Family cars with steering feel - are there any left?
Family cars with steering feel - are there any left?
Author
Discussion

chrispj

Original Poster:

266 posts

174 months

Tuesday 16th April 2013
quotequote all
For 10 years I had a Mk1 Focus estate. Not the fastest thing in the world with its 1.8TDCi lump in the front. But I could feel what its 195/60 tyres were doing on the 15" (or maybe 16") wheels. Feel the tyres grip on a bend and the steering go light as it gives a bit. You felt pretty well connected.

A couple of years ago I replaced it with a Skoda. Practical family estate, nice 1.8 turbo petrol in the front (even nicer with a cheeky map on it). Comfy inside, 225/45/17s all round. Steering dead as a dead thing. Doesn't matter what speed you go round corners, dry, wet, the steering feels the same, it goes in the direction you point it but the only thing telling you that is your eyes. Not connected in the slightest. Seems to be a trait common to all the VAG group (this was partly prompted by the usual conclusion on the S3 driven piece) but not just them.

I was lucky, I bought a Lotus as well, so I get to feel how a car should feel to drive every time I go out. It's made the Skoda feel so lifeless in comparison that there is no fun in driving it anymore (except the childish amusement of burning people off in the slip road drag race in a humble family estate). I know no family car is going to feel as alive as the Elise, but what is left out there that is a worthwhile halfway house as a practical car that you can feel what it's doing, feel connected and get some joy out of driving the thing everyday?

Ideas?

TinyCappo

2,106 posts

184 months

Tuesday 16th April 2013
quotequote all
massively leftfield here but try a suzuki kizashi. awesome handling and friggin cheap now. £12k will get you a sub 10,000 mile model.

Benrad

657 posts

180 months

Tuesday 16th April 2013
quotequote all
GF and I just replaced the Corsa (deaderer than a dead thing steering) with a Citroen C4 (2010 1.6 HDi (92)...zzzzzzz). Now it's not sporty, it rolls and bit and the pedals are ridiculous, such a soft (but effective) brake pedal you always end up sending people through the windscreen.

But the steering is much better, get a little kick back over bumps and stuff. I haven't had the chance to push it yet but feels to me like it will go light with understeer etc. Like I say it isn't a sporty car but the car gives lots of feedback. So much that even with both front wheels definitely balanced there is still a little vibration through the wheel. Nicely weighted too.

chrispj

Original Poster:

266 posts

174 months

Tuesday 16th April 2013
quotequote all
TinyCappo said:
massively leftfield here but try a suzuki kizashi. awesome handling and friggin cheap now. £12k will get you a sub 10,000 mile model.
I'm gobsmacked, I'd never heard of this one. And neither have most people by the look of it with 25 on Autotrader. Autocar are waxing lyrical about the handling, but sadly they've dropped the ball massively with the CVT. Not even a manual alternative. Incomprehensible & a crying shame...

TinyCappo

2,106 posts

184 months

Tuesday 16th April 2013
quotequote all
the CVT is rather good as CVT's go. Its miles better than the nissan and toyota ones I have tried before.

There is specific ratios programmed into a synthesized 6 speed paddle shift that works very well on twisty roads/

Mr2Mike

20,143 posts

286 months

Tuesday 16th April 2013
quotequote all
chrispj said:
A couple of years ago I replaced it with a Skoda. Practical family estate, nice 1.8 turbo petrol in the front (even nicer with a cheeky map on it). Comfy inside, 225/45/17s all round. Steering dead as a dead thing. Doesn't matter what speed you go round corners, dry, wet, the steering feels the same, it goes in the direction you point it but the only thing telling you that is your eyes. Not connected in the slightest. Seems to be a trait common to all the VAG group (this was partly prompted by the usual conclusion on the S3 driven piece) but not just them.
VAG are masters at doing "numb" yes

The purveyors of "The ultimate driving machine" still make family sized cars with steering that has feedback.

richb77

889 posts

192 months

Tuesday 16th April 2013
quotequote all
I have NEVER heard of that Suzuki and what a corker.

One of the industries best kept secrets?

chrispj

Original Poster:

266 posts

174 months

Tuesday 16th April 2013
quotequote all
richb77 said:
I have NEVER heard of that Suzuki and what a corker.

