Are they the same, AWD on car and SUV
Discussion
Because of the annual problems with snow (we get all of an inch or 2 each year), my partner wants to replace her front wheel drive car with a small SUV, such as a RAV4 or VW Tiguan. But, she wants a petrol engine version, which severely limits her choice.
But, as she does not need the other features of a SUV, i.e. height, number of seats etc. and will never go off road (on purpose
), I’m wondering if an AWD system on a car performs just as well in snow. For instance, would an R32 4motion perform just as well? If so, that gives her a larger choice of vehicles.
But, as she does not need the other features of a SUV, i.e. height, number of seats etc. and will never go off road (on purpose
), I’m wondering if an AWD system on a car performs just as well in snow. For instance, would an R32 4motion perform just as well? If so, that gives her a larger choice of vehicles.Snow tyres will give you a better advantage in the snow than a 4WD with 'normal' tyres on them imo.
From memory VW all use the same basic system - Haldex clutch based?? (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Haldex_Traction) - so and 4WD variant will give you 4WD.
If you want serious off road stuff like locking diffs, etc then you will need a proper 4x4.
From memory VW all use the same basic system - Haldex clutch based?? (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Haldex_Traction) - so and 4WD variant will give you 4WD.
If you want serious off road stuff like locking diffs, etc then you will need a proper 4x4.
I don't think there is really any difference between a 4WD car an SUV in terms of snow performance unless the snow gets deeper than the ride height of the car. The individual 4WD system in question makes more difference and, as has been stated above, the tyres (width, compound and tread pattern) make even more difference than that.
If you're determined to buy a 4WD car for its snow driving capability, I'd want something that will engine brake on all four wheels, which I'd guess most part-time 4WD systems do not.
If you're determined to buy a 4WD car for its snow driving capability, I'd want something that will engine brake on all four wheels, which I'd guess most part-time 4WD systems do not.
Even with almost 500bhp and standard tyres , my sons R32 easily out performed our ex Passat in the snow . hence we now have a Tiguan ,
Four motion on VWs , Quattro on Audi , Haldex on a Skoda , in essence I understand they are all the same system , with different tweeks and programing
So so if badge is not a problem Skoda Octavia Scout/Supurb is at the bottom end ,if badge is a problem Audi at the top, cogs much the same
Four motion on VWs , Quattro on Audi , Haldex on a Skoda , in essence I understand they are all the same system , with different tweeks and programing
So so if badge is not a problem Skoda Octavia Scout/Supurb is at the bottom end ,if badge is a problem Audi at the top, cogs much the same
Spent a weekend driving a hired Tiguan a few years ago. Got the impression it was basically a 4motion golf with slightly more ground clearance. Didn't have low range or selectable 2/4 wheel drive like a "proper" 4x4. I didn't enjoy it on the road, just used loads of fuel and made me feel car sick due to the wallowy high suspension. I think 99% of the time you'd be better off with the golf unless you make occasional forays accross slightly rougher than normal terrain..
MX51ROD said:
Even with almost 500bhp and standard tyres , my sons R32 easily out performed our ex Passat in the snow . hence we now have a Tiguan ,
Four motion on VWs , Quattro on Audi , Haldex on a Skoda , in essence I understand they are all the same system , with different tweeks and programing
So so if badge is not a problem Skoda Octavia Scout/Supurb is at the bottom end ,if badge is a problem Audi at the top, cogs much the same
A3 is haldex but A4/5/6/7/8 quattros are all permanent AWD.Four motion on VWs , Quattro on Audi , Haldex on a Skoda , in essence I understand they are all the same system , with different tweeks and programing
So so if badge is not a problem Skoda Octavia Scout/Supurb is at the bottom end ,if badge is a problem Audi at the top, cogs much the same
But, yes, if you're not fussed about the badge and want some sort of 4WD, then the Skoda will probably be the cheaper option

MX51ROD said:
Even with almost 500bhp and standard tyres , my sons R32 easily out performed our ex Passat in the snow . hence we now have a Tiguan ,
Four motion on VWs , Quattro on Audi , Haldex on a Skoda , in essence I understand they are all the same system , with different tweeks and programing
So so if badge is not a problem Skoda Octavia Scout/Supurb is at the bottom end ,if badge is a problem Audi at the top, cogs much the same
Agree with this. Guy at works has a 4wd Skoda Supurb and it works really well in the snow. I guess if u want the extra reassurance though, something with a low range gearbox would be worth looking into. A Jimny has low ratio and are petrol. Maybe worth a look for your Mrs. Four motion on VWs , Quattro on Audi , Haldex on a Skoda , in essence I understand they are all the same system , with different tweeks and programing
So so if badge is not a problem Skoda Octavia Scout/Supurb is at the bottom end ,if badge is a problem Audi at the top, cogs much the same
Or you could have some fun and go for one of these which I really have my eye on at the moment....a Pajero Evolution
http://www.pistonheads.com/classifieds/used-cars/m...
From your list of requirements it has to be a Subaru Forester, truly epic cars. For ultimate Winter go anywhere ability add Winter tyres. They are slightly higher than a normal car (for decent snow/kerb clearance) with rugged quality and so much better than the 'soft readers you have mentioned. Since I got my 2004 Turbo version last year I usually take it ahead of my Range Rover, they are that good. I think only the latest style Forester (around post 09) came with a Diesel option. This car also looks much more '4x4' than the earlier shape. So petrol engines very much the order of the day. Like I said, I have the Turbo which is a real hoot, but there is also a non-Turbo variant available which is probably most suitable for most people
Edited by billzeebub on Monday 15th April 13:13
I've wasted a chunk of my money doing similar the past few years.
