About to buy a mondeo over something german...mad?
About to buy a mondeo over something german...mad?
Author
Discussion

Tiggsy

Original Poster:

10,261 posts

283 months

Sunday 21st April 2013
quotequote all
I have £6k to buy a car.

Needs to be economical, reliable, not too old, fit 4 kids in, fit fishing gear in the boot now and then.

I have narrowed it down to an Audi A6 estate 2006 S line 2tdi and a mondeo hatch (so vast no need for an estate) 2008 2 tdi.

Both have big miles but its motorway stuff (110k each) with LOADS of history and both are mint. All the figures seem to say the ford will be quicker, do better MPG, certainly has more toys...cheaper to service.

Am I missing anything obvious before I go and buy it in the am!

GreatGranny

9,519 posts

257 months

Sunday 21st April 2013
quotequote all
Have you driven both?
Which do you prefer?

samuelellis

1,927 posts

232 months

Sunday 21st April 2013
quotequote all
not really, ive had two mk3 mondeos now and they have coped with everything i throw at them.

If i am honest when i need to buy a 2nd car as my current Mondeo is becoming impractical (2seater, weighs a lot and naff all space for shopping) then i will probably buy another Mondeo as they just do what they say on the tin

Northernchimp

1,282 posts

163 months

Sunday 21st April 2013
quotequote all
Mondeo seems expensive at that mileage. This is a bargain for not much more...

http://www.cargiant.co.uk/Ford/Mondeo/details-5850...

Blue Oval84

5,399 posts

192 months

Sunday 21st April 2013
quotequote all
From those two I think it would be the Mondeo for me.

Tiggsy

Original Poster:

10,261 posts

283 months

Sunday 21st April 2013
quotequote all
Northernchimp said:
Mondeo seems expensive at that mileage. This is a bargain for not much more...

http://www.cargiant.co.uk/Ford/Mondeo/details-5850...
Sorry - mondeo is £5,500 - so that one linked is 40% more and one spec lower .... I know the miles are less, but I'm thinking the 2tdi will be good for space ship miles if looked after?

Fastdruid

9,415 posts

183 months

Sunday 21st April 2013
quotequote all
Ford certainly have a better reputation than Audi for reliability and will be cheaper if it does go wrong. Plus a newer car generally is going to be better than an older one, especially with Diesels where pretty much all the makes have had issues with their first 'refined' versions. Check when they last had a DMF replacement, 110k might be coming up to a second one (generally every 60-80k) and that is going to hurt on either one.

You don't mention which spec level Mondeo but the TitX has a lot of toys and IMO is a very nice interior, not sat in an A6 though so can't compare.

Mondeo is very nice to drive apart from overly assisted brakes, hides its bulk very well. Audi has a reputation for 'dull' handling but not driven an A6 to compare.

Other thing to consider is tyre/wheel sizes, not sure what the 2006 S Line has but I was put off buying one car that was otherwise perfect as it had 19in wheels, meant every tyre change it would costs £200 over the 18in version (for the cheapest 19in tyres available too against decent 18in). Doesn't sound too bad but when you're talking about a set of tyres every 8k it adds up pretty quickly for what is just styling.


Tiggsy

Original Poster:

10,261 posts

283 months

Sunday 21st April 2013
quotequote all
yep - mondeo is a titx....but audi was an sline so both were nice...in fact, I'd say the audi proably had it.

I think the deal maker for me is that the ford will go faster, do more MPG and be cheaper to service. As its just a smart looking work horse for days I want to leave the two seater at home - I think I'm going to have to go with the oval badge!

MissChief

8,021 posts

199 months

Sunday 21st April 2013
quotequote all
How many miles do you do? Modern deisels really need a long run every so often otherwise things can fail that cost a whole lot of money to replace.

DoctorX

8,279 posts

198 months

Sunday 21st April 2013
quotequote all
Sold my 2008 TitX recently and overall it was a fine car. Early Mk 4's (2007-2008) can have steering rack issues which require a new rack and reservoir to fix (which cost me a grand) so watch for noise from the steering. As mentioned above, 18" tyres are not cheap (160-ish is about the cheapest for a 'brand') and I never got more than 15k miles out of any of them. Aircon is pretty poor in these, you won't get a chilly interior if that's what you like on a hot day.

