Why have steering wheel rims become thicker?
Discussion
More of a genuine ponder regarding ergonomics than anything; but I have relative small hands so perhaps it doesn't unduly affect others.
Before the mass adoption of airbags in the early to mid nineties steering wheels had by and large followed the same school of design: for a saloon they were big, for a sports car they were smaller. All, generally, had fairly thin rims being a simple wire circle with a plastic, wooden, or leather wrapping.
I would guess that large steering wheels were a hangover from the pre-PAS days, when they served the useful function of applying greater torque to the end of the steering column. They were effectively rendered redundant by power steering, but many persisted with them until the end of the 20th Century.
But what of rim thickness (fnarr fnarr). Unless wheel construction has altered radically, or safety standards have mandated more padding, I cannot see any practical reason for making the rim itself thicker. In fact there are many reasons not to: thinner rims are more comfortable to hold; they are easier to maintain a proper grip on and manipulate with the finger tips thus lending themselves to better car control.
The worst example I have driven was a humble Fiesta, the wheel rim was so thick it felt more like gripping a pillow! So is there any reason why this has happened? Or do other people actually like a thick rimmed steering wheel?
Before the mass adoption of airbags in the early to mid nineties steering wheels had by and large followed the same school of design: for a saloon they were big, for a sports car they were smaller. All, generally, had fairly thin rims being a simple wire circle with a plastic, wooden, or leather wrapping.
I would guess that large steering wheels were a hangover from the pre-PAS days, when they served the useful function of applying greater torque to the end of the steering column. They were effectively rendered redundant by power steering, but many persisted with them until the end of the 20th Century.
But what of rim thickness (fnarr fnarr). Unless wheel construction has altered radically, or safety standards have mandated more padding, I cannot see any practical reason for making the rim itself thicker. In fact there are many reasons not to: thinner rims are more comfortable to hold; they are easier to maintain a proper grip on and manipulate with the finger tips thus lending themselves to better car control.
The worst example I have driven was a humble Fiesta, the wheel rim was so thick it felt more like gripping a pillow! So is there any reason why this has happened? Or do other people actually like a thick rimmed steering wheel?
I don't know, but personally I hate thick-rimmed wheels and I think most modern wheels are too small in diameter too.
I intensely dislike the modern fashion for wheels which aren't round, too. In order to be "sporty", it seems that they have to have odd protrusions and/or flat bits. Horrible things.
I intensely dislike the modern fashion for wheels which aren't round, too. In order to be "sporty", it seems that they have to have odd protrusions and/or flat bits. Horrible things.
Edited by kambites on Wednesday 17th April 22:24
It is ridiculous. I much prefer a thinner wheel (my 106 Rallye is just right, no PAS and a thin rimmed wheel for maximum feedback).
One particularly silly modern steering wheel is the one in the Z4M Coupe (it may be the same in the Z4 coupe?). It's like something from a bus:

EDIT: No, bus steering wheels are thinner than that.
One particularly silly modern steering wheel is the one in the Z4M Coupe (it may be the same in the Z4 coupe?). It's like something from a bus:

EDIT: No, bus steering wheels are thinner than that.
Just like birds have more trouble perching on a thin wires, than they do on a thicker tree branch, thick steering wheel rims are more comfortable to hold onto than thin rims. They could also be more robust in a crash situation. Films of earlier race drivers show thin steering wheel rims bending like
a bit of wire, and heaven help them in a crash where the rim just bends forward with almost no resistance leaving the steering column / steering wheel boss projecting backwards like a spear waiting
for the drivers chest/ face.
As the steering wheel is one of the main driver / vehicle interfaces, and now forms part of the passive safety system in a modern car. I believe the reasons for having thicker wheel rims would be for comfort and safety.
a bit of wire, and heaven help them in a crash where the rim just bends forward with almost no resistance leaving the steering column / steering wheel boss projecting backwards like a spear waiting
for the drivers chest/ face.
As the steering wheel is one of the main driver / vehicle interfaces, and now forms part of the passive safety system in a modern car. I believe the reasons for having thicker wheel rims would be for comfort and safety.
I can't really comment on this as anything from the mid to late 90's is way to modern for me.
But I guess it's a safety thing.
My father many moons ago was involved in an accident which resulted in him actually bending the steering wheel Completly back on itself.
Also I knew of one guy who got involved in an accident in a 60s car and the steering wheel actually snapped.
But I guess it's a safety thing.
My father many moons ago was involved in an accident which resulted in him actually bending the steering wheel Completly back on itself.
Also I knew of one guy who got involved in an accident in a 60s car and the steering wheel actually snapped.
I totally disagree with the op, purely on ergonomics. I like a chunky wheel, so the msport is good imo. I find a bigger wheel much nicer to hold, with less finger overlap when your hand is all the way round it.
Originally, thin wheels were standard, with chunkier ones typically being the "sports steering wheel". Presuming that personal prference for rim thickness hasn't changed much as a population, is the change due to sports=sales that is the current trend?
Originally, thin wheels were standard, with chunkier ones typically being the "sports steering wheel". Presuming that personal prference for rim thickness hasn't changed much as a population, is the change due to sports=sales that is the current trend?
Baryonyx said:
It is ridiculous. I much prefer a thinner wheel (my 106 Rallye is just right, no PAS and a thin rimmed wheel for maximum feedback).
One particularly silly modern steering wheel is the one in the Z4M Coupe (it may be the same in the Z4 coupe?). It's like something from a bus:

EDIT: No, bus steering wheels are thinner than that.
Yep same on all z4 coupe sports, the se has a thinner wheel, its horrible. All down to personal preference and size of hands I guess.One particularly silly modern steering wheel is the one in the Z4M Coupe (it may be the same in the Z4 coupe?). It's like something from a bus:

EDIT: No, bus steering wheels are thinner than that.
Gassing Station | General Gassing | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff



