months

Friday 12th April 2013
quotequote all
eldar said:
Set your cruise control to 2mph below the limit and doze. Obviously emergency brake stabbing every time you spot a camera. Must be safe, it is becoming more common, it appears.
My Merc has a speed limiter and, as I drive all over the country, if I'm in an area where I don't know the speed trap locations then I set it for 2MPH above the limit.

Seems to go in phases but at the moment it's back in a phase of aggressive tailgating and ridiculous overtaking. Had a guy use a turn left lane to undertake me the other day, and he was then going so fast around a tight left bend that he ripped his OSF tyre in a rut in the road.