I live in the middle of nowhere. It's quite a hilly area with little chance of seeing a gritter out this way so i bought into winter tyres the first year we had the bad snow (09/10?). That was on a wee mk4 Golf and while the tyres were faultless, the depth of snow just completely out-foxed the car. The front bumper makes for a pretty crap snow plough but it's effective at halting the car nonetheless.
Ironically in the past 2 years since we chopped the Golf in for a Grand Vitara on all season rubber the snow's not been deep enough to trouble my Octavia on winter rubber. How typical!
So i reckon winter rubber on the Golf, and a complete set of winter wheels & rubber on the Octavia were not smart money overall (the tyres are excellent i'm definitely not saying otherwise, i just think this wasn't an efficient expenditure). However, chopping the Golf in for a wee Grand Vitara on all season rubber has been excellent money. Even if we've not had deep enough snow to completely justify it, it's justified itself in other ways - comparable fuel economy (30mpg dotting about the doors and down to tesco), similar tax bracket (pre-06), it's also helluva durable and dead simple to service which i like since i do myself. It's so far retained more or less the price we bought in at which is impressive. Only possible down side is it's part time 4wd (no centre diff) but i suppose that saves some tyre wear for 350 days a year, i'd just prefer something that automatically did the right thing.
I've driven some of the other permanent 4wd systems but there's only 2 i really like. The permanent 4wd system as on the BMW X5 is shockingly bad, certainly in the '04 timeframe. It's not about tyres here, it's about a system that is completely outfoxed by having 1 side of the car on ice and 1 side on perfectly grippy tarmac (so never pull to the side of an icy road to let someone past!!)
The Subaru 4wd system is outstandingly good IMO, as fitted on the forester anyway but i've heard others say similar on other models. I've never driven anything so sure footed and drivable at the same time. With the vitara locked into 4wd mode (there's no centre diff so you manually select 4wd on slippy surfaces only) there's no way you'd push on in 4wd mode - any steering feels laboured above 25mph. With the Subaru system it feels almost magically good. I've no idea how it all works but i can appreciate there are some extremely clever tricks going on behind the scenes to make such a well rounded system! Vitara will be chopped in for one of these this year.
The other one i've done a few miles in is the VAG Haldex system (as on the Octavia Scout and a whole bunch of other models). It's very very good as well, almost as good as Subaru - like the subaru you can pull away successfully even if only 1 wheel has any grip. I'd say it doesn't feel entirely as confident in corners on snow as the Subaru system though.
ETA - the OP said about switching to a petrol 4wd, no idea why i decided they said winter tyres...! On that line, nothing but encouragement for the OP - wholy reasonable fuel economy, cheap servicing, warms up way way faster than any diesel, you;re making the best move IMO!
I live in the middle of nowhere. It's quite a hilly area with little chance of seeing a gritter out this way so i bought into winter tyres the first year we had the bad snow (09/10?). That was on a wee mk4 Golf and while the tyres were faultless, the depth of snow just completely out-foxed the car. The front bumper makes for a pretty crap snow plough but it's effective at halting the car nonetheless.
Ironically in the past 2 years since we chopped the Golf in for a Grand Vitara on all season rubber the snow's not been deep enough to trouble my Octavia on winter rubber. How typical!
So i reckon winter rubber on the Golf, and a complete set of winter wheels & rubber on the Octavia were not smart money overall (the tyres are excellent i'm definitely not saying otherwise, i just think this wasn't an efficient expenditure). However, chopping the Golf in for a wee Grand Vitara on all season rubber has been excellent money. Even if we've not had deep enough snow to completely justify it, it's justified itself in other ways - comparable fuel economy (30mpg dotting about the doors and down to tesco), similar tax bracket (pre-06), it's also helluva durable and dead simple to service which i like since i do myself. It's so far retained more or less the price we bought in at which is impressive. Only possible down side is it's part time 4wd (no centre diff) but i suppose that saves some tyre wear for 350 days a year, i'd just prefer something that automatically did the right thing.
I've driven some of the other permanent 4wd systems but there's only 2 i really like. The permanent 4wd system as on the BMW X5 is shockingly bad, certainly in the '04 timeframe. It's not about tyres here, it's about a system that is completely outfoxed by having 1 side of the car on ice and 1 side on perfectly grippy tarmac (so never pull to the side of an icy road to let someone past!!)
The Subaru 4wd system is outstandingly good IMO, as fitted on the forester anyway but i've heard others say similar on other models. I've never driven anything so sure footed and drivable at the same time. With the vitara locked into 4wd mode (there's no centre diff so you manually select 4wd on slippy surfaces only) there's no way you'd push on in 4wd mode - any steering feels laboured above 25mph. With the Subaru system it feels almost magically good. I've no idea how it all works but i can appreciate there are some extremely clever tricks going on behind the scenes to make such a well rounded system! Vitara will be chopped in for one of these this year.
The other one i've done a few miles in is the VAG Haldex system (as on the Octavia Scout and a whole bunch of other models). It's very very good as well, almost as good as Subaru - like the subaru you can pull away successfully even if only 1 wheel has any grip. I'd say it doesn't feel entirely as confident in corners on snow as the Subaru system though.
ETA - the OP said about switching to a petrol 4wd, no idea why i decided they said winter tyres...! On that line, nothing but encouragement for the OP - wholy reasonable fuel economy, cheap servicing, warms up way way faster than any diesel, you;re making the best move IMO!
Edited by ShaunTheSheep on Monday 15th April 13:46
Gassing Station | General Gassing | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff






