RE: Audi S4: PH Carpool
RE: Audi S4: PH Carpool
Monday 15th April 2013

Audi S4: PH Carpool

Chris Harris isn't the only PH fan of the Audi S4, as this week's Carpooler reveals



Name: Tony Holmes (Spitfire)
Car: Audi S4 (B7) Avant
Owned Since: September 2010
Previously Owned: Ford Escort van, Chrysler (Mitsubishi Australia) Lancer, Alfa Romeo Alfetta, Renault 5GT Turbo, Renault Clio 16V, Subaru Impreza WRX (x3), Rover Mini Cooper, Renault Clio 182 Trophy (#415), VW Golf R32 (Mk5) and currently also own a VW Polo TSI, which replaced the R32 when it was stolen last year.

The R32 has gone, the S4 remains
The R32 has gone, the S4 remains
Why I bought it:
"Like all PH readers, I have always enjoyed driving something a little different that also has more horsepower than your average vehicle. I enjoyed 13 years of solid, hassle-free motoring with a series of Impreza WRXs, and with my two sons getting older and my last Subaru (a PPP-modified five-door that really was a terrific car) getting a little long in the tooth I decided to look for something different. I toyed with the idea of a PPP-modified Impreza STI, and even test drove one, but my wife wasn't convinced that there was sufficient leg room in the back. An old school friend of hers has owned a banana yellow B7 RS4 Avant from new, and I joked with her husband that I would buy it off him when he upgraded. He still owns the car, and having driven it I quickly came to the conclusion that an Audi was the way to go. Sadly, however, my finances did not stretch to an RS4, but a low-mileage S4 was just about affordable. I scoured the classifieds on PistonHeads and Autotrader and finally settled on this vehicle, which had covered just 40,000 miles in five years. Aside from being in excellent condition both inside and out, it was also fitted with the relatively rare six-speed manual gearbox."

'Never this clean again' says Tony
'Never this clean again' says Tony
What I wish I'd known:
"I had done my homework before purchasing the car, having read numerous online reviews, as well as the detailed report in Audi Driver magazine, so I felt confident that I was making a sound purchase. I had also pored over the RS246.com forum, which is a rich source of information on all things performance Audi. The end result was a car that has, so far, never let me down."

Things I love:
"The performance of the 345hp V8 engine in the S4 still puts a smile on my face whenever the 'boat anchor' is coaxed into life from its slumber. I was born and raised in Western Australia, where I was a diehard fan of Touring Car Racing - the late great Peter Brock remains a hero of mine - and the V8-powered Toranas, Falcons and Commodores that have dominated motorsport down under. My father could not see the point in big V8s when I was a kid, so I had to wait until I moved to the UK to buy one! Although I love the look of the B7 RS4 Avant with its big wheel arches, vented spoilers and squat appearance, the S4 definitely wins hands down for Q-car appeal. Indeed, with mine being an 05 plater, it doesn't even have the V8 badges on its forward flanks. Aside from the soundtrack, only the quad exhausts and Avus wheels give clues to what is lurking beneath the bonnet. Oh, I also love peeking under the bonnet and marvelling at just how Audi engineers managed to squeeze a V8 into the engine bay!"

V8 S4 a logical grown-up successor to Imprezas
V8 S4 a logical grown-up successor to Imprezas
Things I hate:
"Hate is a strong word when it comes to the S4. Dislike would probably be more appropriate. The car's handling is not all that it could be, being a little nose-heavy under hard cornering thanks to the weight of the engine. I am probably being a little unfair on the car, having previously driven agile Imprezas and Renaults for the past 20 years. I looked into buying some Hotchkiss anti-roll bars a little while back but I could not find the cash to cover their purchase at the time. My only other gripe would be the lack of a decent Audi independent garage locally to me in west Kent. I have had the car serviced by AMD in Thurrock, and they were very good, but hardly local. I can't really grumble about the mpg (usually around 22-23mpg, and up to 27-28mpg on a long motorway run), as I knew what to expect when I bought it."

Fast, subtle family hold-all - S4 equals job done
Fast, subtle family hold-all - S4 equals job done
Costs:
"My only major outlay on the vehicle was its two-yearly service back in 2011. I am running it on the long service plan, as I don't do more than 6,000 miles in it per year thanks to the fact that I work from home. I will need new pads for the front brakes when it is serviced again in July. Other than that, the only money I have spent has been on fixing niggly things like a broken glove box hinge, the rear window washer squirter and, most annoyingly of all, a rear coil spring after I was left with little choice but to disappear down a pothole when confronted by a bus on my side of a country lane."

