Car damaged while at dealer
Car damaged while at dealer
Author
Discussion

Ozone

Original Poster:

3,112 posts

218 months

Thursday 18th April 2013
quotequote all
I took my car to a main dealer for it's service today and when I arrived to collect it I noticed that a door panel had some large creases and some scratches in it. They noted the damage on the service sheet while it was in the workshop and said it was taken for a valet before then (i believe off site). They are going to review their CCTV to see what/when it happened but explained that my car is parked there at my own risk like any other public car park. I am waiting for them to get back to me over the next couple of days

Has anybody had any experience of this sort of thing and offer any advice?

blaineuk

2,615 posts

278 months

Thursday 18th April 2013
quotequote all
My van was damaged whilst in for repair, I didn't notice until, the dat after collecting it, but I had a word with the garage, and although they said they hadn't damaged it, they would as a good will gesture repair it.

Ozone

Original Poster:

3,112 posts

218 months

Thursday 18th April 2013
quotequote all
Blaine, was the garage happy to do the repair or did you have to fight for it? Do you use then regularly?

blaineuk

2,615 posts

278 months

Thursday 18th April 2013
quotequote all
Hadn't used them before, and was only using them as vehicle was under warranty, and had to go to main dealer, only took a couple of phone calls to get them to sort it, I suspect they knew it had happened and that it why they agreed to do it without me pushing it much.
Each dealer will be different though, but if you are a regular customer they may agree to do it, just to keep your custom.

ShaunTheSheep

951 posts

186 months

Thursday 18th April 2013
quotequote all
Had a wheel chipped when my car was in for its 1st service. They resolutely refused under no circumstances was the damage their doing. Luckily i had posted a picture of it in their car park on Facebook that morning. Total luck the wheel in question was in the shot. I'd almost given in trying to get them to take resposibility and was heading back to the car when I remembered about the photo.

Good luck!

wijit

1,512 posts

206 months

Thursday 18th April 2013
quotequote all
If it was on their land on agreed days for an agreed service of any sort then they are contractually obliged to look after it. It is not a public car park on private land and they have a duty to return the car to the same state as when you delivered it to them. They have already admitted liability by claiming to not be liable (thus admitting it happened whilst in their care).
If they refuse to repair the damage, get three quotes to have the damage repaired and write to them (only in writing, not telephone, and recorded delivery)saying you will get it repaired elsewhere. If they still refuse then get a Small Claims Court claim in. You will win.
You can contact their Insurance company or trade body directly to deal with this.

Ozone

Original Poster:

3,112 posts

218 months

Friday 19th April 2013
quotequote all
Thanks wijit, i am expecting them not to find any evidence on CCTV and say tough, but i'll see what happens.

Ozone

Original Poster:

3,112 posts

218 months

Friday 19th April 2013
quotequote all
Should i contact my insurance company or give the garage time to rectify the problem?

Update:
Contacted my insurance company and they put me through to their legal advisors as i have legal cover who said the car was in their care, as wijit said they are liable.



Edited by Ozone on Friday 19th April 11:28

wijit

1,512 posts

206 months

Friday 19th April 2013
quotequote all
They are indeed, cctv or not. Now you have your Insurance people on it, you should have a smooth ride sorting this out. But in case they try it on, don't allow them anything other than getting your car how you expect it to be.

Ozone

Original Poster:

3,112 posts

218 months

Friday 19th April 2013
quotequote all
Just spoken to the garage and they say nothing on CCTV so it was done before they got the car. Waiting for a manager to call me back.

Zyp

16,166 posts

220 months

Friday 19th April 2013
quotequote all
Been through this just recently with BMW.

Car went in for some warranty work, wife dropped it off and picked up a courtesy car.
Service chap walked around the courtesy car to mark damage on his sheet, but 'didn't have the time' to walk around our car to do the same.

I went to pick the car up two days later to find a gouge and dent on the door.

Obviously, they said it was already there, but it wasn't.
They then went into the back office and produced a sheet of paper that shows where damage is (when you book a carin, just like the courtesy car) and amazingly the damage was noted.

Apparently the mechanic does his own sheet when the car goes into the workshop, and our car had been sat outside for 4 hours before it went in.

As the car was in their care I insisted they repair it - several unreturned phone calls came and went and so I lost my rag.
Phoned head of CS and then phoned the salesman that sold me the car 18 months ago.

Within 10 secs of putting the phone down to him the service manager phoned me, apologised, and then they paid for Tito be repaired.

You'd have thought that after a week of arseing around they'd get the repair to be 100% bob on, but no.....

OP - take no st from them, stand your ground, even talk to the general manager or even the DP.
Good luck.

Magic919

14,589 posts

232 months

Friday 19th April 2013
quotequote all
Who would valet a car and then send it to the workshop? Having a condition sheet any filling it in after the customer leaves is not clever either.

Stand your ground and they'll probably sort it. Damage should look fresh in any case. Look around garage for posts etc that may be wearing paint that matches your car.

A main dealer reversed one of our cars and damaged the door on a post. After three repair attempts it still looked rubbish, so we sold the car and replaced it.

Ozone

Original Poster:

3,112 posts

218 months

Friday 19th April 2013
quotequote all
Manager insists that CCTV shows no evidence of damage cause and won't budge. I've asked for the footage, I was hoping that it would show the condition of the car on arrival but apparently it doesn't

Insurance co now saying they can't advise any further, get independant advice. rolleyes

My trusted bodyshop says it needs a new door.

Looks like i'll have to start writing letters.

arguti

1,871 posts

217 months

Friday 19th April 2013
quotequote all
just a tip from a friend re hiring cars and courtesy cars checklists.

By all means walk around the car and note all dents, etc then ask to see the last sign in checksheet just to make sure you have not missed anything!