What Car? 4 Choices
Poll: What Car? 4 Choices
Total Members Polled: 219
Discussion
I'm about to buy my next convertible and have set myself a budget of around £10K. My 4 choices at the moment are:
07 Audi TT 3.2 with 90K miles
06 Nissan 350Z with 50K miles
07 Alfa Spider 2.2 with 30K miles
06 (987) Boxster 2.7 with 75K miles
This is a second/third car so won't be used every day and only in the summer.
I've had a Porsche before (but both 911's) and do like them and my budget just gets me into a 987.
I've never owned an Alfa but the only person I know who did had lots of issues with it (his was a 159 wagon with double the mileage though)
No idea about the Nissan or the Audi.
Thoughts from the PH massive ?
07 Audi TT 3.2 with 90K miles
06 Nissan 350Z with 50K miles
07 Alfa Spider 2.2 with 30K miles
06 (987) Boxster 2.7 with 75K miles
This is a second/third car so won't be used every day and only in the summer.
I've had a Porsche before (but both 911's) and do like them and my budget just gets me into a 987.
I've never owned an Alfa but the only person I know who did had lots of issues with it (his was a 159 wagon with double the mileage though)
No idea about the Nissan or the Audi.
Thoughts from the PH massive ?
OK I'll qualify my statement about the Boxster.
As said, I own a 350Z, and its a very characterful car indeed, but it is also very heavy and not the sharpest handler, although considering its weight its pretty good, and would be my choice if you like oversteer, as its very easy to invoke.
However, I just reckon the Boxster would be the better drivers car, sound just as good, be almost as fast but have much better handling, but probably less reliable. But if its a toy, it would be my choice out of this lot.
ETA I've driven the TT. Very dull.
As said, I own a 350Z, and its a very characterful car indeed, but it is also very heavy and not the sharpest handler, although considering its weight its pretty good, and would be my choice if you like oversteer, as its very easy to invoke.
However, I just reckon the Boxster would be the better drivers car, sound just as good, be almost as fast but have much better handling, but probably less reliable. But if its a toy, it would be my choice out of this lot.
ETA I've driven the TT. Very dull.
Edited by TameRacingDriver on Saturday 13th April 19:22
Not having driven any of them, my opinion is completely meaningless, but I'd go for the Porsche.
I didn't actually know there was a 350Z convertible! Regardless, they just strike me as being a little too "manufactured".
The Alfa is an altogether much more attractive car, but on paper it looks far too slow to justify being as thirsty as it is? In fact, it just looks too slow to be a fun car full stop, unless it's got the same sort of handling as an MX-5 and I'm not aware of it?
The Boxster, what's not to like apart from being maybe a slightly ropier example for the budget than the others would be?
Audi TTs always make me feel like going to try and find an actuary to chat too, in the hope that it might liven the party up a bit. A TT convertible would be an actuary wearing novelty Homer Simpson socks.
I didn't actually know there was a 350Z convertible! Regardless, they just strike me as being a little too "manufactured".
The Alfa is an altogether much more attractive car, but on paper it looks far too slow to justify being as thirsty as it is? In fact, it just looks too slow to be a fun car full stop, unless it's got the same sort of handling as an MX-5 and I'm not aware of it?
The Boxster, what's not to like apart from being maybe a slightly ropier example for the budget than the others would be?
Audi TTs always make me feel like going to try and find an actuary to chat too, in the hope that it might liven the party up a bit. A TT convertible would be an actuary wearing novelty Homer Simpson socks.
Gassing Station | General Gassing | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff





