Learning how to work on your car?
Learning how to work on your car?
Author
Discussion

sammym

Original Poster:

40 posts

163 months

Sunday 14th April 2013
quotequote all
Right - I can do basic things like change brake pads and disks and also do servicing. I have an interest in motoring, but I got to the point a month ago when my alternator went where I just didn't fancy the job. It was a lack of confidence and needing a car for work.

So how did you guys go about learning how to work on your cars? I have a Haynes Manual and that stuff, but see many of you on here taking out engines and replacing clutches which I would never dream of being able to do.

I don't have a garage but do have a reasonable tool kit, and am willing to invest in myself. I enjoy doing a job when it goes right. However I just wondered how you got into working on your cars.


steveo3002

11,243 posts

205 months

Sunday 14th April 2013
quotequote all
i learnt by getting on with it and learning by my mistakes , its much easier now with tinternet , you can punch in your car and the fault and someone will have posted details how to do it

dont get too ambitious at first

Willy Nilly

12,511 posts

198 months

Sunday 14th April 2013
quotequote all
Just a thought. I had my car serviced and MOT'd on Thursday. The total bill was £270. I would have had to pay for the parts and MOT even if I did it myself. The labour cost me 90 quid. I don't know what he charges per hour but I do know that for 90 quid it's not worth me spending a day pissing about with it, breaking it and getting him to do it anyway.

matlee

777 posts

182 months

Sunday 14th April 2013
quotequote all
Dive straight in! Thats what i did, anyway. I didnt have the faintest clue about car mechanics so i bought an MX5 and did this to it (albeit for a kit car build).



Fast forward 12 months and lots of reading up online and i dont think theres a single thing that will go wrong with the car that i wont be able to fix myself.

orangesrule

1,972 posts

179 months

Sunday 14th April 2013
quotequote all
Willy Nilly said:
Just a thought. I had my car serviced and MOT'd on Thursday. The total bill was £270. I would have had to pay for the parts and MOT even if I did it myself. The labour cost me 90 quid. I don't know what he charges per hour but I do know that for 90 quid it's not worth me spending a day pissing about with it, breaking it and getting him to do it anyway.
Fair enough, but you probably paid a mark up on the parts too.


Matt UK

18,084 posts

231 months

Sunday 14th April 2013
quotequote all
Willy Nilly said:
Just a thought. I had my car serviced and MOT'd on Thursday. The total bill was £270. I would have had to pay for the parts and MOT even if I did it myself. The labour cost me 90 quid. I don't know what he charges per hour but I do know that for 90 quid it's not worth me spending a day pissing about with it, breaking it and getting him to do it anyway.
This is a fair point. Although playing with cars can be fun, you have to put a price on your spare and decide if its what you want to be doing.

I think the other critical thing is to play around on a car which is not your daily driver.
That way you can take you time. And if your feel things are not going as you planned, shut the garage door and come back to it next Sunday when you have the appropriate time / tools / parts / knowledge to finish the job.

As much as I love a tinkering with the Caterham in the garage, the thought of having one of the daily drivers in bits on the driveway at 6pm on Sunday fills me with enough dread to just pay someone else to do the jobs I don't fancy.

sammym

Original Poster:

40 posts

163 months

Sunday 14th April 2013
quotequote all
Willy Nilly said:
Just a thought. I had my car serviced and MOT'd on Thursday. The total bill was £270. I would have had to pay for the parts and MOT even if I did it myself. The labour cost me 90 quid. I don't know what he charges per hour but I do know that for 90 quid it's not worth me spending a day pissing about with it, breaking it and getting him to do it anyway.
Logically you are right - I earn between 200-500 a day. Given it would take me 5 times as long as any mechanic to do a simple job then it's madness for me to do it myself.

However - even with simple jobs I quite enjoy it. Ideally I'd like to have a little garage with a nice set up, but I don't want the cost of that. So I am limited to what I can do with a jack, some axle stands and a laptop with dealer software.

So it's more of a hobby. I remember watching the video of the bloke with the porshe and a custom made garage, I thought how much fun it would be having something like that. I just don't want to sink 50k into it.

Also I can get a service and an MOT for £99 from a decent garage. So it's not about money. It's about trying new stuff and enjoying myself.

steveo3002

11,243 posts

205 months

Sunday 14th April 2013
quotequote all
£270 at a garage would prob take the average guy a couple of hours at home , and as said they mark up the parts too

would certainly be worth my time ...if your a high earner why even consider getting dirty

crosseyedlion

2,382 posts

229 months

Sunday 14th April 2013
quotequote all
Willy Nilly said:
Just a thought. I had my car serviced and MOT'd on Thursday. The total bill was £270. I would have had to pay for the parts and MOT even if I did it myself. The labour cost me 90 quid. I don't know what he charges per hour but I do know that for 90 quid it's not worth me spending a day pissing about with it, breaking it and getting him to do it anyway.
You do realise garages usually make money on parts too?

Sounds like it was 1-1.5 hours labour, if it was yourself it might be 3 hours. 3 hours for the sake of saving £100, I'd say thats worth it.

However, I was a mechanic myself, so may be a little biased.

As for advice on learning on cars, the best way to learn would be rebuilding something old. The more seized parts/bolts the better. No matter what any mechanic pretends, cars a blummin simple things. Even now. The skill and knowledge comes into it when liberating seized parts really.

Some things are a pain to do, but never actually requiring much beyond logic.

Professionals will try and bamboozle you with talk 'oh its all computerised now blah blah'. True, but ways around that, and software to access it are readily available, so much info online. Diagnosis is often easier, it will tell you the culprit. Its all glorified parts fitting now.

If it was 'engineering' a car, thats when things are more complicated. Don't get me started on people calling themselves 'motor engineers' when they are techs.

All you need is logic.

So yes, get an old rusty bangar, rebuild it. You'll have the understanding of how to take apart/put stuff back together you need and a warm glow of satisfaction at the end of any repair you complete yourself.

DocArbathnot

29,100 posts

214 months

Sunday 14th April 2013
quotequote all
Matt UK said:
Willy Nilly said:
Just a thought. I had my car serviced and MOT'd on Thursday. The total bill was £270. I would have had to pay for the parts and MOT even if I did it myself. The labour cost me 90 quid. I don't know what he charges per hour but I do know that for 90 quid it's not worth me spending a day pissing about with it, breaking it and getting him to do it anyway.
This is a fair point. Although playing with cars can be fun, you have to put a price on your spare and decide if its what you want to be doing.

I think the other critical thing is to play around on a car which is not your daily driver.
That way you can take you time. And if your feel things are not going as you planned, shut the garage door and come back to it next Sunday when you have the appropriate time / tools / parts / knowledge to finish the job.

As much as I love a tinkering with the Caterham in the garage, the thought of having one of the daily drivers in bits on the driveway at 6pm on Sunday fills me with enough dread to just pay someone else to do the jobs I don't fancy.
I had this attitude when I was working all the hours that god sends. Free time was valuable, I would rather earn and pay a professional. However I've slowed down at work, have more time and quite enjoy it.

deltashad

6,731 posts

228 months

Sunday 14th April 2013
quotequote all
I keep buying more and more stuff for my garage. Ive had a compressor and spray can for about ten years and still never been used. My fancy assed welder and bottle have never been used. That's about 1.5 years gathering dust.

I can do brakes and change the alternator quicker on an integrale quicker than my local garage. But it ends there.

I want to be good at working on cars but im too lazy and afraid of making things worse.

philmots

4,666 posts

291 months

Sunday 14th April 2013
quotequote all
Ill have a go at anything that can be done on axle stands etc..

If I can't do it then it goes to the garage! ...not had to do it yet.

sammym

Original Poster:

40 posts

163 months

Sunday 14th April 2013
quotequote all
It's a shame no one is local to me who is decent.

I'd happily make the tea and coffee and pass the tools for a while just for the insight and knowleldge.

DocArbathnot

29,100 posts

214 months

Sunday 14th April 2013
quotequote all
sammym said:
It's a shame no one is local to me who is decent.

I'd happily make the tea and coffee and pass the tools for a while just for the insight and knowleldge.
You could enrole for evening classes @ your local college. I just picked up a Haynes and started from necessity (young skint and working in the gutter)however I also managed to screw some stuff up with some very unhealthy bodges.

