Windscreen scratch! :-(
Windscreen scratch! :-(
Author
Discussion

stroberaver

Original Poster:

196 posts

199 months

Tuesday 16th April 2013
quotequote all
Well I'm kinda gutted. Since I pushed my finances to breaking point to buy the car I really, really wanted (a pre-reg / nearly-new BMW E92) in January, a couple of weeks ago I discovered a nasty scratch in the windscreen as a result of something trapped under the driver's side wiper blade.

In most conditions, it can't be seen and isn't noticeable. But I was out tonight, driving west into the setting sun on a clear day and it was friggin horrendous - constantly distracting me and impossible not to notice. It's a scratch on the path of the centre of the driver's wiper blade for about 70° of the arc. Spotted it a couple of weeks ago and thought I would see if I could live with it, but this evening was pretty bad.

I can just feel the scratch with my thumbnail - it's not deep but it's definitely more than a cosmetic scuff. fk knows where it's come from, never had anything like this in 15+ years of motoring, and now it happens on my three-month old dream car. :-( *gutted* I'm not sure whether it's because my windscreen is made of soft cheese, or because the council went fking mental with the grit over the past few weeks, laying it down every night after night until there were tyre tracks through the stuff and I couldn't drive more than 500m without having to spray the windscreen.

What are my options? Consensus on some parts of the internet seems to say that if you can feel the groove, it's beyond repair/polishing. At the same time there seem to be companies that advertise repairs to any scratch or damage. Or am I looking at a replacement windscreen on a three month old pride & joy? :-/

scott15

198 posts

190 months

Wednesday 17th April 2013
quotequote all
From what i have read on here previously, you can A. either pay out yourself for a new windscreen, or B. Crack the windscreen and just pay the (usually 50 quid) insurance excess.

If you can feel the scratch, then id say it is unfixable. Definitely will not polish out.

zap mc

105 posts

174 months

Wednesday 17th April 2013
quotequote all
Sorry to hear about your scratch but it is more common than you think and it gets more noticeable when you get the first bit of low sunlight after along period of dull weather. If you park your car next to a concrete tiled roof that can cause the sand in the roof tiles to be dislodged and deposited on your screen by the driving rain. When you next use your wipers the grit particles are just there ready to scratch the screen unfortunately. Or it maybe just an unlucky bit of grit randomly thrown up.

In any case it sounds like it is just repairable by polishing as you can only just feel it with your nail contrary to the other opinion previously expressed. Depending on your insurance wording you may be covered for this. If you have an Admiral type policy clause that specifically names cover for "breakage" and not "damage" then it will not be covered. I would strongly advise against "putting a hammer through it" just to get a new screen as it would be unwise to replace the original screen with a fake copy part for the sake of a scratch if you are forced to go via the insurance route. Most excesses are about £75 now.

It could be polished out on a "no win no fee" basis but I am unsure where you are situated in order to advise whether there is coverage for this service in your area. Cost is about £100.

RS4Audi

6,542 posts

209 months

Wednesday 17th April 2013
quotequote all
Polishing glass is very very hard compared to paint.
You have to get it very hot and risk distorting the glass.
Its a very specialised thing and not really worth bothering with

Bonefish Blues

36,997 posts

254 months

Wednesday 17th April 2013
quotequote all
Speak to your insurers - I had a car which had something similar, albeit more extensive smaller scratches than you describe.

It had got to the point where it too was plain hazardous in a low sun. It was changed without question, presumably due to the safety aspect.

aberdeenelvis

126 posts

199 months

Wednesday 17th April 2013
quotequote all
I would never recommend hitting your windscreen in the corner where the taxdisc normally sits with a ball pein hammer.

As this would cause your cause your screen to crack beyond repair!!!!!

Leaving you with the only option of calling your insurer and having to fork out a heafty £50 on your excess to have the screen replaced and if I rember correctly a free set of wipers!!!!!!!

I have never done this HONEST!!!!!

blueg33

47,021 posts

255 months

Wednesday 17th April 2013
quotequote all
scott15 said:
If you can feel the scratch, then id say it is unfixable. Definitely will not polish out.
This is incorrect.

I had a series of deep scratches in the G33 screen after a tensioned steel cable barrier rode up over the bonnet grating the body work and screen as it went. The scratches were polished out of the screen and it was as good as new.

Frosts even sell a kit that lets you do it yourself,mist be better than Insurance Fraud as some people seem to be advocating

Frosts Kit

Edited by blueg33 on Wednesday 17th April 09:07

margerison

1,018 posts

281 months

Wednesday 17th April 2013
quotequote all
If you're not confident in doing this yourself contact your local car detailer.
If they have the right equipment they should be able to fix this:
http://www.detailingworld.co.uk/forum/showthread.p...

EDLT

15,421 posts

237 months

Wednesday 17th April 2013
quotequote all
blueg33 said:
scott15 said:
If you can feel the scratch, then id say it is unfixable. Definitely will not polish out.
This is incorrect.

I had a series of deep scratches in the G33 screen after a tensioned steel cable barrier rode up over the bonnet grating the body work and screen as it went. The scratches were polished out of the screen and it was as good as new.

Frosts even sell a kit that lets you do it yourself,mist be better than Insurance Fraud as some people seem to be advocating

Frosts Kit

Edited by blueg33 on Wednesday 17th April 09:07
Have you used those before?

My windscreen has quite a few scratches on it caused by a wiper blade, I can't feel them on the outside of the screen so I was hoping it'd polish out.

Craikeybaby

12,179 posts

256 months

Wednesday 17th April 2013
quotequote all
I've got similar scratches on the windscreen of my MX-5, there's some useful stuff in this thread.

blueg33

47,021 posts

255 months

Wednesday 17th April 2013
quotequote all
EDLT said:
Have you used those before?

My windscreen has quite a few scratches on it caused by a wiper blade, I can't feel them on the outside of the screen so I was hoping it'd polish out.
I haven't use the kit myself, but the bodyshop used one to sort out my G33

Captain Muppet

8,540 posts

296 months

Wednesday 17th April 2013
quotequote all
aberdeenelvis said:
I would never recommend hitting your windscreen in the corner where the taxdisc normally sits with a ball pein hammer.

As this would cause your cause your screen to crack beyond repair!!!!!

Leaving you with the only option of calling your insurer and having to fork out a heafty £50 on your excess to have the screen replaced and if I rember correctly a free set of wipers!!!!!!!

I have never done this HONEST!!!!!
Who do you think it is who pays for the difference between the excess and the cost of replacing the screen?

I suspect it's everyone except the person commiting fraud, but then I'm not an expert.

stroberaver

Original Poster:

196 posts

199 months

Wednesday 17th April 2013
quotequote all
Cheers folks - looks like the issue splits opinion here too, some say it can be polishedout good as new, some say it's new windscreen time!

Aside from the moral issue of committing insurance fraud, there is no way I could bring myself to "vandalise" my pride and joy by deliberately cracking the windscreen to get a replacement on the insurance. I haven't checked the wording of my policy yet, but my other concern at the prospect of a replacement windscreen is that it'll be a battle (or heinously expensive) to fit an OEM windscreen rather than some third-party copy, as zap mc says. I'm sure I remember reading (a while ago, long before my scratch) of some guy who had a battle to get even a BMW dealership to source and fit an OEM screen instead of outsourcing it to a third party using non-OEM glass. Or maybe my memory is playing tricks. But I'd also be concerned about the quality of workmanship when changing a windscreen. My car is still effectively brand new - it's barely run in, still smells new, and I'd be concerned that a replacement windscreen is never going to be fitted as perfectly as the windscreen it received in the factory.

It's reassuring to hear that there are cases where proper scratches have been polished out - I can imagine the amount of effort and heat generated in the process of grinding away the glass, but I'd have thought that managing the heat and avoiding distortion is down to the skill of the polisher. I shudder to think what the cost might be though - surely the process must take hours? It doesn't help that I'm in the north east of England, with relatively few specialists compared to the south/London. It'd be prepared to travel though (within reason), if there was someone who could get it as good as new without replacing the windscreen. I'll try and get some photos of it one day in clear sunshine.

I wouldn't contemplate doing it myself - I've no kit, no experience with machine polishers and as I live in a flat, no garage, driveway or power supply of my own. I'd probably ruin the screen some more if I tried!

margerison said:
If you're not confident in doing this yourself contact your local car detailer.
If they have the right equipment they should be able to fix this:
http://www.detailingworld.co.uk/forum/showthread.p...
Thanks, but those scratches look nothing like mine. Those look just like lots of fine scuffs from the wipers, I've got a single scratch from something (a friggin diamond, it seems) being trapped under the blade up to the point at which the washer jets would have blasted it away. frown

Poor car. frown I know, I know, "first world problems" an' all, but I've not even had a chance to properly enjoy the car yet and my pride & joy is compromised already. frown

blueg33

47,021 posts

255 months

Wednesday 17th April 2013
quotequote all
Nothin wrong with pattern windscreens. Had them on my A6 and Outback in the last 12 months. You wouldn't know that they are not original. The downside is that they didnt re-attached the interior trim very well on the Subaru but did an excellent job on the A6.

