Company Car Allowance
Author
Discussion

xRIEx

Original Poster:

8,180 posts

179 months

Friday 19th April 2013
quotequote all
Company car allowance policy as follows:
- £350/month (I think)
- 45p/mile to 10K miles (about £3700/year based on my last 12 months business miles)
- Recommended standard of car:
   - not exceed 4 years old
   - clean and presentable (?!)
   - suitable for position of employment (not sure what that means, I assume "don't turn up in a Bentley" as I'm more at the skivvy end than company director)

What would you do? Get the cheapest lease deal to try and turn a profit to put into a fun car? Try and get something half decent and put own cash in to get it? Or, ignore their 'recommendations' and get something old, comfortable and wafty?

Edited by xRIEx on Friday 19th April 13:37

sjg

7,689 posts

296 months

Friday 19th April 2013
quotequote all
"Suitable for position" normally implies a level of practicality - ie. if your position might involve carrying big things in your day to day job, don't buy an MX5. But there's also an element of what you say - not being completely unexpected (for good or bad) if you turn up at a customer.

If they're just recommending <4 years then it depends on who you might annoy if you don't.

Leasing isn't a bad route, especially if you're sure your mileage isn't going to go through the roof. Else I'd probably try to buy at 2-3 years old and change every couple of years.

moebiusuk

345 posts

189 months

Friday 19th April 2013
quotequote all
I think what they're hinting at you to look for is a BMW 320, Audi A4, VW Passat or similair business saloon. Find the cheapest, most economical, reliable one you can and keep the rest for a RWD roadster of some kind.

Polariz

867 posts

186 months

Friday 19th April 2013
quotequote all
^ This.

xRIEx

Original Poster:

8,180 posts

179 months

Friday 19th April 2013
quotequote all
sjg said:
"Suitable for position" normally implies a level of practicality - ie. if your position might involve carrying big things in your day to day job, don't buy an MX5. But there's also an element of what you say - not being completely unexpected (for good or bad) if you turn up at a customer.

If they're just recommending <4 years then it depends on who you might annoy if you don't.

Leasing isn't a bad route, especially if you're sure your mileage isn't going to go through the roof. Else I'd probably try to buy at 2-3 years old and change every couple of years.
That makes sense. 2-3 years old would be an idea to avoid some of the bigger depreciation losses, plus I short attention span and want to try something else after a year or two.


moebiusuk said:
I think what they're hinting at you to look for is a BMW 320, Audi A4, VW Passat or similair business saloon. Find the cheapest, most economical, reliable one you can and keep the rest for a RWD roadster of some kind.
To compare with existing 'essential' company car users list (which I qualify for), we have a choice of things like a 1.3 Astra and 1.6 Altea (all cars are diesel). I think the best of the bunch is a 1.6 Octavia.

Pints

18,451 posts

225 months

Saturday 20th April 2013
quotequote all
xRIEx said:
To compare with existing 'essential' company car users list (which I qualify for), we have a choice of things like a 1.3 Astra and 1.6 Altea (all cars are diesel). I think the best of the bunch is a 1.6 Octavia.
I was going to say that you'd be unlikely to get (and run) a BMW 320, Audi A4 or VW Passat on a £350 allowance. You might just be able to sneak a Focus - any of those on the options list?

PugwasHDJ80

7,684 posts

252 months

Saturday 20th April 2013
quotequote all
xRIEx said:
Company car allowance policy as follows:
- £350/month (I think)
- 45p/mile to 10K miles (about £3700/year based on my last 12 months business miles)
- Recommended standard of car:
   - not exceed 4 years old
   - clean and presentable (?!)
   - suitable for position of employment (not sure what that means, I assume "don't turn up in a Bentley" as I'm more at the skivvy end than company director)

What would you do? Get the cheapest lease deal to try and turn a profit to put into a fun car? Try and get something half decent and put own cash in to get it? Or, ignore their 'recommendations' and get something old, comfortable and wafty?

Edited by xRIEx on Friday 19th April 13:37
Is it 350 after tax or before tax? It makes a huge difference to your choice!

Bonefish Blues

36,988 posts

254 months

Saturday 20th April 2013
quotequote all
What proportion of total miles in this car will your business miles represent (that is, what percentage will be "funded"?)

stewjohnst

2,479 posts

192 months

Saturday 20th April 2013
quotequote all
Done this both ways in the past.

Currently running a company car due to pretty high mileage at work but my rough maths puts you at about 8000 miles a year.

For that, I'd bend my interpretation of their guidance and get something a bit older that can still get up and down the motorway in comfort.

