Walkie talkie radios
Discussion
Looking to buy a pair of ww radios, I have read a few adverts by several makers. Naturally they all speak glowingly about their products. I then read independent reviews by purchasers who, almost unanimously, rubbish the same items, with most reviews being blisteringly scathing.
For my sins I live in a very large house with an East wing and a West wing about fifty yards apart. It is thatched and has sandstone walls that are at least three feet thick. I need to be able to use the radios between the two wings. I mention the house because the thickness of the walls adversely affect mobile phone and cordless phone connections, and the thatch, which is typically reinforced with wire mesh at the crowns and ridges etc., also bugger up Internet and mobile signals due to the wire mesh screening ( I need only to have lined the attic floors with aluminium cooking foil and I'd be totally cut off from any exterior signals short of nuclear microwave transmissions ! )
If anybody uses walkie talkies that they are wholeheartedly satisfied with, I'd love to hear from them.
Cheers !
For my sins I live in a very large house with an East wing and a West wing about fifty yards apart. It is thatched and has sandstone walls that are at least three feet thick. I need to be able to use the radios between the two wings. I mention the house because the thickness of the walls adversely affect mobile phone and cordless phone connections, and the thatch, which is typically reinforced with wire mesh at the crowns and ridges etc., also bugger up Internet and mobile signals due to the wire mesh screening ( I need only to have lined the attic floors with aluminium cooking foil and I'd be totally cut off from any exterior signals short of nuclear microwave transmissions ! )
If anybody uses walkie talkies that they are wholeheartedly satisfied with, I'd love to hear from them.
Cheers !
Mr MXT said:
Worst 'I have a massive house' post, ever!
Thanks, amigo, that was a really helpful response. It's a pity that you don't have the sense to recognise that the details of the house are key to the nature of the problem. If I lived in a plywood and plastic mobile home I wouldn't need walkie talkies in the first place !NiceCupOfTea said:
I've got some binatone ones I've used for convoying and comms between garage and house. They've been very good, range is 2 or 3 miles so probably good for your use even with thick walls.
I much appreciate your helpful and useful response. Can you provide details of what model they are in the Binatone range ?Cheers !
Salt flat rat said:
Thanks, amigo, that was a really helpful response. It's a pity that you don't have the sense to recognise that the details of the house are key to the nature of the problem. If I lived in a plywood and plastic mobile home I wouldn't need walkie talkies in the first place !
Wind your neck in, it was a joke.The Motorola T5 are quite good and they have a good range so if you use them for convoys or large spaces then they could be up for the job. Just looking a little search on Motorola T5 they have twin packs for a little over £50.00. They are also pretty rugged so a drop or two will see them still working and the casing still intact.
Battery life is fairly good as well so depending what you need them for they can accept rechargeable or normal batteries.
Battery life is fairly good as well so depending what you need them for they can accept rechargeable or normal batteries.
Most low-end 2 way radios sold on Amazon etc. use a common, license-free band (PMR band) and use the same transmit power, frequencies etc. so they all tend to have very similar performance, although the really cheap ones won't have particularly good antennas or sensitive receivers, so won't perform as well as the good ones. To a certain extent, you can buy on price with these. I would go for something costing around £50 for a pair as a minimum.
There are professional PMR radios which cost >£100 each made by the likes of Kenwood and Motorola and these will be better built, have more channels and features and rechargeable battery packs, but they're still essentially using the same radios inside. I have some Kenwood PMR radios and the range on those I am sure would be fine in your environment, but you may not want to spend the money or need all the features.
There are professional PMR radios which cost >£100 each made by the likes of Kenwood and Motorola and these will be better built, have more channels and features and rechargeable battery packs, but they're still essentially using the same radios inside. I have some Kenwood PMR radios and the range on those I am sure would be fine in your environment, but you may not want to spend the money or need all the features.
PMR446 are limited to half a watt, which generally measn you need line of sight, ie won't work too well through thick walls. Anything more powerfull than that and you need a licence. However some newer radios do seem to be getting a lot more range out of the same power. A couple of mates have recently bought Midland G8 radios and seem to get way more range than my Wintec A80 which might be running at slightly more than the official power.
Mr MXT said:
Wind your neck in, it was a joke.
Fine, I'm pleased to hear that it was a joke. My problem is that this forum ( and a couple of others ) seems to have , from my previous experience, a number of contributors who are happy to be " edgy " wind up artistes who submit emails that seem to be anything other than a joke and then when they get a response different to that perhaps intended, plead " it was only a joke ". Maybe, but it didn't make me laugh.Salt flat rat said:
NiceCupOfTea said:
I've got some binatone ones I've used for convoying and comms between garage and house. They've been very good, range is 2 or 3 miles so probably good for your use even with thick walls.
I much appreciate your helpful and useful response. Can you provide details of what model they are in the Binatone range ?Cheers !
NiceCupOfTea said:
I've got some binatone ones I've used for convoying and comms between garage and house. They've been very good, range is 2 or 3 miles so probably good for your use even with thick walls.
This. Binatone Terrain 550s are the ones I use when skiing - if they work across 3 miles of forest/mountain then they'll work in your house. They are also well made and nice to use. Avoid the cheap walkie talkies, they are awfulAlternative idea, can you get VOIP radios at a sensible price yet? The only ones I've seen are all singing all dancing radios with wifi basestations and other stuff built in. If you have wired internet (or homeplugs) with a wifi hub in each wing, you could do it with skype on a couple of mobile phones, but someone must do a dedicated bit of hardware for that.
Salt flat rat said:
Fine, I'm pleased to hear that it was a joke. My problem is that this forum ( and a couple of others ) seems to have , from my previous experience, a number of contributors who are happy to be " edgy " wind up artistes who submit emails that seem to be anything other than a joke and then when they get a response different to that perhaps intended, plead " it was only a joke ". Maybe, but it didn't make me laugh.
Now that was pretty funny.Salt flat rat said:
Mr MXT said:
Wind your neck in, it was a joke.
Fine, I'm pleased to hear that it was a joke. My problem is that this forum ( and a couple of others ) seems to have , from my previous experience, a number of contributors who are happy to be " edgy " wind up artistes who submit emails that seem to be anything other than a joke and then when they get a response different to that perhaps intended, plead " it was only a joke ". Maybe, but it didn't make me laugh.Mr MXT said:
Salt flat rat said:
Mr MXT said:
Wind your neck in, it was a joke.
Fine, I'm pleased to hear that it was a joke. My problem is that this forum ( and a couple of others ) seems to have , from my previous experience, a number of contributors who are happy to be " edgy " wind up artistes who submit emails that seem to be anything other than a joke and then when they get a response different to that perhaps intended, plead " it was only a joke ". Maybe, but it didn't make me laugh.Edited by billzeebub on Saturday 13th April 00:41
http://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/MOTOROLA-GP320-RADIOS-WA...
Something like that should do the trick, professional level, not the cut down toys.
Something like that should do the trick, professional level, not the cut down toys.
Gassing Station | General Gassing | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff



