Mercedes S Class W140 or Lexus IS200
Discussion
Hi gang....a newbie to Pistonheads! After reading some articles on here I thought I'd join in!!
I'm a 41 year old boy racer who has a love of cars!! Forever changing them so I get to drive everything pretty much in my lifetime.
I've had all the new stuff over the years but a while ago I decided to save my money and play about with about £1000- £1500 on some decent sheds, run them for a while and get something else.
Had Mercedes E320, Saab 95 Aero, Jeep Grand Cherokee, Alfa 166,156,GTV, MGZT, Pug 206 GTI, Omega V6's, Bmw 528, 318 all in the last 3 years !!
My latest dilema is I'm lookin to change my Lexus IS200....although a lovely car with all the gizmos....just not quick enough for the amount of fuel she uses and looks a little anonymous. Have been thinking of changing her for a Mercedes S280 (W140) as although there a bit ugly have always fascinated me. Looking at Jaguar XJ6's as well!
So come people....if you've a story to tell and any advice to give I'd be grateful in helping me make my mind up!!
Keep the Lexus or go get an older Merc or a Jag and get some road prescence !!

I'm a 41 year old boy racer who has a love of cars!! Forever changing them so I get to drive everything pretty much in my lifetime.
I've had all the new stuff over the years but a while ago I decided to save my money and play about with about £1000- £1500 on some decent sheds, run them for a while and get something else.
Had Mercedes E320, Saab 95 Aero, Jeep Grand Cherokee, Alfa 166,156,GTV, MGZT, Pug 206 GTI, Omega V6's, Bmw 528, 318 all in the last 3 years !!
My latest dilema is I'm lookin to change my Lexus IS200....although a lovely car with all the gizmos....just not quick enough for the amount of fuel she uses and looks a little anonymous. Have been thinking of changing her for a Mercedes S280 (W140) as although there a bit ugly have always fascinated me. Looking at Jaguar XJ6's as well!
So come people....if you've a story to tell and any advice to give I'd be grateful in helping me make my mind up!!
Keep the Lexus or go get an older Merc or a Jag and get some road prescence !!
Edited by Adgti777 on Tuesday 16th April 09:30
Adgti777 said:
Hi gang....a newbie to Pistonheads! After reading some articles on here I thought I'd join in!!
I'm a 41 year old boy racer who has a love of cars!! Forever changing them so I get to drive everything pretty much in my lifetime.
I've had all the new stuff over the years but a while ago I decided to save my money and play about with about £1000- £1500 on some decent sheds, run them for a while and get something else.
Had Mercedes E320, Saab 95 Aero, Jeep Grand Cherokee, Alfa 166,156,GTV, MGZT, Pug 206 GTI, Omega V6's, Bmw 528, 318 all in the last 3 years !!
My latest dilema is I'm lookin to change my Lexus IS200....although a lovely car with all the gizmos....just not quick enough for the amount of fuel she uses and looks a little anonymous. Have been thinking of changing her for a Mercedes S280 (W140) as although there a bit ugly have always fascinated me. Looking at Jaguar XJ6's as well!
So come people....if you've a story to tell and any advice to give I'd be grateful in helping me make my mind up!!
Keep the Lexus or go get an older Merc or a Jag and get some road prescence !!

If the Lexus is too slow for you, I'd steer well clear of an S280. Very underpowered for such a large car. S500 though....I'm a 41 year old boy racer who has a love of cars!! Forever changing them so I get to drive everything pretty much in my lifetime.
I've had all the new stuff over the years but a while ago I decided to save my money and play about with about £1000- £1500 on some decent sheds, run them for a while and get something else.
Had Mercedes E320, Saab 95 Aero, Jeep Grand Cherokee, Alfa 166,156,GTV, MGZT, Pug 206 GTI, Omega V6's, Bmw 528, 318 all in the last 3 years !!
My latest dilema is I'm lookin to change my Lexus IS200....although a lovely car with all the gizmos....just not quick enough for the amount of fuel she uses and looks a little anonymous. Have been thinking of changing her for a Mercedes S280 (W140) as although there a bit ugly have always fascinated me. Looking at Jaguar XJ6's as well!
So come people....if you've a story to tell and any advice to give I'd be grateful in helping me make my mind up!!
Keep the Lexus or go get an older Merc or a Jag and get some road prescence !!
Edited by Adgti777 on Tuesday 16th April 09:30
Wow. I am very surprised. Just looked up the 0-60 times of the IS200, thinking it would beat the S280 hands down. Exactly the same time in fact.
The main difference will be fuel consumption. The IS has a manufacturer claimed 29mpg; the S280 21mpg. Which is identical to the faster S320. If it was my money, I'd be going for the 320.
In addition, most S280s I see in the classifieds tend to be a little unloved, and they usually have the lowest spec (most people who could afford a better spec got the 320 in the first place)
I have a C140 coupe, which is based on the W140, and similar in many respects. It's lovely to drive, very comfortable, very reliable, and I would thoroughly recommend one. Whichever engine you go for, you won't be disappointed.
The main difference will be fuel consumption. The IS has a manufacturer claimed 29mpg; the S280 21mpg. Which is identical to the faster S320. If it was my money, I'd be going for the 320.
In addition, most S280s I see in the classifieds tend to be a little unloved, and they usually have the lowest spec (most people who could afford a better spec got the 320 in the first place)
I have a C140 coupe, which is based on the W140, and similar in many respects. It's lovely to drive, very comfortable, very reliable, and I would thoroughly recommend one. Whichever engine you go for, you won't be disappointed.
I ran an S320 for almost a year, quick enough but would never break any records - they still cruise at way more than you're allowed to in the UK though. I got mid 20s MPG, sometimes low 30s. Build quality was fantastic though with mine being on of the last it had rust issues, all the toys were there and it actually wasn't bad to drive, especially for the immense weight! Just be aware that any number of problems could easily write off the car.
Would I have another? Yes!
Would I have another? Yes!
Gassing Station | General Gassing | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


