Has the RX8 killed the market for rotary engined cars?
Has the RX8 killed the market for rotary engined cars?
Author
Discussion

TVR Tommy

Original Poster:

630 posts

256 months

Friday 19th April 2013
quotequote all
For past, present and future.

There seems to be a thread every other day confirming how cheap RX8's are. Within a couple of posts it's pointed out what a liability the rotary engine is in the RX8. Either it blows up, drinks fuel and use's copious amounts of oil. But the conscious is what a great handling, useable 4 door car the RX8 is.

You can't get away from the fact the rotary uses more fuel when trundling around town, than a piston engine and they use oil. But would they be so unreliable if people understood that the rotary isn't your run of the mill piston engine.

Should Mazda have gone rotary powered with the RX8 and sold it as a mass market car? Before the RX8 the RX7 was a bit of a niche market. Which only real car fans showed any interest in with it being a sports car and being rather expensive compared to its rivals of the time.

The RX8 tried and failed to be rotary powered all rounder and now anything with a rotary is consigned to the doldrums of the classifieds?

Zombie

1,613 posts

226 months

Friday 19th April 2013
quotequote all
"uses more fuel when trundling around town, than a piston engine and they use oil."

So do alfas, they're worth fk all too.

TVR Tommy

Original Poster:

630 posts

256 months

Friday 19th April 2013
quotequote all
Zombie said:
"uses more fuel when trundling around town, than a piston engine and they use oil."

So do alfas, they're worth fk all too.
What I was trying to get at, was that the rotary uses more fuel when at low revs than a equivalent 2.3ltr i4/v6 piston engine. but when pushing on at high rpm's the mpg difference becomes less significant

Edited by TVR Tommy on Friday 19th April 23:46

Negative Creep

26,146 posts

258 months

Friday 19th April 2013
quotequote all
I never understood why they didn't fit it to the MX5

Grenoble

60,037 posts

186 months

Friday 19th April 2013
quotequote all
Negative Creep said:
I never understood why they didn't fit it to the MX5
It would have been a nice option, but then look at many MX5 owners. Not that into cars, want high reliability and many just trundle in them - don't demand the performance and high noise revs...

(I'd love one but I don't think it is the proposition the MX5 is aiming at)

Haven't they got an ultra light 1.0 turbo engine in the works?

robsa

2,472 posts

215 months

Friday 19th April 2013
quotequote all
Zombie said:
"uses more fuel when trundling around town, than a piston engine and they use oil."

So do alfas, they're worth fk all too.
smile And Ive owned both and were two of the best cars I have owned!

exgtt

2,067 posts

243 months

Friday 19th April 2013
quotequote all
Petrol and tax prices killed the wankel, the RX8 was a bloody good car and had nothing to do with the rotarys demise.

amstrange1

617 posts

207 months

Friday 19th April 2013
quotequote all
Emissions legislation killed it - for the time being at least.

ensignia

947 posts

266 months

Friday 19th April 2013
quotequote all
Awful engine with no redeemIng features aside from being small and light.

They are horrific on fuel and likely to flood if not warmed up properly. That's not mentioning the fact they are massively flawed in the sense that many develop compression issues which require an engine rebuild to the tune of £2.5k.

They're just too flawed and volatile, and this is reflected in prices.

otolith

69,773 posts

235 months

Friday 19th April 2013
quotequote all
Mazda made excellent use of the packaging advantages of the rotary to make a front-mid engined car with six cylinder refinement, two-seater handling and usable rear seats.

Pearls before swine where most drivers are concerned, handling has a very low priority for most people.

Fastdruid

9,415 posts

183 months

Friday 19th April 2013
quotequote all
Reliability has little to do with the prices (apart from the actually broken ones).

All about the number sold the low mpg and the high VED.

HustleRussell

26,709 posts

191 months

Friday 19th April 2013
quotequote all
What is this 'market for rotary engines' of which you speak?

trackerjack

649 posts

215 months

Saturday 20th April 2013
quotequote all
Come on lets speak some truth here.
Even devout owners will confirm that an RX8 engine can fail at mileages as low as 30k no matter how their driven or how well they are looked after,why they even make my Dolomite Sprint look the model of reliability, however they are fantastic cars and my daughter has one that is tuned for track days.


Timberwolf

5,374 posts

249 months

Saturday 20th April 2013
quotequote all
I think the rotary engine killed the market for rotary engined cars.

Mazda, if anything, gave the market enough palliative care to keep it alive (if hardly healthy) into the 21st century, when its natural death would have come in the early '70s after other manufacturers gave up on ever getting decent longevity out of the rotor tip seal.

The Renesis engine in the RX8 was probably the closest the rotary has ever got to the everyday reliability and longevity of reciprocating engines - but the fuel economy and emissions were never going to be there, and in today's market that's what counts.

soad

34,763 posts

207 months

Saturday 20th April 2013
quotequote all
High CO2 emissions plus poor fuel economy. frown
Mind you, petrol was a lot cheaper when these were first launched.

