Volvo s60 auto or merc slk
Volvo s60 auto or merc slk
Author
Discussion

chasdad

Original Poster:

285 posts

175 months

Thursday 18th April 2013
quotequote all
Ive been told of a really nice slk that's coming up for sale. All I know is it's a petrol.i think it's an 02 upwards and apparently it's a minter. The trouble is the wife wants a fairly economical auto diesel, like a s60. Out of the two what would the pistonhead community go for.
I think the mrs can be talked into the slk,long as its not a 500. Cheers

lightthefuse

426 posts

203 months

Thursday 18th April 2013
quotequote all
Need to lug stuff at any point? Need more than 2 seats?

Given the choice I'd take the Merc, to hell with the hairdresser image. An S60 on the other hand is a highly competent machine but I'd say it wouldn't have a tenth of the fun factor. One of the more bizarre head-to-heads I've seen on PH, it has to be said!

billzeebub

3,913 posts

230 months

Thursday 18th April 2013
quotequote all
As above, get. The SLK if you don't need a 4 seat saloon, especially a Dalziel! Never listen to your missus where cars are concerned!

chasdad

Original Poster:

285 posts

175 months

Thursday 18th April 2013
quotequote all
Sorry I meant a clk. I don't normally listen to her .but she's moaning about the fuel e39 drinks. Got a six seat renault lugging gear about

Kitchski

6,552 posts

262 months

Thursday 18th April 2013
quotequote all
I'd got the S60. Never liked the CLK and the S60 is actually a really nice car.

lightthefuse

426 posts

203 months

Thursday 18th April 2013
quotequote all
With that information I'd take it on the condition/spec of both. Would probably prefer the S60 in that case too depending on the toys and leather, if it was me.

chasdad

Original Poster:

285 posts

175 months

Thursday 18th April 2013
quotequote all
All i know of the merc at moment is tha it's a 1 owner always maintained well and immaculate. Just started looking at s60's. But have read that the auto boxes are poor. Am about of a fan of German cars though I must admit

Timberwolf

5,374 posts

249 months

Thursday 18th April 2013
quotequote all
'02-ish S60 auto, on the other hand...

BANG!
clonk.
lurch.
clunk.
BANG!
rev.

... coast gently to side of road with no drive.

Some of them last, but this tends to require an unusually fastidious maintenance schedule (or a lot of luck) by the previous owner, from new. The problem is a design fault with the gearbox that results in the valve body solenoids eventually getting gummed up with dirty/degraded transmission fluid from 50k onward, earlier if the car is used hard. Regular ATF changes from early in the car's life will keep on top of it by avoiding the degraded fluid part of the equation, but by the time the valve body finally gives in it's usually knackered the clutches as well and you'll need a full rebuild by a specialist who really knows their stuff.

Other than that they're lovely cars, though. I'd happily have a manual or a later automatic (they got a lot of revisions and from what I recall post-2005 cars are mostly trouble-free), especially if it was a T5.

chasdad

Original Poster:

285 posts

175 months

Thursday 18th April 2013
quotequote all
Cheers timberwolf. Looks like I,d have to find more money if I go for a s60.mercs looking more likely all the time. That is if he doesn't want silly money for it.