Reliable, economical and comfy car for 4k, Possible?
Reliable, economical and comfy car for 4k, Possible?
Author
Discussion

CHIEF

Original Poster:

2,270 posts

313 months

Sunday 14th April 2013
quotequote all
The current car we have for smoking up and down the motorway is now 12 years old and has now passed 137k miles and we fancy something fresher. The car we have is a 1.9 tdi Passat which despite a few niggly problems engine wise it's been superb and comfortable.

I have a 4k budget but I am worried about buying a newer diesel with all the associated problems that come with these.

I'm doing in excess of 12k miles but I am moving hopefully soon so the current trek down to the south coast will be cut significantly. When this will be I don't know.

This is my criteria:

Comfy

Under 10 year old.

Economical - 45mpg on a run hopefully more.

Reliable - Could do with bombproof but I know this isn't possible with a 10 year old car.

Roomy with decent boot.

Able to maintain decent motorway speeds.

A nice drive would be nice but my current steed handling wise is as far away from this as you could imagine.

I'm thinking of the following:

Ford Focus/Mondeo 1.8 petrol - Not sure if these do 45mpg on a run though.
The diesels I hear are unreliable and have injector issues.

Volvo V70 Diesel - A nice comfy barge. Don't really know how reliable these are though.

Nissan Primera 2.2di - Look good on paper but again know nothing about these.

I've discounted the VW/Audi offerings due to the current crop of problatic diesel engines.

Er that's about it, has anyone experience of above or could offer any other suggestions?

Thanks in advance.

Cheers.


wiliferus

4,225 posts

229 months

Sunday 14th April 2013
quotequote all
For 4 grand I'd be going for a V70 D5. Very reliable engine, well proven. Decent turn of speed whilst returning acceptable economy. The main thing to note if reliability is a major concern, is get a manual. The slush box on some of the earlier models can get a bit problematic if it hasn't been looked after well in previous ownership.
This is quite clean http://www.autotrader.co.uk/classified/advert/2013...

You are right to discount the Mondeo TDCi. Some run to 200k with no problems, but quite a few have issues, and they're complicated, expensive issues!

My only other suggestion, is have you considered Saab? 4k will get you quite a lot of Saab metal nowerdays.
http://www.autotrader.co.uk/classified/advert/2013...


Edited by wiliferus on Sunday 14th April 20:24

cptsideways

13,895 posts

283 months

Sunday 14th April 2013
quotequote all
MG ZT or Rover 75 CDti with the BMW engine, manuals do 50mpg & comfy is the main thing

ARobinson

173 posts

180 months

Sunday 14th April 2013
quotequote all
Being a bmw fanboy I'd spend £3k on a 530d or 330d and £1k on preventative maintenance and general tarting up.

Vulgar LS2

1,785 posts

214 months

Sunday 14th April 2013
quotequote all
Honda Accord without a doubt, you would struggle for 45mpg from a petrol I think. I had my 2.4 exec tourer for 6 years and it never missed a beat.

Fox-

13,577 posts

277 months

Sunday 14th April 2013
quotequote all
ARobinson said:
Being a bmw fanboy I'd spend £3k on a 530d or 330d and £1k on preventative maintenance and general tarting up.
He does 12k a year and is dropping that soon. I see absolutely no point in the diesels at this money. More trouble than they are worth.

welshjohn

1,215 posts

212 months

Sunday 14th April 2013
quotequote all
Mondeo ?

Matt UK

18,084 posts

231 months

Sunday 14th April 2013
quotequote all
I konw it's what you already have, but I'd seriously suggest a last of the line B5 Passat with the 1.9tdi 130 engine. 2005 cars so younger than your current steed.
Highline spec give you heated leather and parking sensors.
Probably get a very lightly used example on budget / chunk of change from £4k.

ARobinson

173 posts

180 months

Sunday 14th April 2013
quotequote all
Fox- said:
He does 12k a year and is dropping that soon. I see absolutely no point in the diesels at this money. More trouble than they are worth.
Nor can I but he asked for 45mpg plus and no petrol saloon is going to do that for £4k wink

Fox-

13,577 posts

277 months

Sunday 14th April 2013
quotequote all
It's not, I agree, but does he really need that? The difference between 45mpg and 35mpg for under 12k a year is not huge - if it *is* huge then I'd suggest the rest of the costs associated with ageing prestige metal thats approaching the end of its economical life is probably a show-stopper as well.

Besieds - how much more 'fresh' than a 2001 Passat is a £3k 330d going to be? It's likely to be of similar age and mileage anyway!

CHIEF

Original Poster:

2,270 posts

313 months

Sunday 14th April 2013
quotequote all
wiliferus said:
For 4 grand I'd be going for a V70 D5. Very reliable engine, well proven. Decent turn of speed whilst returning acceptable economy. The main thing to note if reliability is a major concern, is get a manual. The slush box on some of the earlier models can get a bit problematic if it hasn't been looked after well in previous ownership.
This is quite clean http://www.autotrader.co.uk/classified/advert/2013...

You are right to discount the Mondeo TDCi. Some run to 200k with no problems, but quite a few have issues, and they're complicated, expensive issues!

My only other suggestion, is have you considered Saab? 4k will get you quite a lot of Saab metal nowerdays.
http://www.autotrader.co.uk/classified/advert/2013...


Edited by wiliferus on Sunday 14th April 20:24
That Volvo looks a lot of car for the money.