Practical (but acceptable) 2nd car choice....
Practical (but acceptable) 2nd car choice....
Author
Discussion

keiron

Original Poster:

11 posts

243 months

Friday 12th April 2013
quotequote all
I'm faced with swapping my BMW 120d M-sport coupe for something with 4 doors which needs to be newer, economical and more practical and effectively cost neutral to buy (nursery run is a pain with 2 kids in a 1 coupe) I've got a 3.0 BMW z4 as my fun car so my practical car can focus on just being practical for kids and cheap and comfy on my very long motorway commute (but ideally not too painful to drive)

I'm faced with a choice the following at my local motorpoint and I'm struggling to find the time (or if i'm honest motivation) to test drive they are all the same price and 1-2 years old with same mileage, cost about £11K

Astra SRI 2.0cdti 160ps
Focus Zetec 1.6 cdti 115ps
Alfa Giuletta 1.6 cdti 105pd


Alfa looks too be too slow and concerned about reliability for a "mileage" car so im pretty much discounting this.

Focus would probably be my choice it had a bit more then 115ps (or if anyone's driven one is it ok?)

Astra seems like a lot of car for the money but i'm guessing there is a reason for this..

any thoughts appreciated on which?


aka_kerrly

12,506 posts

241 months

Friday 12th April 2013
quotequote all
Being honest, after having the BMW I wouldn't want any of those suggestions.

Why the stipulation that it has to be newer? Surely a E90 3 series would be a better choice even if it is 2 years older than a Astra!

keiron

Original Poster:

11 posts

243 months

Friday 12th April 2013
quotequote all
aka_kerrly said:
Why the stipulation that it has to be newer? Surely a E90 3 series would be a better choice even if it is 2 years older than a Astra!
A good question and I Forgot to mention the other factor, it needs to be FWD, I live very rurally and being house bound for 2 weeks this year soon lost its novelty value, I could get winter tires on a BM but this car needs to effectively be "white goods" A car you don't think about it just works, no fuss and servicing etc is cheap (helped by a nice manufacturers warranty)


Edited by keiron on Friday 12th April 15:30

aka_kerrly

12,506 posts

241 months

Friday 12th April 2013
quotequote all
keiron said:
A good question and I Forgot to mention the other factor, it needs to be FWD, I live very rurally and being house bound for 2 weeks this year soon lost its novelty value, I could get winter tires on a BM but this car needs to effectively be "white goods" A car you don't think about it just works, no fuss and servicing etc is cheap (helped by a nice manufacturers warranty)


Edited by keiron on Friday 12th April 15:30
I see, regarding the point about warranty, cheap servicing, I'm going to do something I have never done before and suggest looking at the current Kia + Hyundai offerings. If you get an approved Kia you get the balance of the 7 year warranty and your £11k ought to get you a 1-2 year old Cee'D aka reasonably priced car ;-)