Where I've been:
"Being the family car, the S4 has been packed to the gunnels with bags, balls and buckets and spades for trips to the Pas de Calais for a quick four-day jaunt in France, across to southern Ireland for a week around the Hook peninsula and, earlier this month, up to Snowdonia national park for seven fantastic days on the pothole-free roads of north Wales. I refuse to fit a roof box to it (the mpg is already bad enough!), so everything has to be carried inside. None of this bothers the S4, however."

What's next?
"I enjoyed the Harris piece on the S4 vs RS4, and as much as I will hate to lose the V8 burble, the V6TFSI B8 S4 seems to be the only way to go. Prices are still way too high for me, so I think I will soldier on with my B7 S4 for several years yet."


Want to share your car with PHers on Carpool? Email us at carpool@pistonheads.com!

 

 

 

Author
Discussion

BorkFactor

Original Poster:

7,278 posts

189 months

Monday 15th April 2013
quotequote all
Love that! It does have proper "Q Car" credentials, if you debadged it most people would have trouble telling it apart from a 2.0 TDI.

Audis do seem to get a bit of stick on here for some reason, but I like them a lot. Dad has a 3.0 TDI that looks pretty much the same as this, it is a great car.

I wonder why the manual ones are so rare?

BeirutTaxi

6,636 posts

245 months

Monday 15th April 2013
quotequote all
Is the engine an FSI unit related to the RS4 B7?

Output Flange

17,053 posts

242 months

Monday 15th April 2013
quotequote all
Nice to see someone else enjoying theirs.

They make great all-rounders. Like any car, you need to keep on top of replacing worn suspension components, but otherwise nippy enough, wonderful seats and a nice noise.

It's hard to think of something to replace it, other than another S4!

TonyHetherington

32,091 posts

281 months

Monday 15th April 2013
quotequote all
Nice article smile

I've the B6 shape car (slightly older than the one in this carpool) but same engine, and love it to bits. In fact only yesterday, I had the driver's window down for the first time in what felt like an age and I'd forgotten how good the engine sounds! (I have a miltek exhaust).

In case any one is as geeky as me, I made a detailed thread, graphs and all, of my costs to run my B6 S4 for 30k miles here;
http://www.pistonheads.com/gassing/topic.asp?h=0&a...

I agree about not wanting to lose the V8, and the V6 seems the way to go (Chris Harris' recent purchase not helping me ignore them biggrin ) but as the cars get older and inevitably more expensive, I guess I'll have to change at some point. It's just such a bloomin' good car

Mermaid

21,492 posts

202 months

Monday 15th April 2013
quotequote all
BorkFactor said:
..
I wonder why the manual ones are so rare?
sign of the times/fashion etc.

The car has so much torque you could be in any gear and make progress. An easy car to drive, and very reassuring traction.

schmalex

13,616 posts

237 months

Monday 15th April 2013
quotequote all
I have a manual B7 S4 cabriolet.

It is singularly the most disappointing car I've ever owned. It's not particularly quick for what it purports to be, the gearbox is a pig to drive smoothly, on a run it returns 25mpg with the engine screaming at 3,700rpm in 6th at 90. It makes some lovely "rarr / grr / growl" noises, but that is really the only redeeming element. Thank god we plan to trade it next weekend.

It's a real shame, as we owned a B6 S4 Avant tiptronic a few years ago and that was a wonderful car.

thirsty

726 posts

295 months

Monday 15th April 2013
quotequote all
I have a 2010 3.2 Quattro Avant and owned it since new. With more than 60K (kilometers) on the clock I have had zero problems. No little issues or anything. In that regard it is the best car I have ever owned. It isn't a "S" but it does have the same suspension. Handling is just fine in the Swiss mountains, but more importantly it is rock steady on the Autobahn.

TonyHetherington

32,091 posts

281 months

Monday 15th April 2013
quotequote all
schmalex said:
I have a manual B7 S4 cabriolet.

It is singularly the most disappointing car I've ever owned. It's not particularly quick for what it purports to be, the gearbox is a pig to drive smoothly, on a run it returns 25mpg with the engine screaming at 3,700rpm in 6th at 90. It makes some lovely "rarr / grr / growl" noises, but that is really the only redeeming element. Thank god we plan to trade it next weekend.

