62 Reg Suzuki Swift Seized Engine After A Service.
62 Reg Suzuki Swift Seized Engine After A Service.
Author
Discussion

Swampyrn

Original Poster:

5 posts

163 months

Sunday 21st April 2013
quotequote all
Hi,

My son bought a 62 reg Swift last September and he just had it into the Dealership for its first 9000 mile service. No big sweat, oil and filter change and the general once over.
After 5 days of the service the engine cut out and upon investigation the oil sump plug was missing and all the oil had headed south, which looks like a seized engine.
Looks like the dealership hadn't tightened the plug up. The car is back with them and been stripped down to assess the damage. They have said they will replace any parts with genuine manufacturer parts and get it back to full spec.
This is all well and good, but apart from the engine what other parts of the car could be effected from this failure?
Do you think we have a case to ask for a new car seen as its only 7 months old and it was their fault?
Any help is much appreciated.

Swampy.

The Moose

23,709 posts

240 months

Sunday 21st April 2013
quotequote all
I think a new engine would be fair, but not a new car. IMHO of course

Blue Oval84

5,399 posts

192 months

Sunday 21st April 2013
quotequote all
They'll just stick a new engine in and it will be fine I'm sure. No other parts should be affected by a seized engine.

I don't think you'll be on to a winner trying to get a new car from them when your existing one has already presumably done 10-12K and they're replacing the engine.

Good luck getting it all sorted smile

Mr Gear

9,416 posts

221 months

Sunday 21st April 2013
quotequote all
Nothing will have broken apart from the engine. They should probably give you a hire car and a an apologetic bow too though.

philmots

4,666 posts

291 months

Sunday 21st April 2013
quotequote all
Engine broke. New engine fitted. Problem solved.

Slidingpillar

761 posts

167 months

Sunday 21st April 2013
quotequote all
A new engine is probably cheaper! Not only are all the bits you'd expect to change/recondition needed, but ones you'd hope to reuse could be wreaked as well.

Obviously the economics of labour rates and price/availability of new Suzuki engines is a factor but manual engine re-building is not the sort of thing I'd expect most main dealers of any make to have experience in.

matchmaker

9,091 posts

231 months

Sunday 21st April 2013
quotequote all
Was there no warning - like a big red light on the dash showing low oil pressure?

Swampyrn

Original Poster:

5 posts

163 months

Sunday 21st April 2013
quotequote all
matchmaker said:
Was there no warning - like a big red light on the dash showing low oil pressure?
Hi, it happened so fast the engine cut out and that was game over....

Terminator X

21,020 posts

235 months

Sunday 21st April 2013
quotequote all
Did well to get anything from them in my experience! Most will just deny all knowledge once you leave their premises.

TX.

Swampyrn

Original Poster:

5 posts

163 months

Sunday 21st April 2013
quotequote all
Slidingpillar said:
A new engine is probably cheaper! Not only are all the bits you'd expect to change/recondition needed, but ones you'd hope to reuse could be wreaked as well.

Obviously the economics of labour rates and price/availability of new Suzuki engines is a factor but manual engine re-building is not the sort of thing I'd expect most main dealers of any make to have experience in.
Thanks for all the replies. Its a relief they are admitting fault and agreeing on bringing the car back to the manufacturers spec. What my concern is if they cannot tighten up a sump drain plug during a basic service what hope have I got if they are going to rebuild an engine.
It doesn't give me any confidence in their workmanship..

Benbay001

5,895 posts

188 months

Sunday 21st April 2013
quotequote all
Swampyrn said:
Thanks for all the replies. Its a relief they are admitting fault and agreeing on bringing the car back to the manufacturers spec. What my concern is if they cannot tighten up a sump drain plug during a basic service what hope have I got if they are going to rebuild an engine.
It doesn't give me any confidence in their workmanship..
The new engine will be fitted by a mechanic, the service would have been done by a technician. In my experience.

vz-r_dave

3,469 posts

249 months

Sunday 21st April 2013
quotequote all
Swampyrn said:
Slidingpillar said:
A new engine is probably cheaper! Not only are all the bits you'd expect to change/recondition needed, but ones you'd hope to reuse could be wreaked as well.

Obviously the economics of labour rates and price/availability of new Suzuki engines is a factor but manual engine re-building is not the sort of thing I'd expect most main dealers of any make to have experience in.
Thanks for all the replies. Its a relief they are admitting fault and agreeing on bringing the car back to the manufacturers spec. What my concern is if they cannot tighten up a sump drain plug during a basic service what hope have I got if they are going to rebuild an engine.
It doesn't give me any confidence in their workmanship..
I understand your concern but if you look it from a positive you now have a 62 plate with an engine with 9k less miles on it. An engine replacement will likely be done by specialists, not your average service guys.

r11co

6,244 posts

261 months

Sunday 21st April 2013
quotequote all
Swampyrn said:
Hi, it happened so fast the engine cut out and that was game over....
Indeed. If the plug was in but loose the oil would have barely dripped out as it wouldn't exactly pour past the threads. Once the plug run its thread and fell out there would have been seconds before warning then bang if the engine was hot.

Krikkit

27,943 posts

212 months

Sunday 21st April 2013
quotequote all
Benbay001 said:
Swampyrn said:
Thanks for all the replies. Its a relief they are admitting fault and agreeing on bringing the car back to the manufacturers spec. What my concern is if they cannot tighten up a sump drain plug during a basic service what hope have I got if they are going to rebuild an engine.
It doesn't give me any confidence in their workmanship..
The new engine will be fitted by a mechanic, the service would have been done by a technician. In my experience.
Agreed - people charged with the servicing won't be doing serious work like rebuilding/replacing engines. Chances are they'll get a unit crated in and swap them out, then retain the old one to see if anything can be recycled.

P I Staker

3,308 posts

187 months

Sunday 21st April 2013
quotequote all
Swampyrn said:
Thanks for all the replies. Its a relief they are admitting fault and agreeing on bringing the car back to the manufacturers spec. What my concern is if they cannot tighten up a sump drain plug during a basic service what hope have I got if they are going to rebuild an engine.
It doesn't give me any confidence in their workmanship..
They can tighten sump plugs, someone slipped up and made a mistake, they probably got a right bking for it too.

I wouldn't be concerned yet, allow them to rectify the mistake and hopefully you will get the car back running better then ever.

Sogra

471 posts

242 months

Sunday 21st April 2013
quotequote all
Happens more often than you would like to know. Nothing to do with ability just that the guy doing it probably got distracted by a question or whatever or possibly a faulty windy gun. Would normally do finger tight then nip up with a socket but may use a torque set gun!

Will strip and examine the engine to see extent of damage, probably will fit either an exchange short motor and swap head and other bits over (inj system, alternator, etc) or fit a long block which includes head but still swap bits over.

Depending how new the engine model is they may not have units in the system in which case you would end up with a brand new unit (makes no difference in my experiance)

Once had a week old new model with latest engine have a con rod go though the cylinder wall and had to get a brand new engine off the line (26k plus air freight costs, Truck business)

The engine will be sent in a crate and the old unit will go back into their system for rebuild to be sent out again as exchange.

most garages have different levels of techs levels 1 - 4 maybe yu may get a level 1 -2 doing the job supervised by a level 4 or it may get a level 4 depending on workload.

I know to you this is a major failure but I see much worse every day ( I work for a manufacture).

The garage may try and put it through the warranty system and that depends on how well Suzuki check their claims, wont make any difference to you.

The only thing I would be asking for is a courtesy car whilst the car is of the road.

Swampyrn

Original Poster:

5 posts

163 months

Sunday 21st April 2013
quotequote all
Sogra said:
Happens more often than you would like to know. Nothing to do with ability just that the guy doing it probably got distracted by a question or whatever or possibly a faulty windy gun. Would normally do finger tight then nip up with a socket but may use a torque set gun!

Will strip and examine the engine to see extent of damage, probably will fit either an exchange short motor and swap head and other bits over (inj system, alternator, etc) or fit a long block which includes head but still swap bits over.

Depending how new the engine model is they may not have units in the system in which case you would end up with a brand new unit (makes no difference in my experiance)

Once had a week old new model with latest engine have a con rod go though the cylinder wall and had to get a brand new engine off the line (26k plus air freight costs, Truck business)

The engine will be sent in a crate and the old unit will go back into their system for rebuild to be sent out again as exchange.

most garages have different levels of techs levels 1 - 4 maybe yu may get a level 1 -2 doing the job supervised by a level 4 or it may get a level 4 depending on workload.

I know to you this is a major failure but I see much worse every day ( I work for a manufacture).

The garage may try and put it through the warranty system and that depends on how well Suzuki check their claims, wont make any difference to you.

The only thing I would be asking for is a courtesy car whilst the car is of the road.
As soon as i spoke to them about the car they gave us a courtesy car no questions asked. They have had the car since friday and will get back to me at the beginning of this week with their findings of the damage and then we will know how long it will be before we get the car back.

davepoth

29,395 posts

230 months

Sunday 21st April 2013
quotequote all
Swampyrn said:
As soon as i spoke to them about the car they gave us a courtesy car no questions asked. They have had the car since friday and will get back to me at the beginning of this week with their findings of the damage and then we will know how long it will be before we get the car back.
Sounds like they're doing their job properly then.

va1o

16,118 posts

238 months

Sunday 21st April 2013
quotequote all
I'd be pretty pissed off if this happened to me and wouldn't really trust them to put in a replacement engine if they can't even manage an oil change.

Instead could you find a similar 9k mile 62-plate Swift in their used inventory and get them to do a swap?

Krikkit

27,943 posts

212 months

Sunday 21st April 2013
quotequote all
va1o said:
I'd be pretty pissed off if this happened to me and wouldn't really trust them to put in a replacement engine if they can't even manage an oil change.

Instead could you find a similar 9k mile 62-plate Swift in their used inventory and get them to do a swap?
Don't be daft - mistakes happen, a new engine is a good solution that leaves you with a great car.