Tiggsy

Original Poster:

10,261 posts

283 months

Sunday 21st April 2013
quotequote all
MissChief said:
How many miles do you do? Modern deisels really need a long run every so often otherwise things can fail that cost a whole lot of money to replace.
15k a year ish

Plan was to run it for 3 years - and sell it with about 160k on it while its still worth a £2-3k

Fittster

20,120 posts

244 months

Monday 22nd April 2013
quotequote all
Isn't the VAG 2.0 TDI iffy?

Is either going to be worth 2K to 3K with 160K on the clock?

Tiggsy

Original Poster:

10,261 posts

283 months

Monday 22nd April 2013
quotequote all
I'd expect a nice 2 owner mondeo titx with 160k to be around £2k.

Would be a bargain as well! Even if it was dead after 18 months it would have been cheap!

mdm1uk

1,344 posts

179 months

Monday 22nd April 2013
quotequote all
I have an 05 Mondeo st deisel great car lovely handling. My only gripes are the squeaky seats. Oh and gets through a front set of p zeros in no time at all

Fittster

20,120 posts

244 months

Monday 22nd April 2013
quotequote all
Tiggsy said:
I'd expect a nice 2 owner mondeo titx with 160k to be around £2k.

Would be a bargain as well! Even if it was dead after 18 months it would have been cheap!
When I pop mondeo, max price 3K and fuel type diesel into autotrader the results that come back show cars with 110K and less coming back.

I'd have thought a Mondeo with that kind of mileage is going to be between £1500 to £1000 on a good day.

Tiggsy

Original Poster:

10,261 posts

283 months

Monday 22nd April 2013
quotequote all
Fittster said:
When I pop mondeo, max price 3K and fuel type diesel into autotrader the results that come back show cars with 110K and less coming back.

I'd have thought a Mondeo with that kind of mileage is going to be between £1500 to £1000 on a good day.
ok, lets say its worth only £1000. At £5,500 thats £4500 lost over say 3 years. £125pm depreciation.

My alternative is to lease something cheap but that will still be £300+. These new supper efficient engines may mean another £100pm fuel saving but I'm still down £100pm at least. I'd need to be spending out a lot in things going wrong to be worse off....and, despite being a mondeo, it will be a nicer car to be in.

Thats my thinking! Oh, and I can flog it anytime if my situation changes.

I've just ended my 3 yr deal in a lease C350 at £480pm......just cant see it was worth the cost.

Mr2Mike

20,143 posts

286 months

Monday 22nd April 2013
quotequote all
Tiggsy said:
Sorry - mondeo is £5,500 - so that one linked is 40% more and one spec lower .... I know the miles are less, but I'm thinking the 2tdi will be good for space ship miles if looked after?
You'd be wise to budget for a clutch and DMF sometime in the near future at that mileage.

Fastdruid

9,415 posts

183 months

Monday 22nd April 2013
quotequote all
Fittster said:
Tiggsy said:
I'd expect a nice 2 owner mondeo titx with 160k to be around £2k.

Would be a bargain as well! Even if it was dead after 18 months it would have been cheap!
When I pop mondeo, max price 3K and fuel type diesel into autotrader the results that come back show cars with 110K and less coming back.

I'd have thought a Mondeo with that kind of mileage is going to be between £1500 to £1000 on a good day.
I'd have thought all Mk3's at that price and good while the Mk3 is the Mk4 is IMO a massive improvement on it.

bencollins

3,574 posts

236 months

Monday 22nd April 2013
quotequote all
pretty sure the mondeo is german.

paulmoonraker

2,850 posts

194 months

Monday 22nd April 2013
quotequote all
I want to hate my Mondeo, but it does what it says on the tin, and all rather well.

It's had the usual DMF fail at 70K, and the radiator fans at the front packed up (I ignored this all winter, but the coolant started to boil in the summer, so had it fixed)... Oh, and its minus 40 all the time (with the red frost dash light on). I think this had something to do with a little plastic box on two wires eventually falling off (it was hanging down for about a year).