It's a real shame, as we owned a B6 S4 Avant tiptronic a few years ago and that was a wonderful car.
I wonder if it's because the engine, and therefore sheer bulk, suit an estate more so than a sporty cabriolet?! You're not the first person I've seen say that they dislike the cab but like the avant in what is, essentially, the same car.

duffy78

484 posts

170 months

Monday 15th April 2013
quotequote all
The rs4 rear anti roll bar is a popular mod on all B6 and B7 a4's. approx £100 in parts from Audi then pretty easy to fit.

Makes the front end feel a lot more pointy.

Output Flange

17,053 posts

242 months

Monday 15th April 2013
quotequote all
As an aside, I took mine on a trackday to see what it could do - standard car on standard rubber.

It was as quick over a lap of Bedford's GT circuit as an M3 Evo. Not bad considering you spend a lot of time fighting understeer!


Ex Boy Racer

1,167 posts

223 months

Monday 15th April 2013
quotequote all
Funny thing about Audis; they always get slated by the road testers but do well in long term tests. Also as things to own.

It just shows there is a lot more to car ownership than steering feel and Audi seem to have nailed that.

Ps. I had a RS4 cabriolet which I also found disappointing even though it was a wonderful car in so many ways.

m6rk

42 posts

171 months

Monday 15th April 2013
quotequote all
I bought an s4 in need for an engine swap and it was quite interesting.. however I really wouldn't of bothered if I knew how horrible driving an s-tronic was compared to a manual. Took all the fun out of the car..

Little tip to those s4 owners, if you hear any engine rattle get it checked out.. the camchain tensioners are prone to failure and if you leave it nasty things can happen!! (btw camchains are at the back of this engine so it's an engine out job to do!)





tis a beast of an engine though


Seats were amazingly comfy and the soundtrack was great but I only managed around 22mpg and it didn't feel fast enough to justify that to me.. sold it and bought a ep3 type-r which is much more fun.. I still have my 2.5tdi allroad so i guess the s4 didn't feel special enough to justify the higher running costs..



Matt UK

18,084 posts

231 months

Monday 15th April 2013
quotequote all
Tony, for servicing give Dean a call have a chat. I'm nothing to do with this buisness, but did use them when I ran an A6 and was impressed with the service and workmanship.

http://www.4rings.co.uk/

TonyHetherington

32,091 posts

281 months

Monday 15th April 2013
quotequote all
I've used Dean since day 1 of my car; top bloke and highly recommended.

Frimley111R

19,429 posts

265 months

Monday 15th April 2013
quotequote all
I'll never get Q-cars. If I have a sporty car I want it to look like one! I can't image owning an S4 and seeing near identical 20.TDi's!

Cactussed

5,364 posts

244 months

Monday 15th April 2013
quotequote all
which is why my B10 V8 has war paint... wink

RoadToNowhere

954 posts

270 months

Monday 15th April 2013
quotequote all
I bought exactly the same car as you (black Avant, manual etc), at the same time, with (nearly!) the same number of miles on it - I've put 23k on mine since Sept 2010 and love it to bits.

I originally bought it as a "dull" family estate when child #1 arrived, and it's since become a hugely loved part of the family. The wife mostly drives it now, as covering over 20k a year meant I was getting fed up of standing in petrol stations... as said above the only thing I can think to replace it with is (if ever) another S4.

Values seem to be firming up now, too.

Funnily enough, I was looking at my "costs" spreadsheet this morning (needs new rear tyres), and in 23k I've spent £1800 on it (servicing / consumables etc). The only thing that has gone wrong has been the coil packs failed, which are a well know recall (Audi replaced FOC).

Incidentally, the rears have lasted 31k! I am, quite frankly, staggered. I did spend a lot of time on the motorway though.




Output Flange

17,053 posts

242 months

Monday 15th April 2013
quotequote all
Frimley111R said:
I'll never get Q-cars. If I have a sporty car I want it to look like one! I can't image owning an S4 and seeing near identical 20.TDi's!
You can think about it while you're wondering why that boring looking Audi estate is pulling away from your Elise wink

LARK F1 GTR

4,614 posts

177 months

Monday 15th April 2013
quotequote all
What's the road tax per year on these?

I hope it's not £400 a year cry

Output Flange

17,053 posts

242 months

Monday 15th April 2013
quotequote all
LARK F1 GTR said:
What's the road tax per year on these?

I hope it's not £400 a year cry
The difference is less than two tanks of fuel. If that's a deal-breaker on a car that drinks at the rate it does, it's not for you anyway wink

My 04 car is the cheap(er) rate. Can't remember when it changed.