I am about to pay to have the screen done on the Alpine as it needs a new surround and leaks a little, its not a cheap exercise

Screen £426
Surround £140
Labour £130

Total £696


ging84

9,548 posts

177 months

Wednesday 17th April 2013
quotequote all
you will be amazed what will polish out on glass, if it is only noticeable in some lights and you've not already used a decent glass polish you'll probably find it completely disappears when you do

i have a couple of chips that were quite noticeable got me advisories on my MOT, used autoglym glass polish and now you can barely see them

stroberaver

Original Poster:

196 posts

199 months

Wednesday 17th April 2013
quotequote all
ging84 said:
you will be amazed what will polish out on glass, if it is only noticeable in some lights and you've not already used a decent glass polish you'll probably find it completely disappears when you do

i have a couple of chips that were quite noticeable got me advisories on my MOT, used autoglym glass polish and now you can barely see them
Thanks, but I think the scratch I have is beyond a bit of autoglym glass polish. I daresay I'll give it a go as I'm clutching at straws as to improve the situation without doing anything too drastic, but I really can't see how a bit of polish is going to remedy this scratch, unless it's applied with a machine polisher and some brute force. For several hours.

@ blueg33 - I daresay replacement non-OEM windscreens are fine, just that with a car that's still so new, I'm still at the stage where I want to keep it "as new". :-/ Plus I thought there can be issues with wiper/light sensors when the glass is changed for non-OEM stuff.

Edited by stroberaver on Wednesday 17th April 17:44

Glassman

25,105 posts

246 months

Wednesday 17th April 2013
quotequote all
stroberaver said:
I thought there can be issues with wiper/light sensors when the glass is changed for non-OEM stuff.
Correct. But what the consumer wants, the consumer usually gets. If you want to keep your car as original as possible, you get the satisfaction of knowing you've done everything to preserve the best market value of the car. With genuine parts, the chances of any issues, such as rain sensor issues and imperfections in the glass are next to zero.

The aftermarket copies are a bit of a lottery. In the main, they appear to OK and there are different levels of quality between brands. A lot of glass is coming in from China and there is also a Polish manufacturer pushing more and more glass to the AGR market. For a standard, run of the mill car you can't really grumble if you're the paying customer, but it suits the larger windscreen 'insurance nominated' companies because they can offer cheaper rates to inscos and still hold on to a margin by buying cheaper glass. To be fair, some of the 'budget' brands are [sometimes] quite good, but you can't rely on it being consistently good. Most of the time, the insurance nominated replacement companies will not give you a say in the matter. They will be very keen to chuck in a cheaper brand and underscore it with 'we only fit OEM' or 'OEM equivalent' glass. Aftermarket (copy) glass and genuine are not the same and there are discernible differences in some of the manufacturing processes. There are, however, in some cases, OEM branded glass which has the manufacturer logo removed. For example, Land Rover windscreens direct from Pilkington AGR will be exactly the same as the OEM versions from the dealer parts counters. The only difference will be the 'Land Rover' logo would have been removed by laser and overlaid with a black Pilkington logo. Same glass. This is also true for a lot of BMW glass.

My advice/suggestion would be to see if you can find someone to polish it. Deeper scratches: higher risk and there is no guarantee of them being removed entirely; much will depend on the equipment and the guy using it. I have seen a lot of zapmc's work and it's remarkably good (especially comparing the before and after).

Remember, it's glass, and glass - like tyres - is more at risk of damage. You could have the scratch polished or even the screen changed; a stone could meet the windscreen soon after and you're at a similar dilemma again. Think about polishing, but until you find someone reputable you'll be living with it... see how much it really does bug you after a while.

Best of luck and keep us all posted.


Edited by Glassman on Wednesday 17th April 20:50

Araantonak

121 posts

163 months

Wednesday 17th April 2013
quotequote all
I would go to an Autoglass Branch that has a Laddaw attached to it. They usually have some specialized glass polishing equipment for getting rid of small transport damages.

If you ask nicely they might help you for free or at least give you an expert opinion.

I don't know about the UK but in Switzerland they would do this for free just to give good customer service.

If you go let me know how it went smile

northandy

3,540 posts

252 months

Wednesday 17th April 2013
quotequote all
Happened to me on a 1 series, i think the fact that the council had been working on the pavement in the street was the cause, i started the car, screen was wet from rain, as soon as the wipers swept i heard the grit wipe accrss the screen.

blueg33

47,021 posts

255 months

Wednesday 17th April 2013
quotequote all
stroberaver said:
T

@ blueg33 - I daresay replacement non-OEM windscreens are fine, just that with a car that's still so new, I'm still at the stage where I want to keep it "as new". :-/ Plus I thought there can be issues with wiper/light sensors when the glass is changed for non-OEM stuff.

Edited by stroberaver on Wednesday 17th April 17:44

Wiper and light sensors on the A6 are fine, no issues at all.