£8k max, entertaining mid size saloon or estate?
Discussion
Planning to get a second car to take the strain off my ageing VW and to accomodate possible smaller versions of myself in the next year or two, so need something with modern safety stuff, isofix for kiddie seats etc. So it needs to be vaguely practical. Will be keeping my VW for daily commuting so can justify a bigger engine, ideally with 6 cylinders, as it will only be doing 3-4k miles a year. Want something nice to drive and reasonably reliable. Want to stay petrol and ideally non-turbo. Manual 'box too.
I can borrow up to £8k interest free but ideally would like to spend less than that.
First thoughts have been:
late E46 330i
earlyish E90 330i
Jaguar X-type 3.0 AWD
mk2 Octavia VRS (turbo and clogged intakes put me off though)
late E39 530i
I'm aware all of these have pros and cons but are there any other cars worth considering?
I can borrow up to £8k interest free but ideally would like to spend less than that.
First thoughts have been:
late E46 330i
earlyish E90 330i
Jaguar X-type 3.0 AWD
mk2 Octavia VRS (turbo and clogged intakes put me off though)
late E39 530i
I'm aware all of these have pros and cons but are there any other cars worth considering?
Parts are fine, body panels can be a struggle which means they can be written off for relatively minor damage. Insurance through a specialist like Peter Best is cheap 
Eta the owners' club is a great resource: http://www9.mgcars.org.uk/mgoc260/

Eta the owners' club is a great resource: http://www9.mgcars.org.uk/mgoc260/
lufbramatt said:
Interesting. Might have a read up about them then. Cheers. I know I said I wasn't too fussed about economy but I think a 4.6l V8 might be pushing it a bit 
I nearly bought a saloon last year. My research suggests that economy is okay in terms of steady cruising (up to 30 mpg) but quite punishing around town. Depends what you'd be using it for I guess. 
Mondeo ST220?:

http://www.pistonheads.com/classifieds/used-cars/f...
You could get a lovely 280bhp AWD, Manual Subaru Legacy for well under £8k. Though the really fun/quick ones are turbos.
3.2 V6 and very handsome, though perhaps not the quickest or most exciting drive.

http://www.pistonheads.com/classifieds/used-cars/a...

http://www.pistonheads.com/classifieds/used-cars/f...
You could get a lovely 280bhp AWD, Manual Subaru Legacy for well under £8k. Though the really fun/quick ones are turbos.
3.2 V6 and very handsome, though perhaps not the quickest or most exciting drive.

http://www.pistonheads.com/classifieds/used-cars/a...
Had the same dilemma a year ago and chose a Legacy Spec B. Spacious, reliable (IF serviced properly with correct oil - don't buy anything with a ticking engine), great handling, 0-60 in 6.5. Something like this:

www.autotrader.co.uk/classified/advert/20130329600...
At that age likely to need a new cat-back exhaust (£450) and front droplinks if you hear a little clunking when going over speed bumps (£200).
www.autotrader.co.uk/classified/advert/20130329600...
At that age likely to need a new cat-back exhaust (£450) and front droplinks if you hear a little clunking when going over speed bumps (£200).
Legacy sounds v. interesting. Are the quick ones the 2.0 GTB's? Found one on autotrader. Are they all imports or were they officially available in the UK? The ad didn't have any info for performance or mpg etc. so assume its not a uk model? Do like the look of them though.
The v6 ones appear to be band M tax, nearly £500/year is a lot for a car that will be sitting on the drive most of the time. I guess the increase isn't that much if you spreas it over the year, but still, its £200 odd quid I'd rather have in my wallet rather than give to the government.
The v6 ones appear to be band M tax, nearly £500/year is a lot for a car that will be sitting on the drive most of the time. I guess the increase isn't that much if you spreas it over the year, but still, its £200 odd quid I'd rather have in my wallet rather than give to the government.
Edited by lufbramatt on Monday 15th April 12:16
lufbramatt said:
Legacy sounds v. interesting. Are the quick ones the 2.0 GTB's? Found one on autotrader. Are they all imports or were they officially available in the UK? The ad didn't have any info for performance or mpg etc. so assume its not a uk model? Do like the look of them though.
The v6 ones appear to be band M tax, nearly £500/year is a lot for a car that will be sitting on the drive most of the time. I guess the increase isn't that much if you spreas it over the year, but still, its £200 odd quid I'd rather have in my wallet rather than give to the government.
That one will be at the lower rate - just buy one pre-March 06 (I think?). The turbos were not officially imported. The 3 litre flat 6's (lovely sound from that boxer engine!) like the one in the link were the official imports and don't have the ouotright acceleration or surge of the turbos but are plenty fast and have a sort of VVT-thing that kicks in around 3.5k revs so quite fun. They like a drink though (can get up to 32mpg on a run at 70 but around 24mpg on average and sub 20s aroudn town.The v6 ones appear to be band M tax, nearly £500/year is a lot for a car that will be sitting on the drive most of the time. I guess the increase isn't that much if you spreas it over the year, but still, its £200 odd quid I'd rather have in my wallet rather than give to the government.
Edited by lufbramatt on Monday 15th April 12:16
Ahh yes just looked it up, pre 23rd March 2006 goes into band K which is £280/year. That makes it easier to stomach. All the cars I've ever taxed have been pre-2001 so never had to worry about this co2 rating thing!
Any common faults to look out for?
I'll have to check what the insurance is like on one of these. My man-maths has worked out that assuming 25mpg for the Legacy, it will cost me about £250/year extra in fuel vs. my 2.0 16v passat (which averages 35mpg long term worked out properly) for the 3500 or so miles I do a year that isn't commuting.
Any common faults to look out for?
I'll have to check what the insurance is like on one of these. My man-maths has worked out that assuming 25mpg for the Legacy, it will cost me about £250/year extra in fuel vs. my 2.0 16v passat (which averages 35mpg long term worked out properly) for the 3500 or so miles I do a year that isn't commuting.
lufbramatt said:
Ahh yes just looked it up, pre 23rd March 2006 goes into band K which is £280/year. That makes it easier to stomach. All the cars I've ever taxed have been pre-2001 so never had to worry about this co2 rating thing!
Any common faults to look out for?
I'll have to check what the insurance is like on one of these. My man-maths has worked out that assuming 25mpg for the Legacy, it will cost me about £250/year extra in fuel vs. my 2.0 16v passat (which averages 35mpg long term worked out properly) for the 3500 or so miles I do a year that isn't commuting.
Other than the engine ticking, exhaust (split at the Y-joint as tips are either side of car, and standard exhaust is mild steel) and droplinks/wishbones/bushes, I'd also check the Bilstein shock absorbers (make sure not leaking and bounce back, expensive to sort), CD changer hasn't got CD stuck in it (nightmare to sort; also no MP3 although you can get add-ons), maybe wheel bearings (heaavy car) and then of course the usual stuff. Make sure oil clean and always used 5W30 (and check the oil frequently!!).Any common faults to look out for?
I'll have to check what the insurance is like on one of these. My man-maths has worked out that assuming 25mpg for the Legacy, it will cost me about £250/year extra in fuel vs. my 2.0 16v passat (which averages 35mpg long term worked out properly) for the 3500 or so miles I do a year that isn't commuting.
Great owner's forum here: http://www.uklegacy.com/
Cheers for the link, I'll have a good read later. Seem to be pretty bomb proof then. I'm pretty handy with the spanners so stuff like suspension doesn't worry me having rebuilt suspension on a few different cars. On most new cars when you start googling loads of horror stories come up but seems less so on these.
Gassing Station | General Gassing | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff





