Big miles and newer or low miles and older?
Big miles and newer or low miles and older?
Author
Discussion

Tiggsy

Original Poster:

10,261 posts

283 months

Saturday 20th April 2013
quotequote all
Need a work car that's cheap to run, will take the kids and looks ok (doesnt need to be fun as getting a 2 seater for that)

So....£5k to spend, Mondeo seem obvious choice.

That gets me either a 2006 with 60k or a 2008 with 120k

The newer car is the new version so has vastly better economy, lower road tax, new toys (bluetooth) and will look newer longer.

Do I need to worry about the miles though? I'll do 15-20k a year and there seem loads with HUGE miles on....so old or new?

grumpyscot

1,293 posts

223 months

Saturday 20th April 2013
quotequote all
Already a topic on this - and only a day old!
http://www.pistonheads.com/gassing/topic.asp?h=0&a...

davepoth

29,395 posts

230 months

Saturday 20th April 2013
quotequote all
A 2008 car with 120k has done 40,000 miles a year, or about 160 miles a day every working day of the year. I can't think of many jobs where that would be especially normal outside of minicabbing. It's important to consider the type of miles. 120,000 miles up and down motorways at a steady speed is much better than 40,000 miles smoking around a potholed provincial town with drunks vomiting over the rear bench.

texaxile

3,819 posts

181 months

Saturday 20th April 2013
quotequote all
This ^^^

Depends upon servicing, the kind of life it's led and how it's been treated.

Example, a few years back my Dad purchased a Vauxhall Omega which had done an average of 24k pa for the first 3 years of its life. It was previously owned by a large company, had been regularly serviced on mileage and wanted for nothing. As it had been motorway munching, the interior wasn't showing any real kinds of wear associated with heavy, urban "getting in and out", the bodywork was only let down by stone chips, but was surprisingly free from Car park dings and other damage. The tyres were also high end types (michelin) with loads of tread, obviously replaced all at once.

One bonnet & bumper respray later and the car went on for another 10 years doing low mileage in the hands of Dad, by which time the avaerage had come down somewhat.

On the strength of his good experience, I too purchased an Omega which turned out to be the biggest heap of st I've ever had the misfortune to own. Then again, I missed my own caveat because the servicing was intermittent and on that day my spectacles particularly rose tinted..

Edited by texaxile on Saturday 20th April 16:35

matt21

4,404 posts

235 months

Saturday 20th April 2013
quotequote all
davepoth said:
A 2008 car with 120k has done 40,000 miles a year, or about 160 miles a day every working day of the year. I can't think of many jobs where that would be especially normal outside of minicabbing. It's important to consider the type of miles. 120,000 miles up and down motorways at a steady speed is much better than 40,000 miles smoking around a potholed provincial town with drunks vomiting over the rear bench.
A 2008 car could be 5 years old. That's just 24,000 per year, and perfectly normal for a Mondeo. Agree that you need to ensure it hasn't been cabbed though,

Tiggsy

Original Poster:

10,261 posts

283 months

Saturday 20th April 2013
quotequote all
matt21 said:
A 2008 car could be 5 years old. That's just 24,000 per year, and perfectly normal for a Mondeo. Agree that you need to ensure it hasn't been cabbed though,
Just viewed it...couple of previous owners but no sign of cabbing! Rear seats and boot looked unused!

Sir Fergie

795 posts

166 months

Saturday 20th April 2013
quotequote all
Would always give consideration to the newer higher mileage car if the condition and price are right.

The thing that i always think gets overlooked imo - is that your better off with a good reputation car at higher miles - if condition and price are right and service and repair history is good. Rather then going for a lower mileage example of a car that doesn't have such a good reputation.

For example - id be a lot happier with a 150 000 mile 2007 Gen 7 Honda Accord petrol (assuming the Hondas been well minded and in good condition) then a 2003 Mazda 6 diesel with 80,000 miles. Thats because i feel that the Honda will still be a lot more reliable given the Mazda 6 diesel having a reputation for giving a lot of trouble.

Also if your thinking diesel - yes it might be more economical - but id also consider - would buying a normally aspirated petrol give savings on repair costs - and would that plus the cheaper cost to potentially purchase (based on same model, year and mileage) offset the extra fuel costs.

It may do (imo) if your not doing high miles.

Finally - if the 06 Mondeo is a diesel - it would be a Mk 3 TDCI and as such id look into some of the issues - in particular the injector issues that these Mondeo have. Still nothing like as bad as the stories you hear on Mazda 6 diesels though - but worth noting and looking into a bit more.

Im not a Mondeo expert - but am under the impression the Mk 4 diesels aren't as bad in this regard - something to look more closely at - if there is a reliability benefit to the Mk 4 in diesel - and you want diesel - then thats something that merits further consideration of going higher mileage but newer.

I actually like driving diesels - but the snotters replacement - im thinking it will be most likely petrol (unless its a Rover 75 - but thats unlikely inspite of the (very) high temptation)

Sir Fergie

Tiggsy

Original Poster:

10,261 posts

283 months

Saturday 20th April 2013
quotequote all
from what I hear the Mk4 mondeo is a better unit and good for much better MPG.

I dont do spaceship miles - maybe 15k a year. It means a £4500 car now with 115000 will have 160k in a few years and hopefull net me a couple of grand....if it depreciates at less than £1000pa I'm happy

jay140285

626 posts

215 months

Saturday 20th April 2013
quotequote all
For what its worth, I have a new passat and do 160miles a day to work and back.

So if its like mine will be in 4 or 5yrs time, it would be prefectly ok.

sim16v

2,177 posts

232 months

Saturday 20th April 2013
quotequote all
I've got an 09 Mondeo 2.2 diesel as a daily driver and it is coming up to 80,000 miles.

In that time apart from normal servicing, it has had 1 wheel bearing and a split boost hose.

When out for work I often take the "fun" scenic routes rather than motorways and A roads, so it isn't driven gently and I take a couple of European trips a year, often doing 1500-2000 miles in 3 or 4 days.

I'm pleased with the reliability, but when not on motorway runs, it doesn't manage more than about 36mpg.

It's still in excellent condition, and for most of those miles the passenger seats haven't been used.

I'd be happy to take it to 150,000+ miles, but it will be replaced in the next 6 months or so.

Sir Fergie

795 posts

166 months

Saturday 20th April 2013
quotequote all
Tiggsy said:
from what I hear the Mk4 mondeo is a better unit and good for much better MPG.

I dont do spaceship miles - maybe 15k a year. It means a £4500 car now with 115000 will have 160k in a few years and hopefull net me a couple of grand....if it depreciates at less than £1000pa I'm happy
Actually thinking about it a bit more - the Mk 4 is actually one of the few modern cars id have in diesel over the petrol equivelent. The 2.0 normally aspirated petrol is a 145 PS unit (i think) and i do personally think that a 2.0 normally aspirated petrol would be a bit lacklustre in the big heavy Mk 4.

A 2.5 T would be quite nice though - but alas - if your wanting a diesel - you will definitely find the 2.5 a thirsty beast. I see the Focus Mk 2 ST has a reputation for been heavy on fuel - same engine.

So diesels the way to go on the Mk 4 - despite my normal allergy to modern diesels.

Sir Fergie