I started on motorbikes.

williredale

2,866 posts

183 months

Sunday 14th April 2013
quotequote all
It has all been said above really but just do it. This year on my daily driverI've changed the power steering reservoir, track rod, track rod end, coolant hose (that I split due to stupidity) and adjusted my sunroof to stop it rattling. None of them are very big jobs and there's loads of instructions on the Internet. I have a weekend car though so when I split the hose I had the luxury of taking the other car to work. I've also done loads to the weekend car.

Start small, know your limits and know when to get a pro to do it. It helps that's enjoy tinkering with cars!

sammym

Original Poster:

40 posts

163 months

Sunday 14th April 2013
quotequote all
williredale said:
It has all been said above really but just do it. This year on my daily driverI've changed the power steering reservoir, track rod, track rod end, coolant hose (that I split due to stupidity) and adjusted my sunroof to stop it rattling. None of them are very big jobs and there's loads of instructions on the Internet. I have a weekend car though so when I split the hose I had the luxury of taking the other car to work. I've also done loads to the weekend car.

Start small, know your limits and know when to get a pro to do it. It helps that's enjoy tinkering with cars!
I see a trend here. Get a cheap second weekend car to use when I break the main one! Something that is cheap in everything but fuel seems to be in order. I quite fancy an mx5 but don't want a rust bucket. I shall have to look.

Willy Nilly

12,511 posts

198 months

Sunday 14th April 2013
quotequote all
orangesrule said:
Willy Nilly said:
Just a thought. I had my car serviced and MOT'd on Thursday. The total bill was £270. I would have had to pay for the parts and MOT even if I did it myself. The labour cost me 90 quid. I don't know what he charges per hour but I do know that for 90 quid it's not worth me spending a day pissing about with it, breaking it and getting him to do it anyway.
Fair enough, but you probably paid a mark up on the parts too.
Engine Oil: £23.75
Oil Filter: £5.25
Air Filter: £11.50
Pollen Filter: £10.80
Spark Plugs £16.76
Throttle Cleaner£ 3.00
Brake Cleaner £ 3.00

So what if he has put a mark up on the spares, he has a premises to keep, tools to pay for and a family to provide for.

Yes I could have changed the oil, filters and plugs my self easily enough but I don't have the facilities at home to do it which would have meant working on it at work and as I will be spending a lot of time at work between now and November I don't want to pull into the yard unless I am being paid.


snowdude2910

754 posts

195 months

Sunday 14th April 2013
quotequote all
I think it's more about mentality than anything, once you get into your head it is just a car or even simpler it is just a collection of parts bolted together it's easy. My cars have only ever seen a garage for servicing since I've been driving and I had no mechanical experience before that, well I tell a lie I bought a car which had the anti-roll bar fitted above the wishbones as opposed to underneath once and it took a trip to the garage to figure out what was making the knocking noise. At the end of the day just get stuck in I'll never pay anybody to do a job I don't know for sure I can't do myself and I apply this to everything from mechanics to plumbing etc

themanwithnoname

1,634 posts

244 months

Sunday 14th April 2013
quotequote all
sammym said:
It's a shame no one is local to me who is decent.

I'd happily make the tea and coffee and pass the tools for a while just for the insight and knowleldge.
Where are you based? I'm sure there will be a PH close by who is willing to do the tea/tools/guidance method. Its how I learned, and how I 'teach' friends.

People going on about the 'if you're a high earner' rubbish, clearly don't see that some things, which can be done for leisure are not quantifiable in sterling.

I gain no satisfaction from paying a mechanic to do x, y, z to my car, but gain a fantastic sense of wellbeing from a job well done on any of my vehicles.

sammym

Original Poster:

40 posts

163 months

Sunday 14th April 2013
quotequote all
themanwithnoname said:
Where are you based? I'm sure there will be a PH close by who is willing to do the tea/tools/guidance method. Its how I learned, and how I 'teach' friends.

People going on about the 'if you're a high earner' rubbish, clearly don't see that some things, which can be done for leisure are not quantifiable in sterling.

I gain no satisfaction from paying a mechanic to do x, y, z to my car, but gain a fantastic sense of wellbeing from a job well done on any of my vehicles.
I'm based in Romsey, near southampton.

And I wouldn't consider myself a high earner. I have a house to pay for, and other expenses. I like to spend 8-12 weeks a year travelling , meaning I'm not actually that well off.