Think something like a Saab 95. It'll cost you 2 grand to buy an alright one and then run it to the ground or until the mot runs out. I got one from a dealer for 900 quid, stuck 6000 miles on in 3 months and then ebayed it for 770, all it cost me in that time was petrol and a fuse to get the heated seat working.

Edited by stewjohnst on Saturday 20th April 07:53

Bonefish Blues

36,988 posts

254 months

Saturday 20th April 2013
quotequote all
stewjohnst said:
Done this both ways in the past.

Currently running a company car due to pretty high mileage at work but my rough maths puts you at about 8000 miles a year.

For that, I'd bend my interpretation of their guidance and get something a bit older that can still get up and down the motorway in comfort.

Think something like a Saab 95. It'll cost you 2 grand to buy an alright one and then run it to the ground or until the mot runs out. I got one from a dealer for 900 quid, stuck 6000 miles on in 3 months and then beamed if for 770, all it cost me in that time was petrol and a fuse to get the heated seat working
Doesn't meet the 4-year rule the OP mentioned earlier?

stewjohnst

2,479 posts

192 months

Saturday 20th April 2013
quotequote all
Bonefish Blues said:
Doesn't meet the 4-year rule the OP mentioned earlier?
I know, see the bit about bending their recommendation...

In my experience, the recommendation is just that. They don't enforce it and just expect you to pay for your own travel in the event your car is off the road for any reason.

edit - phone is st to type with

Bonefish Blues

36,988 posts

254 months

Saturday 20th April 2013
quotequote all
stewjohnst said:
I know, see the bit about bending their recommendation...

In my experience, the recommendation is just that. They don't enforce it and just expect you to pay for your own travel in the event your car is off the road for any reason.

edit - phone is st to type with
Cheap private plate would help OP, I think , if "bend" might actually be closer to "break" wink

iantek

277 posts

214 months

Saturday 20th April 2013
quotequote all
I switched from company car to car allowance a couple of years ago, but the benefit of our scheme was that there were no limits on what you could have. So I opted for a twenty year old MX5 and significantly looser filings. 45p a mile is generous though, I only got 18p for my 1.6 engine.

Bonefish Blues

36,988 posts

254 months

Saturday 20th April 2013
quotequote all
iantek said:
I switched from company car to car allowance a couple of years ago, but the benefit of our scheme was that there were no limits on what you could have. So I opted for a twenty year old MX5 and significantly looser filings. 45p a mile is generous though, I only got 18p for my 1.6 engine.
You are claiming the tax rebate on the difference between your rate and HMRC rates, aren't you?

Fastdruid

9,415 posts

183 months

Saturday 20th April 2013
quotequote all
Bonefish Blues said:
iantek said:
I switched from company car to car allowance a couple of years ago, but the benefit of our scheme was that there were no limits on what you could have. So I opted for a twenty year old MX5 and significantly looser filings. 45p a mile is generous though, I only got 18p for my 1.6 engine.
You are claiming the tax rebate on the difference between your rate and HMRC rates, aren't you?
This. Plus remembering that every passenger you take is an extra 5p per mile. My company pays company car rates for those with car allowances, I did go for a >2l just so that I got the maximum 26p though. :-)

iantek

277 posts

214 months

Saturday 20th April 2013
quotequote all
Yeah, just need to get round to it! I never need to carry passengers but that is handy to know!

xRIEx

Original Poster:

8,180 posts

179 months

Saturday 20th April 2013
quotequote all
Pints said:
I was going to say that you'd be unlikely to get (and run) a BMW 320, Audi A4 or VW Passat on a £350 allowance. You might just be able to sneak a Focus - any of those on the options list?
Yeah, there probably is a Ford on the list come to think of it; there used to be a Fiesta Econetic but I'm fairly certain they took that off.

PugwasHDJ80 said:
Is it 350 after tax or before tax? It makes a huge difference to your choice!
It's £350 before tax, however I have a company car now so if I swapped I'd still have about £350 extra (less maybe £10-15).

Bonefish Blues said:
Cheap private plate would help OP, I think , if "bend" might actually be closer to "break" wink
I like that idea, might give more flexibility with less hassle thumbup

HorneyMX5

5,809 posts

181 months

Saturday 20th April 2013
quotequote all
I get roughly the same deal but only 19p a mile. I bought this:


Untitled by Nicholas R Horne, on Flickr

and spend the left overs on my pension and these:


Untitled by Nicholas R Horne, on Flickr


Bruce_4 by Nicholas R Horne, on Flickr

Nick

Welshbeef

49,633 posts

229 months

Saturday 20th April 2013
quotequote all
Horney MX5 that's a lovely house you have there.

iantek

277 posts

214 months

Saturday 20th April 2013
quotequote all
Yeah, just need to get round to it! I never need to carry passengers but that is handy to know!