Ray Luxury-Yacht

8,918 posts

247 months

Saturday 20th April 2013
quotequote all
When I dropped my Skoda Octavia VRS into my mate's garage for some work recently (and yes - it is mapped too, lol smile ) he lent me his son's RX8 as a loan car for the day. It was the higher-powered one, 230 bhp is it?

Anyway, having read many column inches on here about these cars, I was interested to try it out for myself (within the boundaries of respectablity, considering that is wasn't my car and so I had to treat it with a modicum of care.)


With a completely open mind, I found this:

It was cramped and uncomfortable inside.

Despite being a fairly recent model, and 6 or 7 years newer than my Skoda, it had more rattles inside than Mothercare.

The engine, it's character and sound - was flat, buzzy and boring, completely devoid of character. It just pulled with the same level of acceleration up to the redline bleep with no discernible excitement or fun, and sounded as flat as a pancake, like this - bzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz.......my Skoda has way more shove, and is much more fun to drive, because it comes onto the turbo boost in each gear to give a huge pull delivering much biggrin factor. But also drives as docile as Miss daisy when required, with almost zero cabin noise, rattles and irritating mechanical intrusion.

And whilst delivering it's boring bzzzz, it also managed to transmit a similar irritating vibration to match, through the cabin, steering wheel and seat.

It was impractical as an every-day car, with space limitations and no room anywhere. Tiny boot as well.

I didn't particularly enjoy the ergonomics and dashboard layout.

And despite the endorsements of the chassis and handling, I didn't think it was anything special. Again, my Skoda, which admittedly is running on different springs and dampers and uprated ARB's, was easily more agile and had greater feel than the Mazda. And it's a 4 door saloon car. My Honda S2000 is without doubt also superior to the RX8. (Both chassis wise and engine wise!)


That said, I can also see the value of these cars to some people, given the low purchase cost nowadays. For a keen amateur driveway mechanic, not scared to maintain and repair them, maybe they are a bit of a bargain. Engine aside, I suppose you do get overall quality Japanese engineering (despite the rattles and squeaks inside my example).

And they are quite pretty cars too, nice bodywork design overall.

So overall, I no likey and wouldn't own one unless my life depended on it. However, this being Pistonheads, and given our overall enthusiasm for cars and interesting stuff, I must concede that I applaud and commend a mainstream manufacturer for being brave enough to design and sell something so different and interesting. It's projects like this that keep the car industry buzzing with diversity.

It would be boring if all we got was similar, dull packages from all the car makers, devoid of something different.

It's mixed feelings then, because of this. As a car enthusiast, I wish so much that the RX8 had been something far more reliable and trustworthy. It would have meant that car makers would see that building cars like these was worth doing. As it is, I very much doubt we'll see anything this radical again from a mainstream manufacturer, which is a shame.

Do you know what I mean??








otolith

69,773 posts

235 months

Saturday 20th April 2013
quotequote all
I really liked the way mine handled, and I really liked the consistent linear power delivery - but then I don't like turbocharged engines in anything but barges.

Ray Luxury-Yacht

8,918 posts

247 months

Saturday 20th April 2013
quotequote all
otolith said:
I really liked the way mine handled, and I really liked the consistent linear power delivery - but then I don't like turbocharged engines in anything but barges.
Eh, really?

So let me get this right - you like flat, linear power delivery in your sports cars, and peaky turbos with a narrow power band giving it everything within a small window of the rev-range in your BARGES? Which by definition are for comfortable, effortless cruising about?

Really???


otolith

69,773 posts

235 months

Saturday 20th April 2013
quotequote all
I like a consistent relationship between throttle, revs and torque which I can precisely meter out in the middle of a corner. I don't want something with a crappy throttle response that comes on boost and suddenly ramps up the torque mid-bend. And I'm not impressed by the party trick of feeling faster than it is as the torque ramps up. I can tolerate the turbo in our Saab barge, because it makes it less involving to drive, just plant the throttle anywhere between 1900 and 4000rpm and after a little pause it accelerates, but front wheel drive turbocharged saloons are just sensible transport, not fun cars.

Zombie

1,613 posts

226 months

Saturday 20th April 2013
quotequote all
TVR Tommy said:
What I was trying to get at, was that the rotary uses more fuel when at low revs than a equivalent 2.3ltr i4/v6 piston engine. but when pushing on at high rpm's the mpg difference becomes less significant

Edited by TVR Tommy on Friday 19th April 23:46
Why would that be a selling point?

As an engine the wankle does have some merits, it revs well and it's compact. As soon as they make the rotor tips last, they may have a viable product.

Edited by Zombie on Saturday 20th April 01:16