E46 330 - buying advice needed please!
Discussion
Thinking of selling my 2006 WRX and replacing it with an E46 330.
Ideally want the coupe but need to check how hard it is to get a baby seat in the back, otherwise it'll be the 4 door saloon.
Anyone regularly cram a baby into the back seat of a coupe?!
Anything I should be on the lookout for generally with the 330? Is the auto better/worse reliability wise than the manual? Also what are the timing belt changes on them?
I love the performance of the WRX but just find the interior a bit cheap. How reliable are the electric toys and bits in the BMW? I don't want to trade cars to then find that half the stuff in there stops working after a week and costs a shed load to fix!
All advice gratefully received
Ideally want the coupe but need to check how hard it is to get a baby seat in the back, otherwise it'll be the 4 door saloon.
Anyone regularly cram a baby into the back seat of a coupe?!

Anything I should be on the lookout for generally with the 330? Is the auto better/worse reliability wise than the manual? Also what are the timing belt changes on them?
I love the performance of the WRX but just find the interior a bit cheap. How reliable are the electric toys and bits in the BMW? I don't want to trade cars to then find that half the stuff in there stops working after a week and costs a shed load to fix!
All advice gratefully received

Very happy with my E46 coupe. The build quality is spot on and the interior is nice and smart, it feels like you're sitting in "grown up's" car. Great comfort with a nice driving position, weight distribution is pretty much perfect (coupe is less tail happy than the saloon as there's equal amounts of grip on the front wheels as there is on the back) and it corners like you're on rails. Just a brilliant car to drive, I love mine to bits.
...However, I'm single with no kids.
I think your coupe days are over bud =P
...However, I'm single with no kids.
I think your coupe days are over bud =P
There is no timing belt, it has a chain.
I have owned my 330i manual saloon for almost 6 years now and it has been brilliant.
Electrics are generally fairly robust, cooling system needs a refresh after about 80k, control arm bushes are pretty much a service item but are easy and cheap to replace.
I have owned my 330i manual saloon for almost 6 years now and it has been brilliant.
Electrics are generally fairly robust, cooling system needs a refresh after about 80k, control arm bushes are pretty much a service item but are easy and cheap to replace.
I've been looking at these. Put off by nearly all the ones I've seen having rotten arches, some better than others (seen some really nasty front arches that you could pretty much see through where the arch liner wears the paint off the inside of the lip then they rot from the inside out). Lots of reports of cracking around the rear subframe but don't really know if this will eventually affect all of them or it's just certain cars.
It's a shame as there's not much out there that's a direct comparison as most if not all the competitors are front wheel drive.
It's a shame as there's not much out there that's a direct comparison as most if not all the competitors are front wheel drive.
Auto is slower and uses more fuel, also reputed to die if the oil isn't changed, despite being sealed for life.
All electrics are still working fine on my X reg 330i, though the window regulator is a weak item (mine died just before I bought it,and needs coding to the ECU, so it's a few hundred to fix officially).
Radiator bulges at the bottom after 10 years, expansion tank can split and water pumps can fail. Control arm bushes perish too quickly and when the ball joints go you have to replace the whole arm.
Rear brake lines corrode if left unprotected.
Coil springs snap (so do nost cars, it seems).
Apart from routine service items, I think I've spent about a grand over 4 years (battery, radiator, 2 control arms, 4 springs - swapped to Eibach pros after one snapped, much better than stock sport springs). A lot of that cost was labour, if you're willing to work on it yourself.
Think there was an article in one of the mags recently, may still be on sale.
All electrics are still working fine on my X reg 330i, though the window regulator is a weak item (mine died just before I bought it,and needs coding to the ECU, so it's a few hundred to fix officially).
Radiator bulges at the bottom after 10 years, expansion tank can split and water pumps can fail. Control arm bushes perish too quickly and when the ball joints go you have to replace the whole arm.
Rear brake lines corrode if left unprotected.
Coil springs snap (so do nost cars, it seems).
Apart from routine service items, I think I've spent about a grand over 4 years (battery, radiator, 2 control arms, 4 springs - swapped to Eibach pros after one snapped, much better than stock sport springs). A lot of that cost was labour, if you're willing to work on it yourself.
Think there was an article in one of the mags recently, may still be on sale.
Others have commented on the general buying guide stuff so I'll comment on the child carrying bit.
I bought my first e46 coupe 4 days after my 2nd child was born. We had a Mamas & Papas Pimo Vaggio SIP car seat which clips into a base that normally stays in the car. It's a rear facing seat. We bought a spare base to make fitting into either car much easier. In the e46, the front seats flip forward quite far, but I did find that in order to clip the seat into the base I'd need to hold the seat at full extension of my arm. Mrs Mk1Matt, being less goatee'd than me, found this quite difficult. Once in, we'd then have to climb in and wrap the belt around that back of the seat.
I'm currently on my 2nd e46 coupe and the little man is now 2 and a half. His seat is now a foward facing Britax Prince. It's much easier, since he can climb into it himself, but before this we could get him in by climbing into the back with him and lifting him. Slightly awkward but not too bad.
What I would say is that it's not too bad to put the kids in when the car is on the drive, but in a tight car park it's a challenge, since the doors need to be open quite wide for us to climb in with him, and they're quite long.
Given my experience, as the main family car I'd choose the saloon to make things easier. Given that we've already got a Galaxy for family duties, kids in my car are a less regular occurrence so the coupe is ok.
I bought my first e46 coupe 4 days after my 2nd child was born. We had a Mamas & Papas Pimo Vaggio SIP car seat which clips into a base that normally stays in the car. It's a rear facing seat. We bought a spare base to make fitting into either car much easier. In the e46, the front seats flip forward quite far, but I did find that in order to clip the seat into the base I'd need to hold the seat at full extension of my arm. Mrs Mk1Matt, being less goatee'd than me, found this quite difficult. Once in, we'd then have to climb in and wrap the belt around that back of the seat.
I'm currently on my 2nd e46 coupe and the little man is now 2 and a half. His seat is now a foward facing Britax Prince. It's much easier, since he can climb into it himself, but before this we could get him in by climbing into the back with him and lifting him. Slightly awkward but not too bad.
What I would say is that it's not too bad to put the kids in when the car is on the drive, but in a tight car park it's a challenge, since the doors need to be open quite wide for us to climb in with him, and they're quite long.
Given my experience, as the main family car I'd choose the saloon to make things easier. Given that we've already got a Galaxy for family duties, kids in my car are a less regular occurrence so the coupe is ok.
Cheers for all the replies people, much appreciated! Just need to sell the WRX now...
We have an A6 so that's the main family car. The BMW wouldn't have her in it that often, although obviously there may be times when all three of us need to go in it. Sounds like it's a bit of a squeeze to get the seat in the back but not impossible so cheers for that mk1matt!
Did you ever try and put the rear facing seat in the front? The majority of the time that she'd be in the car would realistically be when I'm taking her to nursery and the wife would be at work. If it's a ball-ache to get the seat out of the back in a carpark then I could always have it in the front.
We have an A6 so that's the main family car. The BMW wouldn't have her in it that often, although obviously there may be times when all three of us need to go in it. Sounds like it's a bit of a squeeze to get the seat in the back but not impossible so cheers for that mk1matt!
Did you ever try and put the rear facing seat in the front? The majority of the time that she'd be in the car would realistically be when I'm taking her to nursery and the wife would be at work. If it's a ball-ache to get the seat out of the back in a carpark then I could always have it in the front.
Leebo310 said:
Cheers for all the replies people, much appreciated! Just need to sell the WRX now...
We have an A6 so that's the main family car. The BMW wouldn't have her in it that often, although obviously there may be times when all three of us need to go in it. Sounds like it's a bit of a squeeze to get the seat in the back but not impossible so cheers for that mk1matt!
Did you ever try and put the rear facing seat in the front? The majority of the time that she'd be in the car would realistically be when I'm taking her to nursery and the wife would be at work. If it's a ball-ache to get the seat out of the back in a carpark then I could always have it in the front.
I used to put my eldest son in the front my Mk2 Golf, but that was way before the days of airbags. Having them in the front is great, since you can easily see what they're up to and return dummies/toys when they drop them. It's a pain if you all go out as a family though, which is another reason for putting the youngest in the back these days.We have an A6 so that's the main family car. The BMW wouldn't have her in it that often, although obviously there may be times when all three of us need to go in it. Sounds like it's a bit of a squeeze to get the seat in the back but not impossible so cheers for that mk1matt!
Did you ever try and put the rear facing seat in the front? The majority of the time that she'd be in the car would realistically be when I'm taking her to nursery and the wife would be at work. If it's a ball-ache to get the seat out of the back in a carpark then I could always have it in the front.
I'm pretty sure the e46 doesn't have a switch to disable the passenger airbag so putting them in the front is a no-no. If you can get a dealer/indy to disable it via OBD, then go for it.
Your use sounds similar to mine - in which case go for the coupe!
mk1matt said:
I used to put my eldest son in the front my Mk2 Golf, but that was way before the days of airbags. Having them in the front is great, since you can easily see what they're up to and return dummies/toys when they drop them. It's a pain if you all go out as a family though, which is another reason for putting the youngest in the back these days.
I'm pretty sure the e46 doesn't have a switch to disable the passenger airbag so putting them in the front is a no-no. If you can get a dealer/indy to disable it via OBD, then go for it.
Your use sounds similar to mine - in which case go for the coupe!
Ah right, didn't realise they didn't have a switch to disable the front airbag...I'm pretty sure the e46 doesn't have a switch to disable the passenger airbag so putting them in the front is a no-no. If you can get a dealer/indy to disable it via OBD, then go for it.
Your use sounds similar to mine - in which case go for the coupe!
I'm going to print off your last sentence though and show it to my wife as proof that I should get the coupe

Gassing Station | General Gassing | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


