What car? Large estate, fun, quick, decent spec, £3-5k
What car? Large estate, fun, quick, decent spec, £3-5k
Author
Discussion

BIST0

Original Poster:

1,204 posts

273 months

Thursday 18th April 2013
quotequote all
I've just got rid of my wife's XC90 and need to replace it quite urgently with an estate car.

It needs to have a big boot to fit a push chair in alongside our rather large pooch.

Not looking to spend a lot (say £3-5k) as its only going to be used for 2 days a week but has to be decent enough to be up for the occasional long distance schlep when the 15mpg my Range Rover does loses its appeal. As i'll therefore pilot it a bit I'd like it to be half decent to drive and quite quick. If it can do 30mpg on a run I'll be happy enough.

I've been looking at the usual suspects for a while but none of them excite me much.

Audi A6 - can't seem to get a decent spec one without galactic mileage for the cash. Bit dull. I'd have one of the 3.0D Le Mans spec ones but they are out of budget.
BMW 5 - E60 shape a bit pricey. E39 shape a possible. Never been a massive fan of BMWs though.
Merc E class - ones from the era within the price range do nothing for me at all. My experience of early to mid 2000s mercs is that they are woeful in terms of reliability.
Saab 9-5 - Dated and even in Aero guise not massively exciting
Subaru Legacy - used to have one (3.0 R spec b). Prob shouldn't have sold it but don't want to go back to the same.

I'm sure you can get some cracking cars for £3k I just can't seem to find them. Perhaps I've become a car snob!

Where is the 5 grand RS6/E63 when you need one?!






Gad-Westy

16,666 posts

244 months

Thursday 18th April 2013
quotequote all
Subaru seems by far the most promising option on that list going of what you have said.

Maulden7

147 posts

263 months

Thursday 18th April 2013
quotequote all
Volvo T5 Estate?

Fast, comfortable, will do 30mpg on a long run, hold a party in the back.

RenesisEvo

3,828 posts

250 months

BIST0

Original Poster:

1,204 posts

273 months

Thursday 18th April 2013
quotequote all
That 545 looks interesting. Thanks.

I couldn't seem to find a decent Volvo T5 that isn't pretty old. I think they fell out of favour a bit.

The list I provided isn't a view of the only options, just the obvious ones I'd thought of. Looking for some leftfield ideas to inspire me!

shoehorn

686 posts

174 months

Thursday 18th April 2013
quotequote all
Mondeo ST220 estate.

Andy_sx

2,410 posts

237 months

Thursday 18th April 2013
quotequote all
I love my 95 aero, and that's having come from a vx220 directly before it... ok, it wont win a beauty contest, or a handling showdown but it can certainly be made to get a wiggle on down a decent B road, or sit there at a decent heady speed on the motorway.

Only reason it will be advertised next week is emigrating otherwise it would not be going anywhere, a bargain of a car for the outlay

WildCards

4,061 posts

248 months

Thursday 18th April 2013
quotequote all
Has the Legnum VR4 or Nissan Stagea been considered?

billzeebub

3,913 posts

230 months

Thursday 18th April 2013
quotequote all
Legacy, or Forester maybe

chevy-stu

5,392 posts

259 months

Thursday 18th April 2013
quotequote all
WildCards said:
Has the Legnum VR4 or Nissan Stagea been considered?
I'd second a Legnum VR4, only sold mine cos of the fuel usage really, and wanting something newer. Brilliant and handsome all round track/estate/lugger.. very tall gearing so accelerates very well but I never got more than 23 mpg driving like miss daisy on the motorway though..

williredale

2,866 posts

183 months

Thursday 18th April 2013
quotequote all
Ecurie Ecosse said:
Maulden7 said:
Volvo T5 Estate?

Fast, comfortable, will do 30mpg on a long run, hold a party in the back.
The only choice.
Perhaps not the only choice but given your requirements and budget it's what I would do.

longbow

1,610 posts

266 months

Thursday 18th April 2013
quotequote all
chevy-stu said:
WildCards said:
Has the Legnum VR4 or Nissan Stagea been considered?
I'd second a Legnum VR4, only sold mine cos of the fuel usage really, and wanting something newer. Brilliant and handsome all round track/estate/lugger.. very tall gearing so accelerates very well but I never got more than 23 mpg driving like miss daisy on the motorway though..
+2.... You say the usual suspect don't excite you very much...... so how about a twin turbo V6 4wd estate with 'torque vectoring' AYC diff? Mitsubishi reliability and rarity gives them proper Q car appeal if you don't go OTT on mods. Best car in terms of performance value I'll ever have owned... period.


gareth_r

6,792 posts

268 months

Thursday 18th April 2013
quotequote all
chevy-stu said:
I'd second a Legnum VR4, only sold mine cos of the fuel usage really, and wanting something newer. Brilliant and handsome all round track/estate/lugger.. very tall short gearing so accelerates very well but I never got more than 23 mpg driving like miss daisy on the motorway though..
Tall/long/high gearing would make it accelerate more slowly than short/low gearing.

Scootersp

4,137 posts

219 months

Thursday 18th April 2013
quotequote all
IS300 Sportcross?

chevy-stu

5,392 posts

259 months

Thursday 18th April 2013
quotequote all
gareth_r said:
all/long/high gearing would make it accelerate more slowly than short/low gearing.
Yeah. . That's the one

danp

1,658 posts

293 months

Thursday 18th April 2013
quotequote all
accord type-s? (2.4 and 190bhp)

BIST0

Original Poster:

1,204 posts

273 months

Thursday 18th April 2013
quotequote all
Some good ideas thanks! I like the idea of a legnum or stagea but wonder how clean one would be for my budget. They'll all be pretty old won't they? I'll have a look in the classifieds. Wife may not be happy with the looks though...

Wish they did an Accord type R estate!

IS300 sportbrake? In budget? I'll have a look!




Chris_VRS

2,475 posts

224 months

Thursday 18th April 2013
quotequote all
Octavia VRS estate?

43034

2,971 posts

199 months

Thursday 18th April 2013
quotequote all
Another vote for a 9-5 Aero, if the 250bhp isn't enough for you send it to SaabNoob (Karl) for a remap. And even then if it's too slow, get a 3" Downpipe (~£350), 3.5 FPT (~£20) and then another remap. Stage 3 is a right old hoot!

browno

529 posts

265 months

Thursday 18th April 2013
quotequote all
Left-field option, but how about a vectra VXR estate?

A nice smooth turbo v6, 255 or 280BHP standard (and 400lbs ft with a remap), absolutely huge load space too! I bought mine at 18 months old and it has been a great load lugger with a decent turn of speed. You should find one just in budget, or if you want to go to the lower end, you will get an ex-police one (vxr mechanicals, with low spec trim) - although might need to choose carefully!