Don't hit a cyclist in Scotland
Don't hit a cyclist in Scotland
Author
Discussion

McWigglebum4th

Original Poster:

32,414 posts

235 months

Monday 15th April 2013
quotequote all
http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-scotland-22155209

As you will be at fault unless you can prove otherwise

Johnnytheboy

24,499 posts

217 months

Monday 15th April 2013
quotequote all
Cyclists are calling for "strict liability" everwhere.

Daft idea, surely the person who's at fault should be liable?

Coldfuse

518 posts

225 months

Monday 15th April 2013
quotequote all
Johnnytheboy said:
Cyclists are calling for "strict liability" everwhere.

Daft idea, surely the person who's at fault should be liable?
I guess technically that's how it works, but i understand your skepticism. Sounds to me like you have to fight to say your not as apposed to the cyclist having to fight to say you are (assuming your a car drive who is as fault)

ILoveMondeo

9,617 posts

257 months

Monday 15th April 2013
quotequote all
Another reason to get a dash-cam!

munroman

1,908 posts

215 months

Monday 15th April 2013
quotequote all
Based on my experience, it would only make the mad behaviour of some cyclists worse if they think they are untouchable.

I hate driving in Edinburgh, mainly because of the cyclists, they do their own thing, irrespective of what the law says, roads, pavements, they ride as if everyone else should cede to them.

I was on a bus, and, as it was turning left (and indicating so), a cyclist came up the inside and hit the mirror.
He then proceeded to thump the side of the bus, and spat on my window, which was nice.....

I think this proposed law would be a very bad idea!

McSam

6,753 posts

206 months

Monday 15th April 2013
quotequote all
Absolutely ludicrous, I'm astonished to read that a lot of countries already employ this.

So if I'm travelling at 30mph in an urban area, and a cyclist launches themselves off a footpath or whatever directly into my path two feet in front of my car, I'm clearly going to hit them. I have no chance whatsoever of avoiding them, and have done nothing wrong, whereas the cyclist has carried out an incredibly dangerous and negligent act.

And unless I have a camera or witnesses, that would be "assumed" to be my fault? You can fk right off with that idea. Even the concept that any party, in any road situation at all, should be "assumed" to be at fault unless proven otherwise is completely ridiculous.

Chicane-UK

3,861 posts

216 months

Monday 15th April 2013
quotequote all

andym1603

1,885 posts

203 months

Monday 15th April 2013
quotequote all
I wonder how much this is the main reason for this idea,
"Supporters of the Campaign for Strict Liability say it would greatly reduce the time it takes for accident victims to win compensation".

As said already this would be a good time to justify a dash camera.

pad58

12,549 posts

212 months

Monday 15th April 2013
quotequote all
So if a cyclist swerves to miss a pothole,in front of a car which results in a crunch and the cyclist comes of worse (of course), the motorist has to pay?

m30dus

553 posts

216 months

Monday 15th April 2013
quotequote all
I knew of Craig, the cyclist killed in this article, and when you see what the family have been put through, you would find it very hard to put an argument to the proposals.

J4CKO

47,107 posts

231 months

Monday 15th April 2013
quotequote all
pad58 said:
So if a cyclist swerves to miss a pothole,in front of a car which results in a crunch and the cyclist comes of worse (of course), the motorist has to pay?
In that scenario, if the cyclist swerves a couple of foot to miss a pothole, you were probably too close, keep them as far from your car as possible, cyclists by and large don't want to hit a car, it hurts worse than scratched or dented bodywork.


Actually, to be fair to car drivers, I did see some tit on a bike swerve quite a way right tonight, I was on my bike behind, it was very windy and this chimp had two bag for life bags hanging, one on each handlebar and got caught by a gust, sent him about three foot right, nearly got hit, but when I went past it was apparent there was an air of care in the community about him, he had a radio on the bars blaring out, the mark of a mental, you can't legislate for those types, just be glad he hasn't got a car, well I assume he doesn't.

Edited by J4CKO on Monday 15th April 20:15

Johnnytheboy

24,499 posts

217 months

Monday 15th April 2013
quotequote all
ILoveMondeo said:
Another reason to get a dash-cam!
Surely it is a reason not to bother, as even if dash cam footage shows it's not your fault, it still is? As it were...

Johnnytheboy

24,499 posts

217 months

Monday 15th April 2013
quotequote all
Sorry, my mistake, managed to miss the "unless you can prove it" bit.

getmecoat

Doesn't that make it "not particularly strict liability"?

rofl

r11co

6,244 posts

261 months

Monday 15th April 2013
quotequote all
Where this has been implemented in other European countries it has been a technical legal move to allow cyclists to claim on motorists' insurance and nothing more.

I'm dead against this. Instead a fairer approach should be compulsory 3rd party insurance for cyclists. Italy is one country that is moving to such a model, and it is often included as part of home insurance policies in order to cover children in the household.

EDLT

15,421 posts

237 months

Monday 15th April 2013
quotequote all
McWigglebum4th said:
http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-scotland-22155209

As you will be at fault unless you can prove otherwise
You haven't even read the headline, never mind the article.

Evoluzione

10,345 posts

274 months

Monday 15th April 2013
quotequote all
Chicane-UK said:
Don't masticate with your mouth open...

cyprinis

80 posts

214 months

Monday 15th April 2013
quotequote all
I don't understand how it would "reduce the number of cyclists killed an injured."

paranoid airbag

2,679 posts

190 months

Monday 15th April 2013
quotequote all
^ Theory: it would give drivers more incentive to be careful around cyclists. Though I suspect, for most drivers, common decency is enough, and those for whom it isn't would probably do a runner anyway. As someone is SP&L said, people asking for something isn't a good indication it's being seriously considered. It isn't, and it crops up every few years, only to be ignored again.

It's a silly law, but the thread title (taken at face value at least) probably illustrates why people are asking. People should have enough respect for the lives of others to behave around cyclists, even to the extent of making some allowance for the mistakes people inevitably make - I'm damn sure most people on here (myself included) are quick enough to criticise some knob with a helmet cam who is undoubtably technically right, but could have avoided a dangerous situation.

An attitude on the roads of "I'm driving my fecking great SUV so I'm alright" simply doesn't suffice. If significant numbers of people need draconian incentives to get them to behave, that's what we'll get.

Krikkit

27,943 posts

212 months

Monday 15th April 2013
quotequote all
A valid point paranoid, but I come down on the other side of the fence - having had a couple of near-misses with psychotic cyclists I can envision either incident going the wrong way and ending up with a death/serious injury to answer for.


mat777

10,714 posts

191 months

Monday 15th April 2013
quotequote all
This is utterly stupid. Just a licence for the arrogant self-entitled militant brigade to have a go at car drivers. I can see a lot of them "staging" accidents by deliberately doing something to get hit/get hit by a car then point the finger