Seiko Monster, or another Seiko?
Seiko Monster, or another Seiko?
Author
Discussion

rich85uk

Original Poster:

4,400 posts

210 months

Friday 19th April 2013
quotequote all
Chaps

Looking at getting a cheap holiday watch, as much as they fit the bill i just cant pull the trigger on a G Shock mainly due to there size and general look to them plus the fact that one might be abit overkill for me (no extreme sports, just gym and holidays) the Seiko Monster fits the bill perfectly until i spotted this:
http://www.amazon.co.uk/Seiko-Sports-Automatic-Gen...

Appears to be a similar size and is on a rubber strap (which im leaning towards as will be swimming alot)now this model is 100M as oppsed to 200M with a monster but i will be barely going deeper than 2 meters!also i find this watch abit more discreet and although hardly smart would look ok to wear in the evenings

Would this be as tough and durable as a Monster?(although i dont need a G shock something that can take some abuse is a must)or is there another model that fits the bill better?

CardShark

4,264 posts

210 months

Saturday 20th April 2013
quotequote all
Either would be fine for general mucking about with on holiday but if you'll be on the beach I'd choose the Monster as its screw down crown will offer more protection against sand ingress., pretty sure that most, if not all, Seiko 5 models have push/pull crowns. Other than that, just choose whichever you think looks best. Have a look on creation.com for a few more ideas, they have a fair range of Seikos including both the new and old Monsters as well as the popular SKX007/009 models.

ETA that any G would be tougher than just about anything else on offer and the range is huge, the digital 5600 range is discreet in size and there are plenty of smaller analogue models that are available at the more subdued end of the colour range.



Edited by CardShark on Saturday 20th April 01:08

Roadru77er

473 posts

226 months

Saturday 20th April 2013
quotequote all
I like that 5!

Slight hijack does the SKX 007/9 have a screw down crown? I really like the 007 screw down crown would be a bonus any other options? (I really don't like pepsis)

Deanno1dad

604 posts

255 months

Saturday 20th April 2013
quotequote all
http://www.creationwatches.com/products/seiko-dive...

creation watches doing this seiko divers dirt cheap..I've used the site before,safe as houses and free fed ex postage

checkmate91

861 posts

204 months

Saturday 20th April 2013
quotequote all
Roadru77er said:
Slight hijack does the SKX 007/9 have a screw down crown? I really like the 007 screw down crown would be a bonus any other options? (I really don't like pepsis)
Yes, yes it does!

rich85uk

Original Poster:

4,400 posts

210 months

Saturday 20th April 2013
quotequote all
thanks for the input guys, will all Seiko diver watches have screw down crowns?(fairly large collection on creation!)

A900ss

3,314 posts

183 months

Saturday 20th April 2013
quotequote all
CardShark said:
ETA that any G would be tougher than just about anything else on offer and the range is huge, the digital 5600 range is discreet in size and there are plenty of smaller analogue models that are available at the more subdued end of the colour range.



Edited by CardShark on Saturday 20th April 01:08
I'd agree with the above. I have a 5600 for holiday and mucking around. I know it sounds silly but when I had an orange monster for the same use, I got fed up with having to set the time and date as I used it infrequently. The Casio is always showing the right time however infrequently I use it. Another useful feature I find for holidays is the alarm feature.

I guess you are set on an analogue watch but in this case a digi may be better.

Good luck either way.

CardShark

4,264 posts

210 months

Saturday 20th April 2013
quotequote all
Pretty sure that all 200m WR and upwards have screw downs.

One thing to note with creation is that you should be charged import and VAT on top of the prices advertised though the chances of that happening are very low, although in many cases (but not all) it would still be cheaper than buying from elsewhere - and as has already been said, they have a great reputation.

Top tip - if you're unsure as to which model to go for google the model number and also use YouTube, the chances are that someone somewhere has reviewed the watch you're looking at.

sneijder

5,231 posts

265 months

Saturday 20th April 2013
quotequote all
If a watch has the word "Diver's" on the dial, it conforms to this :

http://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/ISO_6425

If it states 200m on the dial, it's been tested to 250m, at sudden pressure too.

I have a Monster, and it's my holiday watch, leaving G Shocks at home.


immigrant

397 posts

226 months

Saturday 20th April 2013
quotequote all
My holiday watch, on green nato.



Have a black Monster as well, but prefer this as it's lighter and less bling. Also, if I squint, I can pretend it's a JLC Navy Seals.

Edited by immigrant on Saturday 20th April 21:38

bry1975

1,246 posts

194 months

Sunday 21st April 2013
quotequote all
Speak to Lee at chronograph.com shouldn't be any worries about charges.


http://chronograph.com/store/productlist.asp?passs...

Edited by bry1975 on Sunday 21st April 11:09

Hoofy

80,186 posts

313 months

Sunday 21st April 2013
quotequote all
I slightly prefer the SKX031 over the SKX007 as it's slightly smaller and the crown is in the right place. Less water proof, though, IIRC.

sneijder said:
I have a Monster, and it's my holiday watch, leaving G Shocks at home.
Sounds a bit like special forces operative goes on relaxing spa holiday. biggrin

Edited by Hoofy on Sunday 21st April 12:14

marcosgt

11,506 posts

207 months

Sunday 21st April 2013
quotequote all
Only thing I'd say is that the Seiko 5s are FULLY automatic (do Monsters use the same movement?)

You can't wind them to keep them going which I find a bit of a pain personally.

Otherwise, really nice watches that seem to keep good time. Not sure how resilient the black will be.

Mine's morphed into a Fifty Five Fathoms (BP 50 Fathoms 'homage') otherwise I'd probably have put it in my box and never worn it again, but if you're going to wear it a lot (or can live with resetting it every time you use it - It's not that hard really...) then there's not much not to like at that price.

I'm not very keen on Monsters, personally, but I know they're popular. Just not to my taste.

M.

Edited by marcosgt on Sunday 21st April 13:48

CardShark

4,264 posts

210 months

Sunday 21st April 2013
quotequote all
marcosgt said:
Only thing I'd say is that the Seiko 5s are FULLY automatic (do Monsters use the same movement?)

You can't wind them to keep them going which I find a bit of a pain personally.

I'm not very keen on Monsters, personally, but I know they're popular. Just not to my taste.

M.

Edited by marcosgt on Sunday 21st April 13:48
The older Monsters use the 7S26 movement, 5s use 7S26 or 36 movements, they're both auto only with no hacking function either - the newer Monsters use the 4R36 which adds hand winding and hacking.

They are a tad Marmite, I used to own the older black faced version on a bracelet, there's little doubt that with the bracelet they're a lot of watch for the money though.