Buying a car as a surprise gift... Experiences? Pitfalls?
Buying a car as a surprise gift... Experiences? Pitfalls?
Author
Discussion

the_lone_wolf

Original Poster:

2,622 posts

217 months

Friday 12th April 2013
quotequote all
Hi all

At some point this summer my partner will be passing her driving test, I intend to buy her a car, don't worry, when she quite seriously tells you "I don't need diamonds, I really want an MX-5" you know she's the one... wink

Thing is, I'd like it to be a surprise.

Obviously people must have done this before, can anybody enlighten me to any pitfalls that I might not have thought of?

Two I can think of:

1. Assuming I want her name to go down on the V5, is there a way to do this without her knowledge? She would understand if I had to forge her signature, but preferably not...

2. Insurance, we're not married, haven't got my documents on me right now but assuming my DOC cover is what it usually is; "Valid for any vehicle not owned or rented to the policy holder" would I be covered to drive any car back from a purchase, as my name wouldn't be on the new keeper slip? Or better to just call my insurer and get them to add it to my policy for a few weeks until she passes her test? - I suspect the latter

Any other comments?

james12345

619 posts

267 months

Friday 12th April 2013
quotequote all
I did this with a Moriis Minor convertible for my wife as a surprise birthday present last summer.

I decided that it was all too risky to try to put anything in her name, so the car is registered to me, and also insured with me as the policyholder.

I had to tell her not to open any post adressed to me - which was lucky as usually she would have opened the V5C that arrived to file it / see if it was a tax reminder etc.

the_lone_wolf

Original Poster:

2,622 posts

217 months

Friday 12th April 2013
quotequote all
Thanks James

I thought that might have to be the way - I suspect the only alternative would be to try and sign her name on the V5c, I know she wouldn't mind but I'd have to intercept the postie (although we'll be living in a household of four, three of whom would be in on it...)

Could start practising signatures... biggrin

lestershaw

1,591 posts

189 months

Friday 12th April 2013
quotequote all
i bought my girlfriend a citroen bx 19 4x4 gti, i thought it was cracking car and cost 4 times as much as the golf that had just died on her.
she went mad, "if i want a new car i will choose it myself" she said, "i cant believe you didnt ask me what i would like" etc so i sold it for £2k and let her get her own car, she ended up with a daewoo ho ho

Lee540

1,586 posts

175 months

Friday 12th April 2013
quotequote all
I bought a car as a present..

Wait till nearer the time, find a car, go and view etc.. place deposit..

Sunday afternoon, take mrs out for a drive in the car, randomly stop at dealer.. and finish the deal with her there

the_lone_wolf

Original Poster:

2,622 posts

217 months

Friday 12th April 2013
quotequote all
lestershaw said:
i bought my girlfriend a citroen bx 19 4x4 gti, i thought it was cracking car and cost 4 times as much as the golf that had just died on her.
she went mad, "if i want a new car i will choose it myself" she said, "i cant believe you didnt ask me what i would like" etc so i sold it for £2k and let her get her own car, she ended up with a daewoo ho ho
Oh dear!! Have to taken a trip to the "The Mental" thread over in the lounge? biggrinwink

I don't think that's going to happen here, her heart was set on the MX-5 as soon as she saw it. She doesn't think she can afford it and has resigned herself to not getting one - we're a UK-HR couple and we're in the process of dealing with the ineptitude of the UKBA trying to get entry clearance to come and settle in the UK, so I figure it would be a nice surprise when we eventually get home...

Just need an excuse to go on some spurious "test drives" or "look baby, they've got an MX-5 for sale, wanna go and sit in it?"

biggrin

zedx19

3,050 posts

171 months

Friday 12th April 2013
quotequote all
lestershaw said:
i bought my girlfriend a citroen bx 19 4x4 gti, i thought it was cracking car and cost 4 times as much as the golf that had just died on her.
she went mad, "if i want a new car i will choose it myself" she said, "i cant believe you didnt ask me what i would like" etc so i sold it for £2k and let her get her own car, she ended up with a daewoo ho ho
I assume you quickly ended the relationship after this?? Deal breaker imo!

Risotto

3,934 posts

243 months

Friday 12th April 2013
quotequote all
Can't you just put your partner's name on the V5 but give the address as that of a relative?

I don't think DVLA care whether the address on the V5 is a residential address or a correspondence address, as long as they can use it as a means to contact the registered keeper. At some point after you've handed over the car, just fill out the V5 as you would for any other change of address.

I wouldn't worry about signing the V5, I've sent unsigned ones to DVLA in the past and they simply don't care.

As for insurance, you can get day insurance if you need to. My experience is that insurance companies tend to get very confused if you tell them you're the owner but not the registered keeper. If you persist, most will eventually grasp the concept and will cover you.

Edited by Risotto on Friday 12th April 15:46

trickywoo

14,281 posts

261 months

Friday 12th April 2013
quotequote all
the_lone_wolf said:
assuming my DOC cover is what it usually is; "Valid for any vehicle not owned or rented to the policy holder" would I be covered to drive any car back from a purchase
Unlikely as the car in question usually has to have a policy of its own before you can use the DOC.

lestershaw

1,591 posts

189 months

Friday 12th April 2013
quotequote all
zedx19 said:
I assume you quickly ended the relationship after this?? Deal breaker imo!
yes i did,( she kicked me out for sleeping with a pole dancer, but thats covered in another thread)

it didnt help that when her golf was dying i gave her £500 to fix a problem, she went to her "friendly" mechanic and said she had £500 to fix the problem !! doh and guess what it came to £498 grrr

Edited by lestershaw on Friday 12th April 15:46

the_lone_wolf

Original Poster:

2,622 posts

217 months

Friday 12th April 2013
quotequote all
trickywoo said:
the_lone_wolf said:
assuming my DOC cover is what it usually is; "Valid for any vehicle not owned or rented to the policy holder" would I be covered to drive any car back from a purchase
Unlikely as the car in question usually has to have a policy of its own before you can use the DOC.
Yep, just checked this year's policy documents, looks like they changed that...

Haven't needed it for several years now, and the last time I needed it I phoned to confirm and found out they'd removed it and forgotten to let me know when I told them I'd deliberately resigned to take six months out and change career paths - would always phone to confirm first smile

Could always insure it in her name with me as a named driver - knocks about 25% off her premium and a new driver and means I can "borrow" the MX-5 wink

Risotto

3,934 posts

243 months

Friday 12th April 2013
quotequote all
the_lone_wolf said:
trickywoo said:
the_lone_wolf said:
assuming my DOC cover is what it usually is; "Valid for any vehicle not owned or rented to the policy holder" would I be covered to drive any car back from a purchase
Unlikely as the car in question usually has to have a policy of its own before you can use the DOC.
Yep, just checked this year's policy documents, looks like they changed that...

Haven't needed it for several years now, and the last time I needed it I phoned to confirm and found out they'd removed it and forgotten to let me know when I told them I'd deliberately resigned to take six months out and change career paths - would always phone to confirm first smile

Could always insure it in her name with me as a named driver - knocks about 25% off her premium and a new driver and means I can "borrow" the MX-5 wink
Has it ever been the case that you could use the DOC clause to drive a car which is not covered by another policy?

the_lone_wolf

Original Poster:

2,622 posts

217 months

Friday 12th April 2013
quotequote all
Risotto said:
Has it ever been the case that you could use the DOC clause to drive a car which is not covered by another policy?
Yes, I'm well aware of it becoming a standard clause on insurance policies and I've had policies where it wasn't mentioned anywhere in the paperwork, but that's going back a few years now smile

LouD86

3,290 posts

184 months

Friday 12th April 2013
quotequote all
Do it! She will love it.

As for the signature on the V5, ive signed it as mickey mouse before, I dont honestly think they check!


MX-5 will be a great little car, I treated my mum to one last year as her 50th. She loved the idea of a topless sports car in red, in my budget thats all I could afford. Just sold it, for an MR-S, also in red, which she loves more!

Just gotta take the risk, im sure itll be worth it. You could sort the insurance out for her aswell, online?? That way your not signing anything wink

the_lone_wolf

Original Poster:

2,622 posts

217 months

Friday 12th April 2013
quotequote all
LouD86 said:
Just gotta take the risk, im sure itll be worth it. You could sort the insurance out for her aswell, online?? That way your not signing anything wink
I'm planning on buying it and keeping it at a 3rd party location off the road until she has her test, when she's doing the test go wash it and bring it home, park it on the drive with a bow on it so when she comes home it's there waiting, insured, ready to go for a drive smile

TurboBlue

686 posts

194 months

Friday 12th April 2013
quotequote all
Did this once a while ago; wife's 190E 2.6 manual was a bit tired and we had our second child on the way so I part-exchanged the '88 190E for a '98 C240 Elegance Auto. The 190 was in Almandine metallic which is a proper pink-red, the C240 was beige! Problem is I don't really bother myself about colour but for my wife it's the first point of reference for whether a car is desirable; she was happy with a newer, safer, easier to drive car but if I were to do it again I'd try to think about it more from her point of view.

SRi Slim R

294 posts

169 months

Friday 12th April 2013
quotequote all
The DVLA don't care about the V5, as once my dad put a fully roadworthy and working Nissan Micra he bought for £80 on my little sisters name. She was 4 at the time

Marcellus

7,210 posts

250 months

Friday 12th April 2013
quotequote all
Are we talking a 2nd hand one... If so ask the seller to hold off sending the forms until after her birthday then job done.

Effortless

197 posts

226 months

Friday 12th April 2013
quotequote all
As an ex-salesman, I have 2 horror stories...

Working for Stratstone Jaguar, a copper bought an S-Type 3.0 from me, for his wife, as a surprise. At handover, she looked at the S-Type, exclaimed, "Oh my God, it's so big, why didn't you get me one of those!!", pointing to an X-Type next to us the handover bay.

The handover was completed in awkward silence with two stony-faced customers.

A few years later at BMW, a chap bought a new X3 3.0i Sport in sapphire black for his wife, as a surprise. He had it delivered to the house on the morning of her birthday, and did the whole "wrapped in ribbon" with flowers thing. When she saw it, she apparently flipped, started shouting how she hated it, it was far too big, she hated black etc etc.

The poor chap returned it the next day... and lost £6k overnight. I think she ended up choosing an Audi A3 or something.

I think the moral of the story is... be damn sure she will be happy with your choice!! Not everyone is brought up to accept gifts with graciousness, even if it's not what they want!!

Cheers,
Effortless.

CAPP0

20,881 posts

234 months

Friday 12th April 2013
quotequote all
I did it with a Vespa for MrsC - same issues around V5/insurance etc, but I hid the scooter at a friend's, and since we have a friendly local postie, I managed to arrange for anything insurance related to be delivered to a neighbour when postie saw the Direct Line logo on the envelope, and I just sat on the V5 until after I gave it to her so that nothing arrived at the house (depends how long you have between purchase/presentation I guess).

On the day, I had already spirited her crash helmet out of the house and I left it on the seat of the scooter at our friend's place. Suggested to her that we went over for a cup of tea, and just took her out to the garden and stood back and watched the bemused/amazed/surprised face unfold!