One of the industries best kept secrets?
Just needs a manual and an estate body. Quite happy for there not to be a diesel option...

chrispj

Original Poster:

266 posts

174 months

Tuesday 16th April 2013
quotequote all
Mr2Mike said:
The purveyors of "The ultimate driving machine" still make family sized cars with steering that has feedback.
Are they not members of the dead electric power steering club? (genuine question, the last I tried was the old 1 series, which was spoilt by the bouncy suspension and tractor-sounding diesel...) edit Decent enough steer though from what I remember.



kambites

71,703 posts

252 months

Tuesday 16th April 2013
quotequote all
chrispj said:
Mr2Mike said:
The purveyors of "The ultimate driving machine" still make family sized cars with steering that has feedback.
Are they not members of the dead electric power steering club? (genuine question, the last I tried was the old 1 series, which was spoilt by the bouncy suspension and tractor-sounding diesel...) edit Decent enough steer though from what I remember.
You're right. The latest BMWs are pretty awful when it comes to steering feel/feedback (if pretty good in other ways). Same with Porsche, sadly. It's hard to find a sports car with decent steering these days, let alone a family car.

Edited by kambites on Tuesday 16th April 17:18

chrispj

Original Poster:

266 posts

174 months

Tuesday 16th April 2013
quotequote all
So, let's say estate car, good seats, moderately brisk (say 7 secs to 60)... and 'feel'. Am I asking the impossible? It really shouldn't be that difficult... On the grounds the most mainstream suggestion so far is a Citroen C4, are we looking at a C5 estate?!

edit: having had a quick google, apparently not...

Edited by chrispj on Tuesday 16th April 17:29

CraigyMc

18,374 posts

267 months

Tuesday 16th April 2013
quotequote all
kambites said:
You're right. The latest BMWs are pretty awful when it comes to steering feel/feedback (if pretty good in other ways). Same with Porsche, sadly. It's hard to find a sports car with decent steering these days, let alone a family car.
You have ridiculously high standards, though (unassisted Lotus).

Current BMWs have decent steering feel, certainly better than anything FWD I've driven in years.

Get one without low profile tyres/runflats and it's actually a nice thing to drive.

C



RikZS

677 posts

180 months

Tuesday 16th April 2013
quotequote all
MG ZS?

Absolutely love the way mine drives and was rated to be one of the top handling FWD mid size saloons when it was released.

kambites

71,703 posts

252 months

Tuesday 16th April 2013
quotequote all
CraigyMc said:
Current BMWs have decent steering feel, certainly better than anything FWD I've driven in years.
I honestly found the E92 3-series and Z4 (excluding the M) to be worse than a mk2 Focus or mk5 Golf in terms of steering feel.

Better to drive in many, many other ways. But I thought the steering was dire.

chrispj

Original Poster:

266 posts

174 months

Tuesday 16th April 2013
quotequote all
CraigyMc said:
Get one without low profile tyres/runflats and it's actually a nice thing to drive.
That is a good point, most cars seem to be ridiculously over-tyred. For a while I did think about taking the Skoda down to 16" wheels and narrower tyres, but it was a touch ridiculous. Still, I can imagine walking into a BMW dealer and saying "I'll take the 330i but put your smallest wheels on it...!"

kambites

71,703 posts

252 months

Tuesday 16th April 2013
quotequote all
IMO, for best steering feel, you want narrow low profile tyres (not that anyone offers them). Low profile tyres are awful in many ways, but they do help turn in and feel.

BorkFactor

7,278 posts

189 months

Tuesday 16th April 2013
quotequote all
chrispj said:
So, let's say estate car, good seats, moderately brisk (say 7 secs to 60)... and 'feel'. Am I asking the impossible? It really shouldn't be that difficult... On the grounds the most mainstream suggestion so far is a Citroen C4, are we looking at a C5 estate?!

edit: having had a quick google, apparently not...

Edited by chrispj on Tuesday 16th April 17:29
E46 touring with sports seats fits the bill yes

ETA - I have seen a couple of these Suzuki things about, quite nice looking motors! Shame about the gearbox.

chrispj

Original Poster:

266 posts

174 months

Tuesday 16th April 2013
quotequote all
Incidentally, how much do most PHers care about steering feel now? Obviously to the 'white goods' motorist it's way behind road tax and mythical fuel economy figures in the priority list but is it something that people on here consider? Or is it lost behind soft dashboard plastic and an easy swell of turbo-diesel torque through the DSG...?

kambites

71,703 posts

252 months

Tuesday 16th April 2013
quotequote all
Some care, some don't. It's certainly not top of many people's lists.

rumple

15,420 posts

182 months

Tuesday 16th April 2013
quotequote all
Watching this thread with intrest as I own a mk1 focus and an E46 330, I'm selling both this year, the focus is